|
On November 08 2010 06:37 DorF wrote: Didn't it say that guy had 1 billion dollars or something ... if he would loose his job wouldn't he technically still have 1 billion dollars and moreover this is just a "that guy has alot of money so we'll let him off the hookf" Seriously , he ran over a guy and deliberately left him to die beacuse he was afraid to loose his job that's what happened , the law is the law isn't it ? I mean WTF ??!
he doesn't have those 1billion dollars. that's the amount of other's peoples money he handles with. well obviously someone with so much cash to handle will not be a poor kid.
|
On November 08 2010 06:17 JeeJee wrote: odd
most of you are suggesting that he lose his job and get thrown in jail which results in the victim unable to undergo medical treatment
the court decided to let the victim undergo medical treatment instead
i think it was a better decision compared to most of your suggestions. care to explain specifically why destroying 2 lives is better than destroying 0? I must have read a different article than you - can you please point me to the line that says the only possible way in the universe the victim can undergo treatment is if the felony charges are dropped? Thanks.
On November 08 2010 06:38 Wr3k wrote: The guy needs his job to pay restitution. I don't see why this is so crazy. Yeah the motherfucker should be thrown in jail and raped int the ass for several years, but that wouldn't do much good to the victim now would it. You mean, the guy needs his job to pay all of the restitution. If the sale of all his assets and all of the funds he has on hand isn't enough to cover everything, then I'm okay with that. Just take it all anyways and the rest of the funding for the medical care can come from something else. Meanwhile the guy gets brought up on felony charges and justice is served.
On November 08 2010 06:46 KurtistheTurtle wrote: justice for the victim > punishment for the offender
this really isn't a big deal. Justice for the victim is punishing the offender. The court is here to judge the crime of the guy getting run over, not have a financial discussion to work out the victim's medical payment plans.
|
Just like everything else in the United States, money buys justice.
It's sickening how much leeway we give to these big money hotshots who look at the rest of us like we are ants.
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
Justice for the victim is punishing the offender. The court is here to judge the crime of the guy getting run over, not have a financial discussion to work out the victim's medical payment plans. that's a wrongheaded view of the situation. what do you suppose the raison d'etre of the courts is, how about the point of the justice system.
if you think the courts are there to exact retribution and uphold some sort of transcendental justice, you'll have to defend those conceptions of justice. the court's decision here shows that they are behaving like a part of a government that works toward the social good.
|
I'm a little confused. Felony convictions don't generally lead to an award of any monetary damages for compensation, you just get sentenced to whatever is outlined in the criminal statute. So even if the prosecutor does go for a felony criminal conviction, the victim won't be compensated since the guy will simply be thrown in jail plus a fine if applicable.
It's the civil remedy (some kind of tort i'm guessing) where he's gonna get the monetary damages, not the criminal trial. Since the victim can only really get compensated via a civil trial, why is everyone talking about the State making him pay compensatory damages through a criminal sentence when the State doesn't even have the authority to do this?
lol? or am I missing something.
|
Oh my god throw this man in a dark cell for a few years.
If my poor, lower class ass would run someone over then run I would be in jail for a very long time. Fuck this shit.
|
On November 08 2010 08:14 oneofthem wrote:Show nested quote +Justice for the victim is punishing the offender. The court is here to judge the crime of the guy getting run over, not have a financial discussion to work out the victim's medical payment plans. that's a wrongheaded view of the situation. what do you suppose the raison d'etre of the courts is, how about the point of the justice system.
It's why we have liability insurance. If we get into a car accident and hurt someone, the insurance can cover for it.
Similarly, this guy hit the bicyclist, the "insurance" is the portion of his paycheck that will be taken to cover the bicyclist.
I think this is the best form of justice. While the action of the perpetrator is reprehensible, both lives will be somewhat salvaged.
|
This whole thing sounds like a weak excuse for Erzinger to keep his cushy job after whatever lighter-than-a-felony penalty results from misdemeanor charges. Milo/Haddon already said they didn't care about Erzinger's ability to pay - the whole thing stinks.
|
This really should be two cases, the first formal pressing of criminal charges for his actions and a civil suit for the damages/medical bills + pain and suffering.
|
At what point did it become a misdemeanor to nearly kill a man, leave him horribly crippled for life, and attempt to hide the fact? Hopefully this case will get some national media attention and this scumbag will get treated like anyone else. Dealing with a billion dollars in clients is not a good excuse as to why it can't be a felony charge.
OP, maybe you didn't notice, but we live in a Capitalist, not Democratic Society.
Money = Freedom.
No money = No Freedom.
|
While I do not necessarily disagree with the ruling given its current benefit to the victim... this appears to highlight the flawed issue of the American overpriced medical care rather than the justice for the rich issue.
|
On November 08 2010 09:49 Prophecy3 wrote:Show nested quote +At what point did it become a misdemeanor to nearly kill a man, leave him horribly crippled for life, and attempt to hide the fact? Hopefully this case will get some national media attention and this scumbag will get treated like anyone else. Dealing with a billion dollars in clients is not a good excuse as to why it can't be a felony charge. OP, maybe you didn't notice, but we live in a Capitalist, not Democratic Society. Money = Freedom. No money = No Freedom.
/thread
Personally, I see this as the best course of action. Victim gets money and can relax for the rest of his life (meds should get rid of the short-term pain and long-term as well if there is any) and the financial manager can continue on with life. Let's all face it. Shit happens. The financial manager was definitely wrong for leaving him to die, but put yourself in his shoes. If you had just run someone over and were facing 20 years in jail, what would you do? I'm pretty sure most of us here would attempt to run as well.
On top of that... cycling on the highway? I'm an avid cyclist myself and even I can't fathom as to why anyone would do that. There's a reason why most people in the cycling community call these cyclists that go on the highways idiots. 3,000 lb vehicles going 60 mph is something to be afraid of and not taken lightly.
|
Halls of justice painted green.
|
To everyone who's discussing the guys ability to pay, the victim is a doctor. I'm pretty sure he has saved up the money to perform all the necessary procedures (as well as health insurance and disability insurance he probably gets from work). The doc himself says he doesn't care about the money, he just wants to see the fucker rot. Really, it seems more like the DA was a douchebag than almost anyone in this case for going for a misdemeanor instead of a felony.
|
|
|
|
|
|