|
I tried some unortodox style vs one friend (myself 1950 T), he was 1770, basically what i tried is going for reactor-starport dual viking style, i waited for 4 vikings and then went into his base, 2-shotting OLs, with this its so damn easy to destroy a LOT of OLs and THe point of this is to prevent zerg from building sizeable army, u basically try to destroy all OLs and BY THAT TIME u make 3 rax-2 tech add on 1 reactor mass bio and u keep trying to destroy his OLs, once he manages to make enough queens/spore shi.t u stop producing vikings and in that time u hit him with ur bio army....i tried it only once since i was rly confused about TvZ after patch and this looked quite fine, with some tweaking i think it could be quite cool opening...basically vikings rape OLs and the key here is to get zerg into red population zerg will have to invest 100 for earch OL, waste larvae and dont produce any unit...
HERE IS WHAT I MEANT: [url blocked] check that out tell me what u think...at the end of game (like last 3 minutes) i stopped playing because i already won and i chatted with him about the game and how UNORTODOX play can surprise zerg who goes FE! i would really never try it versus zerg who goes later Hatch...it would be insta dead, it has only potential when the zerg goes FE(which is like 95% of games now)
|
On October 21 2010 02:42 teamsolid wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 02:07 Endbringer wrote: Using the past GSL results to strengthen your argument is just showing you did not actually read the OP. He is talking about what Terran can do in the New patch. The last GSL was with the old patch. As for MLG, how many good Zergs do we have in the US? 2, 3 + Idra? Hardly a valid sample. Until we see high Z representation in the NEXT GSL/MLG/IEM there's nothing to say. No one has proof that the matchup is actually broken in one way or the other. Also, poor use of the word sample, since that is the entire population of high level Z in the US which in itself is an issue, but is not really worth discussing. Terrans have already had like 8 weeks where they won over 60-70% of tournaments (which is hard empirical evidence that there were balance issues). It's about time something changed. http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=152533http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=160713Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 02:37 BabelFish wrote:On October 21 2010 01:54 teamsolid wrote: Until we see more than 1 Z in top 8 of MLG or 1 Z in top 8 of GSL, the OP is really over exaggerating things. Just do exactly what you did prepatch and you should be fine (unless you abused 5 rax reapers, then you deserve to lose). Unless I'm missing very recent games, so far in the GSL round of 64 only one terran has won a series vs a zerg. TvZ in the GSL is 3-2 so far in favor of Z, which doesn't say much at all.
I believe that their are more than 2-3 good zergs in all of the NA ladder. Therefore 2-3 is a sample of the total population of good Zergs (a number greater than 2-3). Therefore the word sample was used perfectly. You can argue with the dataset I am using, but the terminology was correct.
Yes T's did win a ton of tournaments, that does show that their are balance issues. Are people arguing that their weren't? The question is if this patch changed too much and instead of balancing the match, it instead flipped the roles. I am hoping you don't think that Zerg should be imbalanced in this matchup as some sort of revenge against past balance issues? Personally I want a game thats balanced for all matchups, not one that flips every two months like some sort of wow clone.
Is Z > T this patch? I don't know, but I do know that atm there does not seem to be any stable Terran strat that works against a half way decent Zerg. Thats what this post is supposed to be about...
|
On October 21 2010 02:56 Endbringer wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 02:42 teamsolid wrote:On October 21 2010 02:07 Endbringer wrote: Using the past GSL results to strengthen your argument is just showing you did not actually read the OP. He is talking about what Terran can do in the New patch. The last GSL was with the old patch. As for MLG, how many good Zergs do we have in the US? 2, 3 + Idra? Hardly a valid sample. Until we see high Z representation in the NEXT GSL/MLG/IEM there's nothing to say. No one has proof that the matchup is actually broken in one way or the other. Also, poor use of the word sample, since that is the entire population of high level Z in the US which in itself is an issue, but is not really worth discussing. Terrans have already had like 8 weeks where they won over 60-70% of tournaments (which is hard empirical evidence that there were balance issues). It's about time something changed. http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=152533http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=160713On October 21 2010 02:37 BabelFish wrote:On October 21 2010 01:54 teamsolid wrote: Until we see more than 1 Z in top 8 of MLG or 1 Z in top 8 of GSL, the OP is really over exaggerating things. Just do exactly what you did prepatch and you should be fine (unless you abused 5 rax reapers, then you deserve to lose). Unless I'm missing very recent games, so far in the GSL round of 64 only one terran has won a series vs a zerg. TvZ in the GSL is 3-2 so far in favor of Z, which doesn't say much at all. I believe that their are more than 2-3 good zergs in all of the NA ladder. Therefore 2-3 is a sample of the total population of good Zergs (a number greater than 2-3). Therefore the word sample was used perfectly. You can argue with the dataset I am using, but the terminology was correct. Yes T's did win a ton of tournaments, that does show that their are balance issues. Are people arguing that their weren't? The question is if this patch changed too much and instead of balancing the match, it instead flipped the roles. I am hoping you don't think that Zerg should be imbalanced in this matchup as some sort of revenge against past balance issues? Personally I want a game thats balanced for all matchups, not one that flips every two months like some sort of wow clone. Is Z > T this patch? I don't know, but I do know that atm there does not seem to be any stable Terran strat that works against a half way decent Zerg. Thats what this post is supposed to be about... No, it's that no one has seen evidence that they TvZ is actually imbalanced either way yet. Until we see it, whining is unjustified.
|
There has been evidence, listen to any interview with high level players about the patch changes. Hell, listen to the Zerg uber whiner himself, Idra discuss TvZ post patch. No there has not been any empirical evidence of an imbalance yet.
Was this a whine post in the op? The title is TvZ, "what do you do?" Sounds like a post to get ideas from T's about strats to fight against Zerg post patch. There have been posts from high level Terrans in this thread whining for sure. Thats just showing how completely clueless good Terrans are for how to beat Zergs with this patch. The sad fact is, even with the giant braintrust TL is for mid-high level SC players, no one has come with any half way decent strat.
|
its because all zerg has to do is camp camp camp camp camp and they win and with all the terran nerfs its logical no good player finds a strat. Terran sux past t1 and now with t1 nerfed zerg is freewin vs terran its as simple as that.
|
On October 21 2010 02:57 teamsolid wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 02:56 Endbringer wrote:On October 21 2010 02:42 teamsolid wrote:On October 21 2010 02:07 Endbringer wrote: Using the past GSL results to strengthen your argument is just showing you did not actually read the OP. He is talking about what Terran can do in the New patch. The last GSL was with the old patch. As for MLG, how many good Zergs do we have in the US? 2, 3 + Idra? Hardly a valid sample. Until we see high Z representation in the NEXT GSL/MLG/IEM there's nothing to say. No one has proof that the matchup is actually broken in one way or the other. Also, poor use of the word sample, since that is the entire population of high level Z in the US which in itself is an issue, but is not really worth discussing. Terrans have already had like 8 weeks where they won over 60-70% of tournaments (which is hard empirical evidence that there were balance issues). It's about time something changed. http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=152533http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=160713On October 21 2010 02:37 BabelFish wrote:On October 21 2010 01:54 teamsolid wrote: Until we see more than 1 Z in top 8 of MLG or 1 Z in top 8 of GSL, the OP is really over exaggerating things. Just do exactly what you did prepatch and you should be fine (unless you abused 5 rax reapers, then you deserve to lose). Unless I'm missing very recent games, so far in the GSL round of 64 only one terran has won a series vs a zerg. TvZ in the GSL is 3-2 so far in favor of Z, which doesn't say much at all. I believe that their are more than 2-3 good zergs in all of the NA ladder. Therefore 2-3 is a sample of the total population of good Zergs (a number greater than 2-3). Therefore the word sample was used perfectly. You can argue with the dataset I am using, but the terminology was correct. Yes T's did win a ton of tournaments, that does show that their are balance issues. Are people arguing that their weren't? The question is if this patch changed too much and instead of balancing the match, it instead flipped the roles. I am hoping you don't think that Zerg should be imbalanced in this matchup as some sort of revenge against past balance issues? Personally I want a game thats balanced for all matchups, not one that flips every two months like some sort of wow clone. Is Z > T this patch? I don't know, but I do know that atm there does not seem to be any stable Terran strat that works against a half way decent Zerg. Thats what this post is supposed to be about... No, it's that no one has seen evidence that they TvZ is actually imbalanced either way yet. Until we see it, whining is unjustified.
Name 1 strat that is like he said even halfway of working for T vs Z atm.
Helions sucks Banshee works as harass but as said before even a decent diamond zerg will destroy this kind of fast Bio? Dosnt exist bling ling bling, mutas come to clean up. DEAD Thors? Well zerg will see it coming 60 seconds before it hit his base and.. mass lings +blings Vikings? Maybe as harass but it cannot win you the game and it is soo costeffective against mutas
(i agree it wasnt balanced before patch either but this is overkill and it just have flipped sides)
Tell me if i missed something -.-
|
On October 21 2010 03:03 Endbringer wrote: There has been evidence, listen to any interview with high level players about the patch changes. Hell, listen to the Zerg uber whiner himself, Idra discuss TvZ post patch. No there has not been any empirical evidence of an imbalance yet.
Was this a whine post in the op? The title is TvZ, "what do you do?" Sounds like a post to get ideas from T's about strats to fight against Zerg post patch. There have been posts from high level Terrans in this thread whining for sure. Thats just showing how completely clueless good Terrans are for how to beat Zergs with this patch. The sad fact is, even with the giant braintrust TL is for mid-high level SC players, no one has come with any half way decent strat. OP quoting a whine post saying that it backs him up, means his intent was obviously to whine and to open a thread for other Terrans to whine. As far as I remember, threads like these were closed down unless they had very strong and well supported arguments, like the ones by Lalush and MasterAsia.
Also Terrans are really clueless? Then how was QXC actually close to beating Idra in a Bo3 and PainUser able to elminate Ret from MLG 2-0, etc, etc. No one has been able to come up with a magical formula that beats Zerg, because what was working before STILL works.
|
On October 21 2010 03:13 teamsolid wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 03:03 Endbringer wrote: There has been evidence, listen to any interview with high level players about the patch changes. Hell, listen to the Zerg uber whiner himself, Idra discuss TvZ post patch. No there has not been any empirical evidence of an imbalance yet.
Was this a whine post in the op? The title is TvZ, "what do you do?" Sounds like a post to get ideas from T's about strats to fight against Zerg post patch. There have been posts from high level Terrans in this thread whining for sure. Thats just showing how completely clueless good Terrans are for how to beat Zergs with this patch. The sad fact is, even with the giant braintrust TL is for mid-high level SC players, no one has come with any half way decent strat. OP quoting a whine post saying that it backs him up, means his intent was obviously to whine and to open a thread for other Terrans to whine. As far as I remember, threads like these were closed down unless they had very strong and well supported arguments, like the ones by Lalush and MasterAsia. Also Terrans are really clueless? Then how was QXC actually close to beating Idra in a Bo3 and PainUser able to elminate Ret from MLG 2-0, etc, etc. No one has been able to come up with a magical formula that beats Zerg, because what was working before STILL works.
ret is still no top of the top zerg yet, he still needs to make up quite some missed practice time compared to the other pros. and qxc wasnt close to beating idra in mlg. he won one game by using hsm as a suprise tactic. the next game he tried it again and got crushed.
|
On October 21 2010 03:13 teamsolid wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 03:03 Endbringer wrote: There has been evidence, listen to any interview with high level players about the patch changes. Hell, listen to the Zerg uber whiner himself, Idra discuss TvZ post patch. No there has not been any empirical evidence of an imbalance yet.
Was this a whine post in the op? The title is TvZ, "what do you do?" Sounds like a post to get ideas from T's about strats to fight against Zerg post patch. There have been posts from high level Terrans in this thread whining for sure. Thats just showing how completely clueless good Terrans are for how to beat Zergs with this patch. The sad fact is, even with the giant braintrust TL is for mid-high level SC players, no one has come with any half way decent strat. OP quoting a whine post saying that it backs him up, means his intent was obviously to whine and to open a thread for other Terrans to whine. As far as I remember, threads like these were closed down unless they had very strong and well supported arguments, like the ones by Lalush and MasterAsia. Also Terrans are really clueless? Then how was QXC actually close to beating Idra in a Bo3 and PainUser able to elminate Ret from MLG 2-0, etc, etc. No one has been able to come up with a magical formula that beats Zerg, because what was working before STILL works.
I wonder what arguments you will use after GSL 2 gets win by Zerg once again, as well as next MLG etc... Because this will happen folks, have no doubt about that.
|
The problem is 1 rax FE is nothing like it was in BW, it takes FOREVER to get saturated and if you spend any scans at all instead of mules you get the feeling of being dead broke immediately. Im not exactly sure why 1 rax FE feels so different(maybe its simply because of the mining rate, or because you need to have 6 scvs on double gas, or you need to tech all the way to starport to get medics, or it takes forever to get stim ........-_-) I dont know. But it definately seems to suck like everyone has already stated and its quite easy to get ran the fuck over.
|
On October 21 2010 03:19 Black Gun wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 03:13 teamsolid wrote:On October 21 2010 03:03 Endbringer wrote: There has been evidence, listen to any interview with high level players about the patch changes. Hell, listen to the Zerg uber whiner himself, Idra discuss TvZ post patch. No there has not been any empirical evidence of an imbalance yet.
Was this a whine post in the op? The title is TvZ, "what do you do?" Sounds like a post to get ideas from T's about strats to fight against Zerg post patch. There have been posts from high level Terrans in this thread whining for sure. Thats just showing how completely clueless good Terrans are for how to beat Zergs with this patch. The sad fact is, even with the giant braintrust TL is for mid-high level SC players, no one has come with any half way decent strat. OP quoting a whine post saying that it backs him up, means his intent was obviously to whine and to open a thread for other Terrans to whine. As far as I remember, threads like these were closed down unless they had very strong and well supported arguments, like the ones by Lalush and MasterAsia. Also Terrans are really clueless? Then how was QXC actually close to beating Idra in a Bo3 and PainUser able to elminate Ret from MLG 2-0, etc, etc. No one has been able to come up with a magical formula that beats Zerg, because what was working before STILL works. ret is still no top of the top zerg yet, he still needs to make up quite some missed practice time compared to the other pros. and qxc wasnt close to beating idra in mlg. he won one game by using hsm as a suprise tactic. the next game he tried it again and got crushed. I would hardly classify that game as "crushed", even Idra himself said he thought that was a close game where he might've lost that battle in the center but just went for it anyways. That's besides the point, which is that TvZ strategy-wise hasn't changed all that much and that the better player will still win in a Bo3.
|
He is quoting that post because that is a top level Terran who posted on his thread. Thats not evidence of some secret plot by the op to derail his own thread.
Yes all Terrans are clueless. Zerg users are sooo much smarter than every single Terran user. Brilliant thinking there. If what worked before still worked than we wouldn't be looking for a magical formula. If what Terrans did before still worked than the matchup would still be imbalanced in favor of Terran wouldn't it? Thats all I have heard from Zergs since like half way through the beta.
Obviously what Terrans did before isn't working. Thats why Terrans need threads in the strategy forum to brainstorm idea's for a decent stable strat to use against Zerg. I am sure tons of Terrans would want a magic formula to win every ZvT, but many would just like something thats stable. A decent strat that isnt a guaranteed loss if your opponent does not make a mistake. Thats what we have right now with the old strats. Since you cannot harras a Zerg drone line effectively with Hellions that means the Zerg can out drone you and out macro you. The longer the game is dragged out the better the Zerg is. Even 2 patches ago Zerg won against a late game Terran. It was the early game harassment and mid game all-in timing pushes that beat Zergs so often.
Prior to this patch you had 2 ways to really put the hurt on the Zerg economy so that you could go into the mid and late game with enough of an advantage that you could win. Those were hellions and drops.
Hellions have become vastly less effective with this patch due to the roach range increase. Sure you were not killing roaches before the patch with hellions, but you could at least get some drones and get out. Now you lose the hellions, making it not cost effeciant.
The double nerfs to the drop ship have made drops a much riskier proposition. They still work, but you have a greater chance of losing the units you are dropping in the ship. In addition the Zerg and Protoss buildings all got stronger, this makes the drops you do get off less effective. You need more units in the drops to do the same amount of damage and they are at greater risk.
What you did before as TvZ does not work the same way. Thats what the point of this thread should be, what can T's do now. Lets get some ideas, discuss them, and hopefully something useful will emerge.
|
And let me just add, Zerg may be a bit harder to mirco up, (spread creep and OL + quenns) but in fights there is completly mixed. zerg goes like "ahh i rush my lings+mutas+blings in.
Think of the shitloud amount of thing terrans need to do, ahh shit stim! siege! Move from blings! Thor target mutas!
|
On October 21 2010 03:31 Endbringer wrote: Obviously what Terrans did before isn't working. Unproven statement, which is at the root of this thread. It's "weaker" and "riskier" than before, but does not mean it isn't working. Yes, you have to work harder to earn your wins, but you have no proof that the Z doesn't have to work equally as hard.
Just because the whine post came from a top Terran doesn't mean it wasn't a whine post.
|
On October 20 2010 03:08 SpaceYeti wrote:@OP: I'm a little confused. Is the point of your post that there's no Terran harass/aggression strategy that doesn't fail if the Zerg player is prepared for it? This has always been the case. The only difference now is that the number of different and disparate options available in the very early game has been constrained since 5rax reapers is no longer viable. Yeah, banshees, hellions, and early bio or bio/mech pushes with fail if the Zerg player is prepared...but that's always been true. If it wasn't then that'd mean there's a TvZ uncounterable tactic and that would be fucking absurd. There are a lot of posts, including some by progamers, that complain about certain builds not working if they get scouted. ... Perhaps the problem isn't with the matchup but with the tendency to rely on builds that hinge so singly on surprise. Consider this article.
In order to harass you need a bit of surprise though and thats part of the core issue. Terran has no units like Mutas in bw at all which even if you know they are coming are going to do considerable damage if controlled properly (and by considerable i mean at the very least keeping you in your base unless you went 1 rax exp -> 3-4 rax before gas)
|
I tend to agree with this thread. I think Bugs were powerful before the patches, but rarely used appropriately. Fruit Dealer may have been using exceptional play, but it does prove that Zerg was not as underpowered as many tended to believe. Since the patch It will be very difficult to make it out of bronze now as a Terran. Before the patches I think my biggest problem was not using all of the hot keys. As I watch the new GSL tournament I haven't really seen any good strategies against Zerg, especially late game. I keep crossing my fingers that there is just some under utilized unit in Terrans arsenal that will solve what I feel may be a lack of balance. Terran now seems only good against Terran, but especially weak against Zerg. Although I have not watched every event, the only matches I have sceen Terran win vs P or Z is when the opponent messed up on the other side.
When a zerg lays down their FE, they are pretty much doubling their production capabilities as well as potential income. As a Terran we need to build several facilities to keep up our production up and then build the command center to be able to use them by this time zerg will always be at LEAST one base ahead, and still capable of quickly changing army composition. Building also requires use of SCV's so structures are easily stopped by taking out an scv, while toss and zerg simply have to defend the incoming structures.
Another thing I am noticing as Terran is how bad it hurts to not have effective Air units that are capable of attacking both ground and air at the same time. Once again, we have to build twice as many units to have an air-air/ground army, and that takes time that we don't have as terrans. Even BC's were nerfed. Every T2+ unit Terran Unit Plus terran has can be kited by other races. Our detection and base defense structures are also lacking compared to toss and zerg, observers for toss, and zerg can basically turn overlords into very effective detectors and have them all over the map, but Terrans Ravens seem to be far too expensive for the glass bubbles they are. Perhaps Banshees and Ghosts would do better if cloak were not so amazing easy to counter for zerg and toss. Not to mention detection by spreading creep. Terrans can build bunkers that house marines for ground defensive structures, but they are very expensive and take up supply resources as well. I even find it difficult against zerg when using hard counters but maybe thats because I'm not high level. Thors to counter Mutas are too slow and can be kited, and mutas magic boxed, then zerg counters the Thors with something else, vikings suck against mutas but now also against toss as well since the phoenix is so fast and can shoot while retreating. I just can't think of any really great counters for mutas, other than auto turrets which are completely impractical as a true counters. Sure we can build rines, but they are fragile vs fungal growth and most other units by the time mutas are out.
I tried playing Zerg and it was kind of fun, great practice for my weakness with hotkeys. I fairly certain that for me the solution is going to be to switch to Zerg or Toss or to simply stop investing my time in SC2 (but I like the game). Then I won't have to worry about stopping toss from Proxy/ Building 4 gate in my base on blistering sands either, since I have not been able to counter this yet as terran (only came close once by rushing PF). I think anyone that truely believes Terran sucks now should just change to playing one of the other races.
|
On October 21 2010 03:35 teamsolid wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 03:31 Endbringer wrote: Obviously what Terrans did before isn't working. Unproven statement, which is at the root of this thread. It's "weaker" and "riskier" than before, but does not mean it isn't working. Yes, you have to work harder to earn your wins, but you have no proof that the Z doesn't have to work equally as hard. Just because the whine post came from a top Terran doesn't mean it wasn't a whine post.
Maybe I should have used better terminology there. You are right, what Terrans can still do all kinds of openers. Terrans could still pull of a 5 rax reaper push into expo. Its super risky and super weak, but it could work. What I should have said was "the strats and openings Terrans used before are now not stable". Any half way decent player does not base his normal play around strats that are risky. You want a strat that will be solid no matter what the opponent is doing. I don't give a shit how hard the opponent has to work to get the wins. It could be 2 buttons for him, or 50000 apm. I could care less, I don't give two shits about imbalanced whining. I want a decent strat, I dont care if its harder to pull off than massing banelings and 1a'ing. I don't have any control over balance issues, and I am confident that my micro is better than my opponents anyway.
For example: In TvP I use iEchoic's 3-1-2 with hellion drop. Even if the Protoss counters the hellion drop, then goes for a counter to my entire strat I have a framework to work from. I haven't already lost the game.
This is not true in TvZ. Zerg starts with the strategic advantage. From the first second of the game all Zerg has to do is survive. The longer the Zerg survives the lower the chances are that the Terran can win. This means the onus to attack and do damage is on the Terran. The longer he delays or waits the greater the difference in macro becomes and the lower his chances of winning are.
|
Im 1500 Terran, i try to do some type of 4 rax push then expo with 1 or 2 tech labs depending on if they went roaches, otherwise i go 1 lab and pump marauders and marines and get stim, keep marauders in front to absorb the banelings and micro the marines somtimes not stimming the marauders is effective so they absorb more hits. Hope this helps
|
On October 21 2010 03:46 Endbringer wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2010 03:35 teamsolid wrote:On October 21 2010 03:31 Endbringer wrote: Obviously what Terrans did before isn't working. Unproven statement, which is at the root of this thread. It's "weaker" and "riskier" than before, but does not mean it isn't working. Yes, you have to work harder to earn your wins, but you have no proof that the Z doesn't have to work equally as hard. Just because the whine post came from a top Terran doesn't mean it wasn't a whine post. This is not true in TvZ. Zerg starts with the strategic advantage. From the first second of the game all Zerg has to do is survive. The longer the Zerg survives the lower the chances are that the Terran can win. This means the onus to attack and do damage is on the Terran. The longer he delays or waits the greater the difference in macro becomes and the lower his chances of winning are. This was true in BW as well. Guess what, the matchup was still balanced despite this dynamic (even slightly Terran favored historically ~53%). It's just how the matchup works.
|
Except that in BW there was no larva inject. Therefore this imbalance was less pronounced. It was there for sure, but it was not as pronounced as it is now. Having 2 queens injecting larva is like having what, 2 extra hatcheries with your 1st expo? This means you have even less time to waste before doing damage. The Zerg is climbing ahead at a much faster rate than in BW.
|
|
|
|
|
|