|
On December 16 2010 20:19 why wrote:
By the way, we can confirm (at least the characters of) 3 more people.
Cho Chang or Roger Davies (the one not in the Ravenclaw House) can confirm by saying they are in the Ravenclaw and having no one dispute them (there are 4 total Ravenclaws on the list, 3 are in the House).
There are 5 Gryffindor members on the player list (Harry Potter, Hermione, Colin Creevey, Angelina Johnson, and Pavarti Patil). 3 are in the house. The remaining 2 can claim to be part of the House and, if no one disputes, are confirmed.
Coincidentally, I am in Gryffindor.
I'm trying to decide whether you are a mafia rolefishing, or just stupid enough to give them the identity of the most important town character 
Please stop claiming if your role is of any sort of importance?
|
First: Please be careful with Airbag/DrH. The fact that he has been active in PM land doesn’t make me trust him at all, since the leaks have probably been happening there. I agree the accusations against Pandain are circumstantial, but Pandain has been popping up when summoned, and has failed to give reasons as to why he needed medic protection. We are letting him get away with a lot.
That said, Ilovejohn’s analyse of why is actually very good. I hadn’t noticed the submissive tone or the focus on game hints. Let’s see what happens if we put on pressure.
@why’s analyse of kitaman27. It's not bad, but in the other game I have played with kitman27 (salem mafia), he played a very careful townie, who spend more time trying to make the exactly right decision based on other’s arguments than providing his own targets. That seems to be the pattern here as well.
Also your last argument is wrong: On December 17 2010 15:05 why wrote:Then, he votes for Pandain after posting the below: Show nested quote +On December 17 2010 11:02 kitaman27 wrote:On December 17 2010 10:57 LunarDestiny wrote:
Pandain does look suspicious, but he is posting even less in pokemafia. Well I would hope so, he is dead. Even before he died, he was a replacement for only like half a day, so that would probably explain why he didn't post much there. It is really weird that Kitaman votes for Pandain after he defends him here. Notice that a bandwagon has already formed.
He doesn’t defend Pandain, he dismisses LunarDestiny’s defence for Pandain.
|
Kitaman I feel like I'm missing something here. You say another one claimed Poppy, and that we should lynch both. I agree.
So who is this other Poppy, in case you are lying to us about DrH?
|
I was refering to this sentence by Kitaman.
I had already recieved a pm that a dt type role had already located a Pomfrey. I pm'd annul to confirm that there were not duplicate role claims and he said that I was correct. That leads us to the fact that one of the two sources is lying. What do we do with liars? We lynch them.
He states we lynch them, but he only mentions one.
|
On December 18 2010 02:30 kitaman27 wrote:Show nested quote +On December 18 2010 02:28 Barundar wrote:I was refering to this sentence by Kitaman. I had already recieved a pm that a dt type role had already located a Pomfrey. I pm'd annul to confirm that there were not duplicate role claims and he said that I was correct. That leads us to the fact that one of the two sources is lying. What do we do with liars? We lynch them. He states we lynch them, but he only mentions one. We can only lynch one at a time. DrH makes an uncharacteristic role claim, while the other gets checked by a dt. DrH obviously seems more suspicious. Why reveal both names?
Beceause you are being extremely vague about this other claim. You mention a PM you recieved, about a DT type checking a Pomfrey. This already sound like someone told you that someone else told you. As far as I know you aren't a confirmed town, so I'm questioning why people would invest that knowledge in you.
I'm not necessarily asking you to give out a name. I was merely asking into what struck me as a logical break in your reasoning.
|
Sorry but I can't help but notice this comes up after there is pressure on why and pandain, and the moment I question the reasoning I get yelled at for fishing + I get PM's asking to my thoughts out of nowhere. From Pandain.
Coordinated attack?
|
On December 18 2010 03:01 kitaman27 wrote:Show nested quote +On December 18 2010 02:55 Barundar wrote:
Sorry but I can't help but notice this comes up after there is pressure on why and pandain, and the moment I question the reasoning I get yelled at for fishing + I get PM's asking to my thoughts out of nowhere. From Pandain.
Coordinated attack? Do you still disagree that the second medic should remain hidden until DrH's alignment has been revealed? I'm still not sure why the real medic should claim publicly. You think I'm working with pandain? I had my vote on pandain before this. When DrH flips red, I would suggest he is looked into as well based on how much he is soft defending him.
You don't have to think I'm against you - I read the post. Just please try and understand my concerns. The worst case scenario would be to mislynch a medic, and only have a probable town to blame.
We still have time to hear his side as well.
I don't know who you are working with. I simply found Pandain's timing to be suspecius and pointed it out. He is definitely around.
|
On December 18 2010 06:56 LunarDestiny wrote:
Coag, you are not helping. Are you saying I am mafia or I am disillusion that I am defending Dr.H?
Back on topic:
Annul clarified the rules a page back. Can anyone find any loophole to this plan?
Kenpachi name checks Dr.H.
Dr.H protects Kenpachi.
They kill DrH?
|
Is pandain the safest lynch at this point?
|
On December 18 2010 08:22 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On December 18 2010 08:21 Barundar wrote:
Is pandain the safest lynch at this point? Of course not, it's a fucking terrible lynch. I've been saying that over and over but no one will listen to me.
What do you base it on? I've lost track of the nr's of DT's in this game.
|
Fucking hope I didn't hammer a medic. Annul if you read this, was strugling with the format...
|
|
|
On December 18 2010 18:44 orgolove wrote:
Fuck, should've hit DrH FUCK
and we lost both detectives to inactivity? jesus christ Why the fuck did you two choose TODAY to be inactive
FUCK pandain and his scumminess. I hope you're happy. -_- your Yum Yum crap loses games.
FoS DrH. Now.
I don't think so. Neither Pandain nor DrH voted for each others, why would they do that if it could save them. My guess is Pandain checked DrH and confirmed him. If anything this proves to me I was wrong about Kitaman, he made it sound like both of them was scum...
|
|
|
Sigh I just feel really stupid.
|
I will be stupidly busy this comming week, but will try and keep up. Not that that is hard atm 
|
I think Kitaman is lying about extra DT and whatnot. Based on his dedication, Jcarl "confirmed" him. Obvious he is Voldemort or real Poppy, and at the moment it's down to a flip between him and DrH.
Kitaman said DrH and Pandain was scum. DrH said Pandain was not scum. Kitaman could have been lying about both. DrH could have been right about Pandain beceause he was scum.
Town would be safer to find scum elsewhere.
vote Coagulation
|
On December 20 2010 08:56 kitaman27 wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2010 08:51 Barundar wrote:
I think Kitaman is lying about extra DT and whatnot. Based on his dedication, Jcarl "confirmed" him. Obvious he is Voldemort or real Poppy, and at the moment it's down to a flip between him and DrH.
Kitaman said DrH and Pandain was scum. DrH said Pandain was not scum. Kitaman could have been lying about both. DrH could have been right about Pandain beceause he was scum.
Town would be safer to find scum elsewhere.
vote Coagulation lolz
So you deny?
I'm very aware its mislynch or lose. I see 7 mafia alive, and a shortlist of people it can be. There is a better chance of hitting scum from that list than through kitaman/drh
|
On December 20 2010 09:17 kitaman27 wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2010 09:07 Barundar wrote:On December 20 2010 08:56 kitaman27 wrote:On December 20 2010 08:51 Barundar wrote:
I think Kitaman is lying about extra DT and whatnot. Based on his dedication, Jcarl "confirmed" him. Obvious he is Voldemort or real Poppy, and at the moment it's down to a flip between him and DrH.
Kitaman said DrH and Pandain was scum. DrH said Pandain was not scum. Kitaman could have been lying about both. DrH could have been right about Pandain beceause he was scum.
Town would be safer to find scum elsewhere.
vote Coagulation lolz So you deny? I'm very aware its mislynch or lose. I see 7 mafia alive, and a shortlist of people it can be. There is a better chance of hitting scum from that list than through kitaman/drh You think I'm lying about my Dt? Lunar already confirmed the existence of my dt. Are you saying me, my dt and lunar are all lying?
I say you are lying about your identity, and it hurts town. Especially when it's so glaringly obvious. How are we supposed to trust you?
Deconduo's list.
|
1 exam left before christmas, reading up on thread now, sorry I haven't had much time lately.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
