To Marv

I am only about 50 pages in so quick thoughts are this-

thrawn is very very likely town - Mafia are rarely going to fake claim this early and on top of that oftentimes millers are not self aware. Mafia wont know whether millers are self aware or not so to claim you are a self aware early on in thread is a huge gamble (if it turns out they arent self aware and one flips later on this could potentially be suicide).

I am actually a bit suspicious you just ignored this right after thrawn claimed but you didn't list him under your suspicious list at least so meh.

koshi/rayn both very likely town - both playing the exact same as previous games I have played with them as town.

doge- likely town, every pm game I play most of the people active in pms and trying to seek people out through skype are town. The fact that he is talking to you, he also pmd me right away, is something I don't think many mafia would do unless they were extremely confident in their play (assuming you are town). Your point about him still being suspicious of bh/hopeless is another thing that appear townie to me.

Scummy people

I haven't had a chance to talk to WoS or Yam in pms yet but both look bad to me. WoS's posts that I have read so far are wordy with very little content. Just seems like a lot of pointless fluff.

Yam - I can't really explain it but this is based on tone for me. The last big game with mayors I played with yam he ran for mayor and seemed so much more confident and his posts were way more direct and to the point. This game he starts out writing 10 paragraphs when he could have explained his thoughts in 2 and I don't see him being nearly as aggressive.

I would probably prefer if one of those 2 were lynched, but I imagine I am in the minority on that for now.

Cpt obvious I think would be a bad lynch candidate. He is putting 0 effort into appearing to look good, even after people have yelled at him about looking shitty. Strikes me as a bad/lazy townie.

Xat - I would be ok with a Xat lynch. I don't think his indignant pms to you really point to him being town. I haven't read the most recent stuff yet but his early posts to me seem hesitant and a lot of his early questions were pointless fluff.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 12 2014 22:39 GMT

#1443

Most of your posts are useless thrawn.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 13 2014 00:07 GMT

#1523

ezy pzy

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 13 2014 00:28 GMT

#1550

Bank when did you know you were replacing in?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 13 2014 00:54 GMT

#1565

Mafia was lynched and WoS is furious haha

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 13 2014 15:57 GMT

#1714

Unquestionably everyone should claim to marv. If you look at the marv/xata interactions around page 60 and then marv's hesitation to lynch him right before deadline, he would have to be a pretty godly actor to be mafia. By claiming to him he will be able to organize all the blues to use their powers correctly and will know who to pick as his bgs. Worst case scenario in the 1/1000 chance marv is somehow mafia we can always rethink things if all the blues start immediately dying, but seems very unlikely.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 13 2014 16:08 GMT

#1717

I talked to marv about this last night before sleeping and before anyone had posted it in the thread mocsta! Just echoing it incase some people were hesitant.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 13 2014 16:15 GMT

#1721

On January 13 2014 04:58 gumshoe wrote:
I'm fine with Marv as mayor, also I'm fine with xata dying regardless of my alignment because once he's out of the game I can stop lurking!

## Vote: Marvellosity

Why would xata dying make you not lurk gumshoe? Who are your scum reads now that he is dead?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 00:23 GMT

#1921

wtf there has to be some explanation, even if it is going to side track the game somewhat

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 00:53 GMT

#1969

In the future, why not just tell the masons in their role pm who their partners were. They didn't really need a mod made quick time.

As it is, what's done is done just have to go with it now.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:02 GMT

#1989

Making 3 players mod confirmed masons is a ridiculous thing in the first place honestly. Scum cant fake claim that ever. As soon as the 3 of them claimed it there was no way they were ever getting lynched. It would just be too improbable for scum to ever do it.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:05 GMT

#1995

at least you got your wish rayn!

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:07 GMT

#2001

I agree with marv that killing all 3 of them was unnecessary, the role was already ridiculous in this setup. So even if you confirm the other 2 mafia would be in a better place than they would have been otherwise.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:08 GMT

#2005

Anyway, lets just continue with the game. Nothing to do about it now.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:24 GMT

#2044

wtf..........

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:26 GMT

#2052

games over, the mason thing maybe I could deal with but missed doc coverage on top definitely too much.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:27 GMT

#2062

who were the mafia?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:36 GMT

#2102

marv had derrida pinned perfectly from 1 post haha, pretty solid job

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:37 GMT

#2106

BH I can't blame you, I love you too much.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 01:46 GMT

#2136

Coag would have been the ultimate bg.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 14 2014 02:04 GMT

#2174

Definitely tough for scum, kush who was playing really well gets himself banned on TL haha. BC wasn't around at all, derrida came in made the scummiest post possible and then replaced out.