|
On May 15 2011 06:51 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:42 clusen wrote:On May 15 2011 06:27 Kindred wrote: I could explain to you how misinformed you are but I don't think it will suffice. Go read it. I know its very simple and easy for you to say what you just did because it gives you a feeling that you understand enough of the religion to discuss it but sadly you dont. So please, go read the Koran. Why don't you enlighten us all then? Interesting style of discussion.... Why should I? I've tried to do that in countless debates on the internet and it amounted to nothing. The brain is the laziest of organs, when it has an idea that allows it to expand less resources, it will stick to it and its very hard to change it. A stranger on the web will not change someone's idea. The will to understand must be within the person. The idea that the mature gentlemen before you was saying is simple and no matter how much I try to explain how ridiculous he sounds, he will continue to point at corrupt monarchies and TV news broadcasts he has seen to validate his simple view of a religion and region. I can tell you from now, he is not interested in understanding beyond his limited knowledge because that requires time and effort. It doesn't bother me, I just end up observing his behavior (Im a Neuropsychology student after all :p)
It's truly pitiful, you're whole argument or lack thereof, has amounted to : NUH UH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.
You claim to have extensive knowledge, apparently unknown to me, but then proceed to say the same thing every post. You are like a 5 year old, just avoiding any actual debate and trying to solidify your place of intellectual superiority, which you have failed miserably.
|
On May 14 2011 08:45 Zephy wrote: Humanitarian organizations have tried to convince her with money, to forbear putting the man through the same road of pain she has been through, though not successfully thus far.
they tried to make her see reason, but i guess some people are just blinded by hate....too bad :/
|
@ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p
@ Newguy I don't think you can blame her tho.
|
On May 15 2011 06:55 DwmC_Foefen wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:52 Mailing wrote:On May 15 2011 06:50 DwmC_Foefen wrote: So, in WW2 some 4 million jews were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 4 million germans have to be killed too...
I'll get the shovel, you guys bring your guns. Yes, it is logical. The world would be no worse if those millions died. Will it happen? Of course not. Wait what? Are you for real :p How about..." So, in WW2 some 60 million people were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 60 million germans have to be killed too..." What are your thoughts on that?
60 million were killed by less than 60 million, eye for an eye does not work in an un-even situation.
But yes, if every german solider involved was killed, again, then yes.
There are 7 billion people on this planet.
|
On May 15 2011 06:59 clusen wrote: @ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p Is it not obvious by this point that he is full of it? What have I done to support the idea I wouldn't be open to some insightful information about the religion of peace and heart shaped candies, Islam?
|
On May 15 2011 06:58 Newguy wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 08:45 Zephy wrote: Humanitarian organizations have tried to convince her with money, to forbear putting the man through the same road of pain she has been through, though not successfully thus far.
they tried to make her see reason, but i guess some people are just blinded by hate....too bad :/
![[image loading]](http://y.delfi.ee/orig/80041/5063669_uFWaeJ.jpeg) Oh, if only everyone was as ponderate as you so that they wouldn't get blinded by hate.
|
On May 15 2011 06:50 DwmC_Foefen wrote: So, in WW2 some 4 million jews were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 4 million germans have to be killed too...
I'll get the shovel, you guys bring your guns (which you undoubtedly have). im not taking sides here but your analogy is really bad. those 4mil. jews were not killed by 4mil. (would be victims) germans but the man in question here did poke the womans eyes out
|
On May 15 2011 06:58 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:51 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:42 clusen wrote:On May 15 2011 06:27 Kindred wrote: I could explain to you how misinformed you are but I don't think it will suffice. Go read it. I know its very simple and easy for you to say what you just did because it gives you a feeling that you understand enough of the religion to discuss it but sadly you dont. So please, go read the Koran. Why don't you enlighten us all then? Interesting style of discussion.... Why should I? I've tried to do that in countless debates on the internet and it amounted to nothing. The brain is the laziest of organs, when it has an idea that allows it to expand less resources, it will stick to it and its very hard to change it. A stranger on the web will not change someone's idea. The will to understand must be within the person. The idea that the mature gentlemen before you was saying is simple and no matter how much I try to explain how ridiculous he sounds, he will continue to point at corrupt monarchies and TV news broadcasts he has seen to validate his simple view of a religion and region. I can tell you from now, he is not interested in understanding beyond his limited knowledge because that requires time and effort. It doesn't bother me, I just end up observing his behavior (Im a Neuropsychology student after all :p) It's truly pitiful, you're whole argument or lack thereof, has amounted to : NUH UH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. You claim to have extensive knowledge, apparently unknown to me, but then proceed to say the same thing every post. You are like a 5 year old, just avoiding any actual debate and trying to solidify your place of intellectual superiority, which you have failed miserably.
Go read the Koran or something constructive instead of insulting me for refusing to get into a pointless debate with you. I'm in this thread to debate about the women's choice of "an eye for an eye" not to waste energy trying to explain to you a religion which you have no interest in knowing more of.
|
On May 15 2011 06:59 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:55 DwmC_Foefen wrote:On May 15 2011 06:52 Mailing wrote:On May 15 2011 06:50 DwmC_Foefen wrote: So, in WW2 some 4 million jews were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 4 million germans have to be killed too...
I'll get the shovel, you guys bring your guns. Yes, it is logical. The world would be no worse if those millions died. Will it happen? Of course not. Wait what? Are you for real :p How about..." So, in WW2 some 60 million people were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 60 million germans have to be killed too..." What are your thoughts on that? 60 million were killed by less than 60 million, eye for an eye does not work in an un-even situation. But yes, if every german solider involved was killed, again, then yes. There are 7 billion people on this planet.
Do you take into account the context?
For example, some guy threatens me with a knife. I cut off his hand. What should happen to me then according to you?
Also where are you getting at with "There are 7 billion people on this planet."?
|
On May 15 2011 07:05 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:58 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:51 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:42 clusen wrote:On May 15 2011 06:27 Kindred wrote: I could explain to you how misinformed you are but I don't think it will suffice. Go read it. I know its very simple and easy for you to say what you just did because it gives you a feeling that you understand enough of the religion to discuss it but sadly you dont. So please, go read the Koran. Why don't you enlighten us all then? Interesting style of discussion.... Why should I? I've tried to do that in countless debates on the internet and it amounted to nothing. The brain is the laziest of organs, when it has an idea that allows it to expand less resources, it will stick to it and its very hard to change it. A stranger on the web will not change someone's idea. The will to understand must be within the person. The idea that the mature gentlemen before you was saying is simple and no matter how much I try to explain how ridiculous he sounds, he will continue to point at corrupt monarchies and TV news broadcasts he has seen to validate his simple view of a religion and region. I can tell you from now, he is not interested in understanding beyond his limited knowledge because that requires time and effort. It doesn't bother me, I just end up observing his behavior (Im a Neuropsychology student after all :p) It's truly pitiful, you're whole argument or lack thereof, has amounted to : NUH UH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. You claim to have extensive knowledge, apparently unknown to me, but then proceed to say the same thing every post. You are like a 5 year old, just avoiding any actual debate and trying to solidify your place of intellectual superiority, which you have failed miserably. Go read the Koran or something constructive instead of insulting me for refusing to get into a pointless debate with you. I'm in this thread to debate about the women's choice of "an eye for an eye" not to waste energy trying to explain to you a religion which you have no interest in knowing more of.
Its just comedic at this point, its clear that even if it was necessary to EXPLAIN a religion, that you have absolutely no worthwhile thoughts or viewpoints that could be contributed to anything, evidenced by the fact that you aren't even willing to STATE them, no doubt using your precious time to telling people that they're wrong but not even willing to say why.
|
On May 15 2011 06:59 clusen wrote: @ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p
no its from this: http://www.darkhorse.com/Books/47-313/Predator-Kindred-TPB :-D
I didnt assume that many people here do not. I simply concluded that Olinim does not.
And I fail to see how it can be of value in the thread. This thread is discussing an abused women's right for her justice. This man threw acid on her... in another country it could be fire to burn her or stabbing her, I don't know. The only thing germane to the conversation is that the Sharia offers a choice to the victim. How someone thinks women are treated in Islam is irrelevant. A criminal, a murderer or a person that does not respect life transcends religion, nationality, skin color or gender.
@ Olinim Find it as comedic as you want. Ignorance is bliss. The effort I'm putting telling you to read it is nothing compared to what i would have to do to change your established ideas.
|
Out of the many things I dislike about Islam, their eye for an eye rule is not one of them. I wish I could watch her burn his eyes. He should feel lucky that he gets to be sedated, she didn't get that privilege when he burned her eyes.
|
On May 15 2011 07:07 DwmC_Foefen wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:59 Mailing wrote:On May 15 2011 06:55 DwmC_Foefen wrote:On May 15 2011 06:52 Mailing wrote:On May 15 2011 06:50 DwmC_Foefen wrote: So, in WW2 some 4 million jews were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 4 million germans have to be killed too...
I'll get the shovel, you guys bring your guns. Yes, it is logical. The world would be no worse if those millions died. Will it happen? Of course not. Wait what? Are you for real :p How about..." So, in WW2 some 60 million people were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 60 million germans have to be killed too..." What are your thoughts on that? 60 million were killed by less than 60 million, eye for an eye does not work in an un-even situation. But yes, if every german solider involved was killed, again, then yes. There are 7 billion people on this planet. Do you take into account the context? For example, some guy threatens me with a knife. I cut off his hand. What should happen to me then according to you? Also where are you getting at with "There are 7 billion people on this planet."?
You did nothing wrong because you acted in self-defense.
|
I think any justice system in the world should focus on giving compassion and help for the victim and getting his/her life back on track and as normal as possible again, not just making the offender suffer. Making him suffer will not give her eyesight back, and it would only needlessly ruin another person's life. Sure, I'm not saying he's innocent or should go unpunished, but why not just lock him up and make him pay for her plastic surgery or whatever she needs. That way she benefits and he does not go off unpunished either.
|
On May 15 2011 07:19 LetoAtreides82 wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:07 DwmC_Foefen wrote:On May 15 2011 06:59 Mailing wrote:On May 15 2011 06:55 DwmC_Foefen wrote:On May 15 2011 06:52 Mailing wrote:On May 15 2011 06:50 DwmC_Foefen wrote: So, in WW2 some 4 million jews were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 4 million germans have to be killed too...
I'll get the shovel, you guys bring your guns. Yes, it is logical. The world would be no worse if those millions died. Will it happen? Of course not. Wait what? Are you for real :p How about..." So, in WW2 some 60 million people were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 60 million germans have to be killed too..." What are your thoughts on that? 60 million were killed by less than 60 million, eye for an eye does not work in an un-even situation. But yes, if every german solider involved was killed, again, then yes. There are 7 billion people on this planet. Do you take into account the context? For example, some guy threatens me with a knife. I cut off his hand. What should happen to me then according to you? Also where are you getting at with "There are 7 billion people on this planet."? You did nothing wrong because you acted in self-defense.
Let's say he just says"Gimme your money or you die!" but never actually attacks me. I see a chance to cut off his hand without him ever attacking me. Does he get to cut off my hand because of "an eye for an eye"? Nobody witnesses this scenario, it's just him and me.
What now? :p
|
On May 15 2011 07:22 Menzies wrote: I think any justice system in the world should focus on giving compassion and help for the victim and getting his/her life back on track and as normal as possible again, not just making the offender suffer. Making him suffer will not give her eyesight back, and it would only needlessly ruin another person's life. Sure, I'm not saying he's innocent or should go unpunished, but why not just lock him up and make him pay for her plastic surgery or whatever she needs. That way she benefits and he does not go off unpunished either.
You think he has enough money to pay for her medical bills?
|
On May 15 2011 07:14 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:59 clusen wrote: @ Kindred(is your nick from Vampire btw?) You promoted the idea that you possess knowledge about the Islam that many people here do not possess and that could be of value in this thread. Im not a fan of withholding information in debates and if he is not interested, there could be dozens of others. There are still some open minded people left in the world :p
no its from this: http://www.darkhorse.com/Books/47-313/Predator-Kindred-TPB:-D I didnt assume that many people here do not. I simply concluded that Olinim does not. And I fail to see how it can be of value in the thread. This thread is discussing an abused women's right for her justice. This man threw acid on her... in another country it could be fire to burn her or stabbing her, I don't know. The only thing germane to the conversation is that the Sharia offers a choice to the victim. How someone thinks women are treated in Islam is irrelevant. A criminal, a murderer or a person that does not respect life transcends religion, nationality, skin color or gender. @ Olinim Find it as comedic as you want. Ignorance is bliss. The effort I'm putting telling you to read it is nothing compared to what i would have to do to change your established ideas.
You're telling me its too much work to debate, but you want me to read the Qur'an, an ancient book written years ago by a bunch of barbaric idiots? Just to validate your view that I'm wrong, when you won't even state why? Are you insane? You have no ground to call me ignorant, when you have done nothing to back up any of your statements.
|
On May 15 2011 06:51 Grenadieris wrote: If there's undeniable evidence of the person committing the crime, I fully support this kinda of justice. No amount of jail time can be appropriate to the damage that has been done. Maybe it will make cowards like him think twice before crippling the life of a such beautiful person forever. P.S. And please don't compare war and civilian life, there are different rules/laws working in each situation, so your comparison to Germans and Jews fails.
I wouldn't relate the nazi act of genocide to war. And killing civilians during war is a war crime (and many germans were punished for it)
No amount of punishment will return the womans face. She will never be reimbursed for her sufferings. Burning the mans face will accomplish nothing that jail time couldn't, except jail time provides the chance of rehabilitation and doesn't condemn innocents to commit a violent act on fellow human beings. It also prevents the man who just lost his face ad his reputation, who has nothing to lose from reoffending in an even more sinister manner.
|
--- fail, self-quote instead of edit --- --- a mod can delete ---
|
On May 15 2011 07:23 DwmC_Foefen wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 07:19 LetoAtreides82 wrote:On May 15 2011 07:07 DwmC_Foefen wrote:On May 15 2011 06:59 Mailing wrote:On May 15 2011 06:55 DwmC_Foefen wrote:On May 15 2011 06:52 Mailing wrote:On May 15 2011 06:50 DwmC_Foefen wrote: So, in WW2 some 4 million jews were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 4 million germans have to be killed too...
I'll get the shovel, you guys bring your guns. Yes, it is logical. The world would be no worse if those millions died. Will it happen? Of course not. Wait what? Are you for real :p How about..." So, in WW2 some 60 million people were killed. It's only logical according to you guys 60 million germans have to be killed too..." What are your thoughts on that? 60 million were killed by less than 60 million, eye for an eye does not work in an un-even situation. But yes, if every german solider involved was killed, again, then yes. There are 7 billion people on this planet. Do you take into account the context? For example, some guy threatens me with a knife. I cut off his hand. What should happen to me then according to you? Also where are you getting at with "There are 7 billion people on this planet."? You did nothing wrong because you acted in self-defense. Let's say he just says"Gimme your money or you die!" but never actually attacks me. I see a chance to cut off his hand without him ever attacking me. Does he get to cut off my hand because of "an eye for an eye"? Nobody witnesses this scenario, it's just him and me. What now? :p
Eye for an eye still works, but it has to be blatantly clear what someone did. You are just pointing out one of the holes in the system. If this same thing happened under a jail based system, you could very well goto jail assuming this unlikely scenario.
|
|
|
|
|
|