|
On October 29 2013 19:20 Blazinghand wrote:
The worst part is i know how I would respond to a guy like me, I'd just lynch him. And I'd laugh at him and call him scum, and tell him IRL reasons don't mean anything and that he should use what time he has left alive to make some reads if he's really town. I hate other me, the me that's good at mafia, because I want to be him, and because he's merciless, and I can't be him. I can't be him now
Whats the difference between this spiel and Eccleston 2.0 in Smurf Mafia?
|
On October 29 2013 21:34 Hopeless1der wrote:I would say BH is fully aware that he shouldnt be posting that stuff. I recall a post of his from WhoseLine a while back where the endgame held this post: Show nested quote +On November 10 2012 03:33 Blazinghand wrote:
I never pay attention to IRL excuses under any circumstances. Easily lied about.
Edit: In a way, I almost consider talking about IRL excuses "cheating" in the sense that it's a non-defense that people for whatever reason accept. If I'm ever away from the thread for a period of time, I never give a reason for it. Mafia is about mafia, and that's it. I dont remember the context exactly but that BH would lynch our BH. Not because of the emotional posts, but because he's really scummy looking.
So why does this post from November 2012 count; yet, the posts LA produced of your opinion on Policy Lynching (as town) from 2012 do not count?
|
On October 29 2013 21:55 syllogism wrote:
If Bh is the mafia medic, I don' t understand who he was protecting on n1 unless he just didn't send in his action. None of the people still alive were likely n1 vig shots.
This question has been ringing in my head for days....
but everyone under pressure from Day1 has been lynched?
It is possible he forgot, but I have tried to not consider that.
|
Time to get the choo-choo started
##Vote: Skanjab
|
On October 29 2013 22:29 Onegu wrote:
Are we doing 24 hour days or not?
Where is your vote regardless?
|
On October 29 2013 22:37 Onegu wrote:
I will vote BH or Skan most likely since noone wants a HF lynch...
Im not sure why BH isnt automatic for you? I thought HF has said that you have been mildly suspicious of him all game?
|
Well I am not fussed right now, that only a handful have voted.
But when I wake up in say 10 Hrs, it would be good if people started putting their balls on the chopping block.
This is not the cycle for last minute vote-swap shenanigans.
|
On October 29 2013 23:07 syllogism wrote:
Mocsta: did Slytherin discuss how to use the polyjuice at all? What were people saying?
Its been very loose. You need a house majority to activate (so it has never activated)
(1) 23rd - Mocsta: Lets squib grack, as he may have lied about being VT
BH- is ok with this.
(2) 24th: Sn0 suggests to squib HolyFlare
Skanjab - Thinks squib HF is useless on justification he claimed secret vote, so does not guarantee it will block scum KP
(3)
28th - Mocsta: Squib Hopeless or BH. I suggest lack of "daethly hallows" follow up may be due to me conseq RB BH.
BH - Asks if i know what deathl hallows is and then says it may not be related because since he was RB there was no NK or lynches on scum
Skanjab - asks not to squib BH as the mods specified it wont stop a NK
|
On October 29 2013 23:24 syllogism wrote:
That's a terrible reason for not squibbing HF. Didn't Skanjab say that he has been playing mafia for quite a while? 24th was after the deathless night, so mafia having even more role based KP was clearly not likely.
Depending on the flip today we should absolutely do it due to his extra vote being a bigger potential threat to town than a potential advantage.
Well im 1 of 3 ppl. Only way to squib Skanjab or whoever, is if BH decides to vote with me.
Like I said,
who went after Skanjab early game pretty hard: Koshi + Toad
Who does pandain softly push.. Toad
Who does ET pick on when he first starts reading the game: Toad, followed by Koshi + Onegu
Now, maybe picking on Koshi could be considered chasing lynchbait.. but why Koshi over Skanjab?
Further, why go out of ya way to start with Toad, a damn decent mafia player.
|
Sure, I suppose we can figure out who to squib pending on who is lynched.
My preference is to lynch Skanjab and squib Hopeless1der.
I'm still not sold on his alignment notification potion; and he is relying on it *way* too hard to prove his innocence.
|
On October 29 2013 23:36 syllogism wrote:
What exactly would squibbing Hopeless1der do? Regardless of his alignment it seems extremely unlikely that he can do anything besides give away potions.
Hmmm, this closed setup is doing my head in. I keep thinking of the "deathly hallows".
Fair point you raise however.
Who do you propose?
|
On October 29 2013 23:49 syllogism wrote:
I just want to again emphasize that unless hosts are framing Holyflare, the polyjuice description confirms him as mafia. Yes, it says the person will only lose any magical powers, but it also says that squib is a vanilla townie or mafia goon. Ie. a person with no powers at all. A person with a hidden vote CAN NOT be a vanilla townie.
umm.
so this means Grack is scum too?
|
Wow. If Holyflare is scum he deserves a mafia award.. 20 page filter.. + convincing Day1.
Im going to sleep on this.
Issue with grack is due to Rayn candy.
Apparently he got roleblocked, which is only possible if he is not VT. (so I suppose not related in the squib sense)
|
On October 30 2013 08:19 Grackaroni wrote:
If HF is scum he is probably being bussed.
correct. onegu seems the most likely via approach.
question.
why did you insert *if*
last night you seem,ed confident in the squib slip?
|
On October 30 2013 06:10 Holyflare wrote:
So, just like the other people, you've ignored all the other evidence and just parked your vote on me? What about the other events in this thread. Sn0 just died and BH didn't get rb'd, what is your take on that?
Why aren't you contributing and why aren't you explaining your vote.
jat is correct.
the world is unfair and its YOU that needs to make the counter cases - the ones you keep promising, yet, do not deliver.
though I still disagree with how syllo approaches the game with this squib slip, he is correct in his assessment - that your responses are pretty scummy.
my vote this cycle is on you or skanjab.
|
On October 30 2013 08:31 Grackaroni wrote:Show nested quote +On October 30 2013 08:28 Mocsta wrote:On October 30 2013 08:19 Grackaroni wrote:
If HF is scum he is probably being bussed. correct. onegu seems the most likely via approach. question. why did you insert *if* last night you seem,ed confident in the squib slip? I don't think that was me. I'm kind of struggling with it right now. Leaning against lynching HF. ironic because we have swapped positions.
what has changed your mind?
|
|
|
On October 23 2013 05:01 You-Know-Who wrote:
VayneAuthority as Ginny Weasley has been modkilled.
You are Ginny Weasley. Your parents sent you to Hogwarts to educate you into a proper witch but it turns out you are a Squib.
On October 28 2013 05:00 You-Know-Who wrote:
Chairman Ray, as Anthony Goldstein, was lynched.
You are Anthony Goldstein. Your parents sent you to Hogwarts to educate you into a proper wizard but it turns out you are a Squib.
On October 20 2013 05:03 You-Know-Who wrote:
I-Be-Pro as Gregory Goyle was sent to St. Mungos!
You are Gregory Goyle. Your parents sent you to Hogwarts to educate you into a proper wizard but it turns out you are a Squib.
You and Crabbe are BFFs and therefore inseparable. If one of you dies, the other dies as well.
EchelonTee as Vincent Crabbe was sent to St. Mungos!
You are Vincent Crabbe. Being a beater of the Slytherin Quidditch team you are able to knock someone out with a Bludger. Your target will be hit for 0.5 KP. You have four Bludgers. Type ##Bludger: XY in the game to hit someone during day and PM the host with ##Bludger: XY to hit someone at night. You may hit two bludgers per cycle but only one per day and one per night at most.
Also, you and Goyle are BFFs and therefore inseparable. If one of you dies, the other dies as well.[/n]
(1) I expect Grack (if squib) to have an identical PM to the other 3 squibs (minus the blue component)
(2) As Syllo suggested, the blue (lovers bit) can be easily explained via Echelon Tea being the conjurer.
(3) The consistency of the Squib role PMs, highly suggest it is unlikely that a vote power is included.
[B]On October 23 2013 05:02 You-Know-Who wrote:
Polyjuice Potion- ... By forcing the drink onto a fellow student, you may transform him into a Squib. For one cycle, he will lose any magical powers he previously had. If he was town, he will turn into a Vanilla Townie. If he was mafia, he will turn into a Mafia Goon. To use the item, type ##Polyjuice in the QT.
Lastly,
If I was town and in your situation. I would be furious that people are trying to vote me off for something like this.
(The same could be said if scum too though, especially if playing a great game)
The thing is, as town, I would also be doing my best to answer the questions (respectfully) and then forcefully push should be lynched in my stead.
Your not doing this. Yes, you have your scum reads out in the open; but your approaching the game as if you are following a check-list - AND that is pretty scummy.
I am not sensing conviction: all you keep doing is purporting that XYZ is scum (and maybe you are bussing and they are scum); but I can't follow how you got there, because you are not providing any of that reasoning - AGAIN, that is pretty scummy.
A perfect example is Skanjab: he has not been a person of interest to you prior, and now suddenly he is in your final three. You also tried to phrase it NOT as an OMGUS, suggesting that before he voted you, you considered Skanjab scum. Maybe its in your filter, but I do not recall you trying to ascertain his alignment over people like Onegu etc.
Overall, if your power is true - it is of great risk of town or scum (as you are worth two of either alignment).
With a breakdown of 7-3; if we mislynch and assume 1 NK. We are down to 5-3.
If you are town, it is effectively 6-3.
If you are scum, it is effectively 5-4.
5-4 is a massive risk, as even now, town is not confident on how the 5 town is. That mislynch will seal the game (pending NKs).
|
##Unvote
##Vote: Holyflare
|
On October 18 2013 03:00 supersoft wrote:
one question are you a squib? On October 18 2013 03:04 Grackaroni wrote:
what a dumb question lol.[/QUOTE]The squib comment was addressed to me (with the SAM claim).
Considering you purport to be a squib; why is this a dumb question?
If anything, being a squib, I would not have expected you to role play as hard early-game as well.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
