Persona 4 Mini Mafia - Page 9

C) Hard defended multiple scummy people on flimsy meta reasons like "they play bad as town so they must be town"

On August 24 2013 01:49 VayneAuthority wrote:


no problem, in retrospect your survival instincts now make a lot of sense. I went to sleep before you breadcrumbed =/

I'd say onegu looks the worst coming out of this lynch, he was really up for anything between sn0_man and WOS. If sno man ever flips town at some point I think this guy should basically be an auto lynch.

On August 24 2013 02:18 Sn0_Man wrote:
Its hard to read you as town when you did literally no scumhunting D1, threw away your vote on somebody who obviously wasn't getting lynched AND never even tried to convince others to lynch him, made no case on him beyond "well you voted me and I warned you I'll vote you back" and are now calling him "insanely scummy" still without further justification. And are implying that you have done your job and that it certainly couldn't be even a fraction your fault that we just lynched a powerful blue role.

I'd love to hear some reasons why yamato is scummy. Preferably compare/contrast them to A) a confirmed red check and B) Actively driving a mislynch for ~70 hours.

On August 24 2013 02:21 Sn0_Man wrote:
Getting red checked = bad play.

The very act of taking the initiative to vote for somebody of his own accord is better than just sitting there waiting for somebody to vote you so you can vote them back.

On August 24 2013 02:29 Sn0_Man wrote:
I wouldn't mind lynching Koshi only its literally impossible for Koshi to be scum and rayn to be town unless: Koshi is scum, claimed Self Aware Miller, then got Framed to green by a scum ally so that (get this) any check on him would give away that he lied from the very start of the game.

Or I suppose rayn got framed to red or is a NSAM but I don't buy there being a SAM and NSAM in the same game and I don't buy a scumteam involving Koshi (who has yet to seriously disagree with rayn the entire game) FRAMING rayn. It would make koshi look bad if rayn gets red checked.

So basically as far as I'm concerned there is 0 reason to lynch Koshi over rayn.

On August 24 2013 02:49 Sn0_Man wrote:

Because the latter is not doing anything. Not doing anything defaults to mafia victory. I've explained this already. Town does not win by sitting on their ass and waiting for shit to go down.

On August 24 2013 02:51 Sn0_Man wrote:

I'd assume he was framed since nobody in their right minds claims SAM as a role that shows green to cop checks. That doesn't really affect his alignment. It would actually look good for Koshi since it seems unlikely that scum would frame themselves to green after claiming red.