It really is a crazy world we live in...
Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 40
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
yawnoC
United States3704 Posts
It really is a crazy world we live in... | ||
|
Tor
Canada231 Posts
On May 15 2011 07:33 Bippzy wrote: B is possibly impossible. A and C are possible. Eye for an Eye satisfies C and possibly A. Jail satisfies maybe A and not C, unless if this idea you said was used. Sadly, there is no viable prisoners working for money scenario as far as I know. Thus, Eye for an Eye is most effective in achieving an utopian outcome. No, burning the mans face will not prevent him from reoffending. You would have to kill him or rehabilitate him, thus it doesn't fulfill A (not that there is any reason to believe a,b and c are all that is needed for some imaginary utopia). I'm guessing you'd support the former. | ||
|
Djabanete
United States2786 Posts
On May 15 2011 07:56 Tor wrote: No, burning the mans face will not prevent him from reoffending. You would have to kill him or rehabilitate him, thus it doesn't fulfill A (not that there is any reason to believe a,b and c are all that is needed for some imaginary utopia). I'm guessing you'd support the former. Oh I knew I was forgetting some things. There's also deterrence. edit: And possibly others. I think it's good to brainstorm what an ideal solution would be so that the best practical approximation can be found. | ||
|
Kindred
Canada396 Posts
| ||
|
Xivsa
United States1009 Posts
On May 15 2011 07:55 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote: anyway know if this happened yet? No, some court has postponed the decision to let her do this indefinitely. | ||
|
clusen
Germany8702 Posts
On May 15 2011 07:33 Bippzy wrote: B is possibly impossible. A and C are possible. Eye for an Eye satisfies C and possibly A. Jail satisfies maybe A and not C, unless if this idea you said was used. Sadly, there is no viable prisoners working for money scenario as far as I know. Thus, Eye for an Eye is most effective in achieving an utopian outcome. The guy is in jail for atleast 2 years and he still has to be punished, how can eye for an eye meet criteria C? It does not. And rehabilitating someone in this case is not really possible. No problem to restore his legal status, but restoring his social status and especially integrating him back into work is not really possible when you had a few years of psychological torture to endure and got crippled for rest of his life. Eye for an eye does not meet any criteria in this case. On May 15 2011 07:48 Olinim wrote: All your doing in reinforcing my point, by refusing to refute any of it...I wonder why that would be. He stated that the role of women in islam has nothing to with this case, which is obviously wrong(if we are to talk about prevention this is pretty crucial to the topic, and prevention of such attacks does have it's place here), so, yeah. Interesting style of discussion, as I already stated. | ||
|
clusen
Germany8702 Posts
![]() | ||
|
Kindred
Canada396 Posts
On May 15 2011 08:06 clusen wrote: The guy is in jail for atleast 2 years and he still has to be punished, how can eye for an eye meet criteria C? It does not. And rehabilitating someone in this case is not really possible. No problem to restore his legal status, but restoring his social status and especially integrating him back into work is not really possible when you had a few years of psychological torture to endure and got crippled for rest of his life. Eye for an eye does not meet any criteria in this case. He stated that the role of women in islam has nothing to with this case, which is obviously wrong(if we are to talk about prevention this is pretty crucial to the topic, and prevention of such attacks does have it's place here), so, yeah. Interesting style of discussion, as I already stated. If you are to talk about prevention, you address the mentality of a population, not a worldwide religion. Since every country's government will end up applying a religion to suit its own agenda. | ||
|
Cyber_Cheese
Australia3615 Posts
On May 15 2011 08:05 Xivsa wrote: No, some court has postponed the decision to let her do this indefinitely. is this true, or a sarcastic troll? edit: true, im sorry for doubting you | ||
|
Nevy
Canada169 Posts
On May 15 2011 08:05 Xivsa wrote: No, some court has postponed the decision to let her do this indefinitely. Link? | ||
|
Cyber_Cheese
Australia3615 Posts
http://www.google.com.au/search?sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&q=Amene Bahrami#q=Ameneh Bahrami&hl=en&safe=off&sa=X&prmd=ivnsuo&source=univ&tbm=nws&tbo=u&ei=LBHPTeLYDoXYuAO-hr2iCg&ved=0CCwQqAI&fp=433b0f60b11dbdd2 it's delayed. damn human righs groups/international governments and their intervening | ||
|
Xivsa
United States1009 Posts
On May 15 2011 08:31 Cyber_Cheese wrote: is this true, or a sarcastic troll? edit: true, im sorry for doubting you S'ok, rereading that post of mine I realized I worded it pretty poorly. Making it sound as though she would etch his eyes indefinitely. Even this post isn't so great syntax-wise. Ah well | ||
|
ExO_
United States2316 Posts
While it is sad that this woman would indeed choose to inflict the same pain in retribution on this man, I have no issue with it occurring. | ||
|
Darkness2k11
Chile313 Posts
| ||
|
aTnClouD
Italy2428 Posts
On May 15 2011 09:26 Darkness2k11 wrote: The way i see it, punishing violence with violence is not the best way to do it. why not, at least give her the right to exact her revenge. she will feel much better after that and a retard will learn the only way retards learn how to deal with other people properly. | ||
|
Olinim
4044 Posts
On May 15 2011 09:30 MYM.ClouD wrote: why not, at least give her the right to exact her revenge. she will feel much better after that and a retard will learn the only way retards learn how to deal with other people properly. If it makes her feel better to pour acid in someone's eye then she is just as demented as he is. | ||
|
aTnClouD
Italy2428 Posts
On May 15 2011 09:32 Olinim wrote: If it makes her feel better to pour acid in someone's eye then she is just as demented as he is. or she just got her life ruined by an idiot and nothing else would make her feel slightly better. one of the two. | ||
|
Olinim
4044 Posts
On May 15 2011 09:35 MYM.ClouD wrote: or she just got her life ruined by an idiot and nothing else would make her feel slightly better. one of the two. Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what. Just my 2 cents though. | ||
|
aTnClouD
Italy2428 Posts
On May 15 2011 09:37 Olinim wrote: Nope, pouring acid in someones eye shouldn't make you feel better no matter what. Just my 2 cents though. too bad you are wrong. if somebody ruins your life nothing would make you feel as good as him receiving the same treatment. but keep denying the obvious doesn't really matter. | ||
|
Olinim
4044 Posts
On May 15 2011 09:41 MYM.ClouD wrote: too bad you are wrong. if somebody ruins your life nothing would make you feel as good as him receiving the same treatment. but keep denying the obvious doesn't really matter. You can't tell me what would make me feel good, simply inflicting searing pain on someone would accomplish nothing and would probably scar me further. | ||
| ||
