On November 19 2026 00:52 ChristianS wrote:
“Fights between branches” are absolutely “constitutional issues”? That said we’ve got oBlade in between providing much better examples of what a bad faith right wing interlocutor would sound like, so I should back off on you a little bit.
Show nested quote +
On November 19 2026 00:29 Introvert wrote:
I've long been an advocate for a more assertive Congress. That's not my point here though, which is much more narrow. I am saying that doing things like adding Justices or all but eliminating the EC are more destructive than whatever Trump is up to. I mean look at your lists, they really aren't constitutional issues, they are fights between branches within the system itself about who gets to do what and to what extent.
And BTW the DOJ has been abused throughout it's lifetime that one falls into the category of "useful fiction" that I mentioned before. But again, those are fights that can be had, they aren't constitutional end runs. The constitution doesn't even have any named departments in it, Washington really is why we have the cabinet system we have. So again I just think you aren't considering the consequences or the severity of things like the compact.
On November 19 2026 00:08 ChristianS wrote:
I mean it’s weird because if your point is “sure, Trump has committed a bunch of atrocities and abuses of power but also those are pretty normal throughout American history” then, I mean, yeah, kinda? You sound more like GH than Intro saying that but yes, we’ve got lots of ugly stuff in our history. Is Trump’s current use of ICE worse than COINTELPRO? Or Japanese internment? The Trail of Tears? No, probably not.
That said, has any president ever ordered the DOJ to prosecute their political opponents before? Raided a member of Congress trying to find evidence to get their citizenship revoked? Eliminated whole government agencies, lawfully created and funded by Congress, entirely by executive decree? You can’t carry water for that stuff and then turn around and tell me you’re a traditionalist, a Burkean institutionalist, who just hates to see people tearing down systems without due Chesterton’s Fence respect that maybe what came before was there for a reason.
On November 18 2026 23:26 Introvert wrote:
First, I don't think you are appreciating how big of a change messing with the Electoral College would be and how very intentionally going around is antithetical to the Constitution as set up.
Biden tried forgive hundreds of billions in student debt illegally. Presidents regularly fight with congress how how exactly to spend appropriated money. Presidents have taken millitary action on their own since very early, the congressional input into war making is one of the very first things that started to go in the republic. And of course Trump knows all about people going after him with the law. The NY prosecution was absurd. But thankfully we have judges and juries and I think the problem in coming years actually goes the other way but again something for later.
You do know FDR used the IRS (technically it's predecessor iirc) to go after people, that he used government regulation of the airways to shut down his opponents, that he put Japanese Americans in camps? Nevemind that immigration law has *never* worked the same way as criminal law, it couldn't function if it did.
Yet despite all that, FDR's court packing was rejected by his own party and the EC system remains.
What you think is unprecedented is merely ignorance and a bias towards today since we survived yesterday. The presidency has become more powerful but I'm not seeing any principle here by Trump's opponents as they see it more about him than Congress's abdication.
On November 18 2026 23:00 ChristianS wrote:
Come on, you ask me to believe that? Giving the president unilateral authority to cancel any congressional spending he doesn’t like is a less radical change to our institutions than electing the President based on popular vote?
Two guys walk into the room. The first says “I would support a constitutional amendment to elect presidents by popular vote.” The second says “I think the president should have unilateral authority to go to war, cancel any portion of the budget, order his political opponents to be prosecuted and fire anyone who refuses, and send hundreds of thousands of masked police into any jurisdiction who answer only to him and don’t need a judicial warrant for anything they do. Oh and both the president and all those police should have basically infinite legal immunity for anything they do with that power.”
You’re seriously gonna clutch your pearls about the first guy “burning down institutions”? Speak reverently about the Founders’ Vision and how it’s being betrayed? Fucking hell, man, you make it hard to interpret you generously sometimes. Personally I bet if you showed all the founders the current population and representation of Montana vs California (neither of which were states yet in their time!), a good number would say “hmm, yeah, that’s a bit silly.” Meanwhile I bet you couldn’t find a single founder who would look at the current powers and immunities we grant the executive and say “yup, perfect, that’s what we thought we were building.”
On November 18 2026 15:20 Introvert wrote:
1. My suspicion comes from the fact that nothing has substantively changed between then and now. These are the same arguments although I guess they've had an (anti-)Trump spin put on them. There's a history here, these arguments aren't new.
2. I just don't see what MAGA has to do witg this. Packing the Supreme Court or removing the EC system is far more radical than anything Trump has yet done and I don't think it is particularly close. Of those things you mentioned, some are good, some are useful fictions, and some are subject to revision. But undermining the way we choose our chief constitutional office holder imo would be far more divisive and more destructive than anything DOGE did. You could argue the left's most basic goal is remaking society as they wish it to be so I don't find that argument convincing either. This is for a different discussion but it's a point I made in 2024. For all the talk of the danger of Trump dems did exactly zero to court conservatives who they said should be worried about Trump. Their attitude was "Trump is a fascist so you have to vote for us." Since that first statement was not an agreed upon fact, it held no purchase.
On November 18 2026 13:59 ChristianS wrote:
I’m confused what the disconnect here is, because you’re accusing people of changing their minds about the electoral college who still think it’s bad! Josh Marshall still thinks it’s bad, I still think it’s bad, that law professor still probably thinks it’s bad. Thinking it’s bad on principle and thinking it generally hurts Democrats aren’t mutually exclusive – I still think both – and if someone who thinks both still says “eh, idk about this NPVIC thing though” your reaction is “oh, how convenient all of a sudden you see the value in the EC”. What? It’s not convenient at all! Are you just not paying very close attention? Are you watching a game on the other monitor while posting or something?
All of that said, I actually care much more about this bit:
That’s a very authentically conservative sentiment. Burkean, even. Only problem is, nobody is more keen on burning down institutions in the name of their own power than MAGA! Why is it always Chesterton’s Fence when somebody dares to criticize the Electoral College or imagine adding DC or Puerto Rico as states, but when some right-wing lunatics want to remake all of government and society in their image, that’s just how the game is played?
DOGE completely undermined the way our government has worked for at least a century. The radical destruction of science funding completely undermines a national lab system we’ve relied on since at least WW2. The firewall between the political staff in the White House and the criminal justice staff at DOJ has been a universally exalted norm since at least Nixon. What gives? Aren’t you mad as hell? You don’t seem to hold those folks “in great disrespect” when those are, I’d think, obviously load-bearing institutions being torn down essentially lawlessly, with almost no pretense that it’s for any cause other than “in the name of their own political power.” Is there some reason those institutions don’t count?
On November 18 2026 12:56 Introvert wrote:
tbf I kinda thought there was a passing familiarity with the arguments for the EC because it does come up sometimes. The practical reasons are many of those being articulated in the pieces you mentioned, the other reasons are those actually given for its establishment in the first place. The states are the central unit of the Union, and they get to pick the president through electors (at the founding a popular vote for president in a state was not guaranteed). Also it was intentionally done to make the president be picked by the entire nation not just the populated states or even cities within states. Like so many other parts of the Constitution, it would never have been enacted at all without a way to make sure small states weren't locked out of the process. It did favor slavery through the 3/5ths clause but even if the whole nation was free something like it would probably have emerged. So that's the short version. it's true that land doesn't vote but the cities need the land to live, so it makes sense. Some of the reasons are no longer relevant e.g. electors being able to vote their own way. but to be fair, they never really have even at the beginning.
Also it should be noted that there is an element of compromise here as there is throughout the whole document. Whatever problems the EC has, the framers rejected things like the popular vote explicitly.
My statement about rigor had more to do with you asking for me to back up my idea that this was somehow mainstream. I think I could go through the internet (maybe this would be a good use for LLMs actually) and pull a list of all the prominent people on the left complaining about it, but I thought, perhaps mistakenly, that there should be no real pushback on that point? And at least to me, again maybe I'm wrong, but to me the fact that so many states have already signed on is an indication that this isn't quite as fringe as one might expect (or hope).
So that's what I find incredible. These arguments all existed before and many of these same people now scratching their chin rejected them. All that's changed in the last two weeks was an election where Dems won in very red places. I'm not inclined to give them the assumption of good faith I'm inclined to give you lol. The EC "advantage" moves back and forth. Pretty sure you can find people pre-2000 who thought it went the other way. Like we see the senate, claims of "bias" towards a *party* is misplaced. Parties compete in *states* for which there is a little bit of a bias. But Dems can win in states, in fact Dems are now what, tied once again with the most senators the GOP has had in like 100 years? So I hold in great disrespect those who would burn our institutions down in the name of their own political power while denying that is what they are doing.
On November 18 2026 11:29 ChristianS wrote:
Short is fine, if I were a better poster I’d know how to say things more concisely than I do. But do you understand how vague implied criticisms of huge political groups with zero supporting argumentation or evidence is rhetorically frustrating? Now that you’ve elaborated a little, it seems like you’re conflating opposition to the EC with opposition to the NPVIC, and accusing people with long-standing opposition to the EC of hypocrisy because they’re saying they think the NPVIC is a bad way to address it. But those aren’t in conflict! It’s completely coherent to say “I think the EC is bad but I don’t think this is a good way to solve it.” What’s so rich about that? It’s a bit half-baked, because you’re saying it’s “after a huge win” like that’s self-serving timing, but both before and after big midterm wins, the Dems are pretty clearly disfavored by the EC-popular vote split. The self-serving position, both before and after, would be “let’s kill the EC at all costs.”
But the only reason I can even respond to your reasoning is because you stated it. You’ve gestured at “conservative arguments the NPVIC would be unconstitutional” and “conservative arguments the EC is good actually” but without actually stating them, what’s the point of a discussion thread?
I don’t mean to “selectively demand rigor” – I raised this topic partly to try to kill a deeply un-rigorous St. Patrick’s Day spat – and I don’t mean to be overly hostile. I’m sure I have plenty of bad posts too (and I’m sure you could chase down some examples if you wanted to). But, like, I’m not sure of the nicer way to say “either make an actual argument or stop vaguely implying everybody you disagree with is a hypocrite please”.
Edit:
I mean, I tend to agree that the electoral college is a bit of a distraction. More generally, I think there’s an unfortunate tendency to focus on the formal mechanisms of power (the EC, the filibuster, FPTP, the Senate parliamentarian) because they’re concrete and measurable, when the informal mechanisms of power (political capital, consensus-building, population-level shifts in worldview and reasoning) are probably much more important, albeit harder to concretely describe.
Like, for all their results something I admire about the 60s hippies is that they built a society-wide counter-culture that was not narrowly focused on particular leaders or elections or bills. They didn’t just want to win an election and pass some bills, they wanted to change the way society understood the world. And while particularly extreme components of that (e.g. free love) got rejected, huge swaths of the counter-culture wound up pretty universally accepted, by conservatives and liberals alike! That kind of broad shift in understanding is what’s required to achieve seismic political change and make it last.
That said, the EC discussion is at least an improvement over the previous topic, no?
On November 18 2026 04:38 Introvert wrote:
[quote]
Yes it is a short post, it wasn't meant to advance an argument but to point out how remarkable it is to see all these people come out of the woodwork after a big win. It's like the filibuster where it's an evil, racism protecting rule when in power and an important check on the majority when out of power.
the number of blue states that have passed this plan elevates this beyond just commentators. But people like Marshall or Yglesias who spend their whole lives writing about politics starting to make noise is rich. The standard conservative criticisms are many of the ones listed here + defending the purpose of the EC. The law professor was one of the primary people responsible for these states embracing it, in the context of this topic he is not "some law professor." It's Akhil Amar who funnily enough isn't even that bad for a Dem law professor.
I was alive in 2016 for example, the rended garments over the EC is evidence enough on its own. I say with all kindness but if you're going to start posting again please drop the selective demands for rigor, we already have at least one poster for that.
If you like I will make a modified statement but Dems have been complaining about the EC since 2000 at least, so much so that many states have voted to do an end run around it. To watch some of the biggest hacks call for keeping it is incredible.
[quote]
Most of us have been interacting with ChristianS before you started in this thread, but thanks
[quote]
Yes it is a short post, it wasn't meant to advance an argument but to point out how remarkable it is to see all these people come out of the woodwork after a big win. It's like the filibuster where it's an evil, racism protecting rule when in power and an important check on the majority when out of power.
the number of blue states that have passed this plan elevates this beyond just commentators. But people like Marshall or Yglesias who spend their whole lives writing about politics starting to make noise is rich. The standard conservative criticisms are many of the ones listed here + defending the purpose of the EC. The law professor was one of the primary people responsible for these states embracing it, in the context of this topic he is not "some law professor." It's Akhil Amar who funnily enough isn't even that bad for a Dem law professor.
I was alive in 2016 for example, the rended garments over the EC is evidence enough on its own. I say with all kindness but if you're going to start posting again please drop the selective demands for rigor, we already have at least one poster for that.
If you like I will make a modified statement but Dems have been complaining about the EC since 2000 at least, so much so that many states have voted to do an end run around it. To watch some of the biggest hacks call for keeping it is incredible.
[quote]
Most of us have been interacting with ChristianS before you started in this thread, but thanks
Short is fine, if I were a better poster I’d know how to say things more concisely than I do. But do you understand how vague implied criticisms of huge political groups with zero supporting argumentation or evidence is rhetorically frustrating? Now that you’ve elaborated a little, it seems like you’re conflating opposition to the EC with opposition to the NPVIC, and accusing people with long-standing opposition to the EC of hypocrisy because they’re saying they think the NPVIC is a bad way to address it. But those aren’t in conflict! It’s completely coherent to say “I think the EC is bad but I don’t think this is a good way to solve it.” What’s so rich about that? It’s a bit half-baked, because you’re saying it’s “after a huge win” like that’s self-serving timing, but both before and after big midterm wins, the Dems are pretty clearly disfavored by the EC-popular vote split. The self-serving position, both before and after, would be “let’s kill the EC at all costs.”
But the only reason I can even respond to your reasoning is because you stated it. You’ve gestured at “conservative arguments the NPVIC would be unconstitutional” and “conservative arguments the EC is good actually” but without actually stating them, what’s the point of a discussion thread?
I don’t mean to “selectively demand rigor” – I raised this topic partly to try to kill a deeply un-rigorous St. Patrick’s Day spat – and I don’t mean to be overly hostile. I’m sure I have plenty of bad posts too (and I’m sure you could chase down some examples if you wanted to). But, like, I’m not sure of the nicer way to say “either make an actual argument or stop vaguely implying everybody you disagree with is a hypocrite please”.
Edit:
On November 18 2026 03:13 GreenHorizons wrote:
[quote]
It's basically just a minor procedural change with little to no meaningful payoff (Trump did win the popular vote in 2024).
Democrats need to just focus on the things that the voters told them they wanted them to focus on, affordability and corruption, and that's going to require getting rid of the filibuster (or at least making the person actually speak).
[quote]
It's basically just a minor procedural change with little to no meaningful payoff (Trump did win the popular vote in 2024).
Democrats need to just focus on the things that the voters told them they wanted them to focus on, affordability and corruption, and that's going to require getting rid of the filibuster (or at least making the person actually speak).
I mean, I tend to agree that the electoral college is a bit of a distraction. More generally, I think there’s an unfortunate tendency to focus on the formal mechanisms of power (the EC, the filibuster, FPTP, the Senate parliamentarian) because they’re concrete and measurable, when the informal mechanisms of power (political capital, consensus-building, population-level shifts in worldview and reasoning) are probably much more important, albeit harder to concretely describe.
Like, for all their results something I admire about the 60s hippies is that they built a society-wide counter-culture that was not narrowly focused on particular leaders or elections or bills. They didn’t just want to win an election and pass some bills, they wanted to change the way society understood the world. And while particularly extreme components of that (e.g. free love) got rejected, huge swaths of the counter-culture wound up pretty universally accepted, by conservatives and liberals alike! That kind of broad shift in understanding is what’s required to achieve seismic political change and make it last.
That said, the EC discussion is at least an improvement over the previous topic, no?
tbf I kinda thought there was a passing familiarity with the arguments for the EC because it does come up sometimes. The practical reasons are many of those being articulated in the pieces you mentioned, the other reasons are those actually given for its establishment in the first place. The states are the central unit of the Union, and they get to pick the president through electors (at the founding a popular vote for president in a state was not guaranteed). Also it was intentionally done to make the president be picked by the entire nation not just the populated states or even cities within states. Like so many other parts of the Constitution, it would never have been enacted at all without a way to make sure small states weren't locked out of the process. It did favor slavery through the 3/5ths clause but even if the whole nation was free something like it would probably have emerged. So that's the short version. it's true that land doesn't vote but the cities need the land to live, so it makes sense. Some of the reasons are no longer relevant e.g. electors being able to vote their own way. but to be fair, they never really have even at the beginning.
Also it should be noted that there is an element of compromise here as there is throughout the whole document. Whatever problems the EC has, the framers rejected things like the popular vote explicitly.
My statement about rigor had more to do with you asking for me to back up my idea that this was somehow mainstream. I think I could go through the internet (maybe this would be a good use for LLMs actually) and pull a list of all the prominent people on the left complaining about it, but I thought, perhaps mistakenly, that there should be no real pushback on that point? And at least to me, again maybe I'm wrong, but to me the fact that so many states have already signed on is an indication that this isn't quite as fringe as one might expect (or hope).
So that's what I find incredible. These arguments all existed before and many of these same people now scratching their chin rejected them. All that's changed in the last two weeks was an election where Dems won in very red places. I'm not inclined to give them the assumption of good faith I'm inclined to give you lol. The EC "advantage" moves back and forth. Pretty sure you can find people pre-2000 who thought it went the other way. Like we see the senate, claims of "bias" towards a *party* is misplaced. Parties compete in *states* for which there is a little bit of a bias. But Dems can win in states, in fact Dems are now what, tied once again with the most senators the GOP has had in like 100 years? So I hold in great disrespect those who would burn our institutions down in the name of their own political power while denying that is what they are doing.
I’m confused what the disconnect here is, because you’re accusing people of changing their minds about the electoral college who still think it’s bad! Josh Marshall still thinks it’s bad, I still think it’s bad, that law professor still probably thinks it’s bad. Thinking it’s bad on principle and thinking it generally hurts Democrats aren’t mutually exclusive – I still think both – and if someone who thinks both still says “eh, idk about this NPVIC thing though” your reaction is “oh, how convenient all of a sudden you see the value in the EC”. What? It’s not convenient at all! Are you just not paying very close attention? Are you watching a game on the other monitor while posting or something?
All of that said, I actually care much more about this bit:
So I hold in great disrespect those who would burn our institutions down in the name of their own political power while denying that is what they are doing.
That’s a very authentically conservative sentiment. Burkean, even. Only problem is, nobody is more keen on burning down institutions in the name of their own power than MAGA! Why is it always Chesterton’s Fence when somebody dares to criticize the Electoral College or imagine adding DC or Puerto Rico as states, but when some right-wing lunatics want to remake all of government and society in their image, that’s just how the game is played?
DOGE completely undermined the way our government has worked for at least a century. The radical destruction of science funding completely undermines a national lab system we’ve relied on since at least WW2. The firewall between the political staff in the White House and the criminal justice staff at DOJ has been a universally exalted norm since at least Nixon. What gives? Aren’t you mad as hell? You don’t seem to hold those folks “in great disrespect” when those are, I’d think, obviously load-bearing institutions being torn down essentially lawlessly, with almost no pretense that it’s for any cause other than “in the name of their own political power.” Is there some reason those institutions don’t count?
1. My suspicion comes from the fact that nothing has substantively changed between then and now. These are the same arguments although I guess they've had an (anti-)Trump spin put on them. There's a history here, these arguments aren't new.
2. I just don't see what MAGA has to do witg this. Packing the Supreme Court or removing the EC system is far more radical than anything Trump has yet done and I don't think it is particularly close. Of those things you mentioned, some are good, some are useful fictions, and some are subject to revision. But undermining the way we choose our chief constitutional office holder imo would be far more divisive and more destructive than anything DOGE did. You could argue the left's most basic goal is remaking society as they wish it to be so I don't find that argument convincing either. This is for a different discussion but it's a point I made in 2024. For all the talk of the danger of Trump dems did exactly zero to court conservatives who they said should be worried about Trump. Their attitude was "Trump is a fascist so you have to vote for us." Since that first statement was not an agreed upon fact, it held no purchase.
Come on, you ask me to believe that? Giving the president unilateral authority to cancel any congressional spending he doesn’t like is a less radical change to our institutions than electing the President based on popular vote?
Two guys walk into the room. The first says “I would support a constitutional amendment to elect presidents by popular vote.” The second says “I think the president should have unilateral authority to go to war, cancel any portion of the budget, order his political opponents to be prosecuted and fire anyone who refuses, and send hundreds of thousands of masked police into any jurisdiction who answer only to him and don’t need a judicial warrant for anything they do. Oh and both the president and all those police should have basically infinite legal immunity for anything they do with that power.”
You’re seriously gonna clutch your pearls about the first guy “burning down institutions”? Speak reverently about the Founders’ Vision and how it’s being betrayed? Fucking hell, man, you make it hard to interpret you generously sometimes. Personally I bet if you showed all the founders the current population and representation of Montana vs California (neither of which were states yet in their time!), a good number would say “hmm, yeah, that’s a bit silly.” Meanwhile I bet you couldn’t find a single founder who would look at the current powers and immunities we grant the executive and say “yup, perfect, that’s what we thought we were building.”
First, I don't think you are appreciating how big of a change messing with the Electoral College would be and how very intentionally going around is antithetical to the Constitution as set up.
Biden tried forgive hundreds of billions in student debt illegally. Presidents regularly fight with congress how how exactly to spend appropriated money. Presidents have taken millitary action on their own since very early, the congressional input into war making is one of the very first things that started to go in the republic. And of course Trump knows all about people going after him with the law. The NY prosecution was absurd. But thankfully we have judges and juries and I think the problem in coming years actually goes the other way but again something for later.
You do know FDR used the IRS (technically it's predecessor iirc) to go after people, that he used government regulation of the airways to shut down his opponents, that he put Japanese Americans in camps? Nevemind that immigration law has *never* worked the same way as criminal law, it couldn't function if it did.
Yet despite all that, FDR's court packing was rejected by his own party and the EC system remains.
What you think is unprecedented is merely ignorance and a bias towards today since we survived yesterday. The presidency has become more powerful but I'm not seeing any principle here by Trump's opponents as they see it more about him than Congress's abdication.
I mean it’s weird because if your point is “sure, Trump has committed a bunch of atrocities and abuses of power but also those are pretty normal throughout American history” then, I mean, yeah, kinda? You sound more like GH than Intro saying that but yes, we’ve got lots of ugly stuff in our history. Is Trump’s current use of ICE worse than COINTELPRO? Or Japanese internment? The Trail of Tears? No, probably not.
That said, has any president ever ordered the DOJ to prosecute their political opponents before? Raided a member of Congress trying to find evidence to get their citizenship revoked? Eliminated whole government agencies, lawfully created and funded by Congress, entirely by executive decree? You can’t carry water for that stuff and then turn around and tell me you’re a traditionalist, a Burkean institutionalist, who just hates to see people tearing down systems without due Chesterton’s Fence respect that maybe what came before was there for a reason.
I've long been an advocate for a more assertive Congress. That's not my point here though, which is much more narrow. I am saying that doing things like adding Justices or all but eliminating the EC are more destructive than whatever Trump is up to. I mean look at your lists, they really aren't constitutional issues, they are fights between branches within the system itself about who gets to do what and to what extent.
And BTW the DOJ has been abused throughout it's lifetime that one falls into the category of "useful fiction" that I mentioned before. But again, those are fights that can be had, they aren't constitutional end runs. The constitution doesn't even have any named departments in it, Washington really is why we have the cabinet system we have. So again I just think you aren't considering the consequences or the severity of things like the compact.
“Fights between branches” are absolutely “constitutional issues”? That said we’ve got oBlade in between providing much better examples of what a bad faith right wing interlocutor would sound like, so I should back off on you a little bit.
You didn't at all start to wonder whether you were in a disinformation bubble when you confidently alluded to hundreds of thousands of scary masked police when ICE have... like 22,000 agents?
![[image loading]](https://i.redd.it/o0r6tgwkge2i1.jpeg)