Newbie Mini Mafia XLIV - Page 2

On July 15 2013 03:39 Koshi wrote:

I have no interest in doing so. I am also bored with the fact that we need to keep making our own giant posts to get completely ignored by your tunneling on Kirby.
If you don't agree with me that both players look scummy atm but Kirby might be easier to read in Day 2 because he posts more and is more aggressive. Then we don't have much to discuss.

If there are 6 votes on Kirby expect me to give the 7th.
But for now I believe Super is the best choice.

On July 15 2013 04:01 Koshi wrote:
Staying alive is not important at all. Vanilla Townies are here to post as much as they can, make as much sense as they can, do as much scumreading as they can. And then die with full glory in the night.

On July 15 2013 05:13 Rainbows wrote:


I lied this describes Gotard better.

My votes on super but I really dont care who's lynched between the two. #Scummylogic

On July 15 2013 14:14 Umasi wrote:


Why's that? I actually thought that post was pretty awesome.
I don't necessarily AGREE with it, but I sure liked it :3

On July 15 2013 05:35 Rainbows wrote:
unvote
vote: jrkirby

cus chrom said so

On July 15 2013 05:50 jrkirby wrote:
Well, superfluous is probably going to vote me, and I'll die.

So, reads:

hzflank and chromatically seem town.

Koshi, xzavier seem a bit scummy, not a bad choice.

cloud-9 is probably going to get replaced, no info on him.

nightcat might come back and be worth something, I wish he had realized he couldn't commit to this. Nullread.

Rainbows sounds pretty town to me too.

Hurricane is someone you should take a close look at, it's hard to tell. He might not be the best lynch tomorrow.

Umasi i don't have a good read on, neither stim.

Gotard would be an excellent lynch tomorrow if I die.

On July 15 2013 06:09 Rainbows wrote:
dude i have no idea kirby. My gut actually says you're town LOL.

Im prolly going to change my mind again anyway. I never really read all of what chrom was saying because i dont have time. Patience.

On July 15 2013 07:30 Hurricane Sponge wrote:


You mentioned that, and that's why this is sort of an unholy alliance. Even though the odds are staggeringly in your favor, I would actually be more inclined to believe they were both scum rather than both town. I feel like I have a decent eye for town-on-town crime, although to be fair, kirby and super haven't been sniping at each other NEARLY enough for my taste.

Regardless, this is good news. Now we just need Umasi to confirm he finds both players scummy, and we can decide this lynch.

On July 15 2013 07:24 Hurricane Sponge wrote:
@ Umasi
@ Rainbows

We three control this lynch. I think everyone else is entrenched (via either conviction or inactivity). If you agree, we need to establish some things between the three of us.

First, do we all agree that both of the current wagons are acceptable lynch candidates?

On July 15 2013 07:48 Rainbows wrote:
Scum are the quiet ones. 100%.

Lynch Gotard last hour of game :o

On July 13 2013 21:54 Koshi wrote:
I am from Belgium guys, This game started at 12PM and I was tired after a working week.
I read the thread once now and my initial (this is without using filters, just reading all the posts) is that H.Sponge build enough town kred to not get lynched day 1 no matter what. I loved his opening post, and I loved his defense on that post. Even if he is scum, he has been very helpful to town, and every town should go and read that opening post.
Scum reads are on Umasi and Chroma.
Umasi because his entire early posts were just sucking up to H.Sponge, which is just not useful at all, H. Sponge clearly doesn't need to be defended like this. Another thing I dont like about Umasi is him trying to redirect the thread twice for a Superfluous train on a rather useless moment. Superfluous entered the thread with a bad post, but went afk after, which is not a clear scumread. Not enough the get a train going, and make the rest of the day useless.
Chroma is currently tunneling so heavily on StiMaDDict. The guy is afk, treat him as an afk bad town till he comes back. It is a good thing to spark some conversation around StiMaDDict, but at this point I feel that Chroma is derailing more than necessarily. It's just tunneling into oblivion.

I start filtering now:
Reading Chroma his filter I get a serious scum vibe. Post like this:

This is just being a jack-ass, at least it would be if you say things like this in real life. In mafia it is trying to put suspicion onto somebody without saying anything. I haven't crosschecked this message with the referring Sponge message but it feels dirty. What was your intention while typing this down Chromo?
@ Chromo, Do you agree that this is a very suspicious post? And explain to me why it is "interesting" that Sponge likes to have interaction on his scumreads while playing this game?

Reading Umasi his filter after the Chroma filter makes me want to lynch one of these 2 guys. Umasi and Chroma are either bromancing it up on the stimaddict lynch, or they are both scum. Here is Umasi his game till now:
--> Defend Sponge while pushing lynch on Superfluous.
--> Argue with Sponge about Chroma while pusing a lynch on StiMaDDict.

On July 14 2013 07:11 Koshi wrote:
@hzflank
That is a really impressing post. I would give you a cookie but I will give you this instead.
##Vote: Superfluous

I also like the kirby case but kirby hasn't posted in the last 20 hours. So I am reluctant to put my vote on him. Kirby has proven that he can make big analytical posts or at least is willing to do so. He has proven that he can pick up on 1 scummier sentence in a big convincing pro town post. So I would like to give kirby the chance to do this before I put my vote on him.

On July 14 2013 08:07 Koshi wrote:
I am not leaning Town on kirby AT ALL. But I am saying that I like the Super case much better. If there was a lynch right now I would go:
1) Super
2) kirby
3) Gotard
4) no lynch unless everybody really wants Stim.

On July 15 2013 00:10 Koshi wrote:
Guys, we need to get our shit together if we want a lynch. Don't forget we need at least 7 people on 1 guy. Both look perfect targets, let's try to come to a consensus now so that the more inactive people can follow us if they pop in.

I would say that Sponge and Umasi try to work this out and they give us final target? It seems that Chroma made the kirby case and that hzflank made the super case.

Me, StiM and all others should FOLLOW lead.

On July 15 2013 03:39 Koshi wrote:

I have no interest in doing so. I am also bored with the fact that we need to keep making our own giant posts to get completely ignored by your tunneling on Kirby.
If you don't agree with me that both players look scummy atm but Kirby might be easier to read in Day 2 because he posts more and is more aggressive. Then we don't have much to discuss.

If there are 6 votes on Kirby expect me to give the 7th.
But for now I believe Super is the best choice.

On July 15 2013 04:01 Koshi wrote:
Staying alive is not important at all. Vanilla Townies are here to post as much as they can, make as much sense as they can, do as much scumreading as they can. And then die with full glory in the night.

On July 15 2013 06:15 Koshi wrote:

lol? look at any other game. Sheeping is not allowed. My last post in the Nuclear Mafia game is " Guys I will follow you on X because I believe you". The answer that I got "Don't sheep, make your case if you follow".

On July 15 2013 07:46 Koshi wrote:

THIS IS BULLSHIT


TOWN WE ARE GOING TO GET SO MUCH INFO WHEN WE LYNCH


THERE ARE ONLY 3 FUCKING SCUMS. A MISSLYNCH IS NOT BAD.




ARE YOU PEOPLE KIDDING ME? WE ALL AGREED THAT LYNCHING WAS GOOD. AND NOW CHROM WANTS TO PROTECT SUPER SO MADLY THAT A NO LYNHC IS OK?



WE AGREE THAT THEY BOTH LOOK SCUM. FUCK THIS

On July 15 2013 08:06 Koshi wrote:
I am just going to trow this out here. But with a pending superfluous lynch. Do we want to see superfluous roleclaim? If he claims blue we might want to let him stay alive? It is up to scum to kill him tonight? Or not?

I realize fluff is fluff but maybe we want this to happen?

On July 15 2013 09:00 Koshi wrote:

IF YOU COULDN'T SEE THAT HE WAS USEFUL THE ENTIRE FUCKING GAME I QUESTION YOUR SANITY

On July 15 2013 11:38 Koshi wrote:

The circle was something silly. I have no reads there. They did nothing, except made themselves special.

On July 15 2013 11:44 Koshi wrote:

The counsil were considered townreads. It isn't a problem to sheep your townreads when you have a hard time following.

On July 15 2013 18:50 Gotard wrote:
Hi Onegu. Nice to see ya!

Chromatically - For me he looks more like a town that mafia. He tends to put himself in a headlights by creating wagons and defending them really strongly with no fear (but sometimes he's tunneling himself like when he was pressuring Stim). In 'The Super Case' he brought good points and made some more room for discussion. Would he make such a strong defense to save his scum buddy? I don't thing so because after Super flipping scum he would be in a big trouble. Pushing lynch isn't scummy if you have good points and your target barely shows and signs of life innocence.


Hurricane ensured lynch that day. Everyone agreed that both of them are super scummy. I think leadership like that is useful when you need majority to lynch. His posts are super pro town in general and leading town like that even in wrong direction isn't scummy to me.

Koshi - reading comprehension... I will address him later after reading his filter.

On July 15 2013 04:01 Koshi wrote:
Staying alive is not important at all. Vanilla Townies are here to post as much as they can, make as much sense as they can, do as much scumreading as they can. And then die with full glory in the night.

On July 15 2013 19:18 Koshi wrote:
Do I have to reply somewhere?

On July 15 2013 19:25 Koshi wrote:

No I mean, do you have question for me? You are just analysing the bad parts in my log, ignoring some other things.
The question is? Are the points that you just summed up me being scum? Or is it just me being me?

I am saying the same thing as you. Vanilla Townies should do their best during day and then die from a KP.

On July 15 2013 16:27 Koshi wrote:


@Onegu

Can you please comment on this post by Chroma? I don't want you to comment solely on Chroma, but give your own opinion on the different parts of it.

1)One of Super or Koshi is scum
a) Multiple times Chroma said Super wasn't scum, kirby flip shouldn't affect this. Your opinion?
b) Why is it Super or Koshi? What is the connection between us?

2) Koshi's hard defense of Kirby with little reasoning looks like it could be scum trying to get town cred from a town flip.
a) Do you agree that superfluou would have been a better lynch over kirby? Why? I think that kirby could have been more useful and easier to read Day 2.