I still don't really know why blizzard needed to change the gas/mineral mechanics. If they changed this aspect back to BW, it would help terran do FE builds and it would help zerg's army supply issues late game as well.
TvZ post patch, what do you do - Page 27
| Forum Index > Closed |
|
dave333
United States915 Posts
I still don't really know why blizzard needed to change the gas/mineral mechanics. If they changed this aspect back to BW, it would help terran do FE builds and it would help zerg's army supply issues late game as well. | ||
|
MrCon
France29748 Posts
In game two the zerg is 200 food and he is still like at 110 food. The matchup is still broken, but not for the same side. I hope blizz can fix that, but honestly I don't know how. | ||
|
HalfAmazing
Netherlands402 Posts
| ||
|
prototypue
United States20 Posts
On October 22 2010 04:05 kcdc wrote: I'm hearing a lot of complaints that hellion drops don't work because roaches just book it up from the nat to shut down the harass too quickly. People are also complaining that if T expands, Z takes 3+ bases and drones up an impregnable economic advantage. Why not play it like TvP SC:BW where T takes an early expansion, essentially granting the opponent map control to expand as they please, but indirectly holding their econ in check because with each base they take, their defenses are spread thinner against harass (vultures/hellions). 2-base mutas would shut down the drop harass, but you'd be at 2 bases vs 2 bases well into the midgame, and you could develop a nice thor-based timing push to hit as they're trying to saturate their third. This is actually a really good suggestion. Turning it into a multiple base game would definitely make it easier to harass. There are still problems with drops being shut down with mutas, but unless they stick roaches in every base then they can't defend all the harass, leaving them a bit open to a big push on their front door. PF at the expansion might be a good idea at an open expansion in like Xel'naga or Delta, but A. lack of Mules hurts and B. that's 150 gas you're not spending on tech/tech units. And early pressure by Terran that's not hellion/reaper harass is very risky. Speedling surrounds are very effective in small engagements. If the Zerg happens to be prepared for your push, you (unlike Zerg) cannot simply retreat. You get surrounded and die. If you wait and try to mass up, you're on a timer against Mutalisks. Too much time goes by, and Mutas will clean up your push if it has too little marines/harass your base making your push all-in. This means any sort of early push (as opposed to harass) by Terran has to be meticulously calculated and perfectly micro'd. I personally can't do it. This is why Terrans very rarely push out in force before creating a huge deathball that can (hopefully) take on any lightning fast tech push by the Zerg. To be honest, I feel like anyone I have to explain this to hasn't played enough of the match-up on a reasonably high level. | ||
|
drats
5 Posts
| ||
|
MrCon
France29748 Posts
But I guess making a raven/helion guerilla group to take out creep tumors could work. But mutas will say NO I think. It's still a way to explore. | ||
|
HalfAmazing
Netherlands402 Posts
On October 22 2010 05:47 drats wrote: @Half, I'm confused as to what you mean exactly. Do you mean the terran wall doesn't work as well so it's hard for them to get a decent force of reapers/hellions/banshee's for early harass? Yep, among other things. You can wall and tech to whatever you like, but zerg can counter everything you can throw at them without sacrificing economy if they play well. If you get lucky and hurt them early then transition correctly you can win a longer game. The problem with how good roaches are now, is that you can't tech safely anymore due to how easily early roaches can pressure you. If you mess up even slightly, you can lose the game right there. Even if they can't kill you, they can contain you while benefiting from superior macro mechanics. It's very badly designed right now, with one race having default map control, superior (more cost effective) units, and harassment in its favor. This doesn't mean Terran can't win, but you're 100% reliant on zerg screwing up. | ||
|
proxY_
United States1561 Posts
Late game as well, zerg has an overwhelming advantage because of larvae stockpile and the speed with which they can tech switch. In a 3+ base scenario with both sides at pop, the zerg can stockpile larvae and res and then do a complete tech switch after their army dies. If the zerg has muta bling and the terran's army is setup to counter that, the zerg can essentially throw away their army and mass produce 10-15 ultras or like 50 roaches and just steamroll (Fruitdealer does it in game 1 of his series vs Top in gsl season 1). It was always been a feature of the race but with it being easier and easier to survive to late game that's coming up more and more. The race is still pretty hard to play in terms of balancing out econ and military production but once you get a good understanding of that down, it's just so hard for terran to do anything. Protoss still definitely has some options but I don't know. It goes back to the basic game fundamentals being somewhat broken. | ||
|
XXXSmOke
United States1333 Posts
The muta bling and slign are all light units so first of all my ghosts will do extra dmg which is a nice plus. Second of all Snipe is great for stopping muta harass without the need for thors. Third EMP can stop the fungal growth that is raping my marines. I am starting to think that a mixture of MMM+Ghost+Tank+1 thor(to force magic box) could be quite effective in terms of late game. Any other T's think that this might work?? This would all be based on an FE as well since ghosts are so damn pricey. I think cloak could be extremely useful to, forcing the Z to get overseers and bring them into battle which can easily be sniped by the ghosts. Muta bling is already extrmely gas heavy so forcing a few overseers can lower the muta count a bit. | ||
|
Scila
Canada1849 Posts
On October 21 2010 23:26 Jayzo wrote: a problem i havnt seen mentioned here much at the moment is the fact that when you get into mid/late game, a standard T army takes significantly more micro to defeat a P or Z army. protoss with gateway/colossi can fairly well A-move while spamming FF, add HTs and they have to spam "T". zerg armies can also pretty much A-move, especially the baneling heavy/ultra/lings/muta combo that is very common. when a T army engages, you have to be stim microing or you will be destroyed by storm/colossi/banelings. you also may need to either emp or drop a pdd, or both. also you need to be siegeing and unseigeing tanks. for a player of any standard that is not top level, this is challenging. countless times ive been ahead in food/expansions/army pushed forward to be destroyed by baneling/ling/ultra that i had scouted position and composition wise. Its very annoying. does anyone have any thoughts or advice on this matter? Now that you mention it, I decided to finally post some replays where I completely destroy the Toss in economy, and end up barely winning or losing. Please note that the Toss players do not have to micro ANYTHING in a battle; they just a move and pop storms, while the Terran has to try and micro his army to survive. I'm not claiming here that my micro is good, it probably needs a lot of work, but that still doesn't change the fact that Protoss and to a large extent late game zerg as well do not have to micro at all. These are all around the 1500-1600 Diamond mark. PLEASE keep a note of supply size, Income, upgrades, and APM throughout all the replays. This is the first game where the Toss I played teched to HTs very fast. I take over the entire map, and he wipes out my 200/200 eventually 3/3 upgraded army 2-3 times with largely the same units. I barely win by quickly making marines and vikings to counter his carriers. http://www.gamereplays.org/starcraft2/replays.php?game=33&show=details&id=159477 Here's a similar replay of a Protoss holding on with 1 expo versus 3-4 for me. He ended up PUSHING OUT with basically the same army he had the whole game, and I only win by quickly going banshees and getting cloak to snipe his HTs. http://www.gamereplays.org/starcraft2/replays.php?game=33&show=details&id=159479 Finally here's another TvP replay, where once again I completely outecon the Toss player, and actually end up losing. http://www.gamereplays.org/starcraft2/replays.php?game=33&show=details&id=159485 You can go ahead and blame my poor micro or something else for this, but I still find it ridiculous that I have to rebuild my army 3-5 times while the Toss beats me with literally the same units as before, on less bases, and with no upgrades. Why can't I have magical units like the Colosus or the HT while RAPE large amounts of units at the same time? Siege tanks are a joke and way too immobile for SC2, and nothing else compares. This + the macro advantage of Protoss and Zerg really leave no room for Terran to win unless their opponent makes huge mistakes. I've never been an All-in player, and I don't want to be, but at the same time I can't keep up by going mass expand either. edit: apparently I didnt save the TvZ mass thor vs mass roach replay, but I'll try to get some TvZ replays soon. | ||
|
VanGarde
Sweden755 Posts
On October 22 2010 03:02 Thrombozyt wrote: I guess a step in the right direction would be to increase to benefits from upgrades for the terran units. Take the BC nerf for example. Reducing the damage from 10 to 8 was huge, but watching the BC+infantry rushes displayed in the GSL, it seemed justified. But only in that rush situation, the BC was that strong. So why not nerf the damage from 10 to 8, but increase the bonus from weapon upgrades from +1 to +2? Also if you'd allow terrans to upgrade their units up to a level of 5 instead of capping at 3, then the endgame dynamics would change. Terran would be good early in the game, lack later due to economic disadvantage, but they can pull themself together by getting the 'uber' upgrades that make their units cost efficient enough to prevail. This seems very sensible to me. Everyone knows that terran can't keep up with zerg macro all game and I would argue that you can't with protoss macro either but to a lesser extent. So there are to alternatives here. 1) The devs at blizzard are retards and managed to create this design imbalance so deep in the race without even realizing it. 2) The design philosophy is that zerg is SUPPOSED to be the macro race, and terran is supposed to actually operate off lower economy but have a unit synergy that makes up for the disadvantage. I would rather like to think that the latter is the case and Blizzard is more or less thinking that when terran is played correctly, it will be played more like warcraft 3 while zerg is played more like broodwar. Terran armies will have almost every unit in the game, bio-mech with banshee's and ravens. Terran is supposed to stick to very few bases and only expand beyond 2 or 3 when the first one runs out of minerals. I reckon it would be possible to play this way and rely on micro, unit retention and synergy to take down far superior zerg forces. But then terran upgrades actually need to either scale better than zerg's or have more levels. I think this would be a very interesting experiment. | ||
|
kcdc
United States2311 Posts
On October 22 2010 06:19 Scila wrote: Now that you mention it, I decided to finally post some replays where I completely destroy the Toss/ Zerg in economy, and end up barely winning or losing. Please note that the Toss players do not have to micro ANYTHING in a battle; they just a move and pop storms, while the Terran has to try and micro his army to survive. I'm not claiming here that my micro is good, it probably needs a lot of work, but that still doesn't change the fact that Protoss and to a large extent late game zerg as well do not have to micro at all. This is the first game where the Toss I played teched to HTs very fast. I take over the entire map, and he wipes out my 200/200 eventually 3/3 upgraded army 2-3 times with largely the same units. I barely win by quickly making marines and vikings to counter his carriers. http://www.gamereplays.org/starcraft2/replays.php?game=33&show=details&id=159477 Here's a similar replay of a Protoss holding on with 1 expo versus 3-4 for me. He ended up PUSHING OUT with basically the same army he had the whole game, and I only win by quickly going banshees and getting cloak to snipe his HTs. http://www.gamereplays.org/starcraft2/replays.php?game=33&show=details&id=159479 Here's a replay of a pure thor build versus pure roaches, with the roaches STOMPING the thors, even though I had more upgrades as well. This is for all the Zergs complaining about Roaches being weak versus Thor, and qqing about Thors being too powerful in general. Once again, notice how much more I expand than the Zerg and still struggle to win. http://www.gamereplays.org/starcraft2/replays.php?game=33&show=details&id=159484 Finally here's another TvP replay, where once again I completely outecon the Toss player, and actually end up losing. http://www.gamereplays.org/starcraft2/replays.php?game=33&show=details&id=159485 You can go ahead and blame my poor micro or something else for this, but I still find it ridiculous that I have to rebuild my army 3-5 times while the Toss beats me with literally the same units as before, on less bases, and with no upgrades. Why can't I have magical units like the Colosus or the HT while RAPE large amounts of units at the same time? Siege tanks are a joke and way too immobile for SC2, and nothing else compares. I know this isn't a novel thing to say, but seriously, try playing the other races more. You will find that it's not as easy as you think. For one, P doesn't get to just A-move and think about popping storms. While you're alternating between right-clicking and the 'S' button, we have to try to flank so that our zealots don't get caught in a choke, use multiple casters, keep those casters from bunching up for EMPs, independently micro collosi, and try to find time to move our cameras off the battle in order to macro. The last one is the biggest deal honestly. I'm not saying any race is harder than the others to play. I'm just saying that at least TvP is pretty balanced. When you lose in that MU, you were probably outplayed. | ||
|
Veasel
Sweden159 Posts
1 good example where i played a really good match was when i 1. Denied his 14hatch for like 30 secs 2. Killed 1 overlord and then went into his base with drop to harass. he had 2 zergs + queen and just when he saw drop he made 10 zergs in 20 secs. But i still made a little harass 3. Sniping overlord to SB him again! 4. Pushing 3 tanks, 10 rines 2 medics. Got rolled over with 20 zergs and some lets say -7 drones. the thing with all this is that he can just outdrone me and then just switch to making units whenever he sees an attack. T and P gotta keep a good amount of army all the time(spec T) and nothing works anymore. Something that you atleast may pull of is bio -> banshee harras with cloak Tanks + Rines. (wait til 4+ tanks + stim) or some kind of proxy. Exploit that alot now when everyone is 14 hatch lololol. Also 2 vikings is really nice if someone spreads overlord alot. It will help soo much if he cannot produce a shit in 20-20 seconds ![]() GL. I will prob give up this matchup for a while now. If 20 games of trying out thing didnt give me a shit of working tactics and a whole forum like TL havent figured it out its gonna be soo hard. | ||
|
Bull-Demon
United States582 Posts
On October 22 2010 06:34 Veasel wrote: Played aproxx 20-30 games vs my 1600 zerg friend last 3-4 days, and i may have won 1-2. No im not kidding. The matchup is broken and it is mostly because the zerg kan eithe drone up like a real businessman and when he see's timing push from his creep halfway across the map he will just stop droning for 40 seconds, counter this army and then counterattack. 1 good example where i played a really good match was when i 1. Denied his 14hatch for like 30 secs 2. Killed 1 overlord and then went into his base with drop to harass. he had 2 zergs + queen and just when he saw drop he made 10 zergs in 20 secs. But i still made a little harass 3. Sniping overlord to SB him again! 4. Pushing 3 tanks, 10 rines 2 medics. Got rolled over with 20 zergs and some lets say -7 drones. the thing with all this is that he can just outdrone me and then just switch to making units whenever he sees an attack. T and P gotta keep a good amount of army all the time(spec T) and nothing works anymore. Something that you atleast may pull of is bio -> banshee harras with cloak Tanks + Rines. (wait til 4+ tanks + stim) or some kind of proxy. Exploit that alot now when everyone is 14 hatch lololol. Also 2 vikings is really nice if someone spreads overlord alot. It will help soo much if he cannot produce a shit in 20-20 seconds ![]() GL. I will prob give up this matchup for a while now. If 20 games of trying out thing didnt give me a shit of working tactics and a whole forum like TL havent figured it out its gonna be soo hard. Okay look, I know you really really want your anecdotal evidence to mean something but it doesn't. Your friend is obviously better than you. He outplayed you nothing more. | ||
|
Dragar
United Kingdom971 Posts
4. Pushing 3 tanks, 10 rines 2 medics. Got rolled over with 20 zergs and some lets say -7 drones. 3 tanks? 10 marines? 2 medivacs? Loses to 20 zerglings and 7 drones? This isn't anything to do with TvZ balance. | ||
|
ToxNub
Canada805 Posts
1. Statements like "equal skill" terrans with 200 vs 200 will"autolose" are obviously just out to lunch. Several have even made the claim that their units are even less cost effective. This is patently false. Terran units typically reach critical mass and then dominate all else simply because of their superior range, mass rebuild or not. They also tend to have the most dps for the least cost... Some talk about the "drone advantage", which is really hilarious when you consider how much more it costs your average zerg army to take down a 1 basing terran. 2. The same with the "unbeatable" muta/bling/infestor/ling nonsense. Seriously, what a load of shit. 4 out of 7 combat units in the whole zerg arsenal are required to do this (2 of the remainder are tier 3), and terran only has about a half dozen viable compositions that are not only cost effective but also a lot easier to micro. Oh wow, a composition that isn't completely instagibbed by a 1-a terran ball, must need a nerf. The lack of effort even being shown by players to deal with a hard build is really a testament to the level of ego they've built up since beta. How many threads are there from zergs asking about help vs about every terran composition? and how many threads are there about "impossible to beat" zerg compositions. Seriously, some people need a reality check. The answer is probably forthcoming... as people learn new things, and maybe even realize that likely that terrans need to just micro well... which is true for zergs for about every other ZvT composition. 3. +1 range does not make you "100% immune to harass". This statement is laughable. Most terrans just suicided their hellions before and still got their monies worth in drone kills... Range won't affect those scenarios at all. And hellions were able to dance around roaches before, and they can still do it now... You'll have to work harder for it, and you might need an extra hellion, but saying that it is "impossible" is just so fucking stupid on so many levels it makes me sick. There are still lots of viable mid-game harass options that terrans are still barely exploring... Zerg doesn't have ANY harass until mutas, and now that it's around even, that's a problem? Terran sits behind a wall in perfect safety for the first 10 minutes of the game. Only moving out when it's safe... Terran can tech, spam workers, get ready for a big macro push. Whatever the hell he wants. I guess terrans know how everybody else feels now... 4. Give it some fucking time. Patch has been out like a week and people think they've comprehended every detail already. Even if something was imbalanced, you wouldn't have proof for months, when we can actually see some results. Everyone's just making shit up at this point. When the top players are suddenly 40% zerg and 10% terran (the opposite of before) , then we can begin to TENTATIVELY look for imbalance. People are so quick to call imba, without any forethought. Please go back to the Bnet forums.. | ||
|
Scila
Canada1849 Posts
I know this isn't a novel thing to say, but seriously, try playing the other races more. You will find that it's not as easy as you think. For one, P doesn't get to just A-move and think about popping storms. While you're alternating between right-clicking and the 'S' button, we have to try to flank so that our zealots don't get caught in a choke, use multiple casters, keep those casters from bunching up for EMPs, independently micro collosi, and try to find time to move our cameras off the battle in order to macro. The last one is the biggest deal honestly. I'm not saying any race is harder than the others to play. I'm just saying that at least TvP is pretty balanced. When you lose in that MU, you were probably outplayed. Watch the goddamn replays before you make conclusions you troll. I micro my units the entire time while the Toss basically storms me and attacks me with all his ranged bullshit without having to switch positions or move anywhere. | ||
|
Victim
United States188 Posts
On October 22 2010 06:05 XXXSmOke wrote: I think I am going to start experimenting with ghosts in my TvZ's. The muta bling and slign are all light units so first of all my ghosts will do extra dmg which is a nice plus. Second of all Snipe is great for stopping muta harass without the need for thors. Third EMP can stop the fungal growth that is raping my marines. I am starting to think that a mixture of MMM+Ghost+Tank+1 thor(to force magic box) could be quite effective in terms of late game. Any other T's think that this might work?? This would all be based on an FE as well since ghosts are so damn pricey. I think cloak could be extremely useful to, forcing the Z to get overseers and bring them into battle which can easily be sniped by the ghosts. Muta bling is already extrmely gas heavy so forcing a few overseers can lower the muta count a bit. I've tried ghost based play before, and it seems to lose hard to large numbers of banelings (which are not light). Sure, you can force overseer several times to waste zerg gas - of course, banelings can kill ghosts even without detection, and fungal growth can reveal cloaking units. However, ghosts, medivacs, and tanks are also gas heavy units; going ghosts means you have fewer tanks. You can snipe banelings in small numbers, but not lots of them. Thors have lots of HP, so they can tank as well shoot at mutas. It's always a good sign when a bunch of banelings hit Thors instead of marines. Ghosts have comparatively few HP, even if they're aren't light, so they can die very quickly. Their small size also makes them more vulnerable to splash damage as well. Until the zerg gets a large number of mutas, one Thor sitting near your mineral lines can deter a lot of harass because it can repaired if mutas attempt to focus it, and its durability means that it's easy to react in time to repair. Ghosts have less deterrent value, even if Snipe can get you some muta kills, and mutas can potentially target fire them before they can cloak and snipe. Using Ghosts is also energy dependent, so dealing with reinforcing waves is more difficult than with conventional units. Tanks and Thors also kill buildings more quickly than ghosts, so it's more likely that ghost play will end up facing more reinforcements. It's definitely possible to succeed with Ghosts, but it never seemed especially resilient. | ||
|
Phyxate
United States49 Posts
On October 22 2010 07:12 ToxNub wrote: A lot of the terran delusion in this thread really bugs me. You want to talk about how your harass potential is diminished, sure, fine. That was the POINT of the nerf. But the rest of this thread is trash. 1. Statements like "equal skill" terrans with 200 vs 200 will"autolose" are obviously just out to lunch. Several have even made the claim that their units are even less cost effective. This is patently false. Terran units typically reach critical mass and then dominate all else simply because of their superior range, mass rebuild or not. They also tend to have the most dps for the least cost... Some talk about the "drone advantage", which is really hilarious when you consider how much more it costs your average zerg army to take down a 1 basing terran. 2. The same with the "unbeatable" muta/bling/infestor/ling nonsense. Seriously, what a load of shit. 4 out of 7 combat units in the whole zerg arsenal are required to do this (2 of the remainder are tier 3), and terran only has about a half dozen viable compositions that are not only cost effective but also a lot easier to micro. Oh wow, a composition that isn't completely instagibbed by a 1-a terran ball, must need a nerf. The lack of effort even being shown by players to deal with a hard build is really a testament to the level of ego they've built up since beta. How many threads are there from zergs asking about help vs about every terran composition? and how many threads are there about "impossible to beat" zerg compositions. Seriously, some people need a reality check. The answer is probably forthcoming... as people learn new things, and maybe even realize that likely that terrans need to just micro well... which is true for zergs for about every other ZvT composition. 3. +1 range does not make you "100% immune to harass". This statement is laughable. Most terrans just suicided their hellions before and still got their monies worth in drone kills... Range won't affect those scenarios at all. And hellions were able to dance around roaches before, and they can still do it now... You'll have to work harder for it, and you might need an extra hellion, but saying that it is "impossible" is just so fucking stupid on so many levels it makes me sick. There are still lots of viable mid-game harass options that terrans are still barely exploring... Zerg doesn't have ANY harass until mutas, and now that it's around even, that's a problem? Terran sits behind a wall in perfect safety for the first 10 minutes of the game. Only moving out when it's safe... Terran can tech, spam workers, get ready for a big macro push. Whatever the hell he wants. I guess terrans know how everybody else feels now... 4. Give it some fucking time. Patch has been out like a week and people think they've comprehended every detail already. Even if something was imbalanced, you wouldn't have proof for months, when we can actually see some results. Everyone's just making shit up at this point. When the top players are suddenly 40% zerg and 10% terran (the opposite of before) , then we can begin to TENTATIVELY look for imbalance. People are so quick to call imba, without any forethought. Please go back to the Bnet forums.. First off just want to throw out there that most terran players never said zerg wasn't at a disadvantage pre-patch. But terran is at a disadvantage post patch and if you don't think so you are delusional and I will list why. There is a reason that out of 27 pages of talk about this matchup there has only been one interesting strategy post (2 vikings to snipe overlords, not confirmed how good this works). 1. I semi-agree with this, although zergs late game units are obviously stronger I won't really go into detail (you have 27 pages of thread to read if you wish). 2. Please list a counter to ling/bling/infestor/muta as terran? Also, post a replay to back up your opinions while you're at it. You are flat out wrong and once again go through 27 pages of this thread to find out why. 3. Most people aren't saying this but whatever. I guess I agree but terran HAVE to harass you to win. We cannot out macro you. How much clearer can it get that our options to harass are now severely limited and easily countered? If we can't harass you or timing push perfect we cannot win. Period. 4. There is the misconception you have in your head that terran players are worse at micro than zerg players which is basically just lumping all T into one category and is biased as f*ck. TL;DR : There are some very good terrans posting in this thread and until you can give me one viable strategy versus ANY good zerg player you should just stfu as you are not contributing to this thread. When you come up with a counter, then you can post. This thread is for terran/zerg players who want to talk strategy. So far out of 27 pages there has been 1 interesting post about making 2 quick vikings to snipe overlords. If we fast expand you fast expand quicker than us and you are able to shut down harass very, very easily. And yes, I have read all 27 pages. | ||
|
kcdc
United States2311 Posts
On October 22 2010 07:13 Scila wrote: Watch the goddamn replays before you make conclusions you troll. I micro my units the entire time while the Toss basically storms me and attacks me with all his ranged bullshit without having to switch positions or move anywhere. Zzzz....simmer down, Mr. 11 Posts. No reason to curse at strangers over the internet. Seriously, give the other races a real shot and then try talking about what makes X race more difficult than Y race. Each race has different requirements. None of the MU's are so imbalanced that it's impossible to win with superior play. At this point, TvP is the most balanced match-up outside of the mirrors. If you're consistently losing TvP, you're either playing people who are better than you or you need to rethink your strategies. I'm not into flaming wars, so I won't be commenting in this vein again. | ||
| ||
