He probably isn't going to tell us lol.

Can we start analysing please? There seems consensus that there is at least 1 Mafia between chaos13, kita and Palmar.

Lets analyse them. I have done kita and Palmar already, I concluded that kita was dodgier than Palmar. Please people, build a case instead of just relying on the roles.

Looking at chaos now.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

July 31 2011 06:38 GMT

#2102

To silenceomeone.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

July 31 2011 06:42 GMT

#2103

To silence someone* is Kita's power.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 31 2011 07:37 GMT

#2104

Original Message From deconduo:
Good point. Chaos tried to kill sandroba.

Show nested quote +

Like, I'll get deconduo to confirm that he fucked up initially if you guys need it.

Chaos13 is the best kill today.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 31 2011 07:55 GMT

#2105

On July 31 2011 07:27 sandroba wrote:
You are Sauron's Ring
When someone targets you with a night action, they become a member of your cult, and join a PM circle with you and all other cult members. Once your cult has reached the maximum of 4 members, including yourself, you can choose to roleblock everyone in the cult in exchange for 1 KP.

Btw, this role-message looks so edited.

Do you gain a KP for roleblocking your cult? If you need to pay a KP to do it, where does that KP come from?

Varpulis

United States2517 Posts

July 31 2011 08:08 GMT

#2106

I'd like to hear an explanation for that as well. The role never mentions KP until it wants you to exchange it for roleblocks. Makes very little sense from two perspectives:

1. The thought process of making the role. If it's a kp role, kp is a main part of the role. You don't just tack on kp as an afterthought

2. how such a vague and poorly explained role passed muster and wasn't edited by the hosts.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 31 2011 10:05 GMT

#2107

Sandroba probably isn't mafia though, he got foolishness lynched in big part on his own. He is however playing very similar to what I did in BC's AA as serial killer.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

July 31 2011 10:56 GMT

#2108

No more questions about game mechanics, work it out on your own.

I'll be away for the rest of the day, and some of tomorrow. I should be back before the lynch. If not, Eiii is in charge.

Varpulis

United States2517 Posts

July 31 2011 10:56 GMT

#2109

breaking news from deconduo: The reason that i only got 1 whisper day 2 was because, and i quote "the other ghosts decided to be silent."

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 31 2011 10:57 GMT

#2110

Derp

I think we should lynch Sandroba and then vigi shoot chaos13.

Sandroba's role doesn't add up, and he is some kind of a cultist with a recruiting role. It's also very, very likely sandroba is responsible for killing supersoft on day 2, the whole sacrifice thing usually goes hand in hand with cult-ish types, just check GMarshal's role in PTP2

The only reason Sandroba would hide a KP from us (as he basically must be doing, looking at that role description) is because he intends to use it in a way not acceptable to town.

So, in conclusion:

##Unvote
##Vote Sandroba

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 31 2011 10:59 GMT

#2111

The reason for the change of order, is that you can shoot mafia during the night, but sks, which is by far the more likely role Sandroba is, have BP vests.

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

July 31 2011 14:27 GMT

#2112

Nope, we're either lynch you or chaos. Don't try to start a wagon on sandroba.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

July 31 2011 15:08 GMT

#2113

On July 31 2011 16:55 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

Btw, this role-message looks so edited.

Do you gain a KP for roleblocking your cult? If you need to pay a KP to do it, where does that KP come from?

On July 31 2011 11:25 chaos13 wrote:
Sandroba's role does not have a day kill. I can confirm this beyond doubt. Yes, I made it sound like a cult. I even made him appear third party to DT checks, but I guess that was removed. However, it's basically just a mason circle that gets 1 kill/night at the cost of roleblocking every member, and only if it is full. Whoever that kill was, it was not Sandroba.

Sandroba is not anything harmful. The role PM was worded extremely badly, but chaos explains it. You have to treat roleblocking the Mason circle as a bad thing for it to make sense.

Bad: All members roleblocked
Good: In exchange for that bad, you get 1 KP

I'd still like chaos's explanation for why he chose me to be a Medic prot Night 1.

Kurumi

Poland6130 Posts

July 31 2011 15:12 GMT

#2114

i am sandvich
chaos13 is not defending himself is he
defending is scumtell nowadays so he isn't doing it huh

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

July 31 2011 15:14 GMT

#2115

Palmar, chaos13 confirmed my role. I can roleblock 3 people and I gain 1 kp, not the other way around.
???? Aren't you positive that chaos shot me? That makes it impossible we share the same aligment. So what reason you think chaos has to protect me, even if I'm sk, when I'm trying to lynch him. Also you have one confirmed mafia (which you confirmed yourself) and you think I'm the best lynch?? I'm tired of all your nonsense this game.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

July 31 2011 15:16 GMT

#2116

Palmar does look like he's trying to be intentionally obtuse to leave behind as much havoc as he can before he dies.

I still think chaos's claim is BS though, I mean why in the world would anyone want to Medic prot me Night 1? I led the BC mislynch.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

July 31 2011 15:18 GMT

#2117

I think they may be both mafia. I thought that day2, until they started acusing each other. Whatever, Palmar is not this irrational, he is doing it on purpose.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 31 2011 15:19 GMT

#2118

I missed chaos13's confirmation

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

July 31 2011 15:20 GMT

#2119

And unless DropBear is in league with Palmar, Palmar's ability is more or less confirmed.

That leaves chaos as the liar about his ability.

Drazerk

United Kingdom31255 Posts

July 31 2011 15:22 GMT

#2120

On August 01 2011 00:18 sandroba wrote:
I think they may be both mafia. I thought that day2, until they started acusing each other. Whatever, Palmar is not this irrational, he is doing it on purpose.

I still think they could both be mafia trying to bus each other for the town cred.

Didn't one of them mention there is only five scum? If that is the case and they are both under fire they must be getting pretty desperate.

Shooting one of them will reveal a lot of information.

( I say chaos because that medic claim just looks weak )