EPT/in
[T] Cell (Mini?) Mafia III
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
/in | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On August 30 2014 06:00 Blazinghand wrote: 1) he's a dick 2) i will read his filter when I get home then tell you why he's mafia 3) i should probably read your filter too at some point On August 30 2014 06:05 Blazinghand wrote: you'll have to wait 3 hours for me to get home The only reasons I can really find in your filter for voting bats are the three posted here, and your posts from that point on promise more activity once you get home in three hours with a filter dive and good reasons for voting bat. But once you got home you just said bat is scum and you are on your phone. This could be true but their has to be some reasons besides what you have said here? I do not like how instead of actually posting game relevant insights all you do is fight about whether you are actually moving or making up excuses. There is no content in what you are posting just excuses which I know has been mentioned before. So why is bats scum and why are you so sure that rit is town based on color codeing a few cells seems like a non reason to town read someone. ATM i'm town reading bat, the last few games i've played with him where hes scum hes been a bit more withdrawn and structures his posts a lot better. He does try to be a dick...but hes a dick as town also. And it seems like in his filter he justs posts whatever comes in his mind so he does not seem like scum bats from N&T or storm 2. And hi | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
Besides colorcoding cells what has rit done to be so town to you? Also you gave a sorta reason rit is town cause of color coding cells, ok crappy reason. Why can't you atleast give a small answer why bats is svum? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
However this is where I get a bit confused and hazy, you seem to go from suspicion to sudden firm town read on him. This seems to just be because of his colored voting post. Did you see something in his filter you did not convey at that time? Or was it just because of his post and the small bit of detail he put into the colors? Also could you explain why bat is scum right now? I understand that from your viewpoint that it would be bat has to be scum becuase rit is town and i'm town. But mafia is about convincing the rest of the thread of this. You have given littel reason why Bat is scum so when you have a moment in moving could you tell me why I should vote Bat over you. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
In the thread so far he basically has no content. Didn't really do anything during the initial voteing for mayor overall. And even though he somewhat answered the question posed to him he dodged any analyisis he could make or Its strange you would hard town read him, when he's been active in other games and absent here. So why the townread? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
I disagree that his first post was especially ballsy, and while i wouldn't svum read him on that. I would say he has been scummy in his abscense. I say this mainly for a few reasons. He's been active in his other games, decently active in fact. But his play here does not look like his newb games at all for the most part. My first game i rolled scum here i made similary awkward posts, and then proceeded to lurk and hope i did not garner attention. You do not think that is possible here? No misgivings just 100% town? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
@Wave even when your town you are scum at heart forever | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
1) Could you give some of your reasoning why you initially took a stance that BH was scum. 2) Why do you feel like bat has caught up to BH at this point? 3) Do you still feel like ninja is the scummiest person to you and why? @Bat, I still waiting on an answer to the question i posed you | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
Also BH any other reads on the other cells yet? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
hes made several promises and with almost an hour to go till deadline I really want to see him deliver on something rather than just lurking at this point, though I do know good reads take awhile. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
I'm not as convinced that BH was the scum yesterday as I once was.I hate his inactivity still for most of the thread and I hate that he waited so late in the day cycle to even try to give anything. Its possible in my mind that Ritoky was the mafia and he just barely had to play at all, he barely had any pressure put on him while BH and bats just pushed themselves up the lynch ladder. But I digress as it doesn't have as much to do with today as some other things. On September 01 2014 09:56 lilwade wrote: This day is super easy I had scum read on 27 bunnies like 30 seconds into day 1 And so did apathy... voting 27ninjabunnies. Also this does not make sense to me. On August 31 2014 07:49 lilwade wrote: @Amiko Im not sure now Blazing hand brought a case against 27ninja and if he was the mafia id be more inclined to think Apathy is scum. Also to note that Apathy voted on bat and not blazing. What about you? There does not seem to be a ton of connection between these two posts. On one post he thinks BH is the mafia (from a previous post it felt like to me). And he says that he is more likely to think Apathy is scum, but then he scum reads bunnies 30 seconds into the game and so does apathy the person he was leaning scum on? This doesn't make sense to me and I would like lilwane to post more about this. Why is bunnies scum to you and not apathy anymore? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On September 01 2014 11:36 MysteryMeat1 wrote: I'm rethinking my position on bunnies, Like you noted above, bunnies does vote for BH over BSnacks, at a time when the votes were pretty close. Is that the only reason that you are rethinking bunnies? What has bunnies done that is scum/town in your mind right now MM? Also reading the thread, just the way that the thread feels it does not feel like BH is getting lynched at the time bunnies votes for BH. At the time the thread is dog piling onto bats and he never recovers, and the people who were town reading bats were absent at that point. Would you disagree with this assessment MM? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On September 02 2014 01:49 MysteryMeat1 wrote: Going to work and i probably wont be able to check my phone. Gonna stick to my gut read on bunnies T.T On September 02 2014 01:50 MysteryMeat1 wrote: Ah screw it lilwade it is Why the sudden change MM1? And why did you ignore my first questions? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
He hasn't really contributed to the thread and a lot of what hes said has been contradictory to other things he has said earlier or later in the thread. Even before he voted BH he said that BH and bats were equally scummy but then the next post he scum reads BH and votes him instantly cause BH said he would do like WoS said and post scumreads and some other reasons. And then says he thinks BH is scum and means he thinks apathy is scum, but then completely forgets that and reads bunnies scum and never returns to the thread so yea. Hes my vote today hopefully i make it back in time ##Vote lilwade | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
Right now as the cell stands I would put my order of lynch, Your mom>NRHF>Damdred for a few reasons. Obviously I put myself last because I don't want to lynch myself. Your mom originally voted for BH during the mayoral actions but shortly after the first cell started she voted for BH lynch, this is fine at that moment in time as BH was being inconsistent in the thread and continued to complain about people piling votes on him however BH makes one post about how Rit is town and bats is scummy because he doesn't agree with BH (paraphrase) and Your mom says this On August 31 2014 06:01 your mom wrote: BHs latest post is quite convincing ##Unvote ##Vote batsnacks BH post was actually not bad I admit, but did it warrant an unvote at that point in time and a jump on bats (who at that time was the popular sentiment to lynch)? No, not really. BH was still scummy and had at that point yet still not delivered on other reads besides bunnies. Your mom was questioned about this but never responded to any questions at all in the thread. The next posts we see is sheeping a growing sentiment to lynch lilwade On September 01 2014 23:11 your mom wrote: vote goes easily to lilwade. > scumreads bh > tells amiko that if bh was scum hed be more inclined to think apathy is scum > votes ninja super confidently like he scumread her from the start > effectively makes his post to amiko completely pointless cause he was so sure about bunnies anyway ##Vote lilwade While, lilwade had a few scummy qualities that I even got onto, he made himself an easy mislynch. Your mom never responded to anything else in the thread or even entertained the idea that bunnies or toad could of been the mafia at the moment. Instead the only post that they respond to is one comparing the posting style to another website and has yet to be seen from since. I'm diving nrhf next, but right now your mom seems like a good lynch, sheeps popular sentiment while they are in thread. Never addresses questions that are pointed toward them and then dissapears for long stretches of time. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On September 03 2014 00:20 Amiko wrote: Damdred looks good to me, though I think his post on your mom above is actually pretty weak- I basically feel it boils down to voting the wrong person both times - sheeping popular opinion itself doesn't seem scummy to me; I mean, it can be towny to sheep popular opinion when popular opinion is right. Your mom still feels the best, I'll read some more later but I don't mind putting a vote in for now. ##vote: your mom There really is not much to go on in Your moms filter, and that sucks. NRHF looks towny in his filter his posting has dropped off tremendously over the past couple of cycles which is a worry to me. And your moms activity just sucked all the time. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On September 03 2014 21:56 your mom wrote: ##Vote Damdred apologies for having so little time to play. my play sucks, i know that and now i feel bad for the little commitment i brought to the game, and that it will probably let it end in a loss.. i dont have a magical recipe to convince you im town. i only know that damdred is scum cause since d1 i didnt feel like nrhf was.the outcome of the game is in your hands at this point, aware that for you it must be a coinflip. it is. i hope that it will flip scum. i dont feel like giving lengthy explanations as to why dam probably is, since i got to the conclusion by poe. i might be online again before deadline. Errrr, ok. You could convince them you are town by actually giving a case on me/the person i replaced for. Anyway I feel pretty confident Your mom is the mafia in this cell ##Vote Your Mom As for the next Cell, MM1 would be the person I would lynch. After that I think it comes down between Oak and Marv, and i'm filter diving them again to decide between them. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
MM1: After reading your cell, I think that was your best game. Once I read the back and forth with you and HF I really felt that you were town and I feel bad for saying to lynch you now. The last cell I was conflicted about between oats and marv cause marv hadn't done much but he wouldn't of been on bh... Either way it was a fun game, and the cell format is hellish....i would love to do it starting from the beginning it was kinda hard to replace in and find the flow | ||
| ||
