|
On May 15 2011 07:24 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:14 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:59 clusen wrote: @ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p
no its from this: http://www.darkhorse.com/Books/47-313/Predator-Kindred-TPB:-D I didnt assume that many people here do not. I simply concluded that Olinim does not. And I fail to see how it can be of value in the thread. This thread is discussing an abused women's right for her justice. This man threw acid on her... in another country it could be fire to burn her or stabbing her, I don't know. The only thing germane to the conversation is that the Sharia offers a choice to the victim. How someone thinks women are treated in Islam is irrelevant. A criminal, a murderer or a person that does not respect life transcends religion, nationality, skin color or gender. @ Olinim Find it as comedic as you want. Ignorance is bliss. The effort I'm putting telling you to read it is nothing compared to what i would have to do to change your established ideas. You're telling me its too much work to debate, but you want me to read the Qur'an, an ancient book written years ago by a bunch of barbaric idiots? Just to validate your view that I'm wrong, when you won't even state why? Are you insane?
Its too much work for me to debate. It should be required that you familiarize yourself with a religion if you want to discuss it intelligently. I can't do that for you.
|
Come on guys, really? What the hell is torturing the guy supposed to fix?
In an ideal world, there would be a sentence that met the following criteria:
A) It rehabilitated the guy so he wouldn't do anything of the sort again. B) It rehabilitated the woman so she wouldn't be permanently disfigured and emotionally scarred. C) It didn't cost the taxpayers a dime.
Now obviously this isn't going to happen; not all these things are possible at once, or at all. But torturing him doesn't accomplish anything; it doesn't even make him a better person, because as this woman just proved, being plunged into violence and pain doesn't make you a better person, it makes you more likely to inflict violence and pain on others. The cycle of vindictiveness and crime is the same that we see in our criminal justice system in the U.S. Bad shit happens in prison, and that doesn't make prison sentences more just; it just fosters more bad shit.
IMO there should be infrastructure for locking this guy up safely and humanely. Once he's locked up and no longer a danger to society, then he can work his ass off and the money he earns can go to the woman (for what it's worth in reparation) and to the taxpayers (to alleviate the burden of keeping locked up). Once he's fulfilled both a heavy work quota and a minimum duration (not for me to judge) he can be released. That is the closest thing I can think of to fixing/neutralizing him, helping the victim, and serving the taxpayers.
PS: Prison vs blinding: blinding him also makes him a burden on his society, whereas in prison he can work to mitigate the cost.
|
On May 15 2011 07:29 Djabanete wrote: Come on guys, really? What the hell is torturing the guy supposed to fix?
In an ideal world, there would be a sentence that met the following criteria:
A) It rehabilitated the guy so he wouldn't do anything of the sort again. B) It rehabilitated the woman so she wouldn't be permanently disfigured and emotionally scarred. C) It didn't cost the taxpayers a dime.
Now obviously this isn't going to happen; not all these things are possible at once, or at all. But torturing him doesn't accomplish anything; it doesn't even make him a better person, because as this woman just proved, being plunged into violence and pain doesn't make you a better person, it makes you more likely to inflict violence and pain on others. The cycle of vindictiveness and crime is the same that we see in our criminal justice system in the U.S. Bad shit happens in prison, and that doesn't make prison sentences more just; it just fosters more bad shit.
IMO there should be infrastructure for locking this guy up safely and humanely. Once he's locked up and no longer a danger to society, then he can work his ass off and the money he earns can go to the woman (for what it's worth in reparation) and to the taxpayers (to alleviate the burden of keeping locked up). Once he's fulfilled both a heavy work quota and a minimum duration (not for me to judge) he can be released. That is the closest thing I can think of to fixing/neutralizing him, helping the victim, and serving the taxpayers.
B is possibly impossible. A and C are possible. Eye for an Eye satisfies C and possibly A. Jail satisfies maybe A and not C, unless if this idea you said was used. Sadly, there is no viable prisoners working for money scenario as far as I know. Thus, Eye for an Eye is most effective in achieving an utopian outcome.
|
On May 15 2011 07:32 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:24 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 07:14 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:59 clusen wrote: @ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p
no its from this: http://www.darkhorse.com/Books/47-313/Predator-Kindred-TPB:-D I didnt assume that many people here do not. I simply concluded that Olinim does not. And I fail to see how it can be of value in the thread. This thread is discussing an abused women's right for her justice. This man threw acid on her... in another country it could be fire to burn her or stabbing her, I don't know. The only thing germane to the conversation is that the Sharia offers a choice to the victim. How someone thinks women are treated in Islam is irrelevant. A criminal, a murderer or a person that does not respect life transcends religion, nationality, skin color or gender. @ Olinim Find it as comedic as you want. Ignorance is bliss. The effort I'm putting telling you to read it is nothing compared to what i would have to do to change your established ideas. You're telling me its too much work to debate, but you want me to read the Qur'an, an ancient book written years ago by a bunch of barbaric idiots? Just to validate your view that I'm wrong, when you won't even state why? Are you insane? Its too much work for me to debate. It should be required that you familiarize yourself with a religion if you want to discuss it intelligently. I can't do that for you. I am quite familiar with it, especially on the things I was talking about, namely it's stance on woman, homosexuals, etc.
|
They are both going to hell, enough said. At least the man gets to be sedated...
|
I'd do the same thing in her position, only I would request that the man not be sedated.
|
On May 15 2011 06:13 clusen wrote:Where is it written that he never felt remorse the last 7 years or the last 2 years after the trial? Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:50 dakalro wrote: Maybe in a few generations but ask your parents and grandparents what they think, should they be taxed more to help criminals become citizens? Who cares if the criminal made one mistake, he has to pay for the rest of his life because lower taxes are more important (going to say that for some countries this might not be true but for most ...). I'm not sure if I get this right. You are suggesting that people who pay taxes(like me  ) would like to let a human get tortured/killed/crippled so they save a few bucks? Interesting theory...and considering that citizens can't influence the way tax money is spent anyway the point is, well, weird. I was simply saying that faced with a choice between a guy saying elect me and I'll raise taxes to make the country better by doing <long list of stuff which includes better ways to deal with criminal rehabilitation> and a guy saying random stuff which doesn't include raising taxes people will go for the latter. Though I have to say I have never heard a politicians say they're going to do something about the well being of prisoners, I suppose because it would piss quite a few people off.
What's the point of democracy if you can't influence your elected representatives? Influence is a strong word but at least suggestion and argumentation should be possible, creating ideas for them to develop since elected politicians should have a much better platform for transforming ideas into facts.
I'm a tax payer myself, and have been for a few years now. And frankly I never cared about the level of taxation as long as I had enough money for expenses and some savings.
|
On May 15 2011 07:35 iTzAnglory wrote: They are both going to hell, enough said. At least the man gets to be sedated... Violence does not equal going to hell, espiecially if you are christian. i'm tired of stuck up holier than thou condemning people when it isn't their place to judge according to their religion. Makes you a hypocrite.
|
On May 15 2011 06:58 Newguy wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 08:45 Zephy wrote: Humanitarian organizations have tried to convince her with money, to forbear putting the man through the same road of pain she has been through, though not successfully thus far.
they tried to make her see reason, but i guess some people are just blinded by hate....too bad :/
nah she was blinded by acid not hate, its so easy for you to say that because you are not effected by it, to lose ones face and eyesight, to lose all the possibilities this world can offer, and you say that she cant see reason? she has the right to hate! for people to say that she has to be the bigger person is such...
i dont know have any family or friends that are blind, but a doctor diagnosed my housemate with somekind of sickness or something that deteriorate his eyesight and if not treated he will go blind, part of his treatment was resting his eyes, so his eyes was bandaged most of the time, and he spent most of his day just sitting on the couch doing nothing, he would just sit there like a statue, i always left the radio on for him but it seems he just doesnt care, he was the most cheerful person i ever know but in those months he was like dead inside, the fear of loosing his eyesight crippled him faster then the sickness itself. Thankfully he recovered
well my point is dont judge her for hating, dont judge her for wanting revenge. We dont know what we become if certain things we take for granted are taken from us, and i hope i will never know
|
On May 15 2011 07:34 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:32 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 07:24 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 07:14 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:59 clusen wrote: @ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p
no its from this: http://www.darkhorse.com/Books/47-313/Predator-Kindred-TPB:-D I didnt assume that many people here do not. I simply concluded that Olinim does not. And I fail to see how it can be of value in the thread. This thread is discussing an abused women's right for her justice. This man threw acid on her... in another country it could be fire to burn her or stabbing her, I don't know. The only thing germane to the conversation is that the Sharia offers a choice to the victim. How someone thinks women are treated in Islam is irrelevant. A criminal, a murderer or a person that does not respect life transcends religion, nationality, skin color or gender. @ Olinim Find it as comedic as you want. Ignorance is bliss. The effort I'm putting telling you to read it is nothing compared to what i would have to do to change your established ideas. You're telling me its too much work to debate, but you want me to read the Qur'an, an ancient book written years ago by a bunch of barbaric idiots? Just to validate your view that I'm wrong, when you won't even state why? Are you insane? Its too much work for me to debate. It should be required that you familiarize yourself with a religion if you want to discuss it intelligently. I can't do that for you. I am quite familiar with it, especially on the things I was talking about, namely it's stance on woman, homosexuals, etc.
If believing that makes you feel better then good. What you have written thus far in this thread points to otherwise. Find a way to become familiar with it differently because you are gravely misinformed. I personally don't really care but you might inadvertently insult someone's religious beliefs with your false comments.
|
On May 15 2011 07:38 Bippzy wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:35 iTzAnglory wrote: They are both going to hell, enough said. At least the man gets to be sedated... Violence does not equal going to hell, espiecially if you are christian. i'm tired of stuck up holier than thou condemning people when it isn't their place to judge according to their religion. Makes you a hypocrite.
And isn't it ironic that he thinks that burning someone with acid for burning you with acid, is despicable, and the proper punishment is being burned. ROFL
|
On May 15 2011 07:41 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:34 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 07:32 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 07:24 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 07:14 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:59 clusen wrote: @ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p
no its from this: http://www.darkhorse.com/Books/47-313/Predator-Kindred-TPB:-D I didnt assume that many people here do not. I simply concluded that Olinim does not. And I fail to see how it can be of value in the thread. This thread is discussing an abused women's right for her justice. This man threw acid on her... in another country it could be fire to burn her or stabbing her, I don't know. The only thing germane to the conversation is that the Sharia offers a choice to the victim. How someone thinks women are treated in Islam is irrelevant. A criminal, a murderer or a person that does not respect life transcends religion, nationality, skin color or gender. @ Olinim Find it as comedic as you want. Ignorance is bliss. The effort I'm putting telling you to read it is nothing compared to what i would have to do to change your established ideas. You're telling me its too much work to debate, but you want me to read the Qur'an, an ancient book written years ago by a bunch of barbaric idiots? Just to validate your view that I'm wrong, when you won't even state why? Are you insane? Its too much work for me to debate. It should be required that you familiarize yourself with a religion if you want to discuss it intelligently. I can't do that for you. I am quite familiar with it, especially on the things I was talking about, namely it's stance on woman, homosexuals, etc. If believing that makes you feel better then good. What you have written thus far in this thread points to otherwise. Find a way to become familiar with it differently because you are gravely misinformed. I personally don't really care but you might inadvertently insult someone's religious beliefs with your false comments.
You have yet to point out a false comment, I'm waiting.
|
On May 15 2011 07:41 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:38 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 07:35 iTzAnglory wrote: They are both going to hell, enough said. At least the man gets to be sedated... Violence does not equal going to hell, espiecially if you are christian. i'm tired of stuck up holier than thou condemning people when it isn't their place to judge according to their religion. Makes you a hypocrite. And isn't it ironic that he thinks that burning someone with acid for burning you with acid, is despicable, and the proper punishment is being burned. ROFL Lol, not just being burnt. Being burnt for all eternity.
|
On May 14 2011 15:24 Cifer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 15:05 Reason.SC2 wrote: Stupid woman.
Stupid legal system.
I lose a little more faith in humanity every time I hear some idiots trying to justify the "eye for an eye" bullshit that has plagued people's idea of "justice".
Pleiades makes a good point in not being too critical of a legal system of a place you don't live in.. but goddamn I can't imagine a world in which a properly functioning legal system allows such barbaric and archaic practices happen under their watch. I'm sorry but the Iranian government, legal system included, is a joke and its a matter of time before enough people wake up and do something about it. Someone needs to explain to them (government, not Iranians) thats change, i.e. progress is nothing to be afraid of. For the most part Iran is a full millenium behind the rest of the world on social issues, and based on my interactions with Iranian people that have left the country, that simply does not add up with the beliefs of the constituents... at least not the educated ones. You can say what you want about the legal system, that's your opinion. But the women is a victim of a cruel act here, I think the majority of people anywhere will lose civility and would choose the same thing given the chance. Imagine some idiot basically just ended any chance of you living a normal life. Even if you think its wrong you would do it in heart beat in that situation. So calling her names is very insensitive As for the legal system allowing her to do that is different matter. However, I think if you are willing to criticise this system, you need to be open to criticise all others systems out there. People try their victimisers not for "greater justice" but for retribution, the method being different has nothing to do with the actual concept. Your argument as you say it has nothing to do with morality, its just conflicting social conventions, and you think its out of fashion. which I can also respect, but you need to be less judgemental if you're using that.
Firstly, I would in a heartbeat decline the opportunity to mutilate my attacker. Don't put your perverted standards of justice onto my would-be actions in the scenario. Not everyone thinks the way you do, thats the whole point driving disagreement between us in this discussion.
Secondly, calling her names, while insensitive, is not inaccurate. In my "opinion" (as you say) she is stupid for insisting to mutilate her assailant instead of have him serve jail time.
Thirdly, archaic social conventions actually do have something to do with morality. It is a plain violation of the most fundamental moral principles to wish and insist this happen to someone, even if they attacked you and injured you. If you don't agree then you just have a different take on morality than I do. Does that mean we're equally right? no. You're an idiot... but I can't take half a decade of education in moral philosophy and applied ethics and plant it into your head through a TL forum post. My advice to you, and anyone reading this who is inclined to agree with the "eye for an eye" theory of justice is to do some serious reading and reflect on your views of morality and justice after you've had the chance to read a variety of influential and legit writers on the issues.
Lastly, I don't *need* to be less judgmental. If I come off as abrasive, thats because I mean to. It is a fucking travesty that so many people have access to all sorts of education and tools to broaden their understanding of morality and justice, yet end up with archaic and ass-backwards views such as the "eye for an eye" bullshit that the clowns in Iran are still willing to enforce. They deserve to be ridiculed for their ignorance. More attention should be brought to it so that the world can see the stupidity and someone with the balls and position to intervene can actually do something about it.
|
United States1009 Posts
Update to this story - hours before she was to administer acid eye drops to both his eyes, the ruling was postponed indefinitely. Who knows if it will actually happen now.
|
On May 15 2011 07:42 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:41 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 07:34 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 07:32 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 07:24 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 07:14 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:59 clusen wrote: @ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p
no its from this: http://www.darkhorse.com/Books/47-313/Predator-Kindred-TPB:-D I didnt assume that many people here do not. I simply concluded that Olinim does not. And I fail to see how it can be of value in the thread. This thread is discussing an abused women's right for her justice. This man threw acid on her... in another country it could be fire to burn her or stabbing her, I don't know. The only thing germane to the conversation is that the Sharia offers a choice to the victim. How someone thinks women are treated in Islam is irrelevant. A criminal, a murderer or a person that does not respect life transcends religion, nationality, skin color or gender. @ Olinim Find it as comedic as you want. Ignorance is bliss. The effort I'm putting telling you to read it is nothing compared to what i would have to do to change your established ideas. You're telling me its too much work to debate, but you want me to read the Qur'an, an ancient book written years ago by a bunch of barbaric idiots? Just to validate your view that I'm wrong, when you won't even state why? Are you insane? Its too much work for me to debate. It should be required that you familiarize yourself with a religion if you want to discuss it intelligently. I can't do that for you. I am quite familiar with it, especially on the things I was talking about, namely it's stance on woman, homosexuals, etc. If believing that makes you feel better then good. What you have written thus far in this thread points to otherwise. Find a way to become familiar with it differently because you are gravely misinformed. I personally don't really care but you might inadvertently insult someone's religious beliefs with your false comments. You have yet to point out a false comment, I'm waiting.
Keep waiting then. It's in your brain's best interest to do so.
|
On May 15 2011 07:46 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:42 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 07:41 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 07:34 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 07:32 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 07:24 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 07:14 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:59 clusen wrote: @ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p
no its from this: http://www.darkhorse.com/Books/47-313/Predator-Kindred-TPB:-D I didnt assume that many people here do not. I simply concluded that Olinim does not. And I fail to see how it can be of value in the thread. This thread is discussing an abused women's right for her justice. This man threw acid on her... in another country it could be fire to burn her or stabbing her, I don't know. The only thing germane to the conversation is that the Sharia offers a choice to the victim. How someone thinks women are treated in Islam is irrelevant. A criminal, a murderer or a person that does not respect life transcends religion, nationality, skin color or gender. @ Olinim Find it as comedic as you want. Ignorance is bliss. The effort I'm putting telling you to read it is nothing compared to what i would have to do to change your established ideas. You're telling me its too much work to debate, but you want me to read the Qur'an, an ancient book written years ago by a bunch of barbaric idiots? Just to validate your view that I'm wrong, when you won't even state why? Are you insane? Its too much work for me to debate. It should be required that you familiarize yourself with a religion if you want to discuss it intelligently. I can't do that for you. I am quite familiar with it, especially on the things I was talking about, namely it's stance on woman, homosexuals, etc. If believing that makes you feel better then good. What you have written thus far in this thread points to otherwise. Find a way to become familiar with it differently because you are gravely misinformed. I personally don't really care but you might inadvertently insult someone's religious beliefs with your false comments. You have yet to point out a false comment, I'm waiting. Keep waiting then. It's in your brain's best interest to do so. All your doing in reinforcing my point, by refusing to refute any of it...I wonder why that would be.
|
On May 15 2011 07:33 Bippzy wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:29 Djabanete wrote: Come on guys, really? What the hell is torturing the guy supposed to fix?
In an ideal world, there would be a sentence that met the following criteria:
A) It rehabilitated the guy so he wouldn't do anything of the sort again. B) It rehabilitated the woman so she wouldn't be permanently disfigured and emotionally scarred. C) It didn't cost the taxpayers a dime.
Now obviously this isn't going to happen; not all these things are possible at once, or at all. But torturing him doesn't accomplish anything; it doesn't even make him a better person, because as this woman just proved, being plunged into violence and pain doesn't make you a better person, it makes you more likely to inflict violence and pain on others. The cycle of vindictiveness and crime is the same that we see in our criminal justice system in the U.S. Bad shit happens in prison, and that doesn't make prison sentences more just; it just fosters more bad shit.
IMO there should be infrastructure for locking this guy up safely and humanely. Once he's locked up and no longer a danger to society, then he can work his ass off and the money he earns can go to the woman (for what it's worth in reparation) and to the taxpayers (to alleviate the burden of keeping locked up). Once he's fulfilled both a heavy work quota and a minimum duration (not for me to judge) he can be released. That is the closest thing I can think of to fixing/neutralizing him, helping the victim, and serving the taxpayers.
B is possibly impossible. A and C are possible. Eye for an Eye satisfies C and possibly A. Jail satisfies maybe A and not C, unless if this idea you said was used. Sadly, there is no viable prisoners working for money scenario as far as I know. Thus, Eye for an Eye is most effective in achieving an utopian outcome. B can be partially achieved. There is plastic surgery and there is therapy. And even if those weren't possible, having monetary compensation for being disabled helps a bit. Whether "eye for an eye" accomplishes A is not for either of us to know for sure without citing sources; you suspect it does and I suspect it does not. Also the current sentence sucks because the woman can't be trusted to administer it alone, but if she's guarded or if someone else does it, those poor people have to witness the torture/disfiguration, which fucks people up. At least you agree that eye for an eye is less optimal than the system I proposed. It would definitely be possible but the infrastructure is not in place.
|
Did you see this woman's face? He deserves the acid no questions asked. This is justice due to the circumstances.
|
anyway know if this happened yet?
|
|
|
|
|
|