Financial Manager gets felony charges dropped... - Page 2
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Baby_Seal
United States360 Posts
| ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
On November 08 2010 01:58 Krigwin wrote: Nonsense. It's called liquidating his assets. If he can't pay off the restitution even after that then he can stay in debt for the rest of his entire life. You do this kind of damage, you should be held responsible. No matter how rich you are. Right, I'm sure there'll be plenty of banks willing to lend him all the money he needs if he's going to jail and losing most of his money-making capacity. It's one thing or the other; get the financial manager to pay up for all the damage he caused, OR get him convicted on a felony charge and screw him over for what he did to Dr. Milo. Can't have your cake and eat it too. If your sense of justice tells you Martin Erzinger's life should be destroyed for what he did to Steven Milo, then you're entitled to that opinion. I, for one, agree with the Prosecutors- Erzinger caused harm to Milo, hence Erzinger needs to make it up to the doctor. Two wrongs don't make a right. I also think Erzinger is one lucky motherfucker because he's basically holding his money-making skills hostage, and if it weren't for that he'd go straight to jail- on top of having to pay for the damages caused to Dr. Milo. | ||
|
a176
Canada6688 Posts
On November 08 2010 02:30 itzme_petey wrote: The manager makes at least 400k. 1billion in assets, 2% management fee, 75% goes to MS, 25% goes to his pocket. And he isnt a hedgefund manager or someone special. He just is at the top of the pyramid and got lucky enough to horde alot of high net worth individuals. He does nothing special other than pitch services and investments that analysts at the Morgan Stanley desk suggest. His best bet is to find his ass a really good lawyer. 400,000 is somehow not enough? | ||
|
forgotten0ne
United States951 Posts
| ||
|
ZERG_RUSSIAN
10417 Posts
On November 08 2010 03:04 Zato-1 wrote: Right, I'm sure there'll be plenty of banks willing to lend him all the money he needs if he's going to jail and losing most of his money-making capacity. It's one thing or the other; get the financial manager to pay up for all the damage he caused, OR get him convicted on a felony charge and screw him over for what he did to Dr. Milo. Can't have your cake and eat it too. If your sense of justice tells you Martin Erzinger's life should be destroyed for what he did to Steven Milo, then you're entitled to that opinion. I, for one, agree with the Prosecutors- Erzinger caused harm to Milo, hence Erzinger needs to make it up to the doctor. Two wrongs don't make a right. I also think Erzinger is one lucky motherfucker because he's basically holding his money-making skills hostage, and if it weren't for that he'd go straight to jail- on top of having to pay for the damages caused to Dr. Milo. The point is that if this happened to someone who made 50k a year they'd be in prison with a felony for 20 years and still have to pay on top of losing their job. This is a case of the rich getting off the hook because they're rich. | ||
|
Krigwin
1130 Posts
On November 08 2010 03:04 Zato-1 wrote: Right, I'm sure there'll be plenty of banks willing to lend him all the money he needs if he's going to jail and losing most of his money-making capacity. It's one thing or the other; get the financial manager to pay up for all the damage he caused, OR get him convicted on a felony charge and screw him over for what he did to Dr. Milo. Can't have your cake and eat it too. If your sense of justice tells you Martin Erzinger's life should be destroyed for what he did to Steven Milo, then you're entitled to that opinion. I, for one, agree with the Prosecutors- Erzinger caused harm to Milo, hence Erzinger needs to make it up to the doctor. Two wrongs don't make a right. I also think Erzinger is one lucky motherfucker because he's basically holding his money-making skills hostage, and if it weren't for that he'd go straight to jail- on top of having to pay for the damages caused to Dr. Milo. Why can't I have my cake and eat it too? What's preventing me from doing that? And why is it two wrongs? How is having this guy lose his job a "wrong"? It doesn't matter if he can't borrow from banks. If he has to get a job in another field in order to pay the restitution and then ends up with debt forever I really couldn't care less. | ||
|
Irrelevant
United States2364 Posts
| ||
|
Murderotica
Vatican City State2594 Posts
| ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
On November 08 2010 03:20 ZERG_RUSSIAN wrote: The point is that if this happened to someone who made 50k a year they'd be in prison with a felony for 20 years and still have to pay on top of losing their job. This is a case of the rich getting off the hook because they're rich. Um, no? He's getting off the hook because otherwise, he wouldn't be able to pay damages to the doctor. Prosecution's argument, not mine. If this happened to someone who made 50k a year, he'd go to prison and the doctor would get little, if any, compensatory / punitive money. Is the arrangement reached extremely convenient to the financial manager? Undoubtedly. However, Justice isn't about destroying the lives of the guilty. The guy deserved jail time and the reputation that comes with being a convicted felon, no one disagrees with that- he just got lucky because that conflicted with another (and, in the prosecution's opinion, more important) objective, that of compensating the victim for the harm that was caused to him. On November 08 2010 03:23 Krigwin wrote: Why can't I have my cake and eat it too? What's preventing me from doing that? And why is it two wrongs? How is having this guy lose his job a "wrong"? It doesn't matter if he can't borrow from banks. If he has to get a job in another field in order to pay the restitution and then ends up with debt forever I really couldn't care less. If you eat your cake, it's gone. You can't keep it so you can eat it tomorrow, because you already ate it today. Again with the debt. He can never end up with debt for the rest of his life. It's an impossible outcome. First: He would have to voluntarily sign up for the debt. You can't "force" people into debt. Second: No lender would lend him any money if he can't repay it, therefore the alternative of ending up underemployed, and borrowing to pay the damages is an impossible outcome. The Financial Manager would have to be exceedingly stupid to enter such an arrangement. The only way he's paying the doctor for compensatory / punitive damages is if he gets to KEEP HIS JOB and make enough money to pay. Without his job, he can't pay the damages, goes to jail instead, and the good doctor gets nothing. So, again: Would you rather destroy the life of the financial manager, or would you rather make sure the doctor gets reparations? It's an answer that changes from person to person, depending on how vindictive they are. But as far as justice goes (which is not exactly the same as fairness), I agree with the prosecution's decision. | ||
|
Niton
United States2395 Posts
| ||
|
Krigwin
1130 Posts
On November 08 2010 03:44 Zato-1 wrote: If you eat your cake, it's gone. You can't keep it so you can eat it tomorrow, because you already ate it today. Again with the debt. He can never end up with debt for the rest of his life. It's an impossible outcome. First: He would have to voluntarily sign up for the debt. You can't "force" people into debt. Second: No lender would lend him any money if he can't repay it, therefore the alternative of ending up underemployed, and borrowing to pay the damages is an impossible outcome. The Financial Manager would have to be exceedingly stupid to enter such an arrangement. The only way he's paying the doctor for compensatory / punitive damages is if he gets to KEEP HIS JOB and make enough money to pay. Without his job, he can't pay the damages, goes to jail instead, and the good doctor gets nothing. So, again: Would you rather destroy the life of the financial manager, or would you rather make sure the doctor gets reparations? It's an answer that changes from person to person, depending on how vindictive they are. But as far as justice goes (which is not exactly the same as fairness), I agree with the prosecution's decision. First of all, the doctor in this case is absolutely right. The objective of the court is to dispense justice in the crime of running the doctor over. Who is going to pay for the doctor's medical care or how they're going to do it should not be a factor whatsoever in the court's judgment on the matter. If you think letting this guy off the hook just because he's rich is "justice", then all I can say is you have a very strange idea of justice. Secondly, you can absolutely force someone into debt. It's called ordering that person to pay damages. Liquidate all of his assets, it states he has over $1 billion in them, I find it hard to believe that would be insufficient to cover the doctor's preliminary medical costs. Then order the guy to continue paying punitive damages in maybe a monthly sum or something to cover the doctor's ongoing care. If at any time he is unable to pay for the care, throw his ass in prison. Whether he can or cannot afford it because he gets fired or for whatever other reason is hardly the court's concern. It's not the court's, nor the doctor's fault that having a felony charge would cause him to lose his job. If he has to go find another job to continue making payments, good, maybe some hard work for once will teach him to value other people's lives. But okay, if it came all the way down to that choice, you're right, it changes from person to person. But some people don't matter while others should have a stronger say in the matter. You know whose person's answer to that question should matter the most? How about the actual victim. Judging by how the doctor and his attorneys are protesting the decision, I'd venture a guess to say they don't quite agree with that decision. If it came down to paying for the medical costs or seeing justice done to this asshole, I agree with the doctor - justice comes first. | ||
|
Niton
United States2395 Posts
| ||
|
Kalpman
Sweden406 Posts
| ||
|
JeeJee
Canada5652 Posts
most of you are suggesting that he lose his job and get thrown in jail which results in the victim unable to undergo medical treatment the court decided to let the victim undergo medical treatment instead i think it was a better decision compared to most of your suggestions. care to explain specifically why destroying 2 lives is better than destroying 0? | ||
|
Shockk
Germany2269 Posts
| ||
|
Romantic
United States1844 Posts
If the victim gets significantly more money then perhaps it is a good idea. | ||
|
DorF
Sweden961 Posts
Seriously , he ran over a guy and deliberately left him to die beacuse he was afraid to loose his job that's what happened , the law is the law isn't it ? I mean WTF ??! | ||
|
Wr3k
Canada2533 Posts
| ||
|
KurtistheTurtle
United States1966 Posts
this really isn't a big deal. | ||
|
Niton
United States2395 Posts
On November 08 2010 06:17 JeeJee wrote: odd most of you are suggesting that he lose his job and get thrown in jail which results in the victim unable to undergo medical treatment the court decided to let the victim undergo medical treatment instead i think it was a better decision compared to most of your suggestions. care to explain specifically why destroying 2 lives is better than destroying 0? Because he has the money regardless of his future employment. Any reasonable settlement could be paid for with sale of his own assets on top of the significant wealth he's sure to have accumulated over his lifetime working in the finance industry. He's offering to pay IN LIEU of recieving a felony charge, so that he can continue in his line of work. Nobody short of an extremely rich man would be offered something like this, and not only does it set horrible precent for future cases, but it's specifically not what the injured man wants. On November 08 2010 06:46 KurtistheTurtle wrote: justice for the victim > punishment for the offender this really isn't a big deal. The injured man is upset that Colorado would only charge the assailant with misdemeanor charges. He wants Colorado to proceed with felony charges, because he had a felony committed against him. | ||
| ||