|
On October 21 2010 06:43 link0 wrote: The zerg army is actually more cost effective than the terran army. If the zerg army is even with the terran army in cost, you'll notice the zerg army almost always wins the confrontation. Blings/roachs/infestors are just notoriously good for cost.
Watch any top T v Z replay and keep the army cost tab open right before a big battle. The zerg army will almost always win unless the Terran army is much more expensive.
This is actually weird because Zerg can expand faster and drone faster than terran as well as spending much less in production buildings.
Terran in 1.12 basically has two options in T v Z:
1. do a very nice one-base all-in and hope the Z didn't prepare the right unit composition or droned up too hard.
2. play a macro game and hope that Z makes some major mistakes in army control.
How about instead of telling everyone to watch "any top zvt replay" and actually post some? Cause I just watched a shit ton of the MLG reps and what you're saying isn't true.
|
On October 21 2010 06:46 Treemonkeys wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 06:43 link0 wrote: The zerg army is actually more cost effective than the terran army. If the zerg army is even with the terran army in cost, you'll notice the zerg army almost always wins the confrontation. Blings/roachs/infestors are just notoriously good for cost.
Watch any top T v Z replay and keep the army cost tab open right before a big battle. The zerg army will almost always win unless the Terran army is much more expensive.
This is actually weird because Zerg can expand faster and drone faster than terran as well as spending much less in production buildings.
Terran in 1.12 basically has two options in T v Z:
1. do a very nice one-base all-in and hope the Z didn't prepare the right unit composition or droned up too hard.
2. play a macro game and hope that Z makes some major mistakes in army control. I'm not even sure if what you are saying is true or not, but doesn't the cost tab lump gas and minerals together? Basically a muta costs the same as a hellion according to it? Doesn't seem like a good comparison.
No actually it lists both the minerals and the gas.
|
On October 21 2010 05:50 Treemonkeys wrote: So basically terrans think they have no chance at a macro game.
I want to see some pro games where it's a TvZ macro game and terran continues to macro instead of pushing out and winning or losing right there, because I don't think they exist at this point in time. Every game that Hopetorture lost he sent his army out to death and then lost because of it.
Zerg may be able to drone up faster, but this does not necessarily mean he can use his drone count to break into terran defenses and win right away. Hopetorture could have possible sat back, built more expos, and built more unit production structures before suiciding his army. Hm, do you really think no one tried? I tried to play with a somewhat safe but very fast expand for a while and the problem has never been making it to midgame.
The problem is that with each expo you need to invest in production buildings as well while Z gets increased production capability with each expo. Further, when spreading yourself thin accross the map, you end up having to invest into turrets.
It's just a downhill proposition from the get go.
|
On October 21 2010 06:31 Lipski wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 06:22 pwadoc wrote: The terrans who are complaining in this thread have a deluded sense of what they should be able to do. I get beaten by terrans when I have a 2:1 macro advantage, and a 40 food advantage. Every zerg has had this experience at one point or another. This should never happen. And yet there are people here complaining about the zerg early expo. Let me lay it out for you: a 2 base terran can beat a 4 base zerg. It's not even hard. I've been beaten by a 2 base terran on 4 bases simply because I slightly miscalculated my unit composition. Terran can overcome overwhelming disadvantages and still manage to win. I just played a game where I busted the terran front, killed a bunch of scvs and expanded to 4 bases, and got destroyed by a banshee/thor/marine push. The terran player didn't even micro, and I had a large muta/roach/infestor army. replay or it didnt happen. either this is below-diamond replay, where players have a lot of bad habits that it does not even matter what units you are making as long as you have a solid build order, or you droned too hard, and your actual army size, excuding drones, was smaller than terran player's.
I posted a replay of this happened several days ago. You can search for it you want. The replies I got were basically "yep, that's how it goes". And yes, I'm plat, but who cares? One race should not be fundamentally more powerful than the others at any level of play. I make mistakes, everyone makes mistakes at my level of play. When I make a mistake, I lose the game. When my terran opponent makes a mistake he drops a few super harvesters and recoups. It's destroying the fucking game.
|
On October 21 2010 06:43 OPSavioR wrote:
Have you ever heard of repair? Blings is the only cost effective counter to marines. Or do you want me to rush Infestor?
I don't think Z need to rush for infestor to win. They can get infestor after the third base and still be ok. About repairing I always bring some scv with me into battles but tbh they blow up pretty quickly either because of bling or the bounce attack from mutas.
The next step for me to try is to mass turret at home, bring even more scv to battle with a heavy thors army. I am still looking for some good TvZ where T beat mutaling bling infestors so if anybody in the thread come across such replays please post it here. I appreciate it.
I don't have access to all VOD of GSL 2 but I just watched game 1 between Gilja and JookToJung and it looks pretty sad. The bling hasn't come out and he already lost.
|
On October 21 2010 06:52 pwadoc wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 06:31 Lipski wrote:On October 21 2010 06:22 pwadoc wrote: The terrans who are complaining in this thread have a deluded sense of what they should be able to do. I get beaten by terrans when I have a 2:1 macro advantage, and a 40 food advantage. Every zerg has had this experience at one point or another. This should never happen. And yet there are people here complaining about the zerg early expo. Let me lay it out for you: a 2 base terran can beat a 4 base zerg. It's not even hard. I've been beaten by a 2 base terran on 4 bases simply because I slightly miscalculated my unit composition. Terran can overcome overwhelming disadvantages and still manage to win. I just played a game where I busted the terran front, killed a bunch of scvs and expanded to 4 bases, and got destroyed by a banshee/thor/marine push. The terran player didn't even micro, and I had a large muta/roach/infestor army. replay or it didnt happen. either this is below-diamond replay, where players have a lot of bad habits that it does not even matter what units you are making as long as you have a solid build order, or you droned too hard, and your actual army size, excuding drones, was smaller than terran player's. I posted a replay of this happened several days ago. You can search for it you want. The replies I got were basically "yep, that's how it goes". And yes, I'm plat, but who cares? One race should not be fundamentally more powerful than the others at any level of play. I make mistakes, everyone makes mistakes at my level of play. When I make a mistake, I lose the game. When my terran opponent makes a mistake he drops a few super harvesters and recoups. It's destroying the fucking game.
I watched your replay. First off your 4th base was up for about 45 seconds the entire game, you remade it twice. I am not going to harp on your mistakes because everyone makes mistakes. I understand that, and you said you were plat. Mules had absolutely nothing to do with why you lost. You took forever to saturate your expo's, I don't think the third was ever fully saturated. Just because you have 3 bases doesn't suddenly mean you are making more money then the guy on 1 or 2. You have to have the workers to make that up.
As for the battle, if you had just made ultras instead of your lings as your army died the last time you would have killed his army of leftovers without losing a single Ultra. Then you would have been waaaay ahead since he was depending on a bio mech comp that was thor heavy, There is no way he would have gotten the thor numbers he needed to counter you. You would have had complete map control and you could have actually held that gold you were trying to expo to. He wasnt fundamentally more powerful than you. You just reacted poorly to what he was doing. What mistakes did your opponent make exactly? He handled your roach bust pretty well. Then he built up a large army and rolled down to your base and killed you.
|
On October 21 2010 06:52 pwadoc wrote:
And yes, I'm plat, but who cares?
I do. I don't want to offend you, but you can't talk about balance when you are on that level. A terran on 2 base defeating a 4 base zerg is something I want to see in a replay. It's only possible when the zerg doesn't drone enough.
I want to quote myself again:
Can I ask to not post if you are under 1200 diamond points
|
Just watch it tonight on GOMTV. Terrans have been pretty sad against zerg and toss so far. Every now and then an all in win would get them to a 3rd game. I only watch the events fro 9-12, can't stay up for the later matches. next match is 5 hours 41 minutes.
http://www.gomtv.net/2010gslopens2/live/
|
On October 21 2010 07:14 Endbringer wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 06:52 pwadoc wrote:On October 21 2010 06:31 Lipski wrote:On October 21 2010 06:22 pwadoc wrote: The terrans who are complaining in this thread have a deluded sense of what they should be able to do. I get beaten by terrans when I have a 2:1 macro advantage, and a 40 food advantage. Every zerg has had this experience at one point or another. This should never happen. And yet there are people here complaining about the zerg early expo. Let me lay it out for you: a 2 base terran can beat a 4 base zerg. It's not even hard. I've been beaten by a 2 base terran on 4 bases simply because I slightly miscalculated my unit composition. Terran can overcome overwhelming disadvantages and still manage to win. I just played a game where I busted the terran front, killed a bunch of scvs and expanded to 4 bases, and got destroyed by a banshee/thor/marine push. The terran player didn't even micro, and I had a large muta/roach/infestor army. replay or it didnt happen. either this is below-diamond replay, where players have a lot of bad habits that it does not even matter what units you are making as long as you have a solid build order, or you droned too hard, and your actual army size, excuding drones, was smaller than terran player's. I posted a replay of this happened several days ago. You can search for it you want. The replies I got were basically "yep, that's how it goes". And yes, I'm plat, but who cares? One race should not be fundamentally more powerful than the others at any level of play. I make mistakes, everyone makes mistakes at my level of play. When I make a mistake, I lose the game. When my terran opponent makes a mistake he drops a few super harvesters and recoups. It's destroying the fucking game. I watched your replay. First off your 4th base was up for about 45 seconds the entire game, you remade it twice. I am not going to harp on your mistakes because everyone makes mistakes. I understand that, and you said you were plat. Mules had absolutely nothing to do with why you lost. You took forever to saturate your expo's, I don't think the third was ever fully saturated. Just because you have 3 bases doesn't suddenly mean you are making more money then the guy on 1 or 2. You have to have the workers to make that up. As for the battle, if you had just made ultras instead of your lings as your army died the last time you would have killed his army of leftovers without losing a single Ultra. Then you would have been waaaay ahead since he was depending on a bio mech comp that was thor heavy, There is no way he would have gotten the thor numbers he needed to counter you. You would have had complete map control and you could have actually held that gold you were trying to expo to. He wasnt fundamentally more powerful than you. You just reacted poorly to what he was doing. What mistakes did your opponent make exactly? He handled your roach bust pretty well. Then he built up a large army and rolled down to your base and killed you.
My opponent stayed on two bases, built up an army, and then marched it toward me. That in itself is a mistake. If you look at my income tab, my economy was far far stronger than his the entire game. I was teching to ultras when he attacked. If I were a perfect player, maybe I would already have teched to ultras, but I did get 2/2 upgrades and a larger army.
The fact that terran can play the game at my level in that way is broken. Why should I have to do any more than the terran does to have at least an equal chance at winning? What you're saying is that I have to have more bases, better upgrades, and a higher tech level just to break even? How is that at all fair?
edit: I was a 1150 pt diamond zerg for a while.
|
On October 21 2010 06:51 eloist wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 05:50 Treemonkeys wrote: So basically terrans think they have no chance at a macro game.
I want to see some pro games where it's a TvZ macro game and terran continues to macro instead of pushing out and winning or losing right there, because I don't think they exist at this point in time. Every game that Hopetorture lost he sent his army out to death and then lost because of it.
Zerg may be able to drone up faster, but this does not necessarily mean he can use his drone count to break into terran defenses and win right away. Hopetorture could have possible sat back, built more expos, and built more unit production structures before suiciding his army. Hm, do you really think no one tried? I tried to play with a somewhat safe but very fast expand for a while and the problem has never been making it to midgame. The problem is that with each expo you need to invest in production buildings as well while Z gets increased production capability with each expo. Further, when spreading yourself thin accross the map, you end up having to invest into turrets. It's just a downhill proposition from the get go.
Doesn't seem like you are considering how difficult it is for zerg to crack terran defenses even while having higher production.
Do I think no one tried? I'm sure some have, but not extensively considering terrans have been winning with single 200/200 armies since release, they haven't had a reason to try.
|
1500+ zerg/terran
I like ZvT because most terrans have no idea what to do if you survive there early harass. They seem to just mass up and push blindly.
Things that a terran can do to win
-I dont like these Barrack wallins at all but just putting up a bunker to threaten early expansion harass is an amazing thing, watch idra have to pull 6 drones of his line to take it down at MLG and the guy just cancels it losing maybe 25 minerals and idra loses about 6 drones mining for 6 minutes. You have to make the zerg fight for his expansion. -Thors 50mm Cannon vs ultras is amazing, stun plus damage. -prevent Zerg Scouting!! A zerg cannot STOP a timing push if he does not see it coming. Hellions on xelnagas and around the map are amazing. -Place Marines around your base early so when he sacks and overlord for scouting you can cut it off immediately, dont leave all your units right at the ramp so when he puts up a ling there he can scout your army. -Taking ScVs with your army, in most games zerg is going to throw 1 army at you and lose it all then resupply back up instantly so you need to repair your damaged units and leapfrog towards his base.
Anyways scouting for a zerg is amazing if a zerg knows what your doing hes at a huge advantage, control of the xelnaga towers I think will become huge factors in ZvT. If the zerg scouts an expand he is going to drone up and expand again himself. If he scouts a push next round of larvae are going to be Counter Units if he doesn't scout it you can take out his army easily and do alot of damage.
I also like feigning pressure because it will force units.
|
On October 21 2010 07:23 pwadoc wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 07:14 Endbringer wrote:On October 21 2010 06:52 pwadoc wrote:On October 21 2010 06:31 Lipski wrote:On October 21 2010 06:22 pwadoc wrote: The terrans who are complaining in this thread have a deluded sense of what they should be able to do. I get beaten by terrans when I have a 2:1 macro advantage, and a 40 food advantage. Every zerg has had this experience at one point or another. This should never happen. And yet there are people here complaining about the zerg early expo. Let me lay it out for you: a 2 base terran can beat a 4 base zerg. It's not even hard. I've been beaten by a 2 base terran on 4 bases simply because I slightly miscalculated my unit composition. Terran can overcome overwhelming disadvantages and still manage to win. I just played a game where I busted the terran front, killed a bunch of scvs and expanded to 4 bases, and got destroyed by a banshee/thor/marine push. The terran player didn't even micro, and I had a large muta/roach/infestor army. replay or it didnt happen. either this is below-diamond replay, where players have a lot of bad habits that it does not even matter what units you are making as long as you have a solid build order, or you droned too hard, and your actual army size, excuding drones, was smaller than terran player's. I posted a replay of this happened several days ago. You can search for it you want. The replies I got were basically "yep, that's how it goes". And yes, I'm plat, but who cares? One race should not be fundamentally more powerful than the others at any level of play. I make mistakes, everyone makes mistakes at my level of play. When I make a mistake, I lose the game. When my terran opponent makes a mistake he drops a few super harvesters and recoups. It's destroying the fucking game. I watched your replay. First off your 4th base was up for about 45 seconds the entire game, you remade it twice. I am not going to harp on your mistakes because everyone makes mistakes. I understand that, and you said you were plat. Mules had absolutely nothing to do with why you lost. You took forever to saturate your expo's, I don't think the third was ever fully saturated. Just because you have 3 bases doesn't suddenly mean you are making more money then the guy on 1 or 2. You have to have the workers to make that up. As for the battle, if you had just made ultras instead of your lings as your army died the last time you would have killed his army of leftovers without losing a single Ultra. Then you would have been waaaay ahead since he was depending on a bio mech comp that was thor heavy, There is no way he would have gotten the thor numbers he needed to counter you. You would have had complete map control and you could have actually held that gold you were trying to expo to. He wasnt fundamentally more powerful than you. You just reacted poorly to what he was doing. What mistakes did your opponent make exactly? He handled your roach bust pretty well. Then he built up a large army and rolled down to your base and killed you. My opponent stayed on two bases, built up an army, and then marched it toward me. That in itself is a mistake. If you look at my income tab, my economy was far far stronger than his the entire game. I was teching to ultras when he attacked. If I were a perfect player, maybe I would already have teched to ultras, but I did get 2/2 upgrades and a larger army. The fact that terran can play the game at my level in that way is broken. Why should I have to do any more than the terran does to have at least an equal chance at winning? What you're saying is that I have to have more bases, better upgrades, and a higher tech level just to break even? How is that at all fair? edit: I was a 1150 pt diamond zerg for a while.
Your tech was done when he hit you. I timed it, if you would have started spawning ultra's the second your army evaporated instead of the lings the ultras would have popped just as he was starting to hit your naturals hatch. Feel free to time it out yourself. Your opponent was actually on just one base most of the time. Since he didn't transfer scv's until his main was mined out. Even with that you were making 400 more minerals than him at your highest. You also had over 1k banked. You could have expo'd at every expansion on the map while he was standing at his natural.Your apm numbers were close, you had map control but didn't use it. He had a better army comp than you. Your skill level was about the same, and he didn't make any mistakes and you did. You committed to much to that roach push and you payed for it when he countered with those hellions. He was playing his race at the same level as you were playing yours. You made a mistake and lost. Why is that not fair?
You were not taking advantage of your races strengths and he was. Terran can one base longer than Zerg due to mules. He did that. Zerg can react to unit comp's with fast tech switches, you kind of did that but not well. Zerg can also gain map control and then expand everywhere, you didnt do that. So you lost and he won. Nothing unfair, just a game to learn from.
EDIT: To the guy above me. Thor's 250mm cannon barely out DPS's a Thor's auto attack with +2 and nothing stuns ultras. Using it also stuns the Thor for like 4-5 seconds. There is a reason you don't see people get it very often, its terrible almost all the time. Hellions at the xel-naga's are great. So is delaying an expo with a random building. Unfortunately that delay is very slight and the advantage is quickly erased. Those hellions on the xel'nagas? Those last until the second the first muta pops, which is when Terran's lose all vision of the map and have to turtle while the Zerg gets to drone up.
|
On October 21 2010 07:32 Lowkin wrote: 1500+ zerg/terran
-Thors 50mm Cannon vs ultras is amazing, stun plus damage.
stopped reading there
DPS is almost the same and furthermore Ultra is immune to stun more like 1500+ silver league
|
On October 21 2010 07:29 Treemonkeys wrote: Doesn't seem like you are considering how difficult it is for zerg to crack terran defenses even while having higher production.
Do I think no one tried? I'm sure some have, but not extensively considering terrans have been winning with single 200/200 armies since release, they haven't had a reason to try. Don't even try to crack terran defenses as zerg. Just don't. Wait for the terran to come out. He will eventually.
If a Zerg player has higher production, what he needs to do is deny expansions for his opponent. If, eventually, the zerg is on like 6 bases, and the terran is on 2, and the terran is STILL turtling...well then have at it. Try to nydus in, or build an assload of overlords to tank for a doom drop. And when he fends it off, create your whole army again in three seconds. =D
I'm not saying the Zerg macro mechanic is overpowered. It's one of Zerg's primary strengths, and it needs to be. I'm just saying that Terran needs an effective way to harass to keep Zerg in check. Or even better, two or three ways to harass that can be fended off with a good reaction, not just blind roaches and queens.
|
On October 21 2010 07:36 Elvin wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 07:32 Lowkin wrote: 1500+ zerg/terran
-Thors 50mm Cannon vs ultras is amazing, stun plus damage.
stopped reading there DPS is almost the same and furthermore Ultra is immune to stun more like 1500+ silver league
Is the 250mm not a set damage? cause ultras usually have a alot of armour so the 270 dmg vs 300 I dont think is true. Also just did a unit test, thor vs ultra with +2 armour and +1 to ground, CC thor wins the other thor I had on Auto lost, CC thor survived with half HP. Test it yourself and tell me Thor autoattack is better.
|
On October 21 2010 07:32 Endbringer wrote: Your tech was done when he hit you. I timed it, if you would have started spawning ultra's the second your army evaporated instead of the lings the ultras would have popped just as he was starting to hit your naturals hatch. Feel free to time it out yourself. Your opponent was actually on just one base most of the time. Since he didn't transfer scv's until his main was mined out. Even with that you were making 400 more minerals than him at your highest. You also had over 1k banked. You could have expo'd at every expansion on the map while he was standing at his natural.Your apm numbers were close, you had map control but didn't use it. He had a better army comp than you. Your skill level was about the same, and he didn't make any mistakes and you did. You committed to much to that roach push and you payed for it when he countered with those hellions. He was playing his race at the same level as you were playing yours. You made a mistake and lost. Why is that not fair?
You were not taking advantage of your races strengths and he was. Terran can one base longer than Zerg due to mules. He did that. Zerg can react to unit comp's with fast tech switches, you kind of did that but not well. Zerg can also gain map control and then expand everywhere, you didnt do that. So you lost and he won. Nothing unfair, just a game to learn from.
This is the terran bias at work right here. Even though I managed to find the time and money to beat him on upgrades, expansions and army size, we're even because he "played his race at the same level". The fact is that the reason we are playing our races at the same level even though my mechanics are better, is that his race is less demanding of those mechanics. If I were up against a terran player with the same grasp of mechanics that I have, who expanded and upgraded aggressively, I wouldn't even have had a chance.
|
On October 21 2010 07:15 Dente wrote:I do. I don't want to offend you, but you can't talk about balance when you are on that level. A terran on 2 base defeating a 4 base zerg is something I want to see in a replay. It's only possible when the zerg doesn't drone enough. I want to quote myself again:
I don't have much to contribute here right now except to say you are pretty simple minded and ignorant if you think a rating completely nullifies someone's opinion. Somebody who is intelligent doesn't need to be that skilled to contribute to a discussion, someone who is above 1200 diamond might be terrible and someone skilled doesn't necessarily care about ladders. There are far too many variables to consider, so just listen to people's arguments instead of caring about their ratings.
Example: I am TERRIBLE at this game and I got to 1200 diamond through toss and terran matches. I have always lost almost every zerg match.
|
On October 21 2010 07:47 Lowkin wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 07:36 Elvin wrote:On October 21 2010 07:32 Lowkin wrote: 1500+ zerg/terran
-Thors 50mm Cannon vs ultras is amazing, stun plus damage.
stopped reading there DPS is almost the same and furthermore Ultra is immune to stun more like 1500+ silver league Is the 250mm not a set damage? cause ultras usually have a alot of armour so the 270 dmg vs 300 I dont think is true.
"a lot of armor" = 6 with max upgrades
Thors hit for 30(+3)x2 every 1.28 seconds
2 weapon ups vs 3 armor + ultra up = 30x2 dmg every 1.28 seconds
Armor upgrades are basically worthless vs Thors.
|
On October 21 2010 08:00 Jermstuddog wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 07:47 Lowkin wrote:On October 21 2010 07:36 Elvin wrote:On October 21 2010 07:32 Lowkin wrote: 1500+ zerg/terran
-Thors 50mm Cannon vs ultras is amazing, stun plus damage.
stopped reading there DPS is almost the same and furthermore Ultra is immune to stun more like 1500+ silver league Is the 250mm not a set damage? cause ultras usually have a alot of armour so the 270 dmg vs 300 I dont think is true. "a lot of armor" = 6 with max upgrades Thors hit for 30(+3)x2 every 1.28 seconds 2 weapon ups vs 3 armor + ultra up = 30x2 dmg every 1.28 seconds Armor upgrades are basically worthless vs Thors.
Interesting. I just re-read the thor 250mm its actually 500dmg over 6 seconds so 500 vs 281 is a big difference also in unit testing thor that goes 1v1 against ultra without it loses everytime but the thor that does the cannon wins with 50% hp clearly its not as shitty as people seem to make out.
I have lost to it when I had 1-1 ultra count and enough banes and infestors to deal with his bio.
Also testing more numbers, Ultras win every fight even when im autoattacking them and focus fireing with the thors, only time thors win is when they use the 250mm 1 at a time and focus fire then 250mm the next one and focus fire.
I think thats sufficient to show the effectiveness of the 250mm vs Ultras.
Also in the test gave the ultras +2 armour bonus and the +1 ground because in most ZvT matches ultras will have those upgraded, thors are on base stats.
|
arguing about how something is op/up in plat level is worthless. I am ~1500 dia and IMO it is also worthless to analyze my games regarding balance.
You either need to more or less all in economically in midgame to be able to overwhelm maxed T army or to have good infestor micro. On lower levels not many people can use infestors correctly (I really suck with them too) and as such the MU is pretty tricky.
|
|
|
|
|
|