The video proves absolutely nothing. There are noise generators inside of the booths that should theoretically block out the noise coming from outside, that doesnt mean the massive amount of soundwaves outside stop happening and don't reach the booths themselves (which vibrate based on those soundwaves).

The only people who know if the active noise generation inside of the booths is strong enough are the MLG Staff and players, a poll on TL amonst people who do not fall into that category is 100% pointless.

Scarlett`

Korea (South)2440 Posts

July 05 2013 13:36 GMT

#10

no but they give you headphones which blast static into your ears so you can't hear yourself think

t e a C h e r

Canada151 Posts

July 05 2013 13:37 GMT

#11

ViBraTionS = Fake Booths , come on dude

Faust852

Luxembourg4004 Posts

July 05 2013 13:38 GMT

#12

On July 05 2013 22:34 Manlier wrote:
Video proves all. Either a T-rex stomping out side that booth, or the music is easily getting through to booth.

So heavy bass is now spoiling players in the games ? It's just vibration lol.

sc2superfan101

3583 Posts

July 05 2013 13:38 GMT

#13

On July 05 2013 22:36 Acer.Scarlett` wrote:
no but they give you headphones which blast static into your ears so you can't hear yourself think

Welp, that solves that mystery. lol

i zig zag around you

70 Posts

July 05 2013 13:39 GMT

#14

why would they NOT be soundproof? l0l, you guys

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

July 05 2013 13:39 GMT

#15

Jeez, what depressing poll results.
I am voting "No". Because players would say something if they can hear critical information.

RockIronrod

Australia1369 Posts

July 05 2013 13:40 GMT

#16

On July 05 2013 22:35 Arnstein wrote:
HAHA, that video! It's like those conspiracy movies, hahaha

naniwa did 9/11

LiLSighKoh

United States588 Posts

July 05 2013 13:40 GMT

#17

On July 05 2013 22:36 Acer.Scarlett` wrote:
no but they give you headphones which blast static into your ears so you can't hear yourself think

They also have like fans inside on the top of the booth a little bit above the monitor i think? They said they have white noise blasting in their on top of the headset, whatever that is

Manlier

United States32 Posts

July 05 2013 13:42 GMT

#18

On July 05 2013 22:36 Acer.Scarlett` wrote:
no but they give you headphones which blast static into your ears so you can't hear yourself think

look whos talking

ESCScarlett
http://drop.sc/players/US/2331025/ECScarlett
http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2331025/1/ECScarlett/

you cannot change the profile battle.net

it goes

http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/[account number][region][player name]/

Name change does not delete profile, only the last part of URL changes.

GG hacker scarlette

SChlafmann

France725 Posts

July 05 2013 13:42 GMT

#19

What the fuck did I just watched? xD
Maybe they can hear when the crowd is going very loud, but as SC is dying, no more crowd, so no issue.
jk

GizmoPT

Portugal3040 Posts

July 05 2013 13:43 GMT

#20

what if the music was in the booth?

Manlier

United States32 Posts

July 05 2013 13:43 GMT

#21

Your only option now, hacker scarlett, is to log onto that old battle,net account and change the name. You wont have the name change in your replays on drop.sc. only the URL ESCscarlett, wont be tarnished by your hacking account.

User was temp banned for this post.

Faust852

Luxembourg4004 Posts

July 05 2013 13:43 GMT

#22

On July 05 2013 22:42 Manlier wrote:

Show nested quote +

Wut ?

Thalandros

Netherlands1151 Posts

July 05 2013 13:44 GMT

#23

On July 05 2013 22:36 Acer.Scarlett` wrote:
no but they give you headphones which blast static into your ears so you can't hear yourself think

Suspected something like this. Isn't that annoying to the point where you can't focus? :/

Ropid

Germany3557 Posts

July 05 2013 13:44 GMT

#24

Is it even possible to build a "sound proof" booth? I would hear a crowd doing things outside on the street and that's me sitting in a house, not some crappy tiny booth. I think you can at most expect the booth to help make voices incomprehensible together with the in-ear headphones and something noise cancelling on top, maybe headphones playing music. Expecting the booths to be sound proof seems unrealistic and blaming someone for that seems stupid.

NeV

Italy370 Posts

July 05 2013 13:45 GMT

#25

they can probably hear something when the cheering is very loud, but with booth plus headphones, plus white noise generators, they can't surely understand what casters are saying, and that's what it's relevant.
Naniwa is known for his complaining about everything, he was complaining about ESL PCs which are last generation PCs, when everybody else was just fine. I wouldn't put much weight on his words..

ReignSupreme.

Australia4123 Posts

July 05 2013 13:45 GMT

#26

Vibrations = People wearing big ass headphones (+ static noise) in an enclosed booth = Players getting critical information from casters and fans cheering

good detective skills OP, you've saved the day

HardlyNever

United States1258 Posts

July 05 2013 13:45 GMT

#27

I thought it was pretty obvious the actual booths weren't sound proof. That is why they have ear buds and noise canceling headphones. I mean... why else would they have those?

FnaticPink

Denmark324 Posts

July 05 2013 13:45 GMT

#28

On July 05 2013 22:42 Manlier wrote:

Show nested quote +

what?

HiTeK532

Canada171 Posts

July 05 2013 13:45 GMT

#29

I thought this was already common knowledge I mean there is only so much sound proofing you can actually do.

digmouse

China6331 Posts

July 05 2013 13:46 GMT

#30

I've been into the booths of WCS Asia and World Championship last year, if you shut the door the noise indeed reduces significantly but yes, the booth alone is not completely sound proof, but combined with headphones and white noises it should be fine.