|
On October 20 2010 06:18 Sv1 wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 02:38 Everlong wrote:Guys, you should really watch those replays of Sjow beating Dimaga with pure mech as I posted above.. Really, before saying something like "Immobile army of tanks doesnt seem to do the job like it used to".. The biggest change is I think the dual armory for very fast upgrades and when you get something like +2/+1, you can push out with a solid mech army.. And those two replays are not on the most "mech friendly" maps.. As you can see, Sjow got surrounded nearly every time, Dimaga used very effectively Infestors and tried even the infamous switch to Broodlord/Corruptor.. But as you can see, the good old mech still does the job done.  These were good replays, Sjow actually kind of takes dimaga on 1 less base pretty much the entire time. Sjow really pours on the tanks because He doesn't seem to see any mutas out. I kind of question Dimaga, he had spires in both games but seems to just not go mutas. I don't know whether he didn't think he could assault workers with Sjow's micro or something. I'm guessing because he was planning on going ultras in the end. Dimaga was also a little late with his broodlords in the metalapolis game, by that point he'd already lost 3 expansions. I always like mech vs zerg, upgrades are essential though. I'd say that these are good examples of terran vs ground armies, but against mutas flying in and out of bases, pushing might be a little slower.
I agree, but since he was pushing into 200/200 army which dimaga replenished nearly immidiately I dont think there is a problem with how fast this push comes.
|
Personally, a 30-food marauder heavy push really punishes a Z player who's trying to drone-up still it won't win you the game necessarily, but you have to scout and see if it's droning. Hit him early during a droning cycle with bio and you can set yourself up for a strong midgame.
I like the latest patch as a Zerg player, because we don't feel like we need to be incredibly defensive anymore, but I definitely give up more than a few games to that sort of push because I get too greedy. Just scout for it.
|
I stopped reading after fourth page or so, but it seems like Blizzard wants to make reapers more then an initial harassunit, so I wonder if anyone has actually thought of implementing reapers into their mix? Like sending four reapers into mineralline while another engagement is going on? Or investing the 550 minerals into a PF at stratetic chokes?
|
On October 20 2010 06:18 Sv1 wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 02:38 Everlong wrote:Guys, you should really watch those replays of Sjow beating Dimaga with pure mech as I posted above.. Really, before saying something like "Immobile army of tanks doesnt seem to do the job like it used to".. The biggest change is I think the dual armory for very fast upgrades and when you get something like +2/+1, you can push out with a solid mech army.. And those two replays are not on the most "mech friendly" maps.. As you can see, Sjow got surrounded nearly every time, Dimaga used very effectively Infestors and tried even the infamous switch to Broodlord/Corruptor.. But as you can see, the good old mech still does the job done.  These were good replays, Sjow actually kind of takes dimaga on 1 less base pretty much the entire time. Sjow really pours on the tanks because He doesn't seem to see any mutas out. I kind of question Dimaga, he had spires in both games but seems to just not go mutas. I don't know whether he didn't think he could assault workers with Sjow's micro or something. I'm guessing because he was planning on going ultras in the end. Dimaga was also a little late with his broodlords in the metalapolis game, by that point he'd already lost 3 expansions. I always like mech vs zerg, upgrades are essential though. I'd say that these are good examples of terran vs ground armies, but against mutas flying in and out of bases, pushing might be a little slower.
I really don't think those replays show us how to play TvZ because Dimaga did not use the money build which is mutaling bling infestor. He had spire but did not use them and no bling which is the biggest terror of this match up.
|
On October 20 2010 06:05 Treemonkeys wrote: I think hellion/banshee openings are very strong against zerg currently. The hellions don't have to do a whole lot of damage, they just force the zerg to slow down and not get mutas as fast as he normally would, force him to build roaches or spine crawlers and delay the lair, or lower his drone count. Then use banshees to harass extracters to slow down his gas, snipe queens if they are alone or if you have enough banshees, also go for the queen with the most energy. Extractors are easy to snipe at max queen range making the micro pretty easy, the main thing is DO NOT lose banshees. Get creative and move scvs near his base to repair harassing banshees instead of flying them all the way home. Overseers are also 100 gas a pop and pretty slow. Use this to force zerg to make one overseer per base which will slow down his spire or limit his number of mutas. Threat of banshees also makes Z hesitant to spawn larva until he gets extra queens. A strong banshee harass will force hydras which makes him lose map control and mobility, use this as an advantage by denying his 3rd.
Zerg can have 100 drones and it won't matter if he doesn't have gas, and once his gas/mineral balance is upset it becomes very difficult to get that back on track while fending off banshee harass.
If T can take out an extractor or force hyrdas he will delay mutas by quite a bit and is also in a good position to shut down a zerg from getting a 3rd with the banshees. If I was a T player I would be looking at hellion/banshee openings while trying to squeeze in an expand as early as possible.
Yes hellion banshee is still very strong. But can you see the problem in this match up? Why do T have to harass so much in early game? Because late game T is going to lose most of the battle. I think this is very poor balance design where one race has to try to end game early like this. I know that SC1 is a different game but the state of BW balance is what we should aim for.
|
On October 20 2010 06:44 chokke wrote: I stopped reading after fourth page or so, but it seems like Blizzard wants to make reapers more then an initial harassunit, so I wonder if anyone has actually thought of implementing reapers into their mix? Like sending four reapers into mineralline while another engagement is going on?
not gonna happen, like, ever. hellions are faster, don't cost any gas, don't require techlab, and build much faster. building reapers in your techlabbed barracks is just waste of time mid/late game, they have 45s build time. hellion takes 30s to build, and can be built from reactored factory 2 at a time. reapers are only good for some early scouting now.
|
Currently I am testing going pure air after fast expand. Viking/Raven/Banshee is really unstoppable once you get a critical number and more importantly gives you map control. I'm still not sure what is the best way to FE but now i am testing moving my main to my natural and making it a PF then double expoing (one preferably on island) just before mutas come out. Once you are on 3base there is really nothing stopping you from getting your imba air force leading to a gg. If anyone is interested I have one replay doing this but the strategy is still in beta .
|
On October 20 2010 07:01 kme wrote:Currently I am testing going pure air after fast expand. Viking/Raven/Banshee is really unstoppable once you get a critical number and more importantly gives you map control. I'm still not sure what is the best way to FE but now i am testing moving my main to my natural and making it a PF then double expoing (one preferably on island) just before mutas come out. Once you are on 3base there is really nothing stopping you from getting your imba air force leading to a gg. If anyone is interested I have one replay doing this but the strategy is still in beta  .
Unstoppable where exactly ? Any replays ? What's your league/rating ?
|
On October 20 2010 07:01 kme wrote:Currently I am testing going pure air after fast expand. Viking/Raven/Banshee is really unstoppable once you get a critical number and more importantly gives you map control. I'm still not sure what is the best way to FE but now i am testing moving my main to my natural and making it a PF then double expoing (one preferably on island) just before mutas come out. Once you are on 3base there is really nothing stopping you from getting your imba air force leading to a gg. If anyone is interested I have one replay doing this but the strategy is still in beta  .
what level are u and the opponents against this tactic works?
i really doubt this strategy works on high lvls..... the issues i see with this strat are
a) early counterattacks before banshees are out b) mass mutas. if he has one muta for each viking of urs, he will win. so without considering pdd or hsm, he just has to produce more mutas than u have vikings to win. which is ridiculously easy for a zerg. so if he scouts ur tactic early enough, he can just counter u by mass mutas and shut down ur airfleet before u get tons of ravens out for mass pdd or hsm.
but give a link for ur replay plz, it sounds interesting.
|
On October 20 2010 06:05 Treemonkeys wrote: I think hellion/banshee openings are very strong against zerg currently. The hellions don't have to do a whole lot of damage, they just force the zerg to slow down and not get mutas as fast as he normally would, force him to build roaches or spine crawlers and delay the lair, or lower his drone count. Then use banshees to harass extracters to slow down his gas, snipe queens if they are alone or if you have enough banshees, also go for the queen with the most energy. Extractors are easy to snipe at max queen range making the micro pretty easy, the main thing is DO NOT lose banshees. Get creative and move scvs near his base to repair harassing banshees instead of flying them all the way home. Overseers are also 100 gas a pop and pretty slow. Use this to force zerg to make one overseer per base which will slow down his spire or limit his number of mutas. Threat of banshees also makes Z hesitant to spawn larva until he gets extra queens. A strong banshee harass will force hydras which makes him lose map control and mobility, use this as an advantage by denying his 3rd.
Zerg can have 100 drones and it won't matter if he doesn't have gas, and once his gas/mineral balance is upset it becomes very difficult to get that back on track while fending off banshee harass.
If T can take out an extractor or force hyrdas he will delay mutas by quite a bit and is also in a good position to shut down a zerg from getting a 3rd with the banshees. If I was a T player I would be looking at hellion/banshee openings while trying to squeeze in an expand as early as possible. maybe im missing something but even if i have 4 mutas instead of 5 (morph overseer) when your banshees are incoming... i will still kill the banshee if u come in my base. i think the only way this would work is if u got some nice drone roasts with hellions, which hasnt happened to me since the patch hit.
rereading your post im not really sure what the hell youre talking about. banshees do not force hydras.
|
On October 20 2010 07:19 Ganondorf wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 07:01 kme wrote:Currently I am testing going pure air after fast expand. Viking/Raven/Banshee is really unstoppable once you get a critical number and more importantly gives you map control. I'm still not sure what is the best way to FE but now i am testing moving my main to my natural and making it a PF then double expoing (one preferably on island) just before mutas come out. Once you are on 3base there is really nothing stopping you from getting your imba air force leading to a gg. If anyone is interested I have one replay doing this but the strategy is still in beta  . Unstoppable where exactly ? Any replays ? What's your league/rating ? What do you mean where? The banshee/rave/viking combo is just so strong that it cannot be countered effectively due to PDD and HSM, you just have to get enough of them while surviving.
![[image loading]](http://www.gamereplays.org/community/uploads/repimgs/repimg-33-159037.jpg) Ok here is the replay but note that in this game I was trying that strategy when i move my main to my nat but I didn't build my third early enough. It can still show the idea behind it even tough my opponent wasn't that good. Diamond 1300 + if it means something to you.
Edit:
On October 20 2010 07:22 Black Gun wrote:Show nested quote +On October 20 2010 07:01 kme wrote:Currently I am testing going pure air after fast expand. Viking/Raven/Banshee is really unstoppable once you get a critical number and more importantly gives you map control. I'm still not sure what is the best way to FE but now i am testing moving my main to my natural and making it a PF then double expoing (one preferably on island) just before mutas come out. Once you are on 3base there is really nothing stopping you from getting your imba air force leading to a gg. If anyone is interested I have one replay doing this but the strategy is still in beta  . what level are u and the opponents against this tactic works? i really doubt this strategy works on high lvls..... the issues i see with this strat are a) early counterattacks before banshees are out b) mass mutas. if he has one muta for each viking of urs, he will win. so without considering pdd or hsm, he just has to produce more mutas than u have vikings to win. which is ridiculously easy for a zerg. so if he scouts ur tactic early enough, he can just counter u by mass mutas and shut down ur airfleet before u get tons of ravens out for mass pdd or hsm. but give a link for ur replay plz, it sounds interesting. Well, counterattacks should be stopped with PF. But the BO is still in beta as I said .
Against mass mutas you will have to camp in your base until you get enough vikings/ravens. But once you have hsm mutas can be dealt with easily. In theory, good opponent would never get hit but as someone already stated this gives you space control. HSM is also very good against roach or hydra.
|
I haven't played many ZvT's since the new patch, but i haven't lost one (around 11-0). It's gone from huge struggle to get my eco going, and when it's up i can start to punish the terran back, but now it's an easy ride to getting my eco going, just look out for 1 base all ins, and punish the terran. I feel depot before rax should be changed back and reapers nitro should go back to the tech lab at least...
|
Early reaper harass: almost impossible and really not effective:.... ok first of all build 1 fing reaper to control the zergs options, they are forced to build lings instead of drones... thats one thing to do... DO NOT NEGLECT REAPERS!!!
- Early helion harass: 2 queens at the ramp and a spinecrawler at the natural-mineral line is enough to shut this down completely . Helion drops will die against roaches because of their range: Even with the patch 4 hellions only have to kill 6 drones and some lings to be effective
- Banshee harass: still working, but it will never do enough damage. In the best case you can pick off +- 7 drones but that's not enough. A good zerg will always shut this down very quickly and you will be behind: your not doing it right you have to push with hellions or something else to force them to build army against ground to help your banshee hit.
fast bio push: not working. I saw an OGS member doing it and 1 fungal growth stops it completely. Banelings also destroy this hard. See drewbie @ MLG. i didnt see drewbies game, but yes bio balls do indeed get shut down by infestors.. but maybe attack before infestors?
- fast thor push: roaches are so effective now against thors that you will die (or at least it feels like that to me). Not sure if this doesn't work, but for me it doesn't. roaches dmg didnt change man thors with support are still Roach killen machines...
- fast tank marine push: can work but again: banelings + fungal growth will destroy this. Mass speedling too (yes, tanks will kill the lings, but the lings are so fast that your tanks will shoot your rines). works great as long as you mix some marauders in or some hellions for ling control
- Thor drop: still works on lost temple. On maps like metapolis it's almost wortless. Thor is HERE!
just some ideas for your post
|
On October 20 2010 07:41 Nazarid wrote: Early reaper harass: almost impossible and really not effective:.... ok first of all build 1 fing reaper to control the zergs options, they are forced to build lings instead of drones... thats one thing to do... DO NOT NEGLECT REAPERS!!!
- Early helion harass: 2 queens at the ramp and a spinecrawler at the natural-mineral line is enough to shut this down completely . Helion drops will die against roaches because of their range: Even with the patch 4 hellions only have to kill 6 drones and some lings to be effective
- Banshee harass: still working, but it will never do enough damage. In the best case you can pick off +- 7 drones but that's not enough. A good zerg will always shut this down very quickly and you will be behind: your not doing it right you have to push with hellions or something else to force them to build army against ground to help your banshee hit.
fast bio push: not working. I saw an OGS member doing it and 1 fungal growth stops it completely. Banelings also destroy this hard. See drewbie @ MLG. i didnt see drewbies game, but yes bio balls do indeed get shut down by infestors.. but maybe attack before infestors?
- fast thor push: roaches are so effective now against thors that you will die (or at least it feels like that to me). Not sure if this doesn't work, but for me it doesn't. roaches dmg didnt change man thors with support are still Roach killen machines...
- fast tank marine push: can work but again: banelings + fungal growth will destroy this. Mass speedling too (yes, tanks will kill the lings, but the lings are so fast that your tanks will shoot your rines). works great as long as you mix some marauders in or some hellions for ling control
- Thor drop: still works on lost temple. On maps like metapolis it's almost wortless. Thor is HERE!
just some ideas for your post
1 reaper doesn't work cuz they will build lings to scout u and they will have a queen if they dont decide to build lings for some reason.
hellion harass is not effective if u only kill 6 drones. 4 hellions = 400, 6 drones =300 and zerg can recreate the drones faster than u can recreate hellions.
u do not rush to banshees, u want to get them in a manner that does not hurt yur econ cuz banshee harass usually doesn't work if u need it to do significant damage. u want to harass with them and keep them alive so that u can use them in yur main army.
to me, a bio push that can't attack be4 infestors is not fast.
fast thors, especially pure fast thors, suck
fast thors + rines works better than fast tanks + rines
i dunno about thor drops o.o
|
This is getting bad, really bad every Z is just rollling me. Ive been trying numerous strats but the same thing happens every game. I just cant do any dmg to him and he gets his nice 4 base going and then its GG right there.
Ive tried to play the macro game with him but thats jsut even worse, once his creep is spread and he has 70+ drones he can just keep trading armies and containing me.
The worst Z's now a days are the ones that get a roach warren and hide a spire. If this happens i am absolutely fucked. Muta contain requires me to get thors which then get shat on by roaches. Fungal growth really stops any timing pushes ive tried to use with this patch as by the time i get to his base all my units are hurting and my medes are out of energy.
Not to mention that I have no idea how many mutas will be coming. Some Z's will get 6 to make me turret up while they switch to roaches, while some get 12 mutas and i have at least 3 turrets or I will be contained forever.
Done ranting, I have not given up hope I am going to keep watchign the gsl and keep messing around with new builds I think theres a solution, but definately all of the current T builds need a major reworking after this patch.
Id also like to shed some light ont he posts of"well now you know waht we went through" Z posts. It can be easily assumed that T players realized that there was some imbalance on their favor. However blizz nerfed way to much and switched the balance to the Z side rather than balancing the MU. I dont want my race to be overpowered, I was getting annoyed with the how easy some T builds were. at the same time I dont want my race to be underpowered, I just want a balanced game.
|
How would a viking/ghost(cloak) opening go? Like in a sort of 1-1-1 style build. Using a sort of sair/dt cover style. While spore colonies could mess it up if they expected it or after holding the stealth ghost harass, it still costs them a few drones. Already got techlab raxes for roaches for after the initial harass + it would delay because of OL snipes and drone kills. you could expand and hit em up with the right army. Basicly try to counter what they would create to hold it off. Your ghosts/vikings can take out mutas, while if you have air dominance you force them to go hydra? Also if you throw in several helions for lings counter attacks? Bet you could do some damage with it? Viking dominance could harass Zerg in sniping OLs delaying drones/keeping muta numbers down?
Just TRYING to think out of the box! Am in bed atm but I would love to try it out ( and probably fail bigtime haha but I tried atleast! )
|
On October 20 2010 08:35 Hveen wrote: How would a viking/ghost(cloak) opening go? Like in a sort of 1-1-1 style build. Using a sort of sair/dt cover style. While spore colonies could mess it up if they expected it or after holding the stealth ghost harass, it still costs them a few drones. Already got techlab raxes for roaches for after the initial harass + it would delay because of OL snipes and drone kills. you could expand and hit em up with the right army. Basicly try to counter what they would create to hold it off. Your ghosts/vikings can take out mutas, while if you have air dominance you force them to go hydra? Also if you throw in several helions for lings counter attacks? Bet you could do some damage with it? Viking dominance could harass Zerg in sniping OLs delaying drones/keeping muta numbers down?
Just TRYING to think out of the box! Am in bed atm but I would love to try it out ( and probably fail bigtime haha but I tried atleast! )
The ghost dropping build has been done by acupuncture with a so-so effect. Mutas or a roach bust now witht he range will really hurt you bad.
Ive been trying to think out of the box and do a reactor starport with a fast thor drop
So basically I get 4 vikings+ 1 thorship and try and do a harass while getting my expo up then transitioning into a heavy mech game
|
Let's give it a few weeks...
I really think the last 5 patches or so have been kinda rushed, they changed the races before people discovered what to do against a certain strat.
I didn't think TvZ was that imbalanced before patch and i doubt it is imbalanced now.This is even though i've lost my last 5 TvZ's (1800 ish). I think I just need to adapt to the changes - I really want to make bio work tho (damn infestors).
|
Anyone tried using Turtle Meching? I've tried and it's effective but really boring. You need to also get 3 bases for you to support the heavy tank/thor seput.. the problem would be fast tech BL's if you move out at around 200/200. Since most zergs assume marine/tanks now it kinda ticks them of. Also,
Turrets, turrets everywhere for mass mutas.
|
This match-up has me so uncertain that I am hesitant to ladder. I am not a high-level player, but I depend on high-level analysis of race match-ups, early to mid game options and adaptations in order to have a plan going into a game. Thought process summary:
Punishing a fast-expanding Zerg is exceedingly difficult, often resulting in an early commitment to a bunker rush that may or may not reasonably succeed.
Early Roach pressure and rushes force double wall-ins and commitment to Marauders at a very early state of the game.
Speedlings/Banelings are a frequent follow-up to Roach pressure which contains any forces behind my wall-in until I feel safe enough to poke out. This will often require Hellion construction, hopefully blue flame to dispatch 'lings/blings off creep.
This ground force, though formidable against the composition is rendered immediately useless once the Zerg can open up Spire tech and begin accumulating Mutalisks. This requires a severe tech switch on my behalf, as Marines and Thors may be required to defend against said Mutalisks. Any Starport units would have to be utilized as support for either my remaining ground forces, which I cannot afford to lose, as 'ling surrounds on Thors and Banelings on Marines will end the match rather quickly if I am caught out of position.
Assuming I am able to secure my first expansion within a reasonable amount of time, and that my early Marauders/Hellions have been able to hold off Roaches and 'lings/blings, how can I help my macro game and secure additional expansions once Mutalisks are on the way?
The more I come up with, the more I have come to understand that Vespene Gas accumulation is the deciding factor in my TvZ matches. In order for my composition to effectively counter theirs, I need access to more geysers, hence more expansions. Which brings me back to my original point.
TvZ, fast expo into Roach/sling contain into Banelings and eventually Mutalisks
(I'm just going to disregard units like Infestors, Corruptors, Blords, etc. If the game has gone on that long, they are on 4 bases to my two and I probably should have GG'd by now.)
Is there something other than wall-in with early Marauder/Hellions into Thor/Marine with air support that I should be doing in order to expand beyond my first? It just seems like a continual uphill battle right now.
Any advice/thoughts would be appreciated.
|
|
|
|
|
|