|
On March 09 2014 11:00 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Plumber is town because there isn't a scum assassin that gets an extra kp that goes through jk protection resolving exactly as night ends on the same night as his first shot as well as preventing a shot on gumshoe or a scum assassin that has a busdrive in the game.
|
So a scum assassin with an KP kp is implausible, but so a scum vig with an extra Kp or a Joat Bus driver is perfectly reasonable?
|
Two extra nk on one role of which one is instant and the other isn't and some way to prevent kp on gumshoe (why would he even want to do that?) is indeed more implausible.
A scum joat that can use multiple powers is actually reasonable because it fits within the context of the role. A busdrive role would not fit with the context of an assassin at all, and the alternative is really really implausible.
|
Wait... I thought LSB can only use his power once (pick one power, use it, that's it). Or can he use each one of his possible powers once? I'm confused.
My opinion on Artanis's plan will depend quite a bit on how that works.
|
On March 09 2014 11:59 Xatalos wrote:
Wait... I thought LSB can only use his power once (pick one power, use it, that's it). Or can he use each one of his possible powers once? I'm confused.
My opinion on Artanis's plan will depend quite a bit on how that works.
I believe it's the latter.
|
On March 09 2014 12:04 Artanis[Xp] wrote:Show nested quote +On March 09 2014 11:59 Xatalos wrote:
Wait... I thought LSB can only use his power once (pick one power, use it, that's it). Or can he use each one of his possible powers once? I'm confused.
My opinion on Artanis's plan will depend quite a bit on how that works. I believe it's the latter.
I think it's the former but I asked geript just to be sure. If it's the former, we should definitely lynch LSB. If it's the latter, we should probably lynch prplhz. I just don't see how gumshoe could be scum with a (modified) Veteran role. Also he's probably modkilled soon enough or if he returns, his explanation would clear up the situation significantly. I see no good point in lynching him today (and he's quite likely not even Mafia based on the night actions).
|
|
|
Now I must go to sleep, but we'll figure things out tomorrow!
|
On March 09 2014 12:12 Xatalos wrote:Show nested quote +On March 09 2014 12:04 Artanis[Xp] wrote:On March 09 2014 11:59 Xatalos wrote:
Wait... I thought LSB can only use his power once (pick one power, use it, that's it). Or can he use each one of his possible powers once? I'm confused.
My opinion on Artanis's plan will depend quite a bit on how that works. I believe it's the latter. I think it's the former but I asked geript just to be sure. If it's the former, we should definitely lynch LSB. If it's the latter, we should probably lynch prplhz. I just don't see how gumshoe could be scum with a (modified) Veteran role. Also he's probably modkilled soon enough or if he returns, his explanation would clear up the situation significantly. I see no good point in lynching him today (and he's quite likely not even Mafia based on the night actions).
Gumshoe is unlikely because of role, but his play this game has been so abysmal. Taking all the roles out of the game he is the clear lynch. Prplhz actually has played a pro town game throughout and I find it difficult to see him as scum as well given how he's tried to figure out the game. Even LSB has a few things in his favour (austin hard defending him to try to look good). That's why gumshoe has to die.
|
Also officially longest filter in the game, suck it marv.
|
Just a reminder. Do not talk about host-player interactions. Also, any questions I answer will be what your alignment is privy to.
|
|
|
Okay, once JOAT uses *any* ability once, he becomes a vanilla. So LSB should have no more powers if he used an ability last night (which he claims).
I don't think gumshoe is particularly the most likely Mafia based on play. He was just as useless in GoT Mafia as town. I do agree that prplhz is less likely to be Mafia based on play (he would have bussed yamato+austin during D1, for example...). LSB is IMO the most likely Mafia based on night actions AND play so I see no reason not to lynch him. Now we also know that your plan is faulty so there's no role-based reason to spare LSB.
|
So let's consider the advantages of lynching LSB/gumshoe.
LSB:
+ Scummy play and scummy D1 vote
+ Most sensible role theory for N1 night actions as scum
+ gumshoe is probably getting modkilled anyways
gumshoe:
+ His death wouldn't at least lose us anything
+ His death would possibly reveal us more about the situation (if he's a normal Veteran, then either prplhz was lying or gumshoe was bus drived)
I say we do it like this:
1) Vote LSB for now
2) If gumshoe comes back just to ninja vote, we lynch him - otherwise he gets modkilled so no reason to lynch him
3) Lynch LSB/gumshoe
4) ????
5) profit!
I'm fine with a compromise like that. gumshoe has it coming if he just ninja votes once more.
|
I have no idea why gumshoe even signed up for this game though. I hope we would have had WotC or something to prevent it.
|
I'm a bit tempted to lynch gumshoe just so that he couldn't possibly win if he has some super OP role...
|
Although it makes no difference if he'll just be modkilled in any case.
|
gumshoe, get over here!!!
|
He's been very active in the other game today as well....
|
Alright, if it's one power once per game we lynch LSB
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/3S1fCxV.png)
