batsnacks might be a good lynch since his votes have been pretty scummy, he made a scummy slight defense of Navillus to distance himself from the fallout of the lynch, and he hasn't really done anything to make me think he's town yet.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 16:43 GMT

#2354

##Vote batsnacks

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 16:47 GMT

#2358

I wonder where CR disappeared. He still hasn't explained his read on me+Koshi. And now it's kind of futile since Koshi is semi-confirmed.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 16:51 GMT

#2363

On July 26 2014 01:46 Damdred wrote:
Ok i'm for a few hours now before work.

Show nested quote +

Are you just going with popular sentiments here? Why not post a new case on someone with updated reads with activity from them on posts since your last case eh?

Honestly I could see ray leaving his vote on you, you getting lynched and well him gaining town cred since he helped lynch you if you flipped red. But I don't know he trashes you a lot in his posts...

Is it really a reasonable strategy to bus me D1? He couldn't even claim much credit since he never actually called me scum, just voted me and left his vote there.

Anyways, there's nothing inherently wrong with going after players who are universally suspected. There's usually a reason why they are generally suspected... And pretty much everyone else feels townish enough.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 16:54 GMT

#2370

Not sure if CR is scummy, but he could definitely be worth another look.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 17:12 GMT

#2376

On July 26 2014 01:54 Damdred wrote:

Show nested quote +

Tell me why each of these is scum to you then Xatalos i'm not saying scum can't be in them but let me see your thoughts

Damdred (I realize it's you but eh, just putting it out there):
- Wishy-washy suspicions on me to see if it would catch any support, then voting me later on when I had already gathered votes
- Going along with the flow of the thread by then voting Navillus
- All in all: pretty unimpactful and inactive in the game - a position that scum often assume

Tbh I guess you could still be town, but since there are so many other likely townies, the probability of you being scum goes up.

ObiWan:
- It was a struggle to get enough votes on him whereas I / Navillus easily gathered enough votes
- Didn't really care about the result of the lynch and voted apparently without reasoning
- Nothing really comes to mind when I try to think of something he's done and that's never a good sign

batsnacks:
- His votes have been just scummy sheeping without real input
- Tried to distance himself from the approaching Navillus lynch weakly and without any actual effort/reasoning
- Apparently forgot that he was supposed to be unhappy with lynching Navillus right away and said that there was no reason to be unhappy about it..?

VA:
dunno about him really, I just included him there since I can't exactly think of him as townish either and Koshi I think mentioned that he plays a bit similarly as scum

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 17:21 GMT

#2381

Well, my vote is on batsnacks as you can see.

I just looked a bit at Damdred's filter but I didn't really see anything that I haven't already thought about.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 17:25 GMT

#2382

Btw Damdred you've almost only talked about me. Don't you have any other (scum)reads?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 17:31 GMT

#2385

You've totally convinced me now.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 17:32 GMT

#2386

I wouldn't really mind lynching him though.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 17:49 GMT

#2392

Oh, and we probably have a role like DT as well. So that means that we have several somewhat confirmed players through roles already and then 1) the Vigi who shot rayn obviously and 2) a red/green check on someone. That's quite a lot of information already.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 17:50 GMT

#2393

Haha

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 18:28 GMT

#2402

##Unvote
##Vote ObiWanShinobi

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 18:29 GMT

#2404

VA is the hero this town needs

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

July 25 2014 18:30 GMT

#2405

That was doubly good since it got rid of probably the hardest to catch scum (player+role) and confirmed one of the uncertain players at the same time.