|
On April 16 2014 11:02 sandroba wrote:
Basically it comes down to this:
sandroba
snb
paperscraps
killing
geript?
vayne?
amiko?
ve
jat
Now here is the deal. jat pretty much has to be sk at this point, reason being I held the ring for a lot of nights and he never took a shot on me. Also he went ahead and shot into town tonight, I think it's a safe assumption. The reason for him acting now is probably town being constrained on lynches and not able to act. Also amiko may very well be mafia, not doing what he was suposed to do to prevent town from getting back the res item. VE pretty much has to be mafia, not producing a single useful check in 5 nights he has had to act and being a complete non presence in the entire game.
I agree that we make me and snb both top positions. Now on priorities of who we should kill, definitely jat first since we need to reduce the kp urgently.
Hmm. So you think Palmar was wrong about VE? My gut instinct was that VE is scum, but I put some stock into Palmar's read on him.
Also, you have Killing in your town circle and I have geript in mine. Why do you still like Killing so much?
Also, also, haha, can you try to elaborate on what VA is?
|
On April 16 2014 10:40 strongandbig wrote:
i counterpropose we put sandroba as top and me as second
I am cool with this or SnB at top and Sandroba at second, since second gets mayor.
|
My role can be OP with a lot of chaos. I highly doubt Killing would leave me alive here as scum. VE not being dead and supposedly being some super cop does not bode well for him at all. His checks are just bad. If VE if you could post some more substance that would be great. Right now he doesn't seem very invested in the game or trying to find scum.
|
JAT is being way too defensive for my tastes. It speaks more to him being mafia than 3p, since anytime anyone calls him out he has to respond and defend himself.
|
On April 18 2014 01:58 geript wrote:
We really need to consolidate our votes onto 2 people. Most everyone seems ok with S&B so I propose we stack there for mayor. I don't care who the primary is really but since most people are ok with sandro then that's an ok spot as long as no shenannies get pulled. But we def can't afford no mayor.
I am comfortable with this plan to have SnB as mayor. I have my vote on Sandroba right now. Let's get some more votes on SnB and Sandroba guys!
|
On April 18 2014 10:50 geript wrote:
Daniel, don't protect me tonight. I'll deal with JAT for tonight. Man there's been some weird shit happening with the votes then.
There is no chaos, so I am pretty useless tonight. I will be guarding the device.
|
Also reading into the flavour of VE's role seems a bit cheap, but it does heavily suggest that geript and VA are town.
|
Hmm, so the previous night there were 3 deaths. JAT claims to have shot Amiko. If we believe this to be true then there was 3 KP unaccounted for. Something isn't adding up here. Maybe an item was used that had KP?? Maybe JAT's shot was redirected somehow, maybe he is just lying to us.
Here would be my best guesses for how KP went down on the previous night:
Scenario 1
1 KP - JAT
1 KP - Possible item was used to kill someone? Town KP not announced yet?
1 KP - By mafia
This points to 1 mafia left.
or
Scenario 2
1 KP - JAT
2 KP - Mafia
This implies 2 mafia left.
Where we stand at this point:
Paperscraps - Claims Town - Chaos medic
SnB - Claims Town - Medic and other shenanigans
Killing - Claims Town - Paranormal Investigator
Amiko - Claims 3p - Survivor Hoarder/Thief
JAT - Claims 3p - SK
VA - Claims Town - Horsemen(War) that can affect lynch targets??? (Kind of skeptical about this still, doesn't really go well with his flavour of being the WAR horsemen)
geript = Claims Town - Horsemen(Famine) that can faminate peoples
sandroba - Claims Town - ????
So, Sandroba said he is gone until Monday and we don't know his role. That is not cool.
In conclusion, I am bit lost on where all that KP came from on Night 5. I would like to hear sandroba and VA tell us what their roles are and what they can do/what they have done.
I believe Amiko more than I believe JAT at this point. That doesn't mean I think that JAT isn't 3p, but JAT fighting us so hard and constant defensive nature is scummy to me. Also the I don't want to read too much into the flavour text that clears geript and VA. I think geript's play speaks to him being town, but VA is still a question for me. Sandroba's play as of recent has made me a bit more skeptical, but I still think he is town. I think Killing is town, but this isn't a super strong read. SnB is probably my strongest town read at the moment and if he was pocketed me, well kudos to him, haha.
With how KP went down on Night 5 either a town isn't telling us the whole truth or there is likely 1-2 mafia left. I lean towards there being 1 mafia left right now. Maybe that is just wishful thinking, but with looking at all the claims and what not it makes the most sense to me.
|
On April 18 2014 12:06 Amiko wrote:
Oh also wasn't it claimed that VE became lovers with someone who is apparently not dead?
Apparently whoever VE targeted, the night the lover spell was put on him, would be his lover.
|
Oh, also I left out that geript states he can RB people as well.
|
On April 18 2014 12:31 VayneAuthority wrote:
I havent done anything this entire game except try to kill scum, my filter is proof and that's about it. The flavor fits perfectly as I go to war with other people over trying to get lynched (remember that I MUST be included in the lynch targets)
For similar role see ace's carnival cruise, some one had something similar except he was scum.
Who is your top lynch tomorrow?
|
On April 18 2014 12:34 VayneAuthority wrote:Show nested quote +On April 18 2014 12:32 Paperscraps wrote:On April 18 2014 12:31 VayneAuthority wrote:
I havent done anything this entire game except try to kill scum, my filter is proof and that's about it. The flavor fits perfectly as I go to war with other people over trying to get lynched (remember that I MUST be included in the lynch targets)
For similar role see ace's carnival cruise, some one had something similar except he was scum. Who is your top lynch tomorrow? I don't jump the gun and give unnecessary info, there is still night kills that need to be processed in a crucial point of the game. You'll know when it matters
Thanks you are super helpful.
|
On April 18 2014 12:44 VayneAuthority wrote:
oh VE is dead so nvm thats 3 left with one of those being sandroba...so yea its pretty much you or killing at the noose tomorrow cant see it going any other way.
Picture a world where Killing and I are town. What do you do then?
|
On April 18 2014 12:51 VayneAuthority wrote:Show nested quote +On April 18 2014 12:49 Paperscraps wrote:On April 18 2014 12:44 VayneAuthority wrote:
oh VE is dead so nvm thats 3 left with one of those being sandroba...so yea its pretty much you or killing at the noose tomorrow cant see it going any other way. Picture a world where Killing and I are town. What do you do then? that's easy, sandroba if you have been reading. its troubling to say the least that he hasnt died yet but it appears that mystery might be solved when he fails to post before monday and potentially gets modkilled, who knows.
I don't see sandroba being mod-killed. The mods haven't mod-killed anyone yet for failing to vote a first time.
|
|
|
Oh, Sandroba was mafia. Cools. GJ town.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
