Catastrophe Mafia - Page 18

On April 10 2014 11:37 Oatsmaster wrote:
Dont know what you are asking. Dont care.
we lynch jat today and va/geript/ve tmr

On April 10 2014 18:16 Palmar wrote:
So how do we tell the bad from the scum. Three people are guilty of serious stupidity, who among them is mafia and who is town?

Geript is adamant about being obnoxious. Between talking in code, calling me mafia for no particular reason, and in general refusing to co-operate with people he knows for a fact are town.

VE checked me. Are you fucking serious? That's the dumbest goddamn check anyone could ever have made. Both my role and my alignment were readibly available in the thread. This is like the easiest check anyone could ever have made.

Oats shot a confirmed townie for no good reason and didn't ask for my permission.

Someone want to fill me in?

On April 10 2014 17:49 Oatsmaster wrote:

I lied about nothing. I can prove it.

On April 10 2014 18:45 geript wrote:

Well certain people have called him town all game long...

On April 10 2014 19:06 Palmar wrote:
The problem I have with lynching Oats is that I believe his claim. Don't get me wrong, I want him to die. He lied about his roleclaim to me.

However the whole thing about him figuring out WoS was in orthanc and killing WoS because of that seems overly complicated for Oats to have thought of it on the spot to get an excuse to kill WoS. I don't think scumOats would believe for a second he could get away with it.

There are more things at work here.



If Oats is telling the truth, who do you think JAT is? I wonder who would roleblock someone by putting him in orthanc

So my current suggestion is that we make Oats take poison. JAT has already claimed anti-town afaik (sorry if I'm wrong on this, not really reading the thread). So we need to kill JAT anyway.

If JAT flips what I'm expecting him to flip, we should consider giving Oats antidote. It's important that JAT's flip matches Oats' description of his night actions. If not? We let Oats die. If Oats lies about taking the poison and somehow stays alive, we just lynch him the next day.

Oats, I am expecting you to go along with this plan. I will be so mad if you put your own stupid agenda in front of town again. You're taking the goddamn poison and you will like it. It's a punishment for your blatant stupidity in shooting WoS.

On April 10 2014 20:01 Palmar wrote:
I still think this makes JAT saruman

On April 10 2014 20:45 Palmar wrote:
I still don't understand why scumOats would claim the kill on WoS.

He didn't have to do anything in the thread right?

On April 10 2014 23:17 Oatsmaster wrote:
Maybe jat has sick dodges.
Why woukd I fakeclaim easily confirmable stuff for no reason??

On April 11 2014 02:06 Oatsmaster wrote:
Fuck guys just think it through. Ok scumoats is under some pressure, starts out attacking JAT, WOAH SHIT CLAIMS A WHOLE LOTTA SHIT FOR NO FUCKING REASON. Makes sense? Nope.
Now get off me and onto Jat.

On April 11 2014 11:25 IAmRobik wrote:
I'd lynch Amiko over JAT

On April 11 2014 13:15 geript wrote:

This is a very good point. JAT has shown that he's willing to work with town and has abilities that are useful to us. If the second leader does get lynched Amiko is a more preferential lynch that JAT IMO.

On April 11 2014 19:51 Palmar wrote:

He claimed scum.

or 3p.

I don't really care. He's not town, and I don't think Oats is unlynchable anyway. If Oats somehow is, we at least kill anti-town.

On April 11 2014 20:20 geript wrote:
He has a lot of odd flip flops on LSB, IamP and syllogism. Even if Oats is scum and 1 of JAT/Amiko is scum I still think there's at least a sixth. Idk, maybe all the 3P claims are com scum and there's 7 who knows.

On April 12 2014 02:39 Amiko wrote:
You and kita both also claimed to be immune to nightkills. That's also why I figured you both must be 3p/scum - why claim you are immune if you could soak bullets instead?
I mean, I guess the obvious answer (given kita's flip) is to avoid getting shot at night.

On April 12 2014 03:40 Amiko wrote:
My role feels pretty boring. I mean the random item swap might be interesting but sort of mean. Maybe I would end up with some powerful item? But like I said, even if I got some item, I am dis-incentivized to use it.

I really don't know what syllo was trying to do. I feel like as scum he should have wanted to ally with me, not try to paint me as scum. If I get lynched I flip 3p without any kp, so it just makes him look bad. I guess maybe he could have used this argument to say he must not be scum because why would he lie, and someone else must have also visited whoever it was he claimed, but eh.
It is possible someone has a win condition of killing me (since that kind of role seems popular in this game). I guess he could have been trying to keep the lynch off someone else that day?

If you want I can try to visit you and steal an item to feel more confirmed :3c I'd be willing to give it back afterward.
If I get roleblocked by scum, then whatever, it would uses up a roleblock to prevent nothing important.

On April 12 2014 09:59 Amiko wrote:
30 secs
moving to JAT

On April 12 2014 03:02 strongandbig wrote:
here's one thing, as long as jat is alive and trying to kill sandroba, we have to keep roleblocking him every night. i'd take a scum lynch first, but that in itself is a good enough reason to have jat be the backup lynch if oats is actually lynchproof.

On April 12 2014 10:16 IAmRobik wrote:
Someone shoot that scumbag

On April 12 2014 14:53 Oatsmaster wrote:
Oooo I got a gun.
who should I shoot guys?

On April 13 2014 00:17 Oatsmaster wrote:
Dude no flips tonight and changed rad counter.
I only have 2 1 shots.
RIGHT GUYS?

On April 13 2014 03:56 austinmcc wrote:
geript, question.

If scum has a "target player can't be lynched this cycle" mechanic on someone, why do they wait until now to use it? Could stick it on syllo or iamp earlier, possibly save a power of theirs and also keep a KP maybe, depending on numbers. Could stick it on Gumshoe D1, give no flip information, and PROBABLY have gumshoe be the lynch D2. Save it for a townie on a critical day coming up, no lynch, another set of NKs, and we PROBABLY lynch that dude the next day.

Do you think, if you actually work through it, that a buddy/partner/forbidden lover/supplicant/trusted librarian of Oats's would use that power on Oats? ESPECIALLY if snb's bit is legit and he just has one-shot abilities.