|
On October 22 2010 06:04 proxY_ wrote: It's so interesting how this has turned around. Like everyone has pointed out, the terran's only real viable option here is to constantly harass and hope that they can keep damaging the zerg before the real macro mechanics kick in. They have to do this in tandem with excellent macro, doing a lot of mule drops and taking a third base relatively early. Now terran is the race that requires lots of apm and almost no mistakes whereas zerg is in the driver's seat now.
Late game as well, zerg has an overwhelming advantage because of larvae stockpile and the speed with which they can tech switch. In a 3+ base scenario with both sides at pop, the zerg can stockpile larvae and res and then do a complete tech switch after their army dies. If the zerg has muta bling and the terran's army is setup to counter that, the zerg can essentially throw away their army and mass produce 10-15 ultras or like 50 roaches and just steamroll (Fruitdealer does it in game 1 of his series vs Top in gsl season 1). It was always been a feature of the race but with it being easier and easier to survive to late game that's coming up more and more.
The race is still pretty hard to play in terms of balancing out econ and military production but once you get a good understanding of that down, it's just so hard for terran to do anything. Protoss still definitely has some options but I don't know. It goes back to the basic game fundamentals being somewhat broken.
this post is rather ignorant.
why would terran require more apm than zerg? regardless of what the terran is doing, reacting to it as zerg will require many more actions...hellion harass, banshee harass, thor/tank drops are all annoying as shit for the zerg and easy for the terran.
and really, when zerg was 'behind' every single zerg out there was trying to strategise to formulate builds against 'op' terran. and they produced many solid builds..
why can't terran do the same? also
The race is still pretty hard to play in terms of balancing out econ and military production but once you get a good understanding of that down, it's just so hard for terran to do anything. Protoss still definitely has some options but I don't know. It goes back to the basic game fundamentals being somewhat broken. read as "If zerg is BETTER THAN TERRAN AT GAME, terran probably won't win."
|
On October 22 2010 05:42 HalfAmazing wrote: The game is horrifically broken in favor of Zerg right now. The problem, as has been pointed out many times before, is that Terran can't harrass Zerg _at all_ anymore and they aren't competitive mid/late game due to poor game design. Terran's only option right now is to hope Zerg droned too hard and they're caught off guard by their timing push (almost impossible to do in the real world). Terran needs some big boosts to their production capabilities mid/late game. Tech reactor (from the campaign), maybe? A serious buff to seeker missile (range/damage) would help as well. i say give us back irradiate
|
On October 22 2010 08:12 Pookie Monster wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2010 05:42 HalfAmazing wrote: The game is horrifically broken in favor of Zerg right now. The problem, as has been pointed out many times before, is that Terran can't harrass Zerg _at all_ anymore and they aren't competitive mid/late game due to poor game design. Terran's only option right now is to hope Zerg droned too hard and they're caught off guard by their timing push (almost impossible to do in the real world). Terran needs some big boosts to their production capabilities mid/late game. Tech reactor (from the campaign), maybe? A serious buff to seeker missile (range/damage) would help as well. i say give us back irradiate
With no scourge that could get pretty dodgy, but there needs to be some way to stop fungal lategame :\
|
On October 22 2010 08:17 Sadist wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2010 08:12 Pookie Monster wrote:On October 22 2010 05:42 HalfAmazing wrote: The game is horrifically broken in favor of Zerg right now. The problem, as has been pointed out many times before, is that Terran can't harrass Zerg _at all_ anymore and they aren't competitive mid/late game due to poor game design. Terran's only option right now is to hope Zerg droned too hard and they're caught off guard by their timing push (almost impossible to do in the real world). Terran needs some big boosts to their production capabilities mid/late game. Tech reactor (from the campaign), maybe? A serious buff to seeker missile (range/damage) would help as well. i say give us back irradiate With no scourge that could get pretty dodgy, but there needs to be some way to stop fungal lategame :\
Try cloaked ghosts?
|
FG already rapes bio as it is, I think blings could use a slight nerf past midgame. Once you get the macro to mass them, any bio play is just bound to be doomed.
|
Cloaked ghosts for fungal? Terran seems to use less gas than zerg could be viable but extremely hard to pull off.
|
On October 22 2010 06:04 proxY_ wrote: It's so interesting how this has turned around. Like everyone has pointed out, the terran's only real viable option here is to constantly harass and hope that they can keep damaging the zerg before the real macro mechanics kick in. They have to do this in tandem with excellent macro, doing a lot of mule drops and taking a third base relatively early. Now terran is the race that requires lots of apm and almost no mistakes whereas zerg is in the driver's seat now.
Late game as well, zerg has an overwhelming advantage because of larvae stockpile and the speed with which they can tech switch. In a 3+ base scenario with both sides at pop, the zerg can stockpile larvae and res and then do a complete tech switch after their army dies. If the zerg has muta bling and the terran's army is setup to counter that, the zerg can essentially throw away their army and mass produce 10-15 ultras or like 50 roaches and just steamroll (Fruitdealer does it in game 1 of his series vs Top in gsl season 1). It was always been a feature of the race but with it being easier and easier to survive to late game that's coming up more and more.
The race is still pretty hard to play in terms of balancing out econ and military production but once you get a good understanding of that down, it's just so hard for terran to do anything. Protoss still definitely has some options but I don't know. It goes back to the basic game fundamentals being somewhat broken.
The only issue is that we don't have early medics thus any early pressure is based on Banshees or hellions. Bashees take to long to tech to and a zerg can just kill you and hellions aren't guaranteed pressure. Thus the on'y guaranteed pressure has to come from infantry like in BW but without tier 1.5 medics we have to wait until tier 3 in order to push which is way to late.
|
On October 22 2010 07:57 mikell wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2010 06:04 proxY_ wrote: It's so interesting how this has turned around. Like everyone has pointed out, the terran's only real viable option here is to constantly harass and hope that they can keep damaging the zerg before the real macro mechanics kick in. They have to do this in tandem with excellent macro, doing a lot of mule drops and taking a third base relatively early. Now terran is the race that requires lots of apm and almost no mistakes whereas zerg is in the driver's seat now.
Late game as well, zerg has an overwhelming advantage because of larvae stockpile and the speed with which they can tech switch. In a 3+ base scenario with both sides at pop, the zerg can stockpile larvae and res and then do a complete tech switch after their army dies. If the zerg has muta bling and the terran's army is setup to counter that, the zerg can essentially throw away their army and mass produce 10-15 ultras or like 50 roaches and just steamroll (Fruitdealer does it in game 1 of his series vs Top in gsl season 1). It was always been a feature of the race but with it being easier and easier to survive to late game that's coming up more and more.
The race is still pretty hard to play in terms of balancing out econ and military production but once you get a good understanding of that down, it's just so hard for terran to do anything. Protoss still definitely has some options but I don't know. It goes back to the basic game fundamentals being somewhat broken. this post is rather ignorant. why would terran require more apm than zerg? regardless of what the terran is doing, reacting to it as zerg will require many more actions...hellion harass, banshee harass, thor/tank drops are all annoying as shit for the zerg and easy for the terran.
The issue is that terran's margin of error in the matchup is gone (before it was too big, if zerg messed up controlling against reapers and let the reaper ball get too big they'd lose and similarly if zerg lost too many drones to hellions or cloak banshee they'd lose). The terran needs to micro the harassment significantly better than the zerg response to it in order to make an impact and they need to macro really well as well. If you don't want to use apm that's fine, we'll say that terran has to micro and macro better.
There are really two differences post-patch. The zerg can afford to always go hatch first as the only thing that terran can threaten now is some reaper bunker play that the zerg can shut down with drones killing the worker building the bunker and queens and lings around by the time the second reaper shows up. Because the zerg can hatch first, they'll have more larvae to play with and their econ will take off faster hence they can afford to absorb some drone losses. The other method of terran harassment, the hellion, is heavily impacted by the roach range increase. It's still possible to make an impact with the hellions but much harder. Cloak banshee also really doesn't seem to threaten zerg that much. Most zerg will be in lair with 3 queens about by the time it comes, assuming they get the timing right and they can shut it down fairly easily. A map like LT is probably still unbalanced in favor of terran because of that stupid cliff but that's a problem with the map and not really the matchup.
Basically, the terran can choose to harass but it's hard for that harass to be effective and if it's not very effective they're very far behind. If the terran chooses to macro up he can't keep up with the zerg and is similarly far behind.
On October 22 2010 07:57 mikell wrote: and really, when zerg was 'behind' every single zerg out there was trying to strategise to formulate builds against 'op' terran. and they produced many solid builds.. why can't terran do the same?
That's what this thread is about......I don't know what you've been reading. The problem is pretty clearly outlined and possible solutions are getting discussed. I don't think we really have a "good" solution yet. Sure zergs talked and debated and produced solid builds against terran but obviously there was still a balance issue and it got patched. Similar scenario here, I'm interested in what the solution is and we really don't seem to have it yet. Maybe it's there, not saying that it's not but we don't know it.
On October 22 2010 07:57 mikell wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2010 06:04 proxY_ wrote:The race is still pretty hard to play in terms of balancing out econ and military production but once you get a good understanding of that down, it's just so hard for terran to do anything. Protoss still definitely has some options but I don't know. It goes back to the basic game fundamentals being somewhat broken. read as "If zerg is BETTER THAN TERRAN AT GAME, terran probably won't win."
.........................
Ok, so where is your solution to macro zerg going muta bling infestor while threatening a mass tech switch to roach or ultralisk in the late game? And please don't say outplay the opponent. Should they harass or not? With what? What should their unit composition be?
So all the terran players that did a mass rax reaper strat and beat zergs were better? Or that wasn't balanced? But this is balanced? What is it.
|
On October 21 2010 09:52 JamesJohansen wrote: Lol and just a couple weeks ago the terrans where declaring the zergs to be whiners and unable to come up with new strategies and that the game was actually more balanced then the stats and players made it out to be.
Listen, I'm platinum and not voice of expertise but it doesnt take a genius to realize that terrans simply had too many advantages against zerg before this patch. There were many all-in builds that were simply un-counterable and zerg still had a hell of a time scouting reliably (and who doesnt love a surprise banshee when your expecting much different?)
The SC2 Terran faction has the most units and mechanics (wrong word?) of the three races and has many options against players. What I'm seeing in this forum is complaints from terrans that bio alone is unable to deal with bio's counter. Guess what, you can build other units and your macro won't go to shit. SC1 featured more units in TvZ then just barracks units. Terrans have a lot of shit to play with and have a bunch of support options.
Having said that, I would like to see some things given slight buffs to be useful. 250mm cannons were buffed (tho not sure its enough) and this might open more doors but some other mechanics I'd like to see buffed (namely HSM)
You've got to be kidding me. Terran had too many advantages? Terran has ALWAYS lost to a zerg mid-late game macro, if the two players are of equal skill level. A zerg can easily out-produce a Terran, thus the whole point of early game harass. Everyone who plays Terran basically knows that going a Bio ball is suicide against a zerg's cost efficient and relatively easy to use infestor baneling or even just baneling attack. Most Terrans go Mech, but the fact that a zerg masses up an army so fast and can simply trade continuously while expanding pretty much defeats this point. As a terran I typically get stuck at 2 bases and have trouble securing or defending a 3rd because of the lack of mobility. Zerg basically has entire map vision through creep spread, and your point about Banshees isn't really that relevant. That's the same thing as saying doesn't a Terran hate it when a Zerg goes Mutas? Obviously. It is by no means though uncounterable. The zerg's economic advantage though, is a much greater factor in my opinion.
|
|
|
United States17042 Posts
This thread has degraded to death, and is now just terrible and won't die.
|
|
|
|
|
|