|
On June 06 2013 21:55 Onegu wrote: The strongest read I have is on iVlosk as town t this point, but a wish he would curse less. Prettier faces than you have tried and failed to address that, my friend. I got no clout, small bank, but a big mouth.
|
On June 06 2013 10:45 Umasi wrote: hey everyone, I have no idea how to get a game started. Let's a gogo? Should I put a vote on someone? Carefully analyzed? ##VOTE LoneMeow
On June 06 2013 10:51 Umasi wrote: ##UNVOTE LONEMEOW Umasi, take me through your thought process here.
Why the random vote? Was it to "get the ball rolling?"
And if so, why remove it 6 minutes later, leaving the ball completely unrolled.
|
So I'm bad because I'm abrasive and Yavanna is bad for the opposite reason?
|
On June 07 2013 03:43 Skanjab1s wrote:Show nested quote +On June 07 2013 03:31 Spicydinosaur wrote: @Skanjab1s what do you make of firere345's asking the mods about a jester? Do you feel its newbie town or scum? I'd think that a newbie town would have read the rules quite carefully and would know that kind of thing, so added with his sheeping onto iV for a really terrible reason, I'm leaning scum. I do want to hear more from him though. Could just be someone who said "FUK DA ROOLZ," like myself.
|
Just had a decent look at the filters. That filter link is nice as f#%! I wish we had one where I come from.
Anyways, there are 2 people who haven't even posted since the game started. tE (or whatever) and StimmAddict. Now, T has just one post in the whole thread, his "/in" post and that's it. Pretty clearly someone who just signed up and fucked off. Probably going to be modkilled. Pay no mind.
But the other one, StimmAddict is a little more interesting. Go read his filter. Super interested, super involved prior to the game starting. Posts about how excited he is in the day leading up to the game. Even adds a "Gl Hf" post mere hours before the game starts. But is completely silent now that roles have been sent out.
Just something interesting I found during my lunch break.
|
Well. It's been 24 hours, I am going to monitor the situation with Gotard, but for now I'm going to stick my vote on Stimm. I had the dumbest rationale for picking a vote in my first game. The guy had used his name but excluded all the vowels, (brndnstffrd). I was town, and I voted for him. Because he was a vowel hater. Not a joke.
##Unvote ##Vote: StimmAddict
|
I like it.
##Unvote ##Vote: Gotard
|
The "why would I...?" Argument doesn't work because its completely dependent on you telling us what your actions mean and what your motivations are.
If I had replied to your early game pressure with "Why would I so clearly not give a fuck as scum?" I'd probably be the lynch. And I'd deserve it. Because its an awful defense. And it makes me want to lynch you.
|
If I could lynch 3 people in order right now:
Gotard Umasi That guy whose name is like frefre or something. I dunno.
|
|
On June 08 2013 00:48 Umasi wrote: Onegu, I found what iV was doing scummy and it turned out he was just being an asshole.
It's been explained to you over and over why I play like this. If you want to call it being an asshole, that's fine. But it brought 3-4 players who are now clear reads into the light for me. I'll take that over coming in and being nice to you and gaining nothing from it, any day.
When you call "getting a read on me" "being an asshole," it makes me think that maybe you don't want me to get a read on you.
|
On June 08 2013 01:03 Spicydinosaur wrote:Skanjab is not going to be lynched today barring some huge slip on his part. Right now the votes are between you and Firere345. If you don't want to get lynch you should make a miraculous case and get your vote on Firere345. Yeah we're not lynching skanjab today. As someone who has played with him as scum and as town, I can say that with some confidence.
On June 08 2013 01:03 Skanjab1s wrote: I'm getting worried about this Gotard lynch because most of my scummier reads are voting him, and my townier reads are voting Firere (barring iV). It's cool. I've having some second thoughts.
Yeah, let's do this. I'm missing boxing for this.
##Unvote ##Vote: Firere
|
On June 08 2013 01:42 fferyllt wrote: Hey iVL I'd like to hear your thoughts about Yavannah. You're both in my neverlynch pile and you are game-savvy so you're a player I'd be willing to test my reads with.
Asking good questions, responded well to Umasi saying she was "suspiciously nice". Exploring good avenues that I hadn't even thought of with questioning and logical thought.
Calls her pressure vote a pressure vote. A vote stops being pressure the moment you call it that. Noobie mistake, I'd say.
Has dropped off of the map recently.
Likely town.
|
On June 08 2013 01:55 Onegu wrote: Just so you guys know I will be sleeping in the next 2 hours. Iv can you give a good reason for conforming to votes for your last 2 votes please. I would like to see if firere comes back and offers some more reasoning and defense. Xzav and yavannah what are your thoughts on skan, firere, and umasi? EVeryone conforms to votes unless you're the very first person to vote for a player. In a game of 13 people a majority vote might be 7 players. Does that mean 6 players are scummy for following what that guy said?
I've been fairly active and outspoken in saying that all of the people I've jumped to and from are on my scumdar.
See below,
On June 07 2013 13:55 iVLosK! wrote: If I could lynch 3 people in order right now:
Gotard Umasi That guy whose name is like frefre or something. I dunno. The fact that I'm jumping between 3 people who I said I wanted to lynch based on new posts coming from each of them isn't really all that surprising.
|
On June 08 2013 02:07 fferyllt wrote:Show nested quote +On June 08 2013 02:00 iVLosK! wrote:On June 08 2013 01:42 fferyllt wrote: Hey iVL I'd like to hear your thoughts about Yavannah. You're both in my neverlynch pile and you are game-savvy so you're a player I'd be willing to test my reads with.
Asking good questions, responded well to Umasi saying she was "suspiciously nice". Exploring good avenues that I hadn't even thought of with questioning and logical thought. Calls her pressure vote a pressure vote. A vote stops being pressure the moment you call it that. Noobie mistake, I'd say. Has dropped off of the map recently. Likely town. Maybe. I thought the questions lacked followt hrough, but that could be newb too. I pointed out the futility of indicating votes are for pressure purposes when SpicyDinosaur (I think that's who...not going to check) posted something similar about pressuring lurkers quite early in the game, though. Maybe that comment would stand out as something not to do to newb scum more than to newb town. Noted, and thanks. Not to say that scum can't ask questions. But I just don't see those kind of questions coming from a scum player whose never played a game of mafia before.
|
On June 08 2013 02:12 Xzavier wrote: also i think fferyllt is 100% town. biggest town read by far. Just gonna put that here somewhere. He has explained actions, clarified everything for people. generally done a shit-ton of work to make this a much better pro-town environment. Keeping your town reads to yourself whenever possible keeps your buddies alive longer.
You just explained to mafia why they should kill her tonight.
|
On June 08 2013 02:47 fferyllt wrote:Show nested quote +On June 08 2013 02:29 Xzavier wrote:On June 08 2013 02:14 fferyllt wrote:On June 08 2013 02:05 Xzavier wrote: im okay with lynching either one of them today. Firere or gotard.
i have work from 2-8 today (i leave 30 min from now) so im not gonna b able to make lengthy posts, i can explain the reasoning for my vote (if i do switch it)
but right now if gotard isnt mafia, he needs to grow a pair. He made his first constructive post, then didnt even vote for the most scummy person on his list? or one of the current possible bandwagons. Thats weird to me.
but since he has appeared like hes slowly but surely posting more (however scumlike it is) it means we can kill him later if need be on even stronger evidence.
yavannah is newbie as fuck. probably harmless town. wouldnt hurt for her to post more.
iV is troll-town(probably VT)
spicey dinosoar is somebody i was suspicious of for a good amount, but idk. not much he has said makes me think scum. and what he says makes logical sense, thats more than i can say about half of this thread T.T
skanjab isnt on any of my lists, he puts thought into his actions, and i think there are much better people to lynch right now. and i havnt actually looked at his filter yet.
The bolded was a dumb thing to post. i had to quote this to find where you bolded. and got it, dont post who your positive is town. check. this is one big learning experience. Remind me to revisit this in the postgame discussion if I don't bring it up. No.
|
On June 08 2013 03:41 fferyllt wrote: knock yourself out. Skanjab gave a good enough short answer. Wut?
|
For someone who didn't read, that's not an awful case. Finish reading and see if your thoughts change any.
|
I have a wedding to attend this evening and pool to shoot afterwards so I won't be around for flip. Probably won't check in until tomorrow, as my phone doesn't have internet capabilities anymore.
|
|
|
|