|
On March 01 2012 07:06 Liquid`Sheth wrote:
There was nothing that talked about my sanity in my PM. What more do you want? I can't post my actual pm, and it doesn't say YOUR COMPLETELY SANE, but then again if it said that I'd be more worried then I am now.
To be 100% clear, this means you dont know your sanity which is why i said it felt really coin flippy.
|
|
|
Lol, just let's kill Jackal and Sheth. Or VT first.
|
Wtf killer was town lol wtf wtf
I guess he was lieing to "use his role better."
|
I also knew he was something related to Iraq cause he says he knows GWB (I think everyone understood that from his hint)
|
Damn, that was bloody for a lynch.
Sheth, explain Zephs flip!
|
On March 01 2012 07:11 blubbdavid wrote:
Lol, just let's kill Jackal and Sheth. Or VT first.
You cant say anything about sheth based on the flip. One claimed result flipping one is litterally non conclusive information.
VT and jackal I'll look at some tonight.
At least scum are modkilled just as ez too.
|
Sadly I was a bit suspicious of Chaos, but looks like that amounted to nothing.
and surprised that Tea claimed what he did, that was an....interesting..choice.
Blub what makes you think vt worthy of being lynched?
|
Actually my read on sheth is very town at this point.
The scum cop claim gambit that makes sense really is one where he either busses to gain cred or leads one bad lynch and then claims not sane.
His role was taken and we have a town flip on zeph. I just cant find a logical motive at this point for doing what he did (from a he is scum pov).
|
United States2095 Posts
I think v7 is scum. I should write up a case on it. But basically, why wouldn't you think I'm scum after that? He just wants to keep me around if I was a paranoid cop. : /
|
On March 01 2012 00:19 Jayjay54 wrote:
c) ET are you kidding me? Nuking a person who GAINS POWER when nuked? Power at night? Which spells out NUKEPROOF?
Well it turns out he didn't have those powers, and that there are actually red. I'm going to re-read thread and see if a case is actually able to be built.
@Mattchew, Zephirdd wasn't black, my vote switch was sensible. So be glad you don't have a nuke that would've offed me.
I'm thinking that Zephirdd comes up as non-town to DT reads (cuz he's the Man in Black, unknown to general populace), so it's possible that sheth wasn't lying.
....I am so confused with this game.
|
On March 01 2012 07:23 Liquid`Sheth wrote:
I think v7 is scum. I should write up a case on it. But basically, why wouldn't you think I'm scum after that? He just wants to keep me around if I was a paranoid cop. : /
Because I just see no logical reason for a scum player to try to create so many lies that are front stage on day that create a situation where the day 2 lynch hits a townie.
Your understanding of the chane of you being sane fits with the actions and thoughts you posted.
Your tone and style of claim seem very genuine.
Like I said it a read not a fact.
|
On March 01 2012 07:18 vaderseven wrote:
Actually my read on sheth is very town at this point.
The scum cop claim gambit that makes sense really is one where he either busses to gain cred or leads one bad lynch and then claims not sane.
His role was taken and we have a town flip on zeph. I just cant find a logical motive at this point for doing what he did (from a he is scum pov).
Just because it´s a crazy scum-gamble doesn´t mean that it wasn´t one. If we don´t call out people on the crazy stuff they do then they´ll keep doing them. Right now we have a DT who was wrong, and isn´t a DT anymore, there are endless possibilities for scum to hide behind this. Sheth hurts town and can´t help town anymore, the theft abolishing him from any further responsibility, that´s what makes me think Sheth is scum.
|
On March 01 2012 07:37 Forumite wrote:Show nested quote +On March 01 2012 07:18 vaderseven wrote:
Actually my read on sheth is very town at this point.
The scum cop claim gambit that makes sense really is one where he either busses to gain cred or leads one bad lynch and then claims not sane.
His role was taken and we have a town flip on zeph. I just cant find a logical motive at this point for doing what he did (from a he is scum pov). Just because it´s a crazy scum-gamble doesn´t mean that it wasn´t one. If we don´t call out people on the crazy stuff they do then they´ll keep doing them. Right now we have a DT who was wrong, and isn´t a DT anymore, there are endless possibilities for scum to hide behind this. Sheth hurts town and can´t help town anymore, the theft abolishing him from any further responsibility, that´s what makes me think Sheth is scum.
Ya that actually has a bit of logic to it.
My read on him is still fairly town but their is at least a bit of possible sensible way for him to do what he did as scum. I would be very impressed if he was scum and wrote all his posts exactly like he did. They just seem so genuine to my cynical eye.
|
well don't worry guys, Originalname had a ton of info we can use in his filter, it consisted of the following:
On February 24 2012 06:51 OriginalName wrote:
/in
On February 26 2012 06:09 OriginalName wrote:
I TOTALLY FORGOT I WAS PLAYING THIS GAME LOL WTF IS GOING ON.
On February 26 2012 06:24 OriginalName wrote:
##Nuke Kurumi
I think we can work with this.
-.-
|
Really his understanding of his possible sanity (which is still way up in there air... one result means nothing) and the possible interactions of roles has me thinking he is fairly new to mafia (less than one year of active online play). With that in mind I see him as trying to be 100% transparent at all points in time.
Am I wrong about his experience level with the game? That would factor heavily into how I look at him.
|
Alright so if there is a medic I'd like to be protected tonight. I have a lead on a possible black person and he is getting aimed at.
In other news, you guys shouldn't have lynched Zephirdd, and we are lynching Jackal tomorrow.
|
United States2095 Posts
Ok nisani! I'm on your side! 
|
On March 01 2012 08:08 Nisani201 wrote:
Alright so if there is a medic I'd like to be protected tonight. I have a lead on a possible black person and he is getting aimed at.
In other news, you guys shouldn't have lynched Zephirdd, and we are lynching Jackal tomorrow.
Yea, I remember you pushing extremely hard against a Zephirdd lynch.
Oh wait
|
I stated my opposition for the Zephirdd lynch multiple times in the thread.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
