|
Canada3819 Posts
Aye aye.
I once lived in Saudi for a few years, even though I was pretty much segregated from the Arabic way of life, I did see/hear many things that really put it in to perspective how different the Sharia law world is to the Western world. It's almost in my nature now to stop being shocked at what occurs in these countries. I believe it was a thread on here some time ago...a girl who got raped was publicly flogged because she shouldn't have been hanging out with boys in the first place. Justice is served hm?
Woo!
|
If I were in her shoes of course I'd want revenge just as she does. It's the reason victim's or relatives of victims aren't the ones passing on sentences for the court. I wont condemn her for doing it because, quite frankly, I'd do the same thing. However, the courts shouldn't allow it for that exact reason.
The question that is also debated in this thread about rehabilitation vs punishment is always an interesting one. While the idea of rehabilitation is certainly find and dandy, it just doesn't work yet. And that means in the meantime, keeping the people out of the public is the best option. It's a shame on all accounts, really. Parents just need to figure out how to raise children not to be stupid shits. Then again, that's been a struggle since the birth of man, so I wont hold my breath.
|
who the heck throws acid on the face of someone who rejects them? I'm pretty glad she's able to do the same back to him, he's clearly not of mature mind in the first place and if he's ever going to learn, this would be the only way. I don't advocate their laws though.
|
Canada3819 Posts
It's unfortunate...but she got hydralisked.
And now she shall hydralisk him back.
hEYEdralisk.
|
On May 15 2011 15:39 Barrin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 15:23 Darksidius wrote: Wheter we (or the victim) think the guy deserves this kind of punishment is irrelevant. The question is, is it an accaptable form of law and punishment by a government/legal system. There is only one answer to that: no, it is barbaric.
Take the case of Marc Dutroux in Belgium for instance, do I personally think he would deserve to be tortured and put to death? Yes I do! Is it acceptable for a governmet or legal system to carry out such a sentence? No, it isn't! Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 15:23 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 15:18 Barrin wrote: I find it fascinating that so many people are more readily willing to condemn "her actions" than "his actions". That's because the subject of the thread whether or not its the right form of punishment, everyone is in agreement that what he did was deplorable. Then maybe people should stop making it seem like the woman is to blame, and be clear that it's they think it's the system that is at fault? Oh absolutely! I don't even want to think about being in her shoes, let alone condemn her actions. He is a terrible human being and would deserve any form of torture as a punishment in my eyes. It's just that a government should be above any kind of emotional (or eye for an eye) retribution.
It is a horrible sad story, no matter from what angle you look at it.
|
Just another point to show that certain countries still live in the dark ages :/
|
On May 15 2011 18:28 Darksidius wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 15:39 Barrin wrote:On May 15 2011 15:23 Darksidius wrote: Wheter we (or the victim) think the guy deserves this kind of punishment is irrelevant. The question is, is it an accaptable form of law and punishment by a government/legal system. There is only one answer to that: no, it is barbaric.
Take the case of Marc Dutroux in Belgium for instance, do I personally think he would deserve to be tortured and put to death? Yes I do! Is it acceptable for a governmet or legal system to carry out such a sentence? No, it isn't! On May 15 2011 15:23 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 15:18 Barrin wrote: I find it fascinating that so many people are more readily willing to condemn "her actions" than "his actions". That's because the subject of the thread whether or not its the right form of punishment, everyone is in agreement that what he did was deplorable. Then maybe people should stop making it seem like the woman is to blame, and be clear that it's they think it's the system that is at fault? Oh absolutely! I don't even want to think about being in her shoes, let alone condemn her actions. He is a terrible human being and would deserve any form of torture as a punishment in my eyes. It's just that a government should be above any kind of emotional (or eye for an eye) retribution. It is a horrible sad story, no matter from what angle you look at it.
I don't know about the Netherlands, but the US has the death penalty. I'm sure there are other situations within the laws of all countries where an eye for an eye is suitable. I can't really go one way or another on this one. Losing (or almost) losing your own ability to see because of someone's stupidity I couldn't bring myself to say no if they were getting legal revenge.
|
The way I see it. Probably out of the thousands of people on this site there might be one or two people who in a fit of rage would throw acid into the face of someone who rejected them. My opinion is that the law is fair in this case. Given that she has not only been blinded(which is all that's happening to the man btw), but permanently disfigured, I would say the man is getting off relatively lightly.
I've read arguments regarding an eye for an eye makes the world blind and how this is against christian values and whatever.
I argue that very people will cost others eyes within their lifetimes. I know for a fact that put in the same situation as that man, I would not throw acid into someone's eyes. I'm very sure that even the vast majority of people on TL would not throw acid in her eyes and probably the majority if not everyone in this thread has higher moral values than that. I do not see why anyone would support a monster that would do something like this to someone else.
In addition, based upon the fact that this is occuring in Iran, Christian values didn't even come into the consideration beyond the outside aid and compensation offered. This man is going to the Christian view of hell based on his religion and his acts in life, he's just going to experience it earlier.
One final thought, the fact that she is blind probably has something to do with the not quite eye for an eye thing. I doubt she realizes how disfigured her face truly is given that she's almost completely blind. Five drops of acid in each eye is all the man is getting.
|
On May 15 2011 18:34 Valentir wrote: Just another point to show that certain countries still live in the dark ages :/
More like culture shock
|
Good for her.
Fuck that asshole, he deserves it.
What kind of human just throws acid on someone for no good reason?
|
An eye for an eye is not a smart system, it's easy to see how this could get out of hand
|
"I don't believe in the philosophy an eye for an eye. I believe in two eyes for an eye!" - Bas Rutten
|
United States44453 Posts
On May 15 2011 18:23 Smurg wrote: It's unfortunate...but she got hydralisked.
And now she shall hydralisk him back.
hEYEdralisk. After all these years how do you still not know that hydralisks fire spines?
|
On May 15 2011 18:48 EchoZ wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 18:34 Valentir wrote: Just another point to show that certain countries still live in the dark ages :/ More like culture shock
I think the dark ages comparison is valid because many news items from such countries reminds me of the dark ages a lot.
|
On May 15 2011 06:21 LloydRays wrote: I don't see a problem with eye for an eye in this special circumstance, like you ruined the womans life by disfiguring her. Its much different than if you steal they cut off a finger. We have eye for an eye in the United States, its called the death penalty.
It's not less barbaric just because you do the same thing in the US.
In fact, you making that connection should probably make you reconsider if the US criminal justice system is a system worthy that of a civilized nation.
|
On May 15 2011 19:30 KwarK wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 18:23 Smurg wrote: It's unfortunate...but she got hydralisked.
And now she shall hydralisk him back.
hEYEdralisk. After all these years how do you still not know that hydralisks fire spines?
She got roached, I would say.
|
On May 15 2011 09:37 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 09:35 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:32 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:30 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:26 Darkness2k11 wrote: The way i see it, punishing violence with violence is not the best way to do it. why not, at least give her the right to exact her revenge. she will feel much better after that and a retard will learn the only way retards learn how to deal with other people properly. If it makes her feel better to pour acid in someone's eye then she is just as demented as he is. or she just got her life ruined by an idiot and nothing else would make her feel slightly better. one of the two. Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what. Just my 2 cents though.
Pretty words from a bystander.
Of course, I do not ignore the possibility that you could've had the same thing happen to you in the past, but with your unshakable moral fortitude, you cheekily spanked the perpetrator's bottom, and with a wink of your glittery partially blind left eye, wished him/her best of luck for the future. "hEYEdralisk hwaiting!"
|
On May 15 2011 18:13 bulldyke wrote: who the heck throws acid on the face of someone who rejects them? I'm pretty glad she's able to do the same back to him, he's clearly not of mature mind in the first place and if he's ever going to learn, this would be the only way. I don't advocate their laws though. what does maturity have to do with this lol? sick mind more like and that probably won't "learn"
|
Canada3819 Posts
On May 15 2011 19:30 KwarK wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 18:23 Smurg wrote: It's unfortunate...but she got hydralisked.
And now she shall hydralisk him back.
hEYEdralisk. After all these years how do you still not know that hydralisks fire spines? Acidic spines good sir!
|
On May 15 2011 19:47 nOia.pod wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 19:30 KwarK wrote:On May 15 2011 18:23 Smurg wrote: It's unfortunate...but she got hydralisked.
And now she shall hydralisk him back.
hEYEdralisk. After all these years how do you still not know that hydralisks fire spines? She got roached, I would say.
Baneling'd to the face i would say
|
|
|
|
|
|