|
On May 15 2011 06:05 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:03 Cloud9157 wrote:On May 15 2011 05:55 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 05:46 Cloud9157 wrote:On May 15 2011 05:35 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 05:32 Cloud9157 wrote: Lol, this eye for an eye (literally and figuratively) shit needs to disappear.
"I'm going to show its wrong by doing it to you, lolz"
Good to know that violence is still the preferred punishment in the world. Its comments like these that I find insensitive. Get acid thrown in your face, be permanently disfigured and traumatized, then when you have the choice of whether to have him in jail or get acid in his eye, pick whatever will make YOU feel better. So a murderer kills your loved one, so you should demand he dies to show that what he did is wrong? Fuck this "but it makes me feel better" stuff. You say that now, but when you look back on it, is it really going to make you feel any better? I know every time I try to get revenge on someone, I just feel worse than before. Just my experience though. Thats great for you. If FOR YOU revenge in not a good option, then the choice for you to send the person to jail is still available. And don't say "fuck making you feel better" because really what else can she do? She is scared and scarred for life, so no I must disagree with you here, I cannot say "fuck how she feels" Never did I say "fuck how she feels". What can she do? She can actually try forgiving him, instead of succumbing to our naturally revengeful nature. She is thinking in the now, she isn't thinking about the future and if this will REALLY make her feel any better about this unfortunate event. Forgiveness should never be given, it should be earned. What can this man do to earn the forgiveness of ruining this womans life and taking her sight without trading his own? Prison times does not do this.
Tell that to Pope John Paul II.
And just so people don't jump to conclusions, I'm not Catholic. I was raised it, but I don't practice anymore, I merely hold some of its values as worthwhile and for the betterment of man.
Edit: Just realized that you can't really tell that to JPII, since hes dead and all, but you get what I mean. >.>
|
On May 15 2011 06:15 Taguchi wrote: an eye for an eye might be a good idea for some people i totally dont get it, however
after she's blinded him all that remains is the fact that they're both blind whats the purpose in that? why would she be happier with that instead of accepting the money and living a better life (and with the advances in medicine, possibly regain her sight and appearance in the future)
the only tangible benefit from this sort of punishment would be for it to serve as deterrence to others this is fine from a macrosociologic point of view but not from a microsociologic point of view (ie the perpetrator, who could well be remorseful by now and not in need of any kind of correction/punishment)
i prefer the live and let live line of thought in such cases but i can see how people could possibly support the idea of sharia law after all, many countries still have the death penalty as an option, the idea and actual effect of sharia law seems close to it
The problem with asking for money for a crime is that it's putting a price on someone's eyesight, which is absolutely impossible to accurately do. Additionally, the perpetrator may not have the money that the law asks for. You are accurate in your assessment of macrosociological, which is a large part of why everyone agrees with the punishment. However, your microsociological assessment is missing the point that you cannot do something bad, feel bad about it, and not be punished. Emotions are abstract things that can be faked, and punishment must be served because of the abstract nature of emotions and the simple fact that people do not like having their eyesight damaged. Live and let live is a romantic idea. I'm glad you see both sides.
|
I don't see a problem with eye for an eye in this special circumstance, like you ruined the womans life by disfiguring her. Its much different than if you steal they cut off a finger. We have eye for an eye in the United States, its called the death penalty.
edited for puncutation
|
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE keep up with the punishment. The morality of the situation, has already been discussed. I want to see what this fucker looks like after he gets acid on him. I dont know if Iran will produce a video or pictures of his "punishment", but i have a feeling they will since they seem to like capital punishment. BTW i have sulfuric acid burns on both my arms from drunk chemistry, i know what the scars will look like, what interests me is that the acid will go into his eyes and not so much his skin. I can kinda image how that would feel since ive been burned, but in the eye it must be sooo much worse. Anyways i wanna see how the acid erodes the eye, also if they tell what kind of acid she will be using that would be of interest as well (my was H2SO4-18molar as read off the bottle/ sulfuric acid with molarity of 18, im a shitty chemist btw which explains the burns). The skin "burns" (corrodes is more accurate, although some heat is involved) when its in contact with the acid, and leaves behind dead-brown soupy like skin as it sinks deeper into the tissue. The eye has a method of healing/cleaning itselfs, so im interested to see how the acid reacts with the eyes natural protection methods (for example the eye should water, which will reduce the acids molarity, but then it "washes" itself by moving the water somewhere and adding new water. This i am not sure of, im not an eye biologist, but i think its kinda accurate.)
Now supposing that is how the eye cleans itself, the slightly reduced acid solution will re-enter the tear ducts (or some other thing to drain the eye water), and this will fucking destroy the way the not only the eye functions, but the way various natural eye protections functions. Will he be able to produce tears after being burned?? idk, but i would love to find out. Also i wanna see how the dead eye biomass looks after being corroded (and burned to a lesser degree). Will it be dead, brown, and "kinda soupy"? Or maybe the blood vesils in the eye will rupture and the blood will dilute the acid, in which case the blood will die and turn brown/soupy??
TLDR: Im not a chemist or doctor (math and econ majors), but i have been burned and would love to see images of him being burned, especially since its in the fucking eye. Its a whole different ball game for whats involved biologically. Also, when you burn the skin, it doesn't bleed like you might imagine ( you might think something like a hole with blood poring in from all sides, this is not the case). Secondly, it is not as fast as the movies would make you think (its not gonna instantly burn through his face). Thridly, the longer the acid is on the skin/bio tissue, the more diluted it becomes and corrodes (burns) less. Fourthly, The acid type (and concentration) is a huge deal.
|
On May 15 2011 06:14 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:05 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 05:52 mcc wrote: Why do I have the feeling that this thread is mostly populated by teenage internet tough-guys ?Probably because people here actually require a lecture on why eye-for-an-eye is a bad idea for a justice system, something that should be common civic knowledge for someone leaving highschool. Alright, sir, I'm a freshman in high school. Let me take a crack at it. Eye for an eye is bad because of what it says to society. Since it is a response to something a criminal did, it says that it is okay to do this because the government did this. Another reason for eye for an eye being bad is the dominance of christianity, which promotes forgiveness over retribution. I'm a teenage internet tough guy, and I say that eye for an eye is a just justice system, and the added option of jail time makes it a perfectly good idea for a justice system, especially if everyone isn't christian. This post makes me laugh, Christianity promotes forgiveness over retribution, that's why I will be sentenced to eternal damnation for not obeying God's every command right? That's like saying the Islam promotes woman's rights over misogyny. Dude, relearn christianity. Jesus died for our sins, according to christianity. You are not sentenced to eternal damnation as long as you ask for forgiveness. This is a major principle of christianity. It is not like saying whatever your false simile was.
|
On May 15 2011 06:15 matjlav wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:12 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 06:09 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 06:07 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 06:04 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 06:01 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:56 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:48 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:44 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:42 Bippzy wrote: [quote] People who hear about hitler do not try to start a new holocaust. lol... um... LOL. But seriously, they don't learn that much, stop making bad comparisons. On May 15 2011 05:44 DatBoiRijad wrote: [quote] You've never been to China, have you? I'll stop now since you really aren't addressing my points anymore. Why would I address assumptions? :/ Sorry man I can't. You just assume things and bring no data to support it. You might as well tell me you believe in unicorns and I can't disprove it. Do you see the Chinese even trying to sell drugs? No, because they have a death penalty. I don't agree with the death penalty, but it sure has stopped the Chinese people from doing drugs. you're losing this argument btw. I love that you can make that call. How's this one: I'd rather see people doing largely drugs (for they are free) rather than having the government execute absolutely insane amounts of people, some of which are bound to be innocent due to the low quality of trials. You're losing this argument and I love teh democracy. Play me. Again you're taking this off topic. I was using it as an example of how strict laws work, I never said I agreed with it. Now, please, if you're not going to stay on topic then stop responding. You talked about your perceived upside of executing the population of your own country to prevent drugs from being in circulation in China. I brought up downsides. It was perfectly on topic, unless you consider that your post was off topic. No, you're wrong. I posted an example of how strict rules in China keep people off of drugs, and that if we were strict with the "eye for an eye" rule, how that will keep people from doing whatever crime they are trying to due. You're trying to turn this into a drug debate, I'm not sure why. So you made an analogy and I pointed out that it's not very coherent to compare drugs to murder. Seems linear to me. Again, you're off topic. I'm talking about how if an "eye for an eye" was enforced more, less people would start doing it. It's pretty sad that I have to write this out word for word for you to actually get it. Aren't you the one that was advocating a prison sentence for gay sex? Wouldn't "eye for an eye" dictate that we punish gay sex with more gay sex? Everyone wins! (sorry, I just had to) Wouldn't "they" like that?
On May 15 2011 06:15 Djzapz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:12 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 06:09 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 06:07 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 06:04 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 06:01 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:56 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:48 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:44 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:42 Bippzy wrote: [quote] People who hear about hitler do not try to start a new holocaust. lol... um... LOL. But seriously, they don't learn that much, stop making bad comparisons. On May 15 2011 05:44 DatBoiRijad wrote: [quote] You've never been to China, have you? I'll stop now since you really aren't addressing my points anymore. Why would I address assumptions? :/ Sorry man I can't. You just assume things and bring no data to support it. You might as well tell me you believe in unicorns and I can't disprove it. Do you see the Chinese even trying to sell drugs? No, because they have a death penalty. I don't agree with the death penalty, but it sure has stopped the Chinese people from doing drugs. you're losing this argument btw. I love that you can make that call. How's this one: I'd rather see people doing largely drugs (for they are free) rather than having the government execute absolutely insane amounts of people, some of which are bound to be innocent due to the low quality of trials. You're losing this argument and I love teh democracy. Play me. Again you're taking this off topic. I was using it as an example of how strict laws work, I never said I agreed with it. Now, please, if you're not going to stay on topic then stop responding. You talked about your perceived upside of executing the population of your own country to prevent drugs from being in circulation in China. I brought up downsides. It was perfectly on topic, unless you consider that your post was off topic. No, you're wrong. I posted an example of how strict rules in China keep people off of drugs, and that if we were strict with the "eye for an eye" rule, how that will keep people from doing whatever crime they are trying to due. You're trying to turn this into a drug debate, I'm not sure why. So you made an analogy and I pointed out that it's not very coherent to compare drugs to murder. Seems linear to me. Again, you're off topic. I'm talking about how if an "eye for an eye" was enforced more, less people would start doing it. It's pretty sad that I have to write this out word for word for you to actually get it. If eye for an eye is enforced for drugs, less people would start doing it. That does not translate to the same thing for murder... It's cute that you keep insisting that I'm off topic because it's easy to say even if it's not true. People who aren't following the flow of that conversation may take your word for it and that's a bit sad. You see, when you brought up drugs, I went on a tangent explaining that even if it works for drugs, I'm not in favor of it. It's a perfectly legitimate tangent to explore. You can't go around telling people they're off topic bring they bring a dimension of the argument which you dislike.
How does it not translate into the same thing for murder?
|
On May 15 2011 06:15 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:14 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:05 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 05:52 mcc wrote: Why do I have the feeling that this thread is mostly populated by teenage internet tough-guys ?Probably because people here actually require a lecture on why eye-for-an-eye is a bad idea for a justice system, something that should be common civic knowledge for someone leaving highschool. Alright, sir, I'm a freshman in high school. Let me take a crack at it. Eye for an eye is bad because of what it says to society. Since it is a response to something a criminal did, it says that it is okay to do this because the government did this. Another reason for eye for an eye being bad is the dominance of christianity, which promotes forgiveness over retribution. I'm a teenage internet tough guy, and I say that eye for an eye is a just justice system, and the added option of jail time makes it a perfectly good idea for a justice system, especially if everyone isn't christian. This post makes me laugh, Christianity promotes forgiveness over retribution, that's why I will be sentenced to eternal damnation for not obeying God's every command right? That's like saying the Islam promotes woman's rights over misogyny. I think you should read the koran before spewing the nonsense that you see on TV and what corrupt governments do and believe this is how women should be treated in Islam.
You act as if its completely false that women have basically no rights in Islam. Regardless of what the Qur'an says( it does promote misogyny) it doesn't change the fact that women are required to cover their whole body in public, and are at the mercy of their husbands. After all, wouldn't want to tempt someone into raping her, through no fault of their own of course.
|
Wow, I actually agree with Sharia for once. This guy deserves nothing but harsh punishment, fucking scumbag.
|
On May 15 2011 06:21 LloydRays wrote: I don't see a problem with eye for an eye in this special circumstance, like you ruined the womans life by disfiguring her. Its much different than if you steal they cut off a finger. We have eye for an eye in the United States, its called the death penalty.
edited for puncutation If someone steals and gets their finger cut off, that's not an eye for an eye. An eye for an eye would mean that they would have something stolen from them.
|
On May 14 2011 19:09 EmeraldSparks wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On May 14 2011 18:56 Cr4zyH0r5e wrote: Make the punishment harsh enough and no one will commit the offense. In the Middle Ages, criminals could be executed by having every single bone in their bodies broken on the wheel with iron hammers and left to die of shock or dehydration over the course of days, and people still committed crimes. I guess they just weren't being "harsh enough." I bet you could make that sort of stuff last weeks, or maybe you could just keep piling on even more unpleasant things. For example, maybe you could sodomize him with a steel bar while force-feeding him his own castrated genitals and have him eaten alive by starving dogs after a day of leaving him out to dry.
Quoting this from page 21 in hopes more people read it. Beyond the scope of what I could accomplish in this post, I hope the posters understand that harsher punishment rarely deters crime. Of the four reasons for criminal punishment, deterrence vengeance justice reform, only vengeance sees consistent success.
|
On May 15 2011 06:25 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:15 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:14 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:05 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 05:52 mcc wrote: Why do I have the feeling that this thread is mostly populated by teenage internet tough-guys ?Probably because people here actually require a lecture on why eye-for-an-eye is a bad idea for a justice system, something that should be common civic knowledge for someone leaving highschool. Alright, sir, I'm a freshman in high school. Let me take a crack at it. Eye for an eye is bad because of what it says to society. Since it is a response to something a criminal did, it says that it is okay to do this because the government did this. Another reason for eye for an eye being bad is the dominance of christianity, which promotes forgiveness over retribution. I'm a teenage internet tough guy, and I say that eye for an eye is a just justice system, and the added option of jail time makes it a perfectly good idea for a justice system, especially if everyone isn't christian. This post makes me laugh, Christianity promotes forgiveness over retribution, that's why I will be sentenced to eternal damnation for not obeying God's every command right? That's like saying the Islam promotes woman's rights over misogyny. I think you should read the koran before spewing the nonsense that you see on TV and what corrupt governments do and believe this is how women should be treated in Islam. You act as if its completely false that women have basically no rights in Islam. Regardless of what the Qur'an says( it does promote misogyny) it doesn't change the fact that women are required to cover their whole body in public, and are at the mercy of their husbands. After all, wouldn't want to tempt someone into raping her, through no fault of their own of course.
I could explain to you how misinformed you are but I don't think it will suffice. Go read it. I know its very simple and easy for you to say what you just did because it gives you a feeling that you understand enough of the religion to discuss it but sadly you dont. So please, go read the Koran.
|
On May 15 2011 06:23 Bippzy wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:14 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:05 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 05:52 mcc wrote: Why do I have the feeling that this thread is mostly populated by teenage internet tough-guys ?Probably because people here actually require a lecture on why eye-for-an-eye is a bad idea for a justice system, something that should be common civic knowledge for someone leaving highschool. Alright, sir, I'm a freshman in high school. Let me take a crack at it. Eye for an eye is bad because of what it says to society. Since it is a response to something a criminal did, it says that it is okay to do this because the government did this. Another reason for eye for an eye being bad is the dominance of christianity, which promotes forgiveness over retribution. I'm a teenage internet tough guy, and I say that eye for an eye is a just justice system, and the added option of jail time makes it a perfectly good idea for a justice system, especially if everyone isn't christian. This post makes me laugh, Christianity promotes forgiveness over retribution, that's why I will be sentenced to eternal damnation for not obeying God's every command right? That's like saying the Islam promotes woman's rights over misogyny. Dude, relearn christianity. Jesus died for our sins, according to christianity. You are not sentenced to eternal damnation as long as you ask for forgiveness. This is a major principle of christianity. It is not like saying whatever your false simile was.
Forgiveness for what? Frankly I don't believe in God, so obviously I'm not gonna "ask for forgiveness", and according to Christianity I will go to hell for that.
|
On May 15 2011 06:27 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:25 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:15 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:14 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:05 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 05:52 mcc wrote: Why do I have the feeling that this thread is mostly populated by teenage internet tough-guys ?Probably because people here actually require a lecture on why eye-for-an-eye is a bad idea for a justice system, something that should be common civic knowledge for someone leaving highschool. Alright, sir, I'm a freshman in high school. Let me take a crack at it. Eye for an eye is bad because of what it says to society. Since it is a response to something a criminal did, it says that it is okay to do this because the government did this. Another reason for eye for an eye being bad is the dominance of christianity, which promotes forgiveness over retribution. I'm a teenage internet tough guy, and I say that eye for an eye is a just justice system, and the added option of jail time makes it a perfectly good idea for a justice system, especially if everyone isn't christian. This post makes me laugh, Christianity promotes forgiveness over retribution, that's why I will be sentenced to eternal damnation for not obeying God's every command right? That's like saying the Islam promotes woman's rights over misogyny. I think you should read the koran before spewing the nonsense that you see on TV and what corrupt governments do and believe this is how women should be treated in Islam. You act as if its completely false that women have basically no rights in Islam. Regardless of what the Qur'an says( it does promote misogyny) it doesn't change the fact that women are required to cover their whole body in public, and are at the mercy of their husbands. After all, wouldn't want to tempt someone into raping her, through no fault of their own of course. I could explain to you how misinformed you are but I don't think it will suffice. Go read it. I know its very simple and easy for you to say what you just did because it gives you a feeling that you understand enough of the religion to discuss it but sadly you dont. So please, go read the Koran.
Please, point out one thing that is FACTUALLY FALSE about my post.
|
On May 15 2011 06:28 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:23 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 06:14 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:05 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 05:52 mcc wrote: Why do I have the feeling that this thread is mostly populated by teenage internet tough-guys ?Probably because people here actually require a lecture on why eye-for-an-eye is a bad idea for a justice system, something that should be common civic knowledge for someone leaving highschool. Alright, sir, I'm a freshman in high school. Let me take a crack at it. Eye for an eye is bad because of what it says to society. Since it is a response to something a criminal did, it says that it is okay to do this because the government did this. Another reason for eye for an eye being bad is the dominance of christianity, which promotes forgiveness over retribution. I'm a teenage internet tough guy, and I say that eye for an eye is a just justice system, and the added option of jail time makes it a perfectly good idea for a justice system, especially if everyone isn't christian. This post makes me laugh, Christianity promotes forgiveness over retribution, that's why I will be sentenced to eternal damnation for not obeying God's every command right? That's like saying the Islam promotes woman's rights over misogyny. Dude, relearn christianity. Jesus died for our sins, according to christianity. You are not sentenced to eternal damnation as long as you ask for forgiveness. This is a major principle of christianity. It is not like saying whatever your false simile was. Forgiveness for what? Frankly I don't believe in God, so obviously I'm not gonna "ask for forgiveness", and according to Christianity I will go to hell for that.
Theres actually a split in whether or not you have to believe that Jesus is the savior. Some argue that if you do not accept him, all you do is in vain, while others say that good deeds are just that, and if you are truly sorry for not listening to the message (and you were a good person) you are forgiven.
|
well, ummmm man thats tough spot if it was real love there wouldnt be revenge but then again, the male abauses the wife alot -.-
|
On May 15 2011 06:30 Olinim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:27 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:25 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:15 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:14 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:05 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 05:52 mcc wrote: Why do I have the feeling that this thread is mostly populated by teenage internet tough-guys ?Probably because people here actually require a lecture on why eye-for-an-eye is a bad idea for a justice system, something that should be common civic knowledge for someone leaving highschool. Alright, sir, I'm a freshman in high school. Let me take a crack at it. Eye for an eye is bad because of what it says to society. Since it is a response to something a criminal did, it says that it is okay to do this because the government did this. Another reason for eye for an eye being bad is the dominance of christianity, which promotes forgiveness over retribution. I'm a teenage internet tough guy, and I say that eye for an eye is a just justice system, and the added option of jail time makes it a perfectly good idea for a justice system, especially if everyone isn't christian. This post makes me laugh, Christianity promotes forgiveness over retribution, that's why I will be sentenced to eternal damnation for not obeying God's every command right? That's like saying the Islam promotes woman's rights over misogyny. I think you should read the koran before spewing the nonsense that you see on TV and what corrupt governments do and believe this is how women should be treated in Islam. You act as if its completely false that women have basically no rights in Islam. Regardless of what the Qur'an says( it does promote misogyny) it doesn't change the fact that women are required to cover their whole body in public, and are at the mercy of their husbands. After all, wouldn't want to tempt someone into raping her, through no fault of their own of course. I could explain to you how misinformed you are but I don't think it will suffice. Go read it. I know its very simple and easy for you to say what you just did because it gives you a feeling that you understand enough of the religion to discuss it but sadly you dont. So please, go read the Koran. Please, point out one thing that is FACTUALLY FALSE about my post.
No. There is no point. Because then you will respond by trying to rationalize what you are thinking & saying, and so will start an absolutely useless debate where I have to invest energy to try and make you understand. But you wont at the end, because saying that "women are badly treated in Islam" is simple and easy. It allows you to seemingly understand a part of the world you do know much about. To reiterate, go read it. if i will debate, i rather debate with someone that is well informed.
(PS Im not muslim)
|
On May 15 2011 06:24 DatBoiRijad wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:15 matjlav wrote:On May 15 2011 06:12 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 06:09 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 06:07 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 06:04 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 06:01 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:56 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:48 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:44 Djzapz wrote: [quote] lol...
um...
LOL.
But seriously, they don't learn that much, stop making bad comparisons.
[quote] Why would I address assumptions? :/ Sorry man I can't. You just assume things and bring no data to support it. You might as well tell me you believe in unicorns and I can't disprove it. Do you see the Chinese even trying to sell drugs? No, because they have a death penalty. I don't agree with the death penalty, but it sure has stopped the Chinese people from doing drugs. you're losing this argument btw. I love that you can make that call. How's this one: I'd rather see people doing largely drugs (for they are free) rather than having the government execute absolutely insane amounts of people, some of which are bound to be innocent due to the low quality of trials. You're losing this argument and I love teh democracy. Play me. Again you're taking this off topic. I was using it as an example of how strict laws work, I never said I agreed with it. Now, please, if you're not going to stay on topic then stop responding. You talked about your perceived upside of executing the population of your own country to prevent drugs from being in circulation in China. I brought up downsides. It was perfectly on topic, unless you consider that your post was off topic. No, you're wrong. I posted an example of how strict rules in China keep people off of drugs, and that if we were strict with the "eye for an eye" rule, how that will keep people from doing whatever crime they are trying to due. You're trying to turn this into a drug debate, I'm not sure why. So you made an analogy and I pointed out that it's not very coherent to compare drugs to murder. Seems linear to me. Again, you're off topic. I'm talking about how if an "eye for an eye" was enforced more, less people would start doing it. It's pretty sad that I have to write this out word for word for you to actually get it. Aren't you the one that was advocating a prison sentence for gay sex? Wouldn't "eye for an eye" dictate that we punish gay sex with more gay sex? Everyone wins! (sorry, I just had to) Wouldn't "they" like that? Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:15 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 06:12 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 06:09 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 06:07 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 06:04 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 06:01 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:56 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:48 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:44 Djzapz wrote: [quote] lol...
um...
LOL.
But seriously, they don't learn that much, stop making bad comparisons.
[quote] Why would I address assumptions? :/ Sorry man I can't. You just assume things and bring no data to support it. You might as well tell me you believe in unicorns and I can't disprove it. Do you see the Chinese even trying to sell drugs? No, because they have a death penalty. I don't agree with the death penalty, but it sure has stopped the Chinese people from doing drugs. you're losing this argument btw. I love that you can make that call. How's this one: I'd rather see people doing largely drugs (for they are free) rather than having the government execute absolutely insane amounts of people, some of which are bound to be innocent due to the low quality of trials. You're losing this argument and I love teh democracy. Play me. Again you're taking this off topic. I was using it as an example of how strict laws work, I never said I agreed with it. Now, please, if you're not going to stay on topic then stop responding. You talked about your perceived upside of executing the population of your own country to prevent drugs from being in circulation in China. I brought up downsides. It was perfectly on topic, unless you consider that your post was off topic. No, you're wrong. I posted an example of how strict rules in China keep people off of drugs, and that if we were strict with the "eye for an eye" rule, how that will keep people from doing whatever crime they are trying to due. You're trying to turn this into a drug debate, I'm not sure why. So you made an analogy and I pointed out that it's not very coherent to compare drugs to murder. Seems linear to me. Again, you're off topic. I'm talking about how if an "eye for an eye" was enforced more, less people would start doing it. It's pretty sad that I have to write this out word for word for you to actually get it. If eye for an eye is enforced for drugs, less people would start doing it. That does not translate to the same thing for murder... It's cute that you keep insisting that I'm off topic because it's easy to say even if it's not true. People who aren't following the flow of that conversation may take your word for it and that's a bit sad. You see, when you brought up drugs, I went on a tangent explaining that even if it works for drugs, I'm not in favor of it. It's a perfectly legitimate tangent to explore. You can't go around telling people they're off topic bring they bring a dimension of the argument which you dislike. How does it not translate into the same thing for murder? Murder can have an huge emotional involvement and can happen spontaneously when someone has a psychosis or throws a fit or something.
Drugs don't pop out of thin air and are necessarily planned in advance, the monetary incentive is killed by the fact that it's just "not worth it".
|
This thread is one huge depressing read. It's not like I actually believed the users of TL were better than elsewhere because of the SC/SC2 community being relatively mature and such, but I wanted to believe it. This thread singlehandedly destroys this illusion of mine.
There's a difference between neccessary punishment for the sake of society's well-being and needless cruelty in the name of "vengeance". The ~50% of you in this thread praising this concept need to grow up - morally, that is. Or at least try to be less of a badass on the intertubes, because I can't seriously believe that all of you supporting this here on TL would do so IRL as well.
To the other 50% trying to beat some reason into the bloodthirsty other half, keep it up. Fighting ignorance is a dirty job, but someone's gotta do it.
|
On May 15 2011 06:38 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 06:30 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:27 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:25 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:15 Kindred wrote:On May 15 2011 06:14 Olinim wrote:On May 15 2011 06:05 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 05:52 mcc wrote: Why do I have the feeling that this thread is mostly populated by teenage internet tough-guys ?Probably because people here actually require a lecture on why eye-for-an-eye is a bad idea for a justice system, something that should be common civic knowledge for someone leaving highschool. Alright, sir, I'm a freshman in high school. Let me take a crack at it. Eye for an eye is bad because of what it says to society. Since it is a response to something a criminal did, it says that it is okay to do this because the government did this. Another reason for eye for an eye being bad is the dominance of christianity, which promotes forgiveness over retribution. I'm a teenage internet tough guy, and I say that eye for an eye is a just justice system, and the added option of jail time makes it a perfectly good idea for a justice system, especially if everyone isn't christian. This post makes me laugh, Christianity promotes forgiveness over retribution, that's why I will be sentenced to eternal damnation for not obeying God's every command right? That's like saying the Islam promotes woman's rights over misogyny. I think you should read the koran before spewing the nonsense that you see on TV and what corrupt governments do and believe this is how women should be treated in Islam. You act as if its completely false that women have basically no rights in Islam. Regardless of what the Qur'an says( it does promote misogyny) it doesn't change the fact that women are required to cover their whole body in public, and are at the mercy of their husbands. After all, wouldn't want to tempt someone into raping her, through no fault of their own of course. I could explain to you how misinformed you are but I don't think it will suffice. Go read it. I know its very simple and easy for you to say what you just did because it gives you a feeling that you understand enough of the religion to discuss it but sadly you dont. So please, go read the Koran. Please, point out one thing that is FACTUALLY FALSE about my post. No. There is no point. Because then you will respond by trying to rationalize what you are thinking & saying, and so will start an absolutely useless debate where I have to invest energy to try and make you understand. But you wont at the end, because saying that "women are badly treated in Islam" is simple and easy. It allows you to seemingly understand a part of the world you do know much about. To reiterate, go read it. if i will debate, i rather debate with someone that is well informed. (PS Im not muslim)
Translation: No, I wont, because I cant, because everything you said in the post was a fact. You are so eager to tell me I'm misinformed, but then conveniently omit pointing out my misinformation.
|
On May 15 2011 06:27 Kindred wrote: I could explain to you how misinformed you are but I don't think it will suffice. Go read it. I know its very simple and easy for you to say what you just did because it gives you a feeling that you understand enough of the religion to discuss it but sadly you dont. So please, go read the Koran. Why don't you enlighten us all then?
Interesting style of discussion....
|
|
|
|
|
|