EPTOn July 08 2013 16:50 CaucasianAsian wrote:
Previous
+ Show Spoiler +
Continuing
MajuGarzett
+ Show Spoiler +
Doesn’t post much, but from the few posts he has made, seems to be doing some actual analysis. Although he is inactive, he currently doesn’t seem as scummy or bad townie as other inactives. Should be looked at closely, and made sure that he continues to post again, but I’m not too worried about him yet
Johnnywup
+ Show Spoiler +
He never posted before that he needs to nuke in order to survive. If that were the case, I am starting to understand why he is bad for the town. Not only is his basis to target TanGeng absolutely absurd, when there are many other inactives (I myself was very inactive) who fit into the same line.
Also, I cannot assume that a town role forces you to nuke someone. If he is forced to nuke someone every day, and he is not lying, then that’s simply bad for town. It’s very risky.
Also, he votes for WaveofShadow, and Dandel Ion
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=420340&user=johnnywup
His basis is that Dandel Ion is scummier than WaveOfShadow.
Onegu
+ Show Spoiler +
VayneAuthority
+ Show Spoiler +
I have a similar feeling to VayneAuthority as I do to Onegu. Even though he has less filler posts, he seems to be doing decent analysis. Despite the whole thing of me being drunk and thus that’s a sign of mafia, he’s not looking to be pro-scum from my point of view thus far. He does seem to be lynch happy, but ok. There are people much higher up on my radar currently.
strongandbig
+ Show Spoiler +
gunshoe
+ Show Spoiler +
Will continue later, need to study for class.
Previous
+ Show Spoiler +
On July 08 2013 14:59 CaucasianAsian wrote:
i have to go eat. will continue later today
Dandel Ion
+ Show Spoiler +
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=418049&user=Dandel Ion
So he posts a bunch of filler, and then states that he won’t be beneficial at all to town. Fair enough, so point blank, he has posted a refusal to not help town.
ghost_403
+ Show Spoiler +
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=418049&user=ghost_403
Lurker, very few posts. Not beneficial
Oatsmaster
+ Show Spoiler +
Stutters695
+ Show Spoiler +
Filler, not being beneficial
Z-BosoN
+ Show Spoiler +
Abenson
+ Show Spoiler +
Meapak_Ziphh
+ Show Spoiler +
Ace
+ Show Spoiler +
i have to go eat. will continue later today
Dandel Ion
+ Show Spoiler +
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=418049&user=Dandel Ion
On July 07 2013 07:12 Dandel Ion wrote:
Also, in an concentrated effort to prepare for sicilian mafia (for which I'm not actually signed up for, but you can never know), I'll stop posting for the dayphase, and only vote from now on.
Also, in an concentrated effort to prepare for sicilian mafia (for which I'm not actually signed up for, but you can never know), I'll stop posting for the dayphase, and only vote from now on.
So he posts a bunch of filler, and then states that he won’t be beneficial at all to town. Fair enough, so point blank, he has posted a refusal to not help town.
ghost_403
+ Show Spoiler +
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=418049&user=ghost_403
Lurker, very few posts. Not beneficial
Oatsmaster
+ Show Spoiler +
All his limited posts are pretty much filler, doing nothing beneficial to town.
Stutters695
+ Show Spoiler +
Filler, not being beneficial
Z-BosoN
+ Show Spoiler +
Pretty boring, not beneficial as of yet
Abenson
+ Show Spoiler +
He claims to have unvoted for Johnny here:
Yet, he never even voted, as can see here: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=418049&user=Abenson
Beyond that confusing post, not beneficial
On July 08 2013 12:31 Abenson wrote:
Anyways I've unvoted from Johnny since although he looks kinda suspicious, it might be just newbie town. I think we can pay attention to him but not lynch him right away.
Gonna vote Chez. Interested to see what he flips and what motivated him to throw that nuke
Anyways I've unvoted from Johnny since although he looks kinda suspicious, it might be just newbie town. I think we can pay attention to him but not lynch him right away.
Gonna vote Chez. Interested to see what he flips and what motivated him to throw that nuke
Yet, he never even voted, as can see here: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=418049&user=Abenson
Beyond that confusing post, not beneficial
Meapak_Ziphh
+ Show Spoiler +
Unfortunately he is being nuked by someone who didn’t claim it. As Xatalos stated here: + Show Spoiler +
There is no reason for a townie to randomly nuke someone so early on with very little reads. This makes me assume that he is town, and it is probably a scum nuke. Unfortunately we won’t be able to see him for much longer.
On July 07 2013 20:00 Xatalos wrote:
Looks like I'm still alive. Although after re-reading the rules, it's not that surprising:
So:
1) apparently every nuke will hit at the deadline, not before or after that time
2) there are different types of nukes
I can say that I'm immune to one type of nuke, but clearly I'm still in danger of death, since I don't know which type of nuke Chezinu launched at me. Ultimately it will be resolved at the deadline. If someone wants to use an anti-nuke or something, feel free to do so, although I can't be certain if it's necessary or not.
Chezinu, if you are town, I'd like to hear your reasoning for launching a nuke at me and the type of that nuke.
This at least proves that nukes don't necessarily have to be claimed. Dunno if Chezinu's nuke required claiming, but there's at least a strong possibility that he claimed it without needing to. That makes him look more townish IMO - why claim if my town flip would just put him in a tough spot as scum?
On the other hand, nobody claiming this nuke aimed at Meapak makes it likely a scum nuke... And Meapak town based on that.
Is that an actual read? If so, why?
Looks like I'm still alive. Although after re-reading the rules, it's not that surprising:
So:
1) apparently every nuke will hit at the deadline, not before or after that time
2) there are different types of nukes
I can say that I'm immune to one type of nuke, but clearly I'm still in danger of death, since I don't know which type of nuke Chezinu launched at me. Ultimately it will be resolved at the deadline. If someone wants to use an anti-nuke or something, feel free to do so, although I can't be certain if it's necessary or not.
Chezinu, if you are town, I'd like to hear your reasoning for launching a nuke at me and the type of that nuke.
![[image loading]](http://strikefighterconsultinginc.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/url13.jpg)
This at least proves that nukes don't necessarily have to be claimed. Dunno if Chezinu's nuke required claiming, but there's at least a strong possibility that he claimed it without needing to. That makes him look more townish IMO - why claim if my town flip would just put him in a tough spot as scum?
On the other hand, nobody claiming this nuke aimed at Meapak makes it likely a scum nuke... And Meapak town based on that.
Is that an actual read? If so, why?
There is no reason for a townie to randomly nuke someone so early on with very little reads. This makes me assume that he is town, and it is probably a scum nuke. Unfortunately we won’t be able to see him for much longer.
Ace
+ Show Spoiler +
The first person to actually be posting so far down this list (with the exception of Meapak who is unfortunately being nuked). To say that he is mafia or town is hard at the moment. After all, it’s still Day 1, and there is very little information to go off of. Although as everyone seems to be on the right page, people not talking are simply bad for town, and it’s good that he is saying something, town or mafia, as if he’s town we will be able to understand that through his future posts / voting / nuking (?) and if he is mafia, we will be able to see flaws in his logic and patterns through posts / voting / nuking (?)
Continuing
MajuGarzett
+ Show Spoiler +
Doesn’t post much, but from the few posts he has made, seems to be doing some actual analysis. Although he is inactive, he currently doesn’t seem as scummy or bad townie as other inactives. Should be looked at closely, and made sure that he continues to post again, but I’m not too worried about him yet
Johnnywup
+ Show Spoiler +
On July 07 2013 23:59 johnnywup wrote:
I don't like TanGeng because for one thing he hopped on my bandwagon right after WoS wanted to start it...and he also hasn't said much. He's just been...there. He hasn't said anything of value.
I don't like TanGeng because for one thing he hopped on my bandwagon right after WoS wanted to start it...and he also hasn't said much. He's just been...there. He hasn't said anything of value.
On July 08 2013 14:09 johnnywup wrote:
Guys. I don't have much time left. I need to nuke someone to live. I'm getting a scummy read out of TanGeng. He's one I feel is most likely scum... So there you go.
##nuke TanGeng
I will not be able to change this.
Additionally, I am going to vote for Dandel Ion for now. Of the inactives, he seems most likely scum. I can change this in the morning if I feel like it, and I don't think a chez lynch is the best idea right now, and he seems to be gaining the most traction. I don't support that. So I'm voting for a new candidate which I think most people can agree on lynching on if it comes to it.
Guys. I don't have much time left. I need to nuke someone to live. I'm getting a scummy read out of TanGeng. He's one I feel is most likely scum... So there you go.
##nuke TanGeng
I will not be able to change this.
Additionally, I am going to vote for Dandel Ion for now. Of the inactives, he seems most likely scum. I can change this in the morning if I feel like it, and I don't think a chez lynch is the best idea right now, and he seems to be gaining the most traction. I don't support that. So I'm voting for a new candidate which I think most people can agree on lynching on if it comes to it.
He never posted before that he needs to nuke in order to survive. If that were the case, I am starting to understand why he is bad for the town. Not only is his basis to target TanGeng absolutely absurd, when there are many other inactives (I myself was very inactive) who fit into the same line.
Also, I cannot assume that a town role forces you to nuke someone. If he is forced to nuke someone every day, and he is not lying, then that’s simply bad for town. It’s very risky.
Also, he votes for WaveofShadow, and Dandel Ion
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=420340&user=johnnywup
His basis is that Dandel Ion is scummier than WaveOfShadow.
Onegu
+ Show Spoiler +
So right off the bat, before I even start to say anything. I want to note that MajuGarzett votes for him. As I stated earlier, I don’t feel as if MajuGarzett is very scummy yet.
Overall, even though I’m not a big fan of Onegu, he hasn’t done anything way out of the ordinary that would quantify him as being mafia, or town yet. I feel very neutral on him.
He continues to say that I’m a scummy lurker. I can understand why people would assume I’m a lurker. I’ll defend this once I get to me on the list.
But honestly, he seems to be proactive. I don’t see any hardcore basis behind lynching him yet, unless I want to go about a pride thing. But he gives me a more townie feel to be honest.
Overall, even though I’m not a big fan of Onegu, he hasn’t done anything way out of the ordinary that would quantify him as being mafia, or town yet. I feel very neutral on him.
He continues to say that I’m a scummy lurker. I can understand why people would assume I’m a lurker. I’ll defend this once I get to me on the list.
But honestly, he seems to be proactive. I don’t see any hardcore basis behind lynching him yet, unless I want to go about a pride thing. But he gives me a more townie feel to be honest.
VayneAuthority
+ Show Spoiler +
I have a similar feeling to VayneAuthority as I do to Onegu. Even though he has less filler posts, he seems to be doing decent analysis. Despite the whole thing of me being drunk and thus that’s a sign of mafia, he’s not looking to be pro-scum from my point of view thus far. He does seem to be lynch happy, but ok. There are people much higher up on my radar currently.
strongandbig
+ Show Spoiler +
Very inactive, and blames 2 people that they look scummy. He is really sitting in the corner, showing he is watching the thread (with his 2 random suspicion posts) and not being beneficial to town at all.
gunshoe
+ Show Spoiler +
Almost every single one of his posts are filled with fluff. Not being productive at all.
Will continue later, need to study for class.
First are you sure you were looking at my filter because I never mention you let alone say you are a scummy lurker.
I agree with your thoughts on Johnny though, it just seemed convienent that he only posts he has to fire a nuke after chez says he had to fire his. Just seems like a easy way to fire his at someone on geripts list, especially if he has multiple nukes.
Also he never says why dandol is scummier just odd.
