This is also why I support not that long prision punishments (as long as they're not a danger to society) and rehabilitation. Which works pretty well in Norway, where we got a low crimerate and a low rate of ex-cons who go back to doing criminal activites. This system will not satisfise most victims thurst for vengance, but it will benefit society more.
Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 45
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
TheFisherman
20 Posts
This is also why I support not that long prision punishments (as long as they're not a danger to society) and rehabilitation. Which works pretty well in Norway, where we got a low crimerate and a low rate of ex-cons who go back to doing criminal activites. This system will not satisfise most victims thurst for vengance, but it will benefit society more. | ||
|
nOia.pod
Hungary263 Posts
On May 15 2011 21:55 TheFisherman wrote: What the person deserves or not isn't really relavant. I for once wish to live in a society that is as much nonviolent and safe as possible. Thus I'll have a higher chance at living a long and good life. And in order to achive this, society has to reject violence and torture as much as possible, only using it when it's highly neccesary. That why I think it's rather foolish to support punishments like this, which are based on torture and violence, because it will make the society more positivly tuned toward a more violent mentality. This is also why I support not that long prision punishments (as long as they're not a danger to society) and rehabilitation. Which works pretty well in Norway, where we got a low crimerate and a low rate of ex-cons who go back to doing criminal activites. This system will not satisfise most victims thurst for vengance, but it will benefit society more. Welcome nordic model. This is what we are talking about almost 50 pages ago. You are living in a whole different society, that's because you can't accept the punishment. Vice versa. | ||
|
Vul
United States685 Posts
| ||
|
MadNeSs
Denmark1507 Posts
| ||
|
thekoven
United States128 Posts
| ||
|
TheFisherman
20 Posts
On May 15 2011 22:11 nOia.pod wrote: Welcome nordic model. This is what we are talking about almost 50 pages ago. You are living in a whole different society, that's because you can't accept the punishment. Vice versa. I thought I gave reasons for why I don't approve of these types of punishments in my first paragraph? Alot of people in Norway actually approves of the punishment this man recived, so my standpoint got nothing to do with culture. Just logic (which of course could be flawed, but please point the flaws out in this case). | ||
|
hookyelyak
Egypt184 Posts
| ||
|
Denia1
148 Posts
On May 15 2011 22:53 TheFisherman wrote: I thought I gave reasons for why I don't approve of these types of punishments in my first paragraph? Alot of people in Norway actually approves of the punishment this man recived, so my standpoint got nothing to do with culture. Just logic (which of course could be flawed, but please point the flaws out in this case). Well the flaw is in that you do not choose what society you are born into and hence that society might have a high crime rate and ex-cons happily going back to their old ways once out of prison. And in such a society, harsher punishments like this one might be a more pragmatic and useful solution to the issue than trying to re-establish social pressures and make the rehabilitation system work better; adopting deterring punishments and prevention of crime instead reparation and rehabilitation might work better in such a setting. Sure I agree with you on the fact that a society that has lower crime rates and lower punishments and is non-violent is better to live in, but you have to get there first - a society can't just spontaneously come into that stage. And I think it can start getting there by reducing the crime rates first of all by using deterring punishments and after they have been reduced, then rehabilitation policies can be put into place and punishments can be less severe. I think a legal system is a pragmatic tool that needs to be amended and adapted to each specific society at a certain time; there isn't a universally good solution for any situation at any time. i am not 100% sure that the solution being used in this case is appropriate, but I can see its advantages over a reparation solution. | ||
|
Randomaccount#77123
United States5003 Posts
| ||
|
IzieBoy
United States865 Posts
i guess it's too bad he doesn't have the cash to pay her...by the way "in love with her"? wow... someone's aiming low...is she rich or smart or what is it? from the picture...maybe beauty is different for their people... lol love works in strange ways.... i'm actually more digusted by the mob mentality that wants to blind this poor man for a crime he did... he should be locked away for good and put to good uses... but blinding is a tad too much...strange woman...strange world EDIT: most of the time crimes are fostered and rationalized by the ideas of revenge, fear, and anger... having such harsh punishments only cheapens the value of life... at least in their culture... that man could have many friends to exact revenge and further the cycle... it's pretty easy for ppl to overestimate the hurt they have received... also it just aint good to go around throwing acid ... at women too... wth... i guess you would always have killer rapists and men who can't control their primal urges to prey on women... kinda re-enforces the bad social situation women are already in... acid in the name of love? ... jeez ... anyways, i think the man should pay up with the rest of his life... but blinding should only be used as a last resort if he refuses to slave away or meet performance bars .... | ||
|
zalz
Netherlands3704 Posts
On May 15 2011 23:06 hookyelyak wrote: the sharia punishment regime is build around deterrence ....as any old legal system.because societies lacked the capability for an efficient enforcement force so who get caught get a severe punishment.....an eye for an eye...it will make the world blind but lacking it will make it unlivable. Most crimes aren't planned out so the concept op deterence goes into the long list of: "Things that sound reasonable and therefore are the truth of the land" Deterence is a dangerous idea combined with how politicians will never want to be known for being soft on crime. The endresult can be very gruesome as people continue to strive for a crime-free society. An unobtainable ideal that should not be strived for in any serious degree. The death penalty for example has not been proven to decrease murder rates in America when compared to similarly developed nations like most countries in western Europe. Some even suggest that it increases murder as it sends out a signal to the culture that murder can be justified. | ||
|
Grenadieris
Latvia33 Posts
On May 15 2011 07:28 Tor wrote: I wouldn't relate the nazi act of genocide to war. And killing civilians during war is a war crime (and many germans were punished for it) No amount of punishment will return the womans face. She will never be reimbursed for her sufferings. Burning the mans face will accomplish nothing that jail time couldn't, except jail time provides the chance of rehabilitation and doesn't condemn innocents to commit a violent act on fellow human beings. It also prevents the man who just lost his face ad his reputation, who has nothing to lose from reoffending in an even more sinister manner. It happened before and (mostly) during the war, so I don't see why I wouldn't relate them. In fact many cases of genocide happen during war, I hope you see where this is going. Some germans were punished, but many escaped justice, and died in peace. Punishment for war crimes is a pretty cool thing in theory, but most of the time innocent people just get killed and nobody gets punished. That is the reality. This punishment wont bring her face back, but there's this thing called justice... Punishment that is equal to the crime committed. That is what jail time fails to do. So he sits in the jail, later gets released, lets say he starts to live a normal life again. Now look at the woman, her life is still fucked up, and there will be no release from her "prison" ever. Does that seem like fair punishment for you? One person loses her life quality forever, while the other one loses his freedom for few years. I don't see that as fair. Now imagine the man comes out of the prison and proceeds to kill her or throw acid on another woman. Nothing jail time can't do? And it's not like she was forced to do it, she could choose, so don't talk about innocent people being condemned. | ||
|
OccamsRazer
United States22 Posts
On May 14 2011 08:46 Airship wrote: An eye for an eye. This is an Old Testament philosophy that probably originated before Islam and Christianity split. As such, the "turn the other cheek" philosophy does not apply to Islam. Interesting. | ||
|
Eggm
United States152 Posts
I'd prefer they got creative and ordered a transplant for his eyes to be put in the woman (assuming that's possible) and all the money he has to pay be used for plastic surgery. Everyone saying the whole world goes blind is stupid. Once he's blind he's not going to have the ability to blind anyone else, because he will be BLIND. And no one is going to do it for him cause hes a piece of shit no one cares enough to help. So it ends with him as far as people going blind. | ||
|
IzieBoy
United States865 Posts
On May 16 2011 01:47 OccamsRazer wrote: This is an Old Testament philosophy that probably originated before Islam and Christianity split. As such, the "turn the other cheek" philosophy does not apply to Islam. Interesting. Islam sees Jesus as a prophet, so it should still apply... I really want to learn more about Islam, even though vibe I'm getting now is sort of the "70 virgins for a jihad" or "conquer them infidels?" this woman's story actually reminds me of the time in 3rd grade (it could be 6th grade, because i felt as if my 6th grade buddy was there, but i remember a different school yard, so most likely 3rd). I was more of an impulsive type and provoked a fight over handball, where I got kicked in the balls. I was mad as hell, and first thing I wanted to do was to kick him right back as soon as I could stand, but the friends around me convinced me to go to the principal... i cooled down and basically forgave the guy; i barely knew him anyways... more than a decade later... the memorable experience of being kicked in the balls more than made up for the excruciating pain i felt that day... i understand the woman's situation is way different, but sometimes it's best to just see what brings the most good out of a bad situation... | ||
|
hookyelyak
Egypt184 Posts
On May 16 2011 01:30 zalz wrote: Most crimes aren't planned out so the concept op deterence goes into the long list of: "Things that sound reasonable and therefore are the truth of the land" Deterence is a dangerous idea combined with how politicians will never want to be known for being soft on crime. The endresult can be very gruesome as people continue to strive for a crime-free society. An unobtainable ideal that should not be strived for in any serious degree. The death penalty for example has not been proven to decrease murder rates in America when compared to similarly developed nations like most countries in western Europe. Some even suggest that it increases murder as it sends out a signal to the culture that murder can be justified. here in egypt after the revolution crime rate skyrocketed because the loose security situation...criminals see consequences and they decide depending on it....u say the use of violent punishment cause more violent ...but when criminals already are extremely violent u need a swift counter....that said i think the difference between america and western europe is that america is too conservative right leaning capitalist country that it leave lower classes under pressure .and the slightly socialist Europe is more protective of lower classes......i think the real answer to crime is not only tough punishment but a just and compassionate society where the lesser classes don't feel alienated and no one feel dropped out of the society.where every one has a chance of achieving themselves... crime,hate and envy will vanish. | ||
|
cocosoft
Sweden1068 Posts
On May 14 2011 08:49 Malgrif wrote: it's the woman's fault though. she shouldn't have made him fall in love with her. Uh? ... User was warned for this post | ||
|
Sahand
United Kingdom114 Posts
YES that is the point gandhi was trying to make..... | ||
|
stOrpse
United States175 Posts
On May 14 2011 08:47 daytrippers wrote: will there be a stream? how much is HD pass I lold User was warned for this post | ||
|
Bonkarooni
United States383 Posts
On May 15 2011 21:55 TheFisherman wrote: What the person deserves or not isn't really relavant. I for once wish to live in a society that is as much nonviolent and safe as possible. Thus I'll have a higher chance at living a long and good life. And in order to achive this, society has to reject violence and torture as much as possible, only using it when it's highly neccesary. That why I think it's rather foolish to support punishments like this, which are based on torture and violence, because it will make the society more positivly tuned toward a more violent mentality. This is also why I support not that long prision punishments (as long as they're not a danger to society) and rehabilitation. Which works pretty well in Norway, where we got a low crimerate and a low rate of ex-cons who go back to doing criminal activites. This system will not satisfise most victims thurst for vengance, but it will benefit society more. except when criminals realize they can do whatever they want without harsh punishment. | ||
| ||