|
The inflated sense of self worth of the Z players in this thread has reached the critical level. They somehow think that because their race has been UP in the EARLY game vs. Terran they have acquired higher skill and now that TvZ is "balanced" their skill is showing.
It has been the case for some time now that when it gets to mid-late game the combo of mutaling bling and infestor is so deadly that it is very hard for T to win a battle. No amount of micro can save you because speedling and bling w speed is really fast and if Z hit 1 or 2 good fungal growth the battle is really onesided. Bling take out marines, and mutas just go to town with the rest.
The imba of early TvZ has somewhat been fixed which makes the advantage Z has in midlate game shows even more obvious. I agree with the changes to make Z can defend hellions and reapers because longer game is more entertaining. The roach is not the problem; the problem is that when Z is not harassed Z is too strong for T to handle later.
I am just a mediocre diamond T with 1000 on the ladder and have never been good at harassing the opponent but against Z I am forced to do so to even have a chance. People said "don't rely on harass based strat, learn to play a macro game" You think I don't want that? I would much rather macro than having to do all these harass to slow the Z down.
Again all of this talk is about the strat of mutaling bling and infestor. Somebody posted replay of Dimaga vs Sjow on page 10 where Dimaga built roach, ling infestor to ultra and Sjow took him out with tanks thors and hellions. Dimaga would have owned Sjow so hard if he use mutas so I don't think those replays show how to play TvZ.
|
On October 17 2010 23:51 Baguette wrote: Maruaders still rape everything Zerg has except Lings and Hydras. Instead of making 10 Thors and A-moving in the Zerg's base, you actually have to scout and try hard now. How amazing is that?
User was warned for this post
Marauders aren't very good against Mutas Blords or Corrupters either. So they're good against 3 (Roaches, Blings, Queens) zerg units of all the Zerg units... Smart 1 guy...
|
Again all of this talk is about the strat of mutaling bling and infestor. Somebody posted replay of Dimaga vs Sjow on page 10 where Dimaga built roach, ling infestor to ultra and Sjow took him out with tanks thors and hellions. Dimaga would have owned Sjow so hard if he use mutas so I don't think those replays show how to play TvZ.
Sorry, but Im not buying this.. Can you write somethnig more then just " Dimaga would have owned Sjow so hard if he use mutas"? Because I just cant see this happening. The Roach contain for example on Delta Quadrant was pretty sick. Also, did you see how many Thors Sjow had by the time of his push? Its not like its problem to build 2-3 Missile Turrets for each expo or add a bunch of Marines.. You say, magic box? Oh come on, that was working for people when they were thinking that 1-2 Thors shut down all Mutas any time. But if you have 4-5 Thors?
|
Well i must agree there is a huge problem in TvZ, I can't seem to find decent builds/counters and basically the only way to win is if the Z screws up.
HSM were nerfed in beta already IIRC. They used to annihilate clumped up zerg armies, which is not possible anymore.
I have been trying to adjust my standard build vs zerg to play off 2 bases before pushing (previously i would do a more standard 1-base push then expand)with a fairly fast expand after harass, but with harass being so ineffective, it's not fast enough, the zerg will just outmacro me and win the game even if he loses the first battle. Not because he's the better player, but because he can build more drones in the same time. CCs should get the dual scv production upgrade to balance it (it's in the campaign), this is how bad it has become.
|
HSM will never save TvZ until they get more movement speed. The fact that you can simply move away from them because they're incredibly slow makes it irrelevant how much damage they do. Controlling space with it is worthless because the zerg army is more mobile and can always force a fight somewhere they don't need to defend (like outside your base).
The only reason HSM ever hits targets is because nobody expects it to be used because it's so bad and doesn't prepare to move away from it. If you ever got a reputation for using HSM, it would never work again. It's pure cheese.
|
On October 20 2010 04:06 Everlong wrote:Show nested quote + Again all of this talk is about the strat of mutaling bling and infestor. Somebody posted replay of Dimaga vs Sjow on page 10 where Dimaga built roach, ling infestor to ultra and Sjow took him out with tanks thors and hellions. Dimaga would have owned Sjow so hard if he use mutas so I don't think those replays show how to play TvZ.
Sorry, but Im not buying this.. Can you write somethnig more then just " Dimaga would have owned Sjow so hard if he use mutas"? Because I just cant see this happening. The Roach contain for example on Delta Quadrant was pretty sick. Also, did you see how many Thors Sjow had by the time of his push? Its not like its problem to build 2-3 Missile Turrets for each expo or add a bunch of Marines.. You say, magic box? Oh come on, that was working for people when they were thinking that 1-2 Thors shut down all Mutas any time. But if you have 4-5 Thors?
Well I mean if Dimaga has committed to mutaling bling from the beginning NOT as a transition from the roach opening that he used. He would fly them in and out of the base to harass and keep Sjow in base. With Dimaga's nice timing by the time the sprire finishes he would have had 6 or 8 mutas making. With that many he can take out any lone turret to attack either SP or tech lab or even mineral line. The game would have played out similarly to Apple vs. PhoenixWerra earlier. Even though Phoenix is obviously a much better player than Apple I think that game is an example of the strat I am talking about. A third is hard to take and Z can just outmass T from there. I think we will see more example of this in the GSL. I am really not here to whine. I am reading this thread to learn and just point out the problems that T are having.
|
Well I mean if Dimaga has committed to mutaling bling from the beginning NOT as a transition from the roach opening that he used. He would fly them in and out of the base to harass and keep Sjow in base. With Dimaga's nice timing by the time the sprire finishes he would have had 6 or 8 mutas making. With that many he can take out any lone turret to attack either SP or tech lab or even mineral line. The game would have played out similarly to Apple vs. PhoenixWerra earlier. Even though Phoenix is obviously a much better player than Apple I think that game is an example of the strat I am talking about. A third is hard to take and Z can just outmass T from there. I think we will see more example of this in the GSL. I am really not here to whine. I am reading this thread to learn and just point out the problems that T are having.
Well I agree with you that TvZ is way harder now without any early pressure. But rewatch the replay and tell me at what time would Dimaga catch Sjow with mutas and there was not a single Thor somewhere near. And besides that, Sjow was horribly outmacroed whole the game anyway, so.. Mutas are great tool for containing opponent, but not in this case. When you go mech, you stay in your base for a while and then its just the opponent army, that is weaker because of how Mutas are expensive. But lets see in GSL and next few tournaments, how things will end up.
edit: And btw - since Mutaling/Bling Infestor is so scary, popular and deadly, I would dare to go anything but mech anyways.
|
|
|
I hope this doesn't seem unhelpful, but it seems to me like you're using the "he can stop anything I can do if he does the right thing" arguement. This is what is known as balance. I cant tell if you are asking for help because you don't know what you can do that the zerg can't defend against (there's nothing that they are helpless against now) or because you don't know what can work for you (still everything).
You make it sound like 1.1.2 completely changed the shape of the TvZ matchup, when in reality, you can't 6 rax reaper anymore and you cant get immediate speed up for reapers. Again, I am not judging you as a player, but there is a lot more to the matchup than just reapers.
Try scouting a little more and playing a reactionary game. If he has infestors, stop going bio. If he's massing roaches, siege tanks are great. Make a few vikings to see what he is building and to snipe Overlords.
|
i never understood why terrans make more then a handful of marines against me as zerg. this is the worst thing u can possibly do as i can instantly decimate the whole lot of them. try something else. if marines/thors are your only anti air, and marines are living on borrowed time, then of course once their dead then you are toast also.
i think it comes down to scouting. if you're going to blindly make units you THINK will counter mine, but i have scouted and know what you have, then i will stop production of what you are countering and make something else. ive started opening with ling/muta, getting some map control and harass. then i expand once or twice and stockpile larva. when i see what the terran is doing then i commit to units.
its hilarious when terrans fail with their first push. and then try again with the same unit composition a few minutes later, only to get crushed, and then they do it again at which point i have brood lords and the game is over. its like theyre saying, 'but, but... it worked last week so well!'
|
I've been using 1rax reaper FE with some success, since hellion openings kinda suck ass with the roach buff.
|
On October 20 2010 04:52 bobcat wrote: I hope this doesn't seem unhelpful, but it seems to me like you're using the "he can stop anything I can do if he does the right thing" arguement. This is what is known as balance. I cant tell if you are asking for help because you don't know what you can do that the zerg can't defend against (there's nothing that they are helpless against now) or because you don't know what can work for you (still everything).
You make it sound like 1.1.2 completely changed the shape of the TvZ matchup, when in reality, you can't 6 rax reaper anymore and you cant get immediate speed up for reapers. Again, I am not judging you as a player, but there is a lot more to the matchup than just reapers.
Try scouting a little more and playing a reactionary game. If he has infestors, stop going bio. If he's massing roaches, siege tanks are great. Make a few vikings to see what he is building and to snipe Overlords.
I was more using the "terrans need to early harass or they die but thanks to this patch harass is VERY hard (close to impossible) to do"- argument.
About the dimage vs sjow game: dimage never dropped. One single drop would change the whole game. While the terran is defending his bases the zerg can expand x5.
|
I say this with complete humility because I am not very good at terran, but shouldn't terrans be looking for ways to fast expand instead of trying to rely heavily harass after it has been nerfed? Even if the T expo is a little after the zerg expo, it is very uncomfortable for zerg to be on equal bases as a terran, and mules allow the T to catch up quickly. This will force him to go for a 3rd (or lose) which you can then try to shut down after getting a better army and economy.
Just remember that in the early days zerg felt like they HAD to fast expand but at the same time it seemed like it was very easy to get destroyed in the early game. Never the less good zerg players found ways to fast expand and survive and now it is really paying off, I think that terran might be in a similar situation.
|
On October 20 2010 05:01 Vaporized wrote: i never understood why terrans make more then a handful of marines against me as zerg. this is the worst thing u can possibly do as i can instantly decimate the whole lot of them. try something else. if marines/thors are your only anti air, and marines are living on borrowed time, then of course once their dead then you are toast also.
i think it comes down to scouting. if you're going to blindly make units you THINK will counter mine, but i have scouted and know what you have, then i will stop production of what you are countering and make something else. ive started opening with ling/muta, getting some map control and harass. then i expand once or twice and stockpile larva. when i see what the terran is doing then i commit to units.
its hilarious when terrans fail with their first push. and then try again with the same unit composition a few minutes later, only to get crushed, and then they do it again at which point i have brood lords and the game is over. its like theyre saying, 'but, but... it worked last week so well!'
What is this "something else" you are talking about? You don't make marines your mineral line get killed and you make them bling kill you. Excuse me if I can't change unit composition as fast as you since if I want to go mech I need to add more factories not just build 1 building. Thor in small number get killed by mutas. Massing thors and go pure mech? I think Z only need to make more bling smash into the thors to kill 1 or 2 then mutas clean up the rest of the thors and rape whatever is left since there are not marines. If there are marines? They will die first just as you said in your post.
I would love to try something else like you said. Unfortunately we are playing a game and are limited by what the game allows us to do. I really can't wait for some pro in the GSL show us how to beat mutaling bling infestors.
|
On October 20 2010 04:52 bobcat wrote: Try scouting a little more and playing a reactionary game. If he has infestors, stop going bio.
You don't get how Terran works. You can't just "stop going bio". Am I going to invest in 4-5 raxes with addons (we're looking at over 1000 resources in production facilities) and then once he starts getting infestors I'm just going to stop using them? The cost to build one barracks with a tech lab is 150 for the rax, 50/25 for the tech lab, and ~60 minerals in mining time lost by the building SCV. We're looking at 260/25 per production facility, and more for a reactored rax. You can't just stop using them without being at a severe disadvantage.
The races are not meant to be the same. Terran cannot be a purely reactionary race because their production facilities are the most expensive, even moreso than protoss (when counting worker build time + addon cost). Zerg is designed as the reactionary race because they do not need to produce production facilities beyond the first and their macro, when left untouched, is far above the other two races.
However, 1.1.2 forced Terran into being a reactionary race against Zerg. This makes no sense in context with the way the races are designed.
On October 20 2010 05:13 Treemonkeys wrote: I say this with complete humility because I am not very good at terran, but shouldn't terrans be looking for ways to fast expand instead of trying to rely heavily harass after it has been nerfed?
1rax FE works a lot of the time on ladder because the zerg player doesn't know your strategy and most likely sucks at scouting. If you have a zerg practice partner, try 1 rax FEing on him 2-3 times in a row. If he's smart at all he'll just learn to quick expo, put down 2 spine crawlers and inject up to 60 drones by time you have 35 SCVs.
There's a hard counter to Terran FE builds as Zerg, which makes it not viable as a standard opening. You're never going to win a Bo3 1rax FEing against a zerg with a brain.
|
On October 20 2010 05:15 positron. wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 05:01 Vaporized wrote: i never understood why terrans make more then a handful of marines against me as zerg. this is the worst thing u can possibly do as i can instantly decimate the whole lot of them. try something else. if marines/thors are your only anti air, and marines are living on borrowed time, then of course once their dead then you are toast also.
i think it comes down to scouting. if you're going to blindly make units you THINK will counter mine, but i have scouted and know what you have, then i will stop production of what you are countering and make something else. ive started opening with ling/muta, getting some map control and harass. then i expand once or twice and stockpile larva. when i see what the terran is doing then i commit to units.
its hilarious when terrans fail with their first push. and then try again with the same unit composition a few minutes later, only to get crushed, and then they do it again at which point i have brood lords and the game is over. its like theyre saying, 'but, but... it worked last week so well!'
What is this "something else" you are talking about? You don't make marines your mineral line get killed and you make them bling kill you. Excuse me if I can't change unit composition as fast as you since if I want to go mech I need to add more factories not just build 1 building. Thor in small number get killed by mutas. Massing thors and go pure mech? I think Z only need to make more bling smash into the thors to kill 1 or 2 then mutas clean up the rest of the thors and rape whatever is left since there are not marines. If there are marines? They will die first just as you said in your post. I would love to try something else like you said. Unfortunately we are playing a game and are limited by what the game allows us to do. I really can't wait for some pro in the GSL show us how to beat mutaling bling infestors.
A turret or two per mineral line can shut down early muta harass and then you might be able to apply pressure to keep him from massing mutas. I don't think blings are even cost effective against thors.
|
My mindset is to build up a timing push the second I confirm early expand. Just because you can't harass within the first 6 minutes anymore doesn't mean the army disparity goes away. I'd say, terran can punish a greedy zerg within the first 10 minutes. Do a standard build otherwise.
Here's what I do usually vs muta/ling/bling: supply(scout)->rax->confirm early expo->gas->factory->gas->armory(hellion hereabouts)->factory->hellion poke to scout zerg unit comp, bring back->double thor crank out->CC->rax-> thor/mm/scv push
The above isn't linear timing. A lot is done in conjunction as money becomes available. Change up for tanks vs roaches
|
On October 20 2010 04:06 Everlong wrote:Show nested quote + Again all of this talk is about the strat of mutaling bling and infestor. Somebody posted replay of Dimaga vs Sjow on page 10 where Dimaga built roach, ling infestor to ultra and Sjow took him out with tanks thors and hellions. Dimaga would have owned Sjow so hard if he use mutas so I don't think those replays show how to play TvZ.
Sorry, but Im not buying this.. Can you write somethnig more then just " Dimaga would have owned Sjow so hard if he use mutas"? Because I just cant see this happening. The Roach contain for example on Delta Quadrant was pretty sick. Also, did you see how many Thors Sjow had by the time of his push? Its not like its problem to build 2-3 Missile Turrets for each expo or add a bunch of Marines.. You say, magic box? Oh come on, that was working for people when they were thinking that 1-2 Thors shut down all Mutas any time. But if you have 4-5 Thors?
Actually I was under the impression that the Magic Box becomes more effective the larger the battle is. It's only when more marines get involved that it has problems. But against large numbers of Thors I thought it still worked...
As to "How do I harass zerg when he's able to stop harassment"... I'm sorry you're not automatically allowed to give us a disadvantage before the midgame. You're going to have to learn how to play with an evenly matched midgame zerg now. Shocking, I know.
Obviously the strategy is strong. We get air control quickly and maintain throughout the game. Maybe you should try Vikings supported with marines. I don't know.
However, 1.1.2 forced Terran into being a reactionary race against Zerg. This makes no sense in context with the way the races are designed.
This is complete hyperbole.
|
On October 20 2010 05:18 iEchoic wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 04:52 bobcat wrote: Try scouting a little more and playing a reactionary game. If he has infestors, stop going bio. If he's massing roaches, siege tanks are great. Make a few vikings to see what he is building and to snipe Overlords. You don't get how Terran works. You can't just "stop going bio". Am I going to invest in 4-5 raxes with addons (we're looking at over 1000 resources in production facilities) and then once he starts getting infestors I'm just going to stop using them? The cost to build one barracks with a tech lab is 150 for the rax, 50/25 for the tech lab, and ~60 minerals in mining time lost by the building SCV. We're looking at 225/25 per production facility, and more for a reactored rax. The races are not meant to be the same. Terran cannot be a purely reactionary race because their production facilities are the most expensive, even moreso than protoss (when counting worker build time + addon cost). Zerg is designed as the reactionary race because they do not need to produce production facilities beyond the first and their macro, when left untouched, is far above the other two races. However, 1.1.2 forced Terran into being a reactionary race against Zerg. This makes no sense in context with the way the races are designed. Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 05:13 Treemonkeys wrote: I say this with complete humility because I am not very good at terran, but shouldn't terrans be looking for ways to fast expand instead of trying to rely heavily harass after it has been nerfed? 1rax FE works at lower levels on ladder because the zerg player doesn't know your strategy and most likely sucks at scouting. If you have a zerg practice partner, try 1 rax FEing on him 2-3 times in a row. If he's smart at all he's just quick expo, put down 2 spine crawlers and inject up to 60 drones by time you have 35. There's a hard counter to Terran FE builds as Zerg, which makes it not viable as a standard opening.
Expos + mules make the mineral cost of raxes negligable, it also makes the Z drone count negligible to some degree - after all there is a reason Z has needed 2+ bases vs. 1 base T all this time. I don't think it is unfeasible for terran to do big tech switches in the mid and late game. I don't think the addons should even count as they are interchangeable. Why not have an assortment of tech labs and reactors and then swap out raxes, factories, and star ports as needed?
|
On October 20 2010 05:24 DoubleReed wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 04:06 Everlong wrote: Again all of this talk is about the strat of mutaling bling and infestor. Somebody posted replay of Dimaga vs Sjow on page 10 where Dimaga built roach, ling infestor to ultra and Sjow took him out with tanks thors and hellions. Dimaga would have owned Sjow so hard if he use mutas so I don't think those replays show how to play TvZ.
Sorry, but Im not buying this.. Can you write somethnig more then just " Dimaga would have owned Sjow so hard if he use mutas"? Because I just cant see this happening. The Roach contain for example on Delta Quadrant was pretty sick. Also, did you see how many Thors Sjow had by the time of his push? Its not like its problem to build 2-3 Missile Turrets for each expo or add a bunch of Marines.. You say, magic box? Oh come on, that was working for people when they were thinking that 1-2 Thors shut down all Mutas any time. But if you have 4-5 Thors? As to "How do I harass zerg when he's able to stop harassment"... I'm sorry you're not automatically allowed to give us a disadvantage before the midgame. You're going to have to learn how to play with an evenly matched midgame zerg now...
You could stop the harassment before the patch, the difference now is that instead of having some chance of outmicroing the zerg player, all he has to do is make 4 roaches and park them and instantly stop all harassment. There's a difference between "the opponent being able to stop harassment" and "the opponent can stop harassment 100% of the time if he's ever played the game before".
On October 20 2010 05:26 Treemonkeys wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 05:18 iEchoic wrote:On October 20 2010 04:52 bobcat wrote: Try scouting a little more and playing a reactionary game. If he has infestors, stop going bio. If he's massing roaches, siege tanks are great. Make a few vikings to see what he is building and to snipe Overlords. You don't get how Terran works. You can't just "stop going bio". Am I going to invest in 4-5 raxes with addons (we're looking at over 1000 resources in production facilities) and then once he starts getting infestors I'm just going to stop using them? The cost to build one barracks with a tech lab is 150 for the rax, 50/25 for the tech lab, and ~60 minerals in mining time lost by the building SCV. We're looking at 225/25 per production facility, and more for a reactored rax. The races are not meant to be the same. Terran cannot be a purely reactionary race because their production facilities are the most expensive, even moreso than protoss (when counting worker build time + addon cost). Zerg is designed as the reactionary race because they do not need to produce production facilities beyond the first and their macro, when left untouched, is far above the other two races. However, 1.1.2 forced Terran into being a reactionary race against Zerg. This makes no sense in context with the way the races are designed. On October 20 2010 05:13 Treemonkeys wrote: I say this with complete humility because I am not very good at terran, but shouldn't terrans be looking for ways to fast expand instead of trying to rely heavily harass after it has been nerfed? 1rax FE works at lower levels on ladder because the zerg player doesn't know your strategy and most likely sucks at scouting. If you have a zerg practice partner, try 1 rax FEing on him 2-3 times in a row. If he's smart at all he's just quick expo, put down 2 spine crawlers and inject up to 60 drones by time you have 35. There's a hard counter to Terran FE builds as Zerg, which makes it not viable as a standard opening. Expos + mules make the mineral cost of raxes negligable, it also makes the Z drone count negligible
You don't know what you're talking about. Go get a zerg player to try it out with and tell him to spend all his larva on drones off two bases while you pump SCVs and mule. Come back here once you realize that he can have double your worker count and your mules only give you 4-6 virtual SCVs.
The mule isn't a magical resource fairy. One OC constantly dropping mules is worth approximately 4-6 additional SCVs. If the zerg player has more workers than you he's ahead of you.
|
|
|
|
|
|