I mean come on, look at the before and after picture.
Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 43
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
PaqMan
United States1475 Posts
I mean come on, look at the before and after picture. | ||
|
Novalisk
Israel1818 Posts
| ||
|
Randomaccount#77123
United States5003 Posts
| ||
|
Amui
Canada10567 Posts
| ||
|
Triscuit
United States722 Posts
On May 15 2011 15:39 Barrin wrote: Then maybe people should stop making it seem like the woman is to blame, and be clear that it's they think it's the system that is at fault? She did make the choice to exact revenge in this way as opposed to letting the prison system handle him. For that, I believe she was wrong. The system gave her the option of what is essentially torture, and for that I believe the system is also wrong. It's not torture in the sense that he is feeling pain, but he is being disfigured. Just because you have something horrible done to you by someone does not excuse you from scrutiny for your actions afterwards. | ||
|
nOia.pod
Hungary263 Posts
| ||
|
Randomaccount#77123
United States5003 Posts
| ||
|
vetinari
Australia602 Posts
On May 15 2011 15:55 Barrin wrote: I stand by my original statement. It is fascinating how some people jump right to their opinion on her actions instead of his/the system's. You know, you could just say, "you're all a bunch of misogynists". We don't talk about his actions, because there is nothing to debate about it. Acid throwing is wrong. Period. | ||
|
TYJ.Aoy
Brazil1265 Posts
On May 15 2011 15:43 Triscuit wrote: She did make the choice to exact revenge in this way as opposed to letting the prison system handle him. For that, I believe she was wrong. The system gave her the option of what is essentially torture, and for that I believe the system is also wrong. It's not torture in the sense that he is feeling pain, but he is being disfigured. Just because you have something horrible done to you by someone does not excuse you from scrutiny for your actions afterwards. Well now, that's kinda lopsided, isn't it?It opens way for e.g pedophiles to think that abusing lots of children is totally worth whatever light punishment(let's say 20 years in prison) they may get instead of getting castrated and being tortured to death .It may not excuse you, but it totally excuses me and I hope many more out there. | ||
|
Olinim
4044 Posts
On May 15 2011 16:22 TYJ.Aoy wrote: Well now, that's kinda lopsided, isn't it?It opens way for e.g pedophiles to think that abusing lots of children is totally worth whatever light punishment(let's say 20 years in prison) they may get instead of getting castrated and being tortured to death .It may not excuse you, but it totally excuses me and I hope many more out there.The punishment shouldn't be inhumane or disproportionate simply to reduce the number of offenses. Hey, I have an idea, lets give the death sentence for shoplifting!! No one will do it anymore that's for sure. | ||
|
TYJ.Aoy
Brazil1265 Posts
On May 15 2011 16:44 Olinim wrote: How is an eye for an eye disproportionate?Also, abusing children and getting castrated for it is not disproportionate either, but this particular situation unlike the woman's is pretty subjective as most situations are, so I'm open to discuss how molesters should get punished but I'm pretty sure prison only won't do it.The punishment shouldn't be inhumane or disproportionate simply to reduce the number of offenses. Hey, I have an idea, lets give the death sentence for shoplifting!! No one will do it anymore that's for sure. | ||
|
Triscuit
United States722 Posts
On May 15 2011 16:48 TYJ.Aoy wrote: How is an eye for an eye disproportionate?Also, abusing children and getting castrated for it is not disproportionate either. I don't really have much perspective on such a situation. I see such treatments as being barbaric and, although you might see them as being 'just' or 'proportionate', I would not want to live in a country that condones such violence. I also don't really condone the death penalty, either. I guess don't have a particularly strong opinion on this because death penalty and life incarceration both seem like terribly inelegant solutions. I don't have a better idea, granted, but life incarceration seems like the better of the two given options. Really I'm just happy something like this couldn't happen here in the US because of the 8th amendment (cruel or unusual punishment). Don't read this as being particularly nationalistic though, because I'm not. I just don't want to think about the government carrying out something like dripping acid in the eyes of a criminal. | ||
|
Valashu
Netherlands561 Posts
I feel better about the outcome of this case because the way Western media describes it, justice is rarely done and the perpetrator (if it's a male) get a slap on the wrist for ruining a womans life I do agree that people who commit crimes are most probably mentally ill but does that mean we have to keep trying to integrate them into society? Let them burn like they burned their victims and serve as an example. There are boundaries and I can think of a thousand places I'd rather be than in prison be but how is prison different from this type of punishment? In prison people get punished for their crimes and in severe cases (there is a thread about this) get the chance to either be a butt buddy or to grab a piece of glass and murder someone to get a 'better reputation'. Note that I said severe cases earlier, this doesn't happen to everyone in prison (I read the numbers somewhere) and I think prison has a place in law but I think prison isn't effective enough in it's job. It's like a loan, you rid society from a dangerous individual but he/she/it will come back several years older, scarred (not to be confused with scared) and 9 out of 10 cases (guessing) not helped/looked after in any way. Personally I see prison as random punishment, you essentially take someone out of society and therefore give the victim(s) a sense of security which lasts till the criminal is freed and you let the prison perform some random measure of punishment. Long post is long D: | ||
|
methematics
United States392 Posts
ok double mind fuck, what if she is so insistent on revenge so that HE will have to be with HER. man is this love or what. + Show Spoiler + Ok the second ones not so good, but anyone know a motive for any of this shit. obviosly revenge by the women, but what about the man?? | ||
|
Yoshi Kirishima
United States10383 Posts
You exact revenge. So what? Ok now you will know the rest of your life you caused someone else to suffer. If you were perfect, you would be able to ignore the fact that he caused you suffering. Of course we're not perfect, but we should strive to be. | ||
|
Pika Chu
Romania2510 Posts
On May 15 2011 15:55 Barrin wrote: I stand by my original statement. It is fascinating how some people jump right to their opinion on her actions instead of his/the system's. It is about her actions and not the system. The iranian justice system gave her two choices according to their laws: prison or same punishment (and this came only after she and her lawyers requested multiple times). The judges as far as i red even begged her not to chose the second, same as a big part of the people of iran. She chose to definitely destroy his chances of living a good life, just as hers has been. We find it barbaric and we find it against the christian beliefs, that most of us have been pumped with since we were little, but who are we to judge this? Can we comprehend what she's been going through ever since that? How her life was destroyed in an irremediable way? She won't be able to turn back time and make herself any better but i do understand what her amount of hate must be. This can be debated in so many ways from endless perspectives, from the absolute morale to the subjective emotion of the person herself. She's the one who however had the choice in her hands, and she made it. The whole justice system basically just washed their hands (reminds me of the biblical story of pillat who washes his hand on jesus's matter) and transferred the whole emotional charge over her. | ||
|
Valashu
Netherlands561 Posts
On May 15 2011 17:18 Yoshi Kirishima wrote: An eye for an eye makes the world go blind. You exact revenge. So what? Ok now you will know the rest of your life you caused someone else to suffer. If you were perfect, you would be able to ignore the fact that he caused you suffering. Of course we're not perfect, but we should strive to be. The problem with that is that people will keep doing those things and no one is perfect. Yes, in a perfect world, the victim has such a big heart that he/she/it won't demand punishment for what the criminal has done and the criminal will have all the help society can give him/her/it to integrate into society. But that is not just a perfect person but also a perfect society and a perfect situation. | ||
|
zaldinfox
Canada60 Posts
This is the real moral dilemma: who should administer the punishment? | ||
|
TheAntZ
Israel6248 Posts
On May 15 2011 15:43 Triscuit wrote: She did make the choice to exact revenge in this way as opposed to letting the prison system handle him. For that, I believe she was wrong. Its easy to judge others and say they're wrong, when nothing of this magnitude was ever done to you or anyone you hold dear. | ||
|
MamiyaOtaru
United States1687 Posts
On May 15 2011 17:13 methematics wrote: WOW, i just thought about this. What if he did it to make her ugly so that she couldn't find anyone else, since he wanted to marry her. Maybe he tried to burn her so that she would have to be with him essentially. anyone else know a motive??? ok double mind fuck, what if she is so insistent on revenge so that HE will have to be with HER. man is this love or what. Ok the second ones not so good, but anyone know a motive for any of this shit. obviosly revenge by the women, but what about the man?? spite. it's not rocket science | ||
| ||
.It may not excuse you, but it totally excuses me and I hope many more out there.