|
On November 26 2012 15:30 syllogism wrote:
Oh ok, so outing marv's action and the fact he has a role helps town, but you revealing your role name does not. You seem more worried about claiming your role name than your powers
I did not believe that Marv was town and wanted to make sure town knew that he targeted you. Do you really think that there is anyone in this game without a role?
I have claimed one of my powers. By doing so we know what power was used on you n1 by mafia.
|
Also, when did you get to be this dumb? There is no mafia motivation for my play and there are people who are very scummy. Why are you focused on me when there are actual scum to hunt. Tunneling me doesn't serve any useful purpose for town Syllo. What are you hoping to gain from this?
|
why do you want to know it?
|
and if it is so obvious why do you need me to claim it?
|
I'm having trouble here, your play is not that of a good player right now. I don't get it.
Hypothetical situation where I am what you think I am:
If it is so obvious what I claimed I don't need to outright say it for the mafia safe claim to be gone. If someone else comes down after I'm dead and have flipped red saying "oh yeah I'm Ayla" or whatever role it is which I have obviously crumbed you could just point that out and kill them.
|
heading out for a bit, back on soon.
|
Man Syllo you sure managed to reply to my concerns in the last 45 minutes I've been gone. Glad to see you living up to your reputation as a good player.
keir: hey mang! Do you feel that Acro's refusal to give his reasoning on being included in the party is a scum or a town tell?
|
cool beans Oats, when did you change your name to Kier? Being a dick aside, I ask you (Oats) if you think that, in that case, all of the players on the quests are confirmed as town?
|
I would like everyone's opinion but I was asking Kier because he is the player most intimately involved in this besides Acro. I wanted his opinion unadulterated by the other players in the game but ah well, I don't get everything I want (like Syllo to stop being dumb).
See, I think you are town. I really do. I just don't get how you come to some of the conclusions you come to. I disagree with you whole heartedly.
|
On November 26 2012 16:45 syllogism wrote:
Prom: for future reference, it's not a good strategy to berate me in every post, especially given what happened on day 1 and 2. That and telling fewer unnecessary lies should help in your future endeavours.
for present reference not being dumb will help you with this game. I have told no unnecessary lies, the only person I lied to was Sandroba and we gained information from that.
Thanks Kier, I find the whole thing a null tell (though totally weird) and my town read on Acro stands however I never want him included in a party. No matter what he claims later.
|
Syllo, you referenced "what happened d1 and d2" do you mean the success of the party and sand's lynch? Do you believe that since the party was successful the members (in this case you) must be town?
|
Dieno: could you tell us what you infer from your crazy maps? Those help us as much as me posting a list of player names with everyone shaded a different shade of purple. It probably means something to me but you have no idea what.
|
Risk: no comments on the last 14 hours?
|
On November 26 2012 18:52 risk.nuke wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 18:50 Promethelax wrote:
Dieno: could you tell us what you infer from your crazy maps? Those help us as much as me posting a list of player names with everyone shaded a different shade of purple. It probably means something to me but you have no idea what. It's more simmilar to posting bad/useless lists. Except worse.
I think it has gone past that to totally meaningless. That is why I want his conclusions. If ntohing else they are good for a laugh.
|
On November 26 2012 18:56 risk.nuke wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 18:51 Promethelax wrote:
Risk: no comments on the last 14 hours? I'm in school, I've only briefly read through the thread as I ate breakfast, didn't see anything I felt like commenting on. Feel free to ask me something you want me to comment on, it will serve to motivate me to actually have a closer look at it.
In a rather selfish way I'd like you to look at Syllo's scum read of me. I don't see where it comes from at all and he hasn't done a good job of supporting it even if there is some merit to his case in his eyes. I'd like you, as a more experienced player, to tell me 1)Why Syllo would be so blase about pressuring me if he actually thought I was scum and 2)if you think I am scum and why/why not.
In addition I'd like to hear your thoughts on the party selection, you have said you'd prefer Syllo over dieno, why is that?
|
On November 26 2012 19:15 Dienosore wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2012 18:53 Promethelax wrote:On November 26 2012 18:52 risk.nuke wrote:On November 26 2012 18:50 Promethelax wrote:
Dieno: could you tell us what you infer from your crazy maps? Those help us as much as me posting a list of player names with everyone shaded a different shade of purple. It probably means something to me but you have no idea what. It's more simmilar to posting bad/useless lists. Except worse. I think it has gone past that to totally meaningless. That is why I want his conclusions. If ntohing else they are good for a laugh. They are relationship maps, not scum/town indicators. If someone is talking about someone else, I connect them with the arrow pointing towards who is being talked about. The more erratic the line, the more negativity associated with it. The maps don't lean one way or another, they are a tool that shows who feels what about who, and who is talking about who. While this is all good by itself, the real fun comes when you start cross-referencing people from day to day as situations change. Also, it is useful to see how the names group up, and if there are any cliques forming. Anyone specific you want a conclusion about?
I'd like the conclusions you feel are most important, the ones you think I should be paying attention to.
Risk: who are those you feel more strongly about than me as scum? Since I am (as far as I can tell) on your be-wary-of-but-don't-bother to-deal-with-yet list. I'd also like your opinion on the necessity of a name claim from me, esspecially for the reason which Syllo gave.
|
oh look Adam exists.
Syllo, ever going to respond to me? Or have you decided to totally write me off? I hope to hell you are town so I can throw this in your face post game.
|
Hey Risk, we're suspicious. Wanna buddy up and pretend to have extra knowledge so that Syllo can keep crapping his pants?
|
Okay but you are relying on your status as 'confirmed' from the first mission (which I think you believe yourself to be, though you haven't answered yet) to push that read. This is not good play. You are calling me scum by essentially saying 'lol that guy over there, him scum' without justification. That is poor play and it pisses me off not that you would suspect me but that you have so little respect for both me and the game that you can't even be assed to make a case.
Who do you have scum reads on Adam? I know lurking is your thing but I thought you'd have some ideas too.
|
Syllo, could you take five goddmna minutes to write up why each of Me, Risk and Acro is scum. Three sentences on each of us in one post. I'd also like a why VE, Adam, CJ and mostly Hope are town post.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
