|
On October 21 2010 03:22 Sadist wrote: The problem is 1 rax FE is nothing like it was in BW, it takes FOREVER to get saturated and if you spend any scans at all instead of mules you get the feeling of being dead broke immediately. Im not exactly sure why 1 rax FE feels so different(maybe its simply because of the mining rate, or because you need to have 6 scvs on double gas, or you need to tech all the way to starport to get medics, or it takes forever to get stim ........-_-) I dont know. But it definately seems to suck like everyone has already stated and its quite easy to get ran the fuck over.
I don't understand why this is a problem, why is it unheard of that terran should have to scout like other races if they choose to fast expand? You go fe you need mules to help pay for it, you go one base all in and you can afford a couple scans to see what you're up against. Seems fair to me.
|
On October 21 2010 03:51 Endbringer wrote: Except that in BW there was no larva inject. Therefore this imbalance was less pronounced. It was there for sure, but it was not as pronounced as it is now. Having 2 queens injecting larva is like having what, 2 extra hatcheries with your 1st expo? This means you have even less time to waste before doing damage. The Zerg is climbing ahead at a much faster rate than in BW. Sure, but Z also had dark swarm, etc. Z also usually expanded much faster in BW giving them access to even more gas. Either way this dynamic doesn't preclude the match-up from being perfectly balanced as Z units are in general less efficient than Terran's. As the game continues to develop, Terrans will probably discover the exact timings to punish Z.
|
I just watched the Gilja vs JookToJung match at the GSL which ended 2-1 in the T's favour. A few notes on the T build:
- In all the games, the T went a relatively early expand (in game 1, after 2-rax iirc and games 2 & 3, after the first couple of reactored helions). As I stated earlier, I believe the T's correct response is to expand early. The obs mode didn't show, but I think that the T probably took some SCVs off the gas.
- In all the games, the T went for a 2-base timing push designed to hit just as the Muta's popped out. The T failed in game 1 because of an early mistake, but the strat worked very well in games 2 & 3.
- One of Idra's comments was, the helion harass worked (despite killing nothing) because the Zerg was forced to get 8 speedlings. That's 4 drones that he could've got, hurting his economy. Thus, the T doesn't have to do any damage, all he needs is to force units instead of drones.
- In games 2 & 3, I think the T only went 4 helions. I also believe this is the correct response, the T should not commit too heavily to the harass, and ensure that they economy up as well.
|
have there been any global shifts in win % in ZvT?
|
On October 21 2010 03:57 Treemonkeys wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 03:22 Sadist wrote: The problem is 1 rax FE is nothing like it was in BW, it takes FOREVER to get saturated and if you spend any scans at all instead of mules you get the feeling of being dead broke immediately. Im not exactly sure why 1 rax FE feels so different(maybe its simply because of the mining rate, or because you need to have 6 scvs on double gas, or you need to tech all the way to starport to get medics, or it takes forever to get stim ........-_-) I dont know. But it definately seems to suck like everyone has already stated and its quite easy to get ran the fuck over. I don't understand why this is a problem, why is it unheard of that terran should have to scout like other races if they choose to fast expand? You go fe you need mules to help pay for it, you go one base all in and you can afford a couple scans to see what you're up against. Seems fair to me.
An expansion should pay for itself after a short amount of time, thats why its called an expansion. It takes FOREVER for a terran expansion to pay off in tvp and tvz since you have to be massing units at the risk of dying if you dont (unlike tvt where you can use a few tanks or something to hold the opponent off or at the very least making it not cost effective for him to attack)
Terran doesnt have a unit like the other races to scout. Scan is terriblely expensive, im going to start scouting with Rax now and hope i find something because wasting mules is horrible. People dont realize terran needs mules just to break even on economy since P has chrono boost and Z has inject larva. Try playing an entire game without chrono boosting probes or inject larva and tell me scans are worth it.
|
2 hatch with 2 quenns -> like 6 rax (just saying)
and from that u cant even get ultras,mutas etc
|
On October 21 2010 03:31 Endbringer wrote:Yes all Terrans are clueless. Zerg users are sooo much smarter than every single Terran user. Brilliant thinking there. If what worked before still worked than we wouldn't be looking for a magical formula. If what Terrans did before still worked than the matchup would still be imbalanced in favor of Terran wouldn't it? Thats all I have heard from Zergs since like half way through the beta.
It's not that they are smarter, they have had to innovate more, that is normal when you're back is up against a wall - innovation just tends to happen. Zerg had their back against the wall since the roach nerfs in beta, while terran has been in this situation (some terrans?) for a little over a week. If you look back at the GSL finals, you had a zerg pulling everything he could to try and win what was thought to be an unfair matchup for him. Then on the other side you had a terran doing professional versions of basic strats that every terran in diamond has been doing since release.
|
This version of SC2 is still young. I think the complaints are a little premature. People are yelling, "I can't go X because that will lose to Y!" but compare that to PvZ. Sure, if you open with banshees, you'll be behind a Z player that quickly techs to hydras or mutas. Protoss faces the same issues--if P opens with robo pressure, they'll be behind a Z player that opens with 2-base mutas. Zerg is supposed to have a response to every attack you can throw at them. It was a bad situation when Terran could make reapers or hellions and beat roaches with them. As a Protoss player, I would have loved to have a T1 unit that could rack up free kills until Z hit lair tech, but I was forced to either go all-in or try to play a economy game against a race that has better econ mechanics.
Now Terrans will join Protoss at this game. People make it sound impossible (But if I expand, he makes workers faster than I can!), but it's not that bad. P and T can't make workers as fast as Z, but they have the advantage of being able make military while they make workers. Prevent pure droning by finding timing windows where you can poke and slow their droning without losing your forces. Get creative and find solutions. It was absurd that T1 Terran beat T1 Zerg so badly. Now that it's more even, you'll need to find ways to beat Zerg's T2 and T3.
|
On October 21 2010 04:03 Treemonkeys wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 03:31 Endbringer wrote:Yes all Terrans are clueless. Zerg users are sooo much smarter than every single Terran user. Brilliant thinking there. If what worked before still worked than we wouldn't be looking for a magical formula. If what Terrans did before still worked than the matchup would still be imbalanced in favor of Terran wouldn't it? Thats all I have heard from Zergs since like half way through the beta. It's not that they are smarter, they have had to innovate more, that is normal when you're back is up against a wall - innovation just tends to happen. Zerg had their back against the wall since the roach nerfs in beta, while terran has been in this situation (some terrans?) for a little over a week. If you look back at the GSL finals, you had a zerg pulling everything he could to try and win what was thought to be an unfair matchup for him. Then on the other side you had a terran doing professional versions of basic strats that every terran in diamond has been doing since release.
Unfortunately this lends itself to the argument that the matchup was not imbalanced before, and that all Blizzard needed to do was wither the yelling of Zerg players until the Zerg metagame caught up to the Terran strats. This may have actually been happening after the GSL, as more Zergs saw that they didn't need to be more aggressive, but could instead just soak up damage and expo. The sc2 professor himself Day9 even talked about this in a podcast. Unfortunately Blizzard immediately released a patch waay earlier than they said they were going to, so we will never know, but I digress.
Innovation is what T needs right now, and threads like this are good for it. People need to stop whining about imbalance and start coming up with ways to play. You don't have any control over balance people, and blizzard could give two shits what you think. I will say the same thing to my Terran buddies that I said to the Zergs who used to whine. Play better. Then come back and post what you did here on the forums for the rest of us :D
|
^That doesn't mean it wasn't imbalanced, it just meant that Zerg needed to play harder to try to match terran even if it meant other deficiencies. 14 gas/pool was standard not because it could be standard, but because it kept zerg safe. Going 14 gas/pool kept zerg behind, but it didn't lose outright like if it went 14 hatch.
The game is certainly closer to being balanced, and that's why it seems that zerg is suddenly very good right now. Imagine fighting people with 1 hand, getting decent at it, then suddenly getting your second hand back.
|
On October 21 2010 04:00 mburke05 wrote: have there been any global shifts in win % in ZvT?
Win % between Z and T doesn't proof anything. Neither do the number of Zerg in the TOP 200 (at least if you're not comparing it with the overall ratio of Zerg players in all leagues).
People should get a clue about how statistics work before trying to use their results.
Unfortunately this lends itself to the argument that the matchup was not imbalanced before, and that all Blizzard needed to do was wither the yelling of Zerg players until the Zerg metagame caught up to the Terran strats. This may have actually been happening after the GSL, as more Zergs saw that they didn't need to be more aggressive, but could instead just soak up damage and expo. The sc2 professor himself Day9 even talked about this in a podcast. Unfortunately Blizzard immediately released a patch waay earlier than they said they were going to, so we will never know, but I digress.
Innovation is what T needs right now, and threads like this are good for it. People need to stop whining about imbalance and start coming up with ways to play. You don't have any control over balance people, and blizzard could give two shits what you think. I will say the same thing to my Terran buddies that I said to the Zergs who used to whine. Play better. Then come back and post what you did here on the forums for the rest of us :D
I like your idea. Here's my thoughts, I think that the Zerg's strategy is perfect and that Terran and Protoss should steal it. I mean whining non-stop until Blizzard makes all the buffs/nerfs you were looking for.
User was temp banned for this post.
|
Larva inject, cloacked tumours, and queens for a very good anti air
|
On October 21 2010 04:21 dave333 wrote: ^That doesn't mean it wasn't imbalanced, it just meant that Zerg needed to play harder to try to match terran even if it meant other deficiencies. 14 gas/pool was standard not because it could be standard, but because it kept zerg safe. Going 14 gas/pool kept zerg behind, but it didn't lose outright like if it went 14 hatch.
The game is certainly closer to being balanced, and that's why it seems that zerg is suddenly very good right now. Imagine fighting people with 1 hand, getting decent at it, then suddenly getting your second hand back.
\Sorry to burst some Zerg players bubbles, but you are all not magically more skilled than every T and P because you played Zerg.
Heres what I dont understand, and a Zerg can answer my question I have no doubt. Just prior to this patch, why could you not go hatch before pool? 5 rax reaper has been pretty much dead since the balance patch before this one added 5 seconds to the build time. This meant if you lost any reapers with your 5 rax strat you couldn't recover. What exactly was Zerg afraid of if they went hatch before pool? From a non-zerg prospective it seems like the patch was just a mental shift. I don't see how any change suddenly aloud the Zerg to make hatch before pool where they couldn't before.
|
On October 21 2010 03:34 Veasel wrote:And let me just add, Zerg may be a bit harder to mirco up, (spread creep and OL + quenns) but in fights there is completly mixed. zerg goes like "ahh i rush my lings+mutas+blings in. Think of the shitloud amount of thing terrans need to do, ahh shit stim! siege! Move from blings! Thor target mutas! 
hm.....not true at all. Zerglings, mutas, and :3anelings all require a separate control group. When fighting on creep, banelings can outrun stimmed marines, which makes fighting on creep extremely crucial. That means that off-creep, banelings can get shot down efficiently. Meanwhile, the zerglings, mutas, and banelings all require a different type of micro. Zerglings are pretty much there to prevent units from running away from banelings, so they are used to surround the terran ground forces. Mutalisks, meanwhile, need to black box before entering the fray to ensure that thors don't 2-3 shot them (and there are almost always thors in a terran composition when the zerg player has mutas). Lastly, banelings should NOT A-move in because that would waste banelings on non-light units. So all in all, you have three groups of units that are trying to surround/prevent retreat, black box, and ensure that banelings only explode in an as ideal as possible location. It is NOT easy to utilize a ling/muta/bling composition well and to bring in the wrong unit at the wrong time is often devastating. For instance, bringing in mutas before blings = mutas get ripped up by marines. If the banelings were not able to destroy enough marines, the zerg player usually already lost because morphing in more banelings requires a lot more time and on certain maps (such as steppes of war), it is impossible to make a second wave of zling/blings/mutas without losing a crucial mining base.
To contribute to the thread, I played against a terran player (at least 1700) who built 3 banshees instead of 2 and did GREAT damage to my economy. I had 4 queens because I anticipated the banshee harass (no add-ons on barrack or factory), but they were separated from my main and my natural expo and thus, had an extremely difficult time fighting the banshees off. This match was on Jungle Basin, which as you might know, is the perfect map for zerg to block helion harass with queens at the front ramp. And since the OP asked for it, I am a 1700 zerg player.
Also, a zerg player who builds early roaches = much delayed or no mutas.That means less emphasis on anti-air! YAY!!!
edit: spelling
|
On October 21 2010 01:54 teamsolid wrote: Until we see more than 1 Z in top 8 of MLG or 1 Z in top 8 of GSL, the OP is really over exaggerating things. Just do exactly what you did prepatch and you should be fine (unless you abused 5 rax reapers, then you deserve to lose).
I'd have to agree with this. Until zerg are ACTUALLY dominating the pro scene in the same way that terran has been, I'm not going to be taking any of these "THE SKY IS FALLING" posts seriously...
|
On October 21 2010 04:44 Endbringer wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 04:21 dave333 wrote: ^That doesn't mean it wasn't imbalanced, it just meant that Zerg needed to play harder to try to match terran even if it meant other deficiencies. 14 gas/pool was standard not because it could be standard, but because it kept zerg safe. Going 14 gas/pool kept zerg behind, but it didn't lose outright like if it went 14 hatch.
The game is certainly closer to being balanced, and that's why it seems that zerg is suddenly very good right now. Imagine fighting people with 1 hand, getting decent at it, then suddenly getting your second hand back. \Sorry to burst some Zerg players bubbles, but you are all not magically more skilled than every T and P because you played Zerg. Heres what I dont understand, and a Zerg can answer my question I have no doubt. Just prior to this patch, why could you not go hatch before pool? 5 rax reaper has been pretty much dead since the balance patch before this one added 5 seconds to the build time. This meant if you lost any reapers with your 5 rax strat you couldn't recover. What exactly was Zerg afraid of if they went hatch before pool? From a non-zerg prospective it seems like the patch was just a mental shift. I don't see how any change suddenly aloud the Zerg to make hatch before pool where they couldn't before. dave's analogy is actually pretty good.
Zerg has been on the back foot and figuring out how to win despite some disadvantages for a while now. Sorry to burst your bubble, but an equal level Z to your T has better game sense, map awareness, unit control, and harassment defense by necessity. Now that Z's tools are more on par with what they should be via the roach range increase, they're having an easier time applying the skills they played hard to develop. They got their second hand back.
By the same token, now T will be forced to learn how to apply harass in difficult situations, learn how to position their units vs. different Z compositions to minimize Z effectiveness + maximize their own damage, implement spellcasters to swing the battle in their favor the way zerg has had to, etc. T will get better at the game now and things will seem "even" again.
|
I wonder how many terrans use a raven to actively destroy creep? Or in the early game instead of sending in hellions (or whatever) to harass, keep them outside the natural to prevent creep from leaving the natural? It seems like this will be a crucial step towards the evolution of terran strats, just as spreading creep is crucial for zerg. Loss of creep means that suddenly sling/bling/muta become much less of a hard counter to a mmm ball.
|
Teamsolid hit the nail right on the head. There is zero supporting evidence and whole lot of anecdotal whining.
If the gsl says anything about balance things are looking pretty good. Same with the newest top 200s.
|
On October 21 2010 04:54 RampancyTW wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 04:44 Endbringer wrote:On October 21 2010 04:21 dave333 wrote: ^That doesn't mean it wasn't imbalanced, it just meant that Zerg needed to play harder to try to match terran even if it meant other deficiencies. 14 gas/pool was standard not because it could be standard, but because it kept zerg safe. Going 14 gas/pool kept zerg behind, but it didn't lose outright like if it went 14 hatch.
The game is certainly closer to being balanced, and that's why it seems that zerg is suddenly very good right now. Imagine fighting people with 1 hand, getting decent at it, then suddenly getting your second hand back. \Sorry to burst some Zerg players bubbles, but you are all not magically more skilled than every T and P because you played Zerg. Heres what I dont understand, and a Zerg can answer my question I have no doubt. Just prior to this patch, why could you not go hatch before pool? 5 rax reaper has been pretty much dead since the balance patch before this one added 5 seconds to the build time. This meant if you lost any reapers with your 5 rax strat you couldn't recover. What exactly was Zerg afraid of if they went hatch before pool? From a non-zerg prospective it seems like the patch was just a mental shift. I don't see how any change suddenly aloud the Zerg to make hatch before pool where they couldn't before. dave's analogy is actually pretty good. Zerg has been on the back foot and figuring out how to win despite some disadvantages for a while now. Sorry to burst your bubble, but an equal level Z to your T has better game sense, map awareness, unit control, and harassment defense by necessity. Now that Z's tools are more on par with what they should be via the roach range increase, they're having an easier time applying the skills they played hard to develop. They got their second hand back. By the same token, now T will be forced to learn how to apply harass in difficult situations, learn how to position their units vs. different Z compositions to minimize Z effectiveness + maximize their own damage, implement spellcasters to swing the battle in their favor the way zerg has had to, etc. T will get better at the game now and things will seem "even" again. No, Zerg does not need a better game sense, better awareness, or better unit control. They do need better harassment defense. I will give you that. Lets go through them one at a time.
Game sense? I am assuming you are talking about keeping track of the large number of openers that a T can do and reacting correctly to them? The problem is all the Zerg needs to actually do is know if a T is going air or ground. If the T is going air, the Zerg will need more queens. If he is going ground speedlings and spinecralwers completly counter all early game Terran pressure. Then you can tech to Muta's and boom, you are doing ok.
Unit control? Zerg needs to make sure your units don't run off creep and commit suicide. This is true. Oh and magic box, you gotta make sure you don't attack with your muta's on any unit but instead move them and hold position. Every other unit is a-move just as much as T. Also, for the record, micro'ing marines away from banelings while also keeping them close enough to the tanks to be able to cover them from mutas and splitting them up so the banes that are rolling towards them dont kill every marine you own is one of the most micro intensive things in all of sc2.
Map awareness? Really, with overlords? I am sorry but come on. You make extra overlords and you put them everywhere, and you expand your creep. Congrats, you see 3x the amount of the map of the other 2 races. Scouting inside opponents bases is hard for zerg. But map awareness? Your damn farm is a vision providing flying scout.
T will get better BO's and openings against Zerg. No doubt that adversity is the mother of innovation. What T will not suddenly do is get more skilled. Z's were not more skilled on average than T's, and T's will not suddenly have to be better players. The skill of the players is spread about the races evenly at just about every level.
|
~1600 diamond terran I don't think many of you are thinking about the TvZ matchup correctly.
First, we must take it as fact that leaving a Zerg alone to drone up and expand is suicide. Zerg's ability to build an economy is completely unmatched by the other two races. This was balanced by the fact that Terrans could very (too) effectively harass, to even up the economy by forcing the Zerg to spend larva on military.
So, it is the Terran's duty to pressure and threaten the Zerg to do damage (obviously), and more importantly, to force him into making as large a military as possible, so he cannot drone up as quickly. I see it as a big balancing act.
Now, the problem is, Zergs can open roaches, and be invulnerable to early harass. This isn't a matter of "reacting properly," this is "I opened roach, so you can't touch my drones unless you enjoy suiciding your units." Properly micro'd queens will stop banshee harass (most zergs will have 3 queens on two bases, one for each base and one to spread creep). Where does this leave Terran?
You can expand yourself and attempt to outmacro a Zerg. Terrible idea. Zergs LOVE it when you leave them alone and macro because in the short term they will saturate their 2nd much faster than you and in the long term they will expand to the whole map and trade armies with you every time you try to move out.
You can try to harass anyway. Hellion/infantry drops are probably going to be the most effective, but against a mobile zerg army on two bases connected with creep, it is very limited in effectiveness. (day9's daily yesterday did a very good job of explaining when and how to drop if you haven't seen it) Of course we have also been seeing hellion/banshee openers lately, which is interesting, but it says something when the terran has to tech to two separate harassing units to have a chance at doing significant damage.
You can attempt a timing push. This is actually probably the best idea at the moment, but there's a good chance that the zerg will see it coming with a spotter zergling/overlord and be ready with spines/more units. However, I personally find the "MAKE BIG ARMY THEN A-MOVE LOL" strategy to be boring and stupid.
On a side note, it's just silly to assume that all Terran players are just plain worse, or that all Zerg players are better, and such assumptions have no place in a strategy discussion.
|
|
|
|
|
|