|
On January 22 2010 03:08 Bill Murray wrote:
let's ASSUME you and meeple get into office, Doc
you will both be protected.
they will target (in my opinion)
Citi.zen,
Jugan,
and I.
that's why i'm asking for a medic to protect me night #1. We need all the townie aligned players we can get.
citi.zen is more likely, although you both are pretty high up on the active list.
|
That's difficult... any person can just "say" they're a dt
|
Even if we did have a detective rolechecking, the mafia would probably whack him pretty fast.
|
On January 22 2010 06:13 Abenson wrote:
Hmm... I think i'll just stop talking now and just lurk :D
I do not wish to get lynched in the first few days, so I will remain silent since I don't want to say something that can be misinterpreted.
I have to study for my exams anyways :D
Lurking is more suspicious than posting your ideas, unless you have horrible ideas  which I don't think you do. Just be sure to back up what you say...
|
So... I went through the last 6 pages and roughly tallied the people who either mentioned they would support lynching t_co or explicitly stated it. I also pointed out a few people who haven't said much at all about it.
t_co
Mystlord
Abenson
Flamewheel
Hobbes - presumably
DrH
789
Bill Murray
citi.zen
Jugan
t_co - hey man, he said it
tredmaster
Faronel
someone else/Hobbes?
Ser aspi
Where do you stand?
Ng5... I like your chess but all you've done is wisecrack and not really stated your opinion.
Ace
The_Master
keit - you haven't spoken a word yet...
Let me know if I made a mistake or whatever
|
Yup, I think you would vote in the voting thread, but are alot of people for this? We only get 2 a game...
|
On January 22 2010 08:32 Qatol wrote:Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 08:16 meeple wrote:
So... I went through the last 6 pages and roughly tallied the people who either mentioned they would support lynching t_co or explicitly stated it. I also pointed out a few people who haven't said much at all about it.
t_co
Mystlord
Abenson
Flamewheel
Hobbes - presumably
DrH
789
Bill Murray
citi.zen
Jugan
t_co - hey man, he said it
tredmaster
Faronel
someone else/Hobbes?
Ser aspi
Where do you stand?
Ng5... I like your chess but all you've done is wisecrack and not really stated your opinion.
Ace
The_Master
keit - you haven't spoken a word yet...
Let me know if I made a mistake or whatever Ace isn't playing in this game. (Nor am I). We are just interested in the game.
Ah, sorry, I just saw a name and didn't double check with the list
|
On January 22 2010 08:33 Bill Murray wrote:
also, meeple, where do you stand on the mayoral lynch issue?
i suppose we'll get to see in under 2 and 1/2 hours
Well... to be honest, I lean towards following clues. However, in this case, the clues are very shaky at best and t_co has made a great case against himself. If I were elected mayor, I would serve the interests of the people, and thus probably lynch t_co, unless some major revelation occurs.
|
I can understand opposing views... but really? t_co??? He's been totally incomprehensible from the beginning
|
On January 22 2010 09:28 Zona wrote:Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 08:16 meeple wrote:
So... I went through the last 6 pages and roughly tallied the people who either mentioned they would support lynching t_co or explicitly stated it. I also pointed out a few people who haven't said much at all about it.
t_co
Mystlord
Abenson
Flamewheel
Hobbes - presumably
DrH
789
Bill Murray
citi.zen
Jugan
t_co - hey man, he said it
tredmaster
Faronel
I do not see where Faronel has supported lynching t_co or expressed sentiment along these lines, please point out a quote to me if I have missed it.
You're right, I misread one of his earlier quotes
|
Zona: If you were mayor, who would you lynch?
|
If we don't lynch him, then who? nobody seems able to decide on something.
|
On January 22 2010 09:59 Zona wrote:
Also, to those who suggested that t_co may not go with the will of the town when using his triple vote, I acknowledge this danger and thus retract my desire to have him as mayor. However, please leave him alive for day 2 at least.
Can you support your statement? Why should we leave him alive?
|
Very nice, I hadn't thought of that. Still you have defended t_co but not given an alternate solution. Who would you see go?
|
On January 22 2010 10:09 Zona wrote:Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 10:08 meeple wrote:
Very nice, I hadn't thought of that. Still you have defended t_co but not given an alternate solution. Who would you see go? Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 09:58 Zona wrote:
I suggest lynching Faronel. Unlike other suggestions of hidden alliances, Faronel's few actions in this game DO link him to t_co, and unlike t_co, Faronel has not contributed a lot to the thread.
Ah yup, thanks...
The only problem with Faronel, is that other than some admittedly suspicious actions, there's nothing really concrete. You say that he supported t_co before he had reason to do so... but that kinda implies that t_co is up to no good. The only difference between them really is that t_co ran for office. Doesn't it make more sense to take out the leader than a supporter?
Besides, it seems we've totally abandoned all hope for a clues-based Day 1 lynching, so if we're basing this on suspicious actions alone, t_co's trump Faronel's imo.
|
Sorry, you posted first but I didn't hit refresh...
Ok so what if Faronel is Mafia... then what? We hit t_co next?
|
Is a low post count and support of a suspicious character grounds for lynching? I understand wanting to keep an active member in the game... but t_co hasn't been productive for all his activity. He wildly points fingers without much support and changes his story all the time. If you want to see the other side of things, and wish that other people do... why don't you take that side and challenge people. You seem much more coherent than he was...
|
It's getting down to the wire guys... can everyone please put their choice and perhaps a short blurb describing why?
|
On January 22 2010 10:30 Mystlord wrote:Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 09:47 meeple wrote:
If we don't lynch him, then who? nobody seems able to decide on something. I'm still all for the lynching of t_co. I'm just saying that even if we don't lynch him, it hurts us to let him into office. Zona: I see your reasoning for wanting to lynch Faronel and not t_co, but you cannot randomly lynch people based off of low activity and a tenuous link at best. We won't get any information at all from Faronel's lynching, which drops him even lower on the priority list. I still believe that t_co's lynching will give us the most information. Even if he isn't mafia, it will point us in a clear direction. I've already seen evidence of his strange and wild arguments confusing some people, and it hurts us to keep him in if he starts confusing the town, regardless of whether he's a townie or not.
Whats the clear direction if he's green/blue?
|
On January 22 2010 10:31 CynanMachae wrote:Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 10:29 meeple wrote:
It's getting down to the wire guys... can everyone please put their choice and perhaps a short blurb describing why? Day 1 lynching choices for the mayor?
Yes please
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
