Newbie Mini Mafia XLIV - Page 7

On July 15 2013 07:46 Koshi wrote:

THIS IS BULLSHIT


TOWN WE ARE GOING TO GET SO MUCH INFO WHEN WE LYNCH


THERE ARE ONLY 3 FUCKING SCUMS. A MISSLYNCH IS NOT BAD.




ARE YOU PEOPLE KIDDING ME? WE ALL AGREED THAT LYNCHING WAS GOOD. AND NOW CHROM WANTS TO PROTECT SUPER SO MADLY THAT A NO LYNHC IS OK?



WE AGREE THAT THEY BOTH LOOK SCUM. FUCK THIS

On July 15 2013 07:53 Hurricane Sponge wrote:
TRIBUNAL COMMENCE:

I'm leaning Super right now. One tiebreaker is activity level. Kirby has 3 1/2 pages of content vs. Super's 1 1/2.

My reads also line up better with Kirby. Super has some of the easiest, surface-level scum reads in the history of mankind. Guy who poked him early (Xzavier), guy leading his wagon (hzflank), and Lurkers. Not like, actual lurkers, but literally the word 'lurkers'. Didn't even name actual lurkers that he's suspicious of.

The koshi scum read is odd, but I'm willing to chalk that up to a mafia protecting his mafiabro in the event he flips red. If Super were to flip green, this interpretation would be moot.

On July 15 2013 07:58 Superfluous wrote:
I am giving examples, by day two there could be different people controlling the discussion anyway. A good player would know who to check, and a good mafia player would know to frame them so it doesnt change that much. There's a chance one of the newer players hasn't played cop much before and ends up doing a bad check. I care about cop cause it's the defining/most important town role and want to give good advice in case I die.

On July 13 2013 19:53 Gotard wrote:
Hello! After some lurking (jk I was sleeping) i'd like to share my thoughts:

1) hzflank - cold, calculated. Null read.
2) StiMaDDict - bad town. It would be too easy if he's mafia.
3) Chromatically - I think he's pushing stim too hard (he's agressive in general) but at the same time it's good for town to see some bandwagons going
4) jrkirby - confuses me a little.But he has a similar view on StiMaDDict as i do.

5) Koshi - inexperienced or lurking hard.
6) Xzavier - one good post

No wait, that one was good. Need to see some more activity from him to have a read. I don't agree that lynching lurker is better than no lynch (9v3 > 8v3)

7) Rainbows - A lot of posts with minimum impact seems more townie than mafia.
wtf?

8) Nightcat99 - lurking newbie.
9) Umasi - Very aggressive same as last game I played with him (He was town).
11) Hurricane Sponge - biggest town read. Really liked this post.
12) Superfluous - Town vibe.
13) cloud-9 - US timezone and 0 posts.

On July 13 2013 20:12 Gotard wrote:

Easy question. Umasi and Xzavier!!! (jk)

I'm really confused because my biggest (biggest doesn't mean that i'm really sure of anything) scum reads don't think that Stim is mafia. Maybe they don't want to vote on him because they know that this is too easy and don't want to jump on him that early.


He looks like a bad town not like mafia.

On July 13 2013 20:51 Gotard wrote:
Because it's obvious that he's mad that you think that he's mafia. I don't see any reasoning behind his posts except for being mad. Why would he write posts like that if he's mafia?

On July 13 2013 21:35 Gotard wrote:
But there was no reason for him to get mad if he's mafia.

On July 13 2013 22:41 Gotard wrote:
Yeah he looks bad or i should say useless for town. But you need to ask yourself "What would he gain with posts like that as mafia?". Bad town not mafia.

On July 14 2013 08:22 Gotard wrote:
Jrkirby looks like a better lynch than Superfluous right now.

Why not Superfluous? He isn't afraid to share his strong reads. His posts aren't full of useless crap (Hello Rainbows!) even when he isn't 100% right which concerns me. More pro town that jrkirby in general feel.

Why Jrkirby? I don't see him making pro town content. His post claiming that hzflank is mafia was awkward and then he defended himself saying that it was only a joke/pressure combo. Then posing useless lurker list (seems like every newbie game needs one). But as far as his interaction with stim goes I think you are overthinking it.

##vote: jrkirby.

On July 15 2013 08:15 Xzavier wrote:
what could would either of them claiming do? if you claim 15 min before you die your probably still goign to die anyway, its like when in the movies you hold a gun to somebodys head and they start spewing off how they will do anything, give anything, blahblahblah. same principle.

i honestly am so lost right now, i think super is a fine lynch. But im not following this tribunal at all, it appears to have formed during my 25 min game of LoL.. T.T

is the tribunal the hammer that was going to hit gotard really close before the end?

On July 15 2013 08:16 jrkirby wrote:

Oh wait, I am pretty close. But anyway, if I'm blue, you'll know it on the flip.

On July 15 2013 08:41 hzflank wrote:
People should not think about what happens if someone flips scum. If someone flips scum then that is a win, plain and simple.

Considering what happens if someone flips town hold more weight, although with 13 people still in the game even that is WIFOM.

I suggest just asking yourselves: Of all the players we could possibly hope to lynch today, who is the most likely to flip scum?