|
If you're town, are you more concerned about a serial killer? or are you more concerned about mafia?
As town, I'm more concerned about mafia, which are guaranteed to be in the setup, rather than the serial killer.
After a bit of mulligan, I've noticed something.
Eden is mafia.
He has been talking quite a bit less than the other game.
He pushes yellow first.
Then he gets out the serial killer case on tambo. Before this, he was pretty much sure that yellow was mafia. It doesn't make sense to go after serial killer if you're town, and you have a mafia suspect, because what if tambo was telling the truth? From a townie's perspective, he should have stuck with the yellow lynch, rather than potentially killing vigi.
He changed his vote to tambo because he believes the vigi claim. He's afraid of leaving the vigi alive. That means, that if eden is mafia, there's definitely no roleblocker.
Yes, it is possible that tambo is serial killer. However, Eden's actions following tambo's roleclaim is a dead giveaway of his alignment.
Eden is mafia.
|
|
|
Okay, now if Eden is mafia, who else is?
Not tambo for obvious reasons.
Not yellow, either.
Otherwise, he hasn't interacted much with others. (another reason why he's mafia)
Hm.... I can't see who else mafia could be, working from the perspective that Eden is proved mafia.
However, I do have my reads.
From my reads, however, ahswtini is mafia.
I can see ahswtini + eden as scum team.
|
If you're town, you don't want vigi to die. Sure, he might be SK, but he might be vigi also. You don't even know if there is a SK. I think tambo's claim was strange too, but I'm not willing to risk losing vigi. You are. That makes you mafia.
|
It's not obvious because there's no guarantee that there even is an SK. I'm not risking killing a vigi on the possibility that there is a SK.
|
To be honest, eden doesn't like fishy claims, from last game. But we got a mislynch because of it. And I'm not risking that.
|
|
|
Ladies and gentlemen, I have 2 potential wagons. Eden and ahs.
I've explained my reasoning on both of them.
Eden is more contributing than ahs.
However, looking at the time remaining, I don't think I'll get enough votes on any of these guys. Therefore, I'm switching to sweetfrost also, because the general consensus is that he's mafia.
##Vote Sweetfrost
|
forgot to bold, but who cares.
I'm just saying, Sweetfrost is not my most optimal lynch.
|
On May 02 2014 03:47 ahswtini wrote:Show nested quote +On May 01 2014 19:44 ahswtini wrote:Ok I'm voting for mysterymeat, his posts so far have essentially been meaningless. A lot of one-liners, spam and dumb hashtags. What sticks out to me is how he always talks about what he doesn't like I just don't like this feeling of accusing people in the beginning based off of some joke claim that he is mafia. Exept for tamburini, i just don't like the fact that imo, with soo little information that he was trying to pocket bunny that hard. Yet never mentioning what he would like to see or happen. This negative-only attitude reads to me as typical scum behaviour. On top of that, he's banned so he's not going to be useful for the next couple of days. Yes, it looks rather suspicious that my only case is against someone that can't defend themselves, but this is honestly the only thing that's standing out to me so far. I don't really follow the other arguments that are being thrown around in this thread. Since he's banned for the vote today, will his vote stay on mtamburini? I just want to reiterate my suspicions of MysteryMeat1. Yes he's banned and can't defend himself. Yes he's said that he doesn't have much to say on day one and will be more active after the first night of kills. People seem to be letting his useless posts slide, yet I'm getting fingers pointed at me. I can see the case for sweetfrost, I have nothing of my own to add to that and so I don't want to just jump onto that vote. The votes ARE really dangerously spread out and it would be easy for the Mafia team to stack onto someone innocent to kill them. That said, if we forced their hand to vote in such a way, it could also make it easier to narrow down the list of suspects.
I like this. Even when he's under suspicion, he's talking about his suspicions. Although I disagree with lynching Meat, the fact that he's saying this seems townie.
|
On May 02 2014 04:22 Eden1892 wrote:Show nested quote +On May 02 2014 04:08 sqrtofneg1 wrote:On May 02 2014 03:47 ahswtini wrote:On May 01 2014 19:44 ahswtini wrote:Ok I'm voting for mysterymeat, his posts so far have essentially been meaningless. A lot of one-liners, spam and dumb hashtags. What sticks out to me is how he always talks about what he doesn't like I just don't like this feeling of accusing people in the beginning based off of some joke claim that he is mafia. Exept for tamburini, i just don't like the fact that imo, with soo little information that he was trying to pocket bunny that hard. Yet never mentioning what he would like to see or happen. This negative-only attitude reads to me as typical scum behaviour. On top of that, he's banned so he's not going to be useful for the next couple of days. Yes, it looks rather suspicious that my only case is against someone that can't defend themselves, but this is honestly the only thing that's standing out to me so far. I don't really follow the other arguments that are being thrown around in this thread. Since he's banned for the vote today, will his vote stay on mtamburini? I just want to reiterate my suspicions of MysteryMeat1. Yes he's banned and can't defend himself. Yes he's said that he doesn't have much to say on day one and will be more active after the first night of kills. People seem to be letting his useless posts slide, yet I'm getting fingers pointed at me. I can see the case for sweetfrost, I have nothing of my own to add to that and so I don't want to just jump onto that vote. The votes ARE really dangerously spread out and it would be easy for the Mafia team to stack onto someone innocent to kill them. That said, if we forced their hand to vote in such a way, it could also make it easier to narrow down the list of suspects. I like this. Even when he's under suspicion, he's talking about his suspicions. Although I disagree with lynching Meat, the fact that he's saying this seems townie. How? He said outright a couple posts up that he found no one suspicious and he's settling on a guy who's literally unable to defend himself at all due to a ban. How is that setting off your townie alarm?
Well, think of it this way. He reminds me of cavalinho a couple of newbie mini mafia games ago. The one where he got lynched day 1? Not the one we were in, but the one he was in before that. Cav, in that game, was under pressure, but he stuck to his suspicions even though they weren't the suspicions of the majority of the others. Ahs reminded me of cav, that's why I liked that post.
|
@dfs
You keep on saying there are better targets.
Care to explain the targets that aren't me?
|
What I mean by that is explain why you think they're mafia.
|
On May 02 2014 04:43 Amiko wrote:
Back in thread, writing a few comments up
@sqrt: I think his post just above yours is relatively straightforward about his other targets (mtamburini / yell0w / sweetfrost)
I just explained my request further.
|
Ah, that.
Well, it was a silly read, now that I look back into it.
Epishade brought up mysterymeat near the beginning of the game, even thought mystermeat didn't talk yet. I thought they were masons.
His first serious comment was directed to epishade too.
|
Yeah, amiko, I would rather lynch someone else, but I don't think we have enough time to make everyone to switch to someone.
|
Eden, you're concentrating more on the SK than the mafia right now. Who are your mafia reads, other than the yellow read?
|
On May 02 2014 04:59 27ninjabunnies wrote:
I honestly don't think that tamburini should out his shot.
Why not? He should, at the very least, right before the end of N1.
|
Well, I g2g right now, sorry guys. I'll be back about an hour after the deadline.
|
I think we can.
No N1 flavour? awww....
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
