|
On May 15 2011 09:43 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 09:41 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:37 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:35 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:32 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:30 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:26 Darkness2k11 wrote: The way i see it, punishing violence with violence is not the best way to do it. why not, at least give her the right to exact her revenge. she will feel much better after that and a retard will learn the only way retards learn how to deal with other people properly. If it makes her feel better to pour acid in someone's eye then she is just as demented as he is. or she just got her life ruined by an idiot and nothing else would make her feel slightly better. one of the two. Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what. Just my 2 cents though. too bad you are wrong. if somebody ruins your life nothing would make you feel as good as him receiving the same treatment. but keep denying the obvious doesn't really matter. You can't tell me what would make me feel good, simply inflicting searing pain on someone would accomplish nothing and would probably scar me further.
I'm in this camp. However much I would want to hurt someone I wouldn't actually do it.
|
On May 15 2011 07:56 Tor wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:33 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 07:29 Djabanete wrote: Come on guys, really? What the hell is torturing the guy supposed to fix?
In an ideal world, there would be a sentence that met the following criteria:
A) It rehabilitated the guy so he wouldn't do anything of the sort again. B) It rehabilitated the woman so she wouldn't be permanently disfigured and emotionally scarred. C) It didn't cost the taxpayers a dime.
Now obviously this isn't going to happen; not all these things are possible at once, or at all. But torturing him doesn't accomplish anything; it doesn't even make him a better person, because as this woman just proved, being plunged into violence and pain doesn't make you a better person, it makes you more likely to inflict violence and pain on others. The cycle of vindictiveness and crime is the same that we see in our criminal justice system in the U.S. Bad shit happens in prison, and that doesn't make prison sentences more just; it just fosters more bad shit.
IMO there should be infrastructure for locking this guy up safely and humanely. Once he's locked up and no longer a danger to society, then he can work his ass off and the money he earns can go to the woman (for what it's worth in reparation) and to the taxpayers (to alleviate the burden of keeping locked up). Once he's fulfilled both a heavy work quota and a minimum duration (not for me to judge) he can be released. That is the closest thing I can think of to fixing/neutralizing him, helping the victim, and serving the taxpayers.
B is possibly impossible. A and C are possible. Eye for an Eye satisfies C and possibly A. Jail satisfies maybe A and not C, unless if this idea you said was used. Sadly, there is no viable prisoners working for money scenario as far as I know. Thus, Eye for an Eye is most effective in achieving an utopian outcome. No, burning the mans face will not prevent him from reoffending. You would have to kill him or rehabilitate him, thus it doesn't fulfill A (not that there is any reason to believe a,b and c are all that is needed for some imaginary utopia). I'm guessing you'd support the former.
Actually, besides pure fairness, isn't a justification for eye for an eye the idea that the offender wont do it again? Oh wait, its that they wont do it in the first place. I still stand by my point that burning him in the face might make him be a good(admittedly waste-faced) citizen. The only reason i said utopia was because of the post above.
Edit: okay i was being stupid i didnt know he was going in jail for two years too you win.
|
I was talking about this with one of the girls I work with, we both agree this is a great punishment. I mean, him sitting in jail for a while just adds more of a burden to the government (money wise) and after a while he may even get out. After looking at the picture of the lady her life will never be the same, so why should his?
|
Logically the punishment is ridiculous. I could never condone the use of "eye for an eye" from a standpoint of reason alone. Emotionally, though, it definitely feels justified. What I see in this thread is a clash of emotion versus logic. And in this world, logic usually wins. Usually. Sometimes we get crazy laws like don't buy alcohol on sunday.
In a civilized society, there are limitations on what we can do in the name of justice. And there should be limitations. It's not our responsibility to make sure that people suffer properly for their crimes... a true sense of justice is not something that we can claim. We simply try our best to make sure that people that are a danger to society are either prevented from doing so again or rehabilitated.
|
i think i would go out of my way to attack and blind someone who had blinded me and disfigured my face, legally or not... Wether you call it justice or retribution, it would make no difference. Throw acid in my face and I'll most likely try to snap your neck, and not think twice about it. What kind of human would I be if I didn't? I'm not gandhi or jesus, I won't love you for throwing acid in my face. As I see it, anyone not punching back or wanting revenge is either extremely accepting or just not entirely 'human'. By simple and crude logic, you are more worth than the scumbag throwing acid in your face, so why shouldn't you strike back? it is our fear of being violent and being "barbaric" that truly makes us barbaric, for what are we if we tell a burnt woman that she must accept it? Reasoning and rationalizing isn't for everyone.
I understand that "our" western law will never allow for this, and also I don't think I support capital punishment. I feel strongly for self defence, but I don't want to consider extreme cases where people cut off your head or throw acid in your face, it is just bizarre and something almost none of us ever have to deal with. I still don't feel that there is nothing wrong with the word "retribution". I got retribution! Good for me! Maybe I was violent, but I feel it's the lesser 'inhumane' option, where you're being inhumane towards the offender rather than towards yourself or the victim. What assholes would tell that woman that the offender does not deserve to be blinded? That things are as they should be. That it was a tragedy but she must let it go. Hell no, that's just further abusing her as a victim. She's basically saying "Hey, he cant fucking do this to me, I'm not some animal you treat like shit because you felt like it". Anyone attempting to tell her to go down that 'path' (of thinking and reasoning) should get punched in the gut. It's basically stating that she's not human like the attacker and the rest of us. We will stand by watching and declaring justice, and frown upon your emotions and use words with negative connotation like "retribution".
Atleast that's how I see it. If anyone burnt my face, they better wish they can stay in jail forever.
p.s I'm NOT violent, I've never been in a situation with any physical abuse even remotely close to this one. But there are other forms of abuse, and none of them should you try to accept without feeling anger and a need to stand up for yourself or telling anyone they should; be it a school yard bully or an abusive husband/wife/anyone
--blinding her attacker might not make her medical situation better, but dangit, she'll feel good about it, she might feel more human again, feel stronger, and that she deserves. Obv revenge isn't for everyone, but she clearly feels strongly about it and I wouldn't fault her even 1% by trying to use negative words and make her look bad.
p.s.s. On the other hand, if you wish to make their legal system look bad, go for it :p, it sounds like it is less than optimal, and possibly irrational. But in this case I feel it's +1 for the victim
|
On May 15 2011 11:55 Cutlery wrote: i think i would go out of my way to attack and blind someone who had blinded me and disfigured my face, legally or not... Wether you call it justice or retribution, it would make no difference. Throw acid in my face and I'll most likely try to snap your neck, and not think twice about it. What kind of human would I be if I didn't? I'm not gandhi or jesus, I won't love you for throwing acid in my face. As I see it, anyone not punching back or wanting revenge is either extremely accepting or just not entirely 'human'. By simple and crude logic, you are more worth than the scumbag throwing acid in your face, so why shouldn't you strike back? it is our fear of being violent and being "barbaric" that truly makes us barbaric, for what are we if we tell a burnt woman that she must accept it? Reasoning and rationalizing isn't for everyone.
I understand that "our" western law will never allow for this, and also I don't think I support capital punishment. I feel strongly for self defence, but I don't want to consider extreme cases where people cut off your head or throw acid in your face, it is just bizarre and something almost none of us ever have to deal with. I still don't feel that there is nothing wrong with the word "retribution". I got retribution! Good for me! Maybe I was violent, but I feel it's the lesser 'inhumane' option, where you're being inhumane towards the offender rather than towards yourself or the victim. What assholes would tell that woman that the offender does not deserve to be blinded? That things are as they should be. That it was a tragedy but she must let it go. Hell no, that's just further abusing her as a victim. She's basically saying "Hey, he cant fucking do this to me, I'm not some animal you treat like shit because you felt like it". Anyone attempting to tell her to go down that 'path' (of thinking and reasoning) should get punched in the gut. It's basically stating that she's not human like the attacker and the rest of us. We will stand by watching and declaring justice, and frown upon your emotions and use words with negative connotation like "retribution".
Atleast that's how I see it. If anyone burnt my face, they better wish they can stay in jail forever.
p.s I'm NOT violent, I've never been in a situation with any physical abuse even remotely close to this one. But there are other forms of abuse, and none of them should you try to accept without feeling anger and a need to stand up for yourself or telling anyone they should; be it a school yard bully or an abusive husband/wife/anyone
--blinding her attacker might not make her medical situation better, but dangit, she'll feel good about it, she might feel more human again, feel stronger, and that she deserves. Obv revenge isn't for everyone, but she clearly feels strongly about it and I wouldn't fault her even 1% by trying to use negative words and make her look bad.
p.s.s. On the other hand, if you wish to make their legal system look bad, go for it :p, it sounds like it is less than optimal, and possibly irrational. But in this case I feel it's +1 for the victim
"IF YOU WRONG ME I WILL SEEK YOU OUT AND DESTROY YOU, YOU BETTER PRAY YOU STAY IN JAIL FOREVER OR I WILL BREAK YOUR NECK!!!!!!!!!! DIE!!!!!! ps im not violent"
rofl.
|
On May 15 2011 09:37 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 09:35 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:32 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:30 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:26 Darkness2k11 wrote: The way i see it, punishing violence with violence is not the best way to do it. why not, at least give her the right to exact her revenge. she will feel much better after that and a retard will learn the only way retards learn how to deal with other people properly. If it makes her feel better to pour acid in someone's eye then she is just as demented as he is. or she just got her life ruined by an idiot and nothing else would make her feel slightly better. one of the two. Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what. Just my 2 cents though.
"Heres how I think other people should think, and here is the set of morals everyone should have. If you say im wrong you're dumb.
Just my 2 cents though."
|
On May 15 2011 12:16 TheAntZ wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 09:37 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:35 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:32 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:30 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:26 Darkness2k11 wrote: The way i see it, punishing violence with violence is not the best way to do it. why not, at least give her the right to exact her revenge. she will feel much better after that and a retard will learn the only way retards learn how to deal with other people properly. If it makes her feel better to pour acid in someone's eye then she is just as demented as he is. or she just got her life ruined by an idiot and nothing else would make her feel slightly better. one of the two. Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what. Just my 2 cents though. "Heres how I think other people should think, and here is the set of morals everyone should have. If you say im wrong you're dumb. Just my 2 cents though."
What? I never said anyone was dumb, and you could say the same thing about what the other guy said, so what are you even talking about? Obviously everyone has an opinion, and mine is that if pouring acid in someones eye gives you pleasure, you are messed up.
|
True retribution could only happen if the guy wasn't sedated.
An eye for an eye .... not! -.-
I mean the results will be almost the same, but it won't be nearly as painful as it was for her.
|
On May 15 2011 12:18 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 12:16 TheAntZ wrote:On May 15 2011 09:37 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:35 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:32 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:30 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:26 Darkness2k11 wrote: The way i see it, punishing violence with violence is not the best way to do it. why not, at least give her the right to exact her revenge. she will feel much better after that and a retard will learn the only way retards learn how to deal with other people properly. If it makes her feel better to pour acid in someone's eye then she is just as demented as he is. or she just got her life ruined by an idiot and nothing else would make her feel slightly better. one of the two. Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what. Just my 2 cents though. "Heres how I think other people should think, and here is the set of morals everyone should have. If you say im wrong you're dumb. Just my 2 cents though." What? I never said anyone was dumb, and you could say the same thing about what the other guy said, so what are you even talking about? Obviously everyone has an opinion, and mine is that if pouring acid in someones eye gives you pleasure, you are messed up. "Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what." You are imposing your morals on others, saying that it shouldn't be possible for others to feel better by going for revenge with the acid thing. Clearly this implies that there is something wrong with everyone who supports the woman's choice. While that isn't synonymous to "you're all dumb," it does give off that sort of impression.
|
On May 15 2011 07:56 Tor wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:33 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 07:29 Djabanete wrote: Come on guys, really? What the hell is torturing the guy supposed to fix?
In an ideal world, there would be a sentence that met the following criteria:
A) It rehabilitated the guy so he wouldn't do anything of the sort again. B) It rehabilitated the woman so she wouldn't be permanently disfigured and emotionally scarred. C) It didn't cost the taxpayers a dime.
Now obviously this isn't going to happen; not all these things are possible at once, or at all. But torturing him doesn't accomplish anything; it doesn't even make him a better person, because as this woman just proved, being plunged into violence and pain doesn't make you a better person, it makes you more likely to inflict violence and pain on others. The cycle of vindictiveness and crime is the same that we see in our criminal justice system in the U.S. Bad shit happens in prison, and that doesn't make prison sentences more just; it just fosters more bad shit.
IMO there should be infrastructure for locking this guy up safely and humanely. Once he's locked up and no longer a danger to society, then he can work his ass off and the money he earns can go to the woman (for what it's worth in reparation) and to the taxpayers (to alleviate the burden of keeping locked up). Once he's fulfilled both a heavy work quota and a minimum duration (not for me to judge) he can be released. That is the closest thing I can think of to fixing/neutralizing him, helping the victim, and serving the taxpayers.
B is possibly impossible. A and C are possible. Eye for an Eye satisfies C and possibly A. Jail satisfies maybe A and not C, unless if this idea you said was used. Sadly, there is no viable prisoners working for money scenario as far as I know. Thus, Eye for an Eye is most effective in achieving an utopian outcome. No, burning the mans face will not prevent him from reoffending. You would have to kill him or rehabilitate him, thus it doesn't fulfill A (not that there is any reason to believe a,b and c are all that is needed for some imaginary utopia). I'm guessing you'd support the former.
Well, burning his eyes would probably prevent him from reoffending, when you consider how practical eyes are when it comes to commiting crimes. Also mental pain/scarring is close to overlooked compared to physical pain (and money for that matter). Mental pain barely exists in a logical world. The victim is not considered when giving sentence. It's slightly skewed with all the people crying out about terrorists being tortured, when alot worse is happening to regular people close to home, and specially to children, that isn't being taken nearly as seriously or as urgently. You can rehabilitate the victim mentally aswell. I think it should be considered as D) , even if it is impractical or impossible in most cases. There are many ways to take human life and health seriously, one of them is considering a form of retribution for the vicim should it help begin a healing process (releasing anger etc). Specially in cases such as rape, where the current jail time isn't nearly sufficient. I wouldn't want to be the one to demand public castration, but I'm sure it could feel awesome for the victim at some point in their life. ..Just as a wild idea
|
On May 15 2011 12:18 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 12:16 TheAntZ wrote:On May 15 2011 09:37 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:35 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:32 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:30 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:26 Darkness2k11 wrote: The way i see it, punishing violence with violence is not the best way to do it. why not, at least give her the right to exact her revenge. she will feel much better after that and a retard will learn the only way retards learn how to deal with other people properly. If it makes her feel better to pour acid in someone's eye then she is just as demented as he is. or she just got her life ruined by an idiot and nothing else would make her feel slightly better. one of the two. Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what. Just my 2 cents though. "Heres how I think other people should think, and here is the set of morals everyone should have. If you say im wrong you're dumb. Just my 2 cents though." What? I never said anyone was dumb, and you could say the same thing about what the other guy said, so what are you even talking about? Obviously everyone has an opinion, and mine is that if pouring acid in someones eye gives you pleasure, you are messed up.
Maybe losing eye-sight and your face can be qualified as "messed up". You can't hold her to your own couch-sitting toothpicking standards of what, to you, is 'theoretically' right and wrong. You haven't felt her pain, have you?
|
On May 15 2011 12:10 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 11:55 Cutlery wrote: i think i would go out of my way to attack and blind someone who had blinded me and disfigured my face, legally or not... Wether you call it justice or retribution, it would make no difference. Throw acid in my face and I'll most likely try to snap your neck, and not think twice about it. What kind of human would I be if I didn't? I'm not gandhi or jesus, I won't love you for throwing acid in my face. As I see it, anyone not punching back or wanting revenge is either extremely accepting or just not entirely 'human'. By simple and crude logic, you are more worth than the scumbag throwing acid in your face, so why shouldn't you strike back? it is our fear of being violent and being "barbaric" that truly makes us barbaric, for what are we if we tell a burnt woman that she must accept it? Reasoning and rationalizing isn't for everyone.
I understand that "our" western law will never allow for this, and also I don't think I support capital punishment. I feel strongly for self defence, but I don't want to consider extreme cases where people cut off your head or throw acid in your face, it is just bizarre and something almost none of us ever have to deal with. I still don't feel that there is nothing wrong with the word "retribution". I got retribution! Good for me! Maybe I was violent, but I feel it's the lesser 'inhumane' option, where you're being inhumane towards the offender rather than towards yourself or the victim. What assholes would tell that woman that the offender does not deserve to be blinded? That things are as they should be. That it was a tragedy but she must let it go. Hell no, that's just further abusing her as a victim. She's basically saying "Hey, he cant fucking do this to me, I'm not some animal you treat like shit because you felt like it". Anyone attempting to tell her to go down that 'path' (of thinking and reasoning) should get punched in the gut. It's basically stating that she's not human like the attacker and the rest of us. We will stand by watching and declaring justice, and frown upon your emotions and use words with negative connotation like "retribution".
Atleast that's how I see it. If anyone burnt my face, they better wish they can stay in jail forever.
p.s I'm NOT violent, I've never been in a situation with any physical abuse even remotely close to this one. But there are other forms of abuse, and none of them should you try to accept without feeling anger and a need to stand up for yourself or telling anyone they should; be it a school yard bully or an abusive husband/wife/anyone
--blinding her attacker might not make her medical situation better, but dangit, she'll feel good about it, she might feel more human again, feel stronger, and that she deserves. Obv revenge isn't for everyone, but she clearly feels strongly about it and I wouldn't fault her even 1% by trying to use negative words and make her look bad.
p.s.s. On the other hand, if you wish to make their legal system look bad, go for it :p, it sounds like it is less than optimal, and possibly irrational. But in this case I feel it's +1 for the victim "IF YOU WRONG ME I WILL SEEK YOU OUT AND DESTROY YOU, YOU BETTER PRAY YOU STAY IN JAIL FOREVER OR I WILL BREAK YOUR NECK!!!!!!!!!! DIE!!!!!! ps im not violent" rofl.
nice tl dr. I stand by it I would never harm a soul unless they were to threaten my life or someone elses life whom i cared about, and i'm not embarassed to say it. Punch me in the face and I'd probably just smile. Rape my friend and I'd probably taze you, for a very long time, and blow up your car maybe. Edit: Maybe stuff a stick up your ass too, while you are paralyzed from tazing. o_o and then i'd make arroused noises and ask you how you liked that stick up your poophole, while probably sobbing uncontrollably. It would be nice if we all had superheroes protecting us. Second best is to have an outlet for your severly crippling anger
|
I saw the picture, that poor woman. That guy should be tortured for weeks before being killed for what he did. He ruined her LIFE for NO reason. Hope he burns in hell
|
revenge would only bring more hatred - pain
|
On May 15 2011 13:07 Daiki wrote: revenge would only bring more hatred - pain
try saying that without a face :o
|
On May 15 2011 12:52 synapse wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 12:18 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 12:16 TheAntZ wrote:On May 15 2011 09:37 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:35 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:32 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 09:30 MYM.ClouD wrote:On May 15 2011 09:26 Darkness2k11 wrote: The way i see it, punishing violence with violence is not the best way to do it. why not, at least give her the right to exact her revenge. she will feel much better after that and a retard will learn the only way retards learn how to deal with other people properly. If it makes her feel better to pour acid in someone's eye then she is just as demented as he is. or she just got her life ruined by an idiot and nothing else would make her feel slightly better. one of the two. Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what. Just my 2 cents though. "Heres how I think other people should think, and here is the set of morals everyone should have. If you say im wrong you're dumb. Just my 2 cents though." What? I never said anyone was dumb, and you could say the same thing about what the other guy said, so what are you even talking about? Obviously everyone has an opinion, and mine is that if pouring acid in someones eye gives you pleasure, you are messed up. "Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what." You are imposing your morals on others, saying that it shouldn't be possible for others to feel better by going for revenge with the acid thing. Clearly this implies that there is something wrong with everyone who supports the woman's choice. While that isn't synonymous to "you're all dumb," it does give off that sort of impression.
How am I imposing my morals? I think its wrong that she would do that, and by connection yes I think its wrong that they would support that choice, but you are doing the same exact same thing to me, saying she is justified in doing so. STOP IMPOSING YOUR MORALS ON ME MAN WTFWAQQTWTQTRQ WHY ARE U CALLING ME DUMB FOR THINKING THAS ABD AEFASEF
That's basically you.
|
On May 15 2011 13:01 Cutlery wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 12:10 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 11:55 Cutlery wrote: i think i would go out of my way to attack and blind someone who had blinded me and disfigured my face, legally or not... Wether you call it justice or retribution, it would make no difference. Throw acid in my face and I'll most likely try to snap your neck, and not think twice about it. What kind of human would I be if I didn't? I'm not gandhi or jesus, I won't love you for throwing acid in my face. As I see it, anyone not punching back or wanting revenge is either extremely accepting or just not entirely 'human'. By simple and crude logic, you are more worth than the scumbag throwing acid in your face, so why shouldn't you strike back? it is our fear of being violent and being "barbaric" that truly makes us barbaric, for what are we if we tell a burnt woman that she must accept it? Reasoning and rationalizing isn't for everyone.
I understand that "our" western law will never allow for this, and also I don't think I support capital punishment. I feel strongly for self defence, but I don't want to consider extreme cases where people cut off your head or throw acid in your face, it is just bizarre and something almost none of us ever have to deal with. I still don't feel that there is nothing wrong with the word "retribution". I got retribution! Good for me! Maybe I was violent, but I feel it's the lesser 'inhumane' option, where you're being inhumane towards the offender rather than towards yourself or the victim. What assholes would tell that woman that the offender does not deserve to be blinded? That things are as they should be. That it was a tragedy but she must let it go. Hell no, that's just further abusing her as a victim. She's basically saying "Hey, he cant fucking do this to me, I'm not some animal you treat like shit because you felt like it". Anyone attempting to tell her to go down that 'path' (of thinking and reasoning) should get punched in the gut. It's basically stating that she's not human like the attacker and the rest of us. We will stand by watching and declaring justice, and frown upon your emotions and use words with negative connotation like "retribution".
Atleast that's how I see it. If anyone burnt my face, they better wish they can stay in jail forever.
p.s I'm NOT violent, I've never been in a situation with any physical abuse even remotely close to this one. But there are other forms of abuse, and none of them should you try to accept without feeling anger and a need to stand up for yourself or telling anyone they should; be it a school yard bully or an abusive husband/wife/anyone
--blinding her attacker might not make her medical situation better, but dangit, she'll feel good about it, she might feel more human again, feel stronger, and that she deserves. Obv revenge isn't for everyone, but she clearly feels strongly about it and I wouldn't fault her even 1% by trying to use negative words and make her look bad.
p.s.s. On the other hand, if you wish to make their legal system look bad, go for it :p, it sounds like it is less than optimal, and possibly irrational. But in this case I feel it's +1 for the victim "IF YOU WRONG ME I WILL SEEK YOU OUT AND DESTROY YOU, YOU BETTER PRAY YOU STAY IN JAIL FOREVER OR I WILL BREAK YOUR NECK!!!!!!!!!! DIE!!!!!! ps im not violent" rofl. nice tl dr. I stand by it  I would never harm a soul unless they were to threaten my life or someone elses life whom i cared about, and i'm not embarassed to say it. Punch me in the face and I'd probably just smile. Rape my friend and I'd probably taze you, for a very long time, and blow up your car maybe. Edit: Maybe stuff a stick up your ass too, while you are paralyzed from tazing. o_o and then i'd make arroused noises and ask you how you liked that stick up your poophole, while probably sobbing uncontrollably. It would be nice if we all had superheroes protecting us. Second best is to have an outlet for your severly crippling anger Yes that's all well and good, but there is a difference between self defense and actively seeking out a bloody vengeance on someone who's no longer a threat.
|
On May 15 2011 13:15 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 13:01 Cutlery wrote:On May 15 2011 12:10 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 11:55 Cutlery wrote: i think i would go out of my way to attack and blind someone who had blinded me and disfigured my face, legally or not... Wether you call it justice or retribution, it would make no difference. Throw acid in my face and I'll most likely try to snap your neck, and not think twice about it. What kind of human would I be if I didn't? I'm not gandhi or jesus, I won't love you for throwing acid in my face. As I see it, anyone not punching back or wanting revenge is either extremely accepting or just not entirely 'human'. By simple and crude logic, you are more worth than the scumbag throwing acid in your face, so why shouldn't you strike back? it is our fear of being violent and being "barbaric" that truly makes us barbaric, for what are we if we tell a burnt woman that she must accept it? Reasoning and rationalizing isn't for everyone.
I understand that "our" western law will never allow for this, and also I don't think I support capital punishment. I feel strongly for self defence, but I don't want to consider extreme cases where people cut off your head or throw acid in your face, it is just bizarre and something almost none of us ever have to deal with. I still don't feel that there is nothing wrong with the word "retribution". I got retribution! Good for me! Maybe I was violent, but I feel it's the lesser 'inhumane' option, where you're being inhumane towards the offender rather than towards yourself or the victim. What assholes would tell that woman that the offender does not deserve to be blinded? That things are as they should be. That it was a tragedy but she must let it go. Hell no, that's just further abusing her as a victim. She's basically saying "Hey, he cant fucking do this to me, I'm not some animal you treat like shit because you felt like it". Anyone attempting to tell her to go down that 'path' (of thinking and reasoning) should get punched in the gut. It's basically stating that she's not human like the attacker and the rest of us. We will stand by watching and declaring justice, and frown upon your emotions and use words with negative connotation like "retribution".
Atleast that's how I see it. If anyone burnt my face, they better wish they can stay in jail forever.
p.s I'm NOT violent, I've never been in a situation with any physical abuse even remotely close to this one. But there are other forms of abuse, and none of them should you try to accept without feeling anger and a need to stand up for yourself or telling anyone they should; be it a school yard bully or an abusive husband/wife/anyone
--blinding her attacker might not make her medical situation better, but dangit, she'll feel good about it, she might feel more human again, feel stronger, and that she deserves. Obv revenge isn't for everyone, but she clearly feels strongly about it and I wouldn't fault her even 1% by trying to use negative words and make her look bad.
p.s.s. On the other hand, if you wish to make their legal system look bad, go for it :p, it sounds like it is less than optimal, and possibly irrational. But in this case I feel it's +1 for the victim "IF YOU WRONG ME I WILL SEEK YOU OUT AND DESTROY YOU, YOU BETTER PRAY YOU STAY IN JAIL FOREVER OR I WILL BREAK YOUR NECK!!!!!!!!!! DIE!!!!!! ps im not violent" rofl. nice tl dr. I stand by it  I would never harm a soul unless they were to threaten my life or someone elses life whom i cared about, and i'm not embarassed to say it. Punch me in the face and I'd probably just smile. Rape my friend and I'd probably taze you, for a very long time, and blow up your car maybe. Edit: Maybe stuff a stick up your ass too, while you are paralyzed from tazing. o_o and then i'd make arroused noises and ask you how you liked that stick up your poophole, while probably sobbing uncontrollably. It would be nice if we all had superheroes protecting us. Second best is to have an outlet for your severly crippling anger Yes that's all well and good, but there is a difference between self defense and actively seeking out a bloody vengeance on someone who's no longer a threat.
Yes there is a difference. I don't feel like a bad person just because I'd want to do the latter just because i wasnt or had no superhero. If you essentially end my life or the life of someone I care about, I consider you as having forfeit your life. I don't want to sound like I make my own law, but I would not be able to surpress my anger, I don't think. Nor would I want to.
|
This story is crazy, I'm not surprised Amnesty International got involved and postponed this.
|
|
|
|
|
|