On October 20 2010 01:15 TSL-Lore wrote: quick edit regarding KawaiiRice's question "how do you scout a spire? don't tell me scan." I think terrans aren't using flying buildings nearly often enough. A barracks has WAY more hit points than an overlord, flies about TWICE as fast, is pretty much cheaper (you don't lose supply when you lose it) and Zerg doesn't have nearly as much anti-air to stop it from seeing everything before spire.... so yea, i think that's how you scout spire tech without scanning.
nah, that won't work at all. there is no build that allows you to use your's first rax, and fly it into zerg's main fast enough to scout a spire before mutas are in your mineral line, and still put you in a decent position in midgame. at least i think there is no such build. you're welcome to provide one.
Can't you just build a rax near the zerg base and fly it in? I've had it done to me a few times before by decent players, so i'm sure Ts can work it into their build. Doesn't have to be your first rax...
Anyways, we're talking about a Z who FEs, so the spire won't come up too terribly early.
On October 19 2010 23:26 MforWW wrote: Not to be a dick, but now Terrans are just going to have to learn how to micro their stuff better when they make a push if they want to win.
While zerg have to do absolutely no micro to win against 90% of armies in the late game. Blings, Slings, and Roaches A-Move, Infestors use growth, and mutas just magic box.
I'm not agreeing with the other guy, but this is totally false.
You have to time everything right. If you move in with blings too quickly, they will die to tank fire before the rest of your army engages. Same with infestors. And who the hell A-moves with banelings? If you do that you'll lose all of your banelings while only killing a small amount of marauder/tank, or possibly 1 thor.
If you move in too quickly with mutas, they get shredded by stimmed marines extremely fast.
You have to stop your mutas at just the right time, or else they will bunch up and try to attack and die to thors.
On top of all of this you need to flank to reduce tank splash and to prevent marine/maruader from stimming and running back behind tanks.
None of these things are very difficult to do by itself, but doing all of it together is extremely difficult. Saying "zerg have to do absolutely no micro to win against 90% of armies in the late game" is total bullshit.
On October 19 2010 23:26 MforWW wrote: Not to be a dick, but now Terrans are just going to have to learn how to micro their stuff better when they make a push if they want to win.
While zerg have to do absolutely no micro to win against 90% of armies in the late game. Blings, Slings, and Roaches A-Move, Infestors use growth, and mutas just magic box.
I'm not agreeing with the other guy, but this is totally false.
You have to time everything right. If you move in with blings too quickly, they will die to tank fire before the rest of your army engages. Same with infestors.
If you move in too quickly with mutas, they get shredded by stimmed marines extremely fast.
You have to stop your mutas at just the right time, or else they will bunch up and try to attack and die to thors.
On top of all of this you need to flank to reduce tank splash and to prevent marine/maruader from stimming and running back behind tanks.
None of these things are very difficult to do by itself, but doing all of it together is extremely difficult. Saying "zerg have to do absolutely no micro to win against 90% of armies in the late game" is total bullshit.
100% agree with this. Managing the Zerg army is definitely the most micro-intensive of all armies to manage. I've played plenty of Terran and Protoss and colo/stalker/any-unit-for-flare or MMM/tank is way easier to manage than sling/bling/muta/infestor. The only time Z can A-move and own is when the Z army is way way bigger.
On October 20 2010 01:15 TSL-Lore wrote: 1800-diamond zerg chiming in here
I have definitely been enjoying the ZvT match up a lot more now. Been getting a lot more wins as a result I believe. Not having to worry about proxy rax AND reaper rush definitely simplifies the match for a Zerg. However, the patch didn't touch the core fighting units that Terran has (marines, marauders, tanks, thors, etc), all of which are forces to be reckoned with. In the end, i think the reaper changes were good (because that play style is totally retarded and not fun to watch anyway), but the supply->rax requirement was bad (proxy rax is just about the most ballsy and cool thing Terran can do).
Watching the games between IdrA and QXC got me thinking about the not-so-dreaded Hunter Seeker Missile. When QXC was researching it and IdrA was running around with his swarm-like mass of low HP units (muta/ling/bane) i was thinking, "AWESOME, we're going to see a revolution in TvZ where HSM becomes as important as Irradiate was in SC:BW." But then... QXC casted it and it landed on the ling swarm. The result? Totally anti-climactic. It only killed like 6 zerglings and damaged maybe 20. We've seen HSM do incredible damage when used on stacked Mutas during the Beta, but this is really only under perfect conditions.
I think HSM will definitely become more of an integral ability in the TvZ match up... but probably only after it gets patched. Whether the energy cost goes down, the research requirement goes away, or the damage gets buffed, any one of these changes would probably make it a lot more dangerous for the zerg, and a lot more entertaining for the fans. If HSM could potentially do really significant damage, watching one get released and hearing that high pitched droning would definitely get my blood pumping, whether i'm watching or playing.
I see HSM as an ability that either does catastophic damage (think mutas that stay clumped on an irradiate) or controls space (again, think mutas that are forced to retreat when an irradiate is cast). Just hearing the HSM should be enough for the Zerg to have to retreat, allowing the T to control that space for a moment, and allowing the T to kill the expansion/protect his own mineral line/control a watch tower/etc.
Aside from all this, i do believe that the majority of the ZvT match up right now is quite balanced. In the matches i play vs Terran, I find that I destroy the terrans who march blindly into my creep with their seemingly scary army. Its the terrans that have good positioning that can still get me. Terrans are complaining a lot right now because, I believe, most of them haven't learned how to get good positioning. You can't just present yourself like a flock of sheep in the middle of creep. Get a Raven, kill tumors, control choke points or position your army against a wall so it can't be surrounded so easily. There's still a lot left to be discovered, so go out there in discover it instead of sitting in this thread and complaining!
quick edit regarding KawaiiRice's question "how do you scout a spire? don't tell me scan." I think terrans aren't using flying buildings nearly often enough. A barracks has WAY more hit points than an overlord, flies about TWICE as fast, is pretty much cheaper (you don't lose supply when you lose it) and Zerg doesn't have nearly as much anti-air to stop it from seeing everything before spire.... so yea, i think that's how you scout spire tech without scanning.
I think your right regarding the raven. Next prioty for lbizzard should be to make terran units better late game (mostly against zerg), and the buffing the seeker missile makes a lot of sense. Becasue the raven unit has some good abilities vs zerg as it can detect, pdd is very good vs mtuas and somehow decent vs hydras. Turrets are pretty decent as well.
On October 19 2010 20:00 BigFatRoAcH wrote: Gas before rax into earlly banshee can throw the Z off so much.
It only works on small maps, scout at 10(the same timing you make a depot) if you see a pool go standard 10depo 12rax 13gas, if he's FEing gas before rax and pump a cloakshee out before 8:00. Remember he has 2 bases to cover so abusing banshee mobility against the queen. Even if he gets an overseer and a couple of hydras you already have done your job delaying the Spire.
This works very well at Plat~LowDia but probably not any further.
This strategy with 3 hellions to force roaches, basically had me win 90% of my games against zerg until I was high diamond. Its very effective. What I do in particular is build my rax at the upper part of the ramp, but then build my factory and a bunker at the bottom of the ramp to scare zerg away so they can't see my tech or units. Even one or two marines in the bunker is enough to scare them. It also allows you to double wall if necessary, building the standard depot/rax wall on top, and a solid bunker/factory at the bottom.
Great until you're high diamond, when zerg usually have an extra queen out for defense and creep. And now with 1.1.2 I doubt the hellion harass will do too much.
I've been doing a reactored helion harass, at least you can stop mining at their expansion plus pick off a few drones/lings at the cost of a helion or two. Helions are cost effective if you kill more than 2 drones at the expense of one helion, getting behind their naturals mineral line to lose 3 helions at the cost of 8 drones is still a good investment.
I do this, then jump into a blue flame/marauder pressure. 2 factories 1 tech lab for blue flame 1 reactored, 1 rax into expansion, you can still get a decent number of marauders out, when they pull to the front, run your helions by into the main.
Couple this with an expand and your pressure is pretty solid. From there you can transition into bio helion, which don't underestimate helions even late game, they are still a threat to mineral lines throughout the entire game. What I generally do is transition into a 5 fac mech build, primarily focused on thor helion, with a few marauders. Since your early pressure before your expand was just helions and marauders, you will have enough gas to support at least 2 factories constantly producing thors. When you run out of gas for the third, produce a helion and wait for the gas to come in.
Thor/Helion is damn hard for zerg to hold off late game, especially when you get into that critical mass number of thors (9+). Just make sure not to throw any of them away and you should be golden.
The main thing I've noticed about TvZ now is its like ZvT used to be. You have to delay them from leaving their base. I've used tanks a lot before the patch, but now roaches are so popular, an immobile army comprised of tanks just doesn't seem to do the job like it used to. I think Thor/Helion is probably the most well rounded army can get against zerg at this point, especially since the Ultra splash nerf.
Guys, you should really watch those replays of Sjow beating Dimaga with pure mech as I posted above.. Really, before saying something like "Immobile army of tanks doesnt seem to do the job like it used to".. The biggest change is I think the dual armory for very fast upgrades and when you get something like +2/+1, you can push out with a solid mech army.. And those two replays are not on the most "mech friendly" maps.. As you can see, Sjow got surrounded nearly every time, Dimaga used very effectively Infestors and tried even the infamous switch to Broodlord/Corruptor.. But as you can see, the good old mech still does the job done.
On October 20 2010 02:24 Huragius wrote: Sure, whenever a Terran wins, it's because of the imbalance. When zerg wins it's due to his superior skills. I will tell you what zerg now does: 1) FE, with few roaches and spine crawler. ( Stops hellions harass) 2) 3-4 Queens win overseer (insane creeps spread, banshee harass proof, overseer scouting after defending.)
No rush helps against this. And after zerg gets eco running, he masses roaches and sends them a-move, and I'm serious. Mine APM was about 130 last few games against zerg and they were like 80-100 and it was insane hard to play. TvZ favours zerg as hell in my eyes now. And bio build against zerg is a fail like mech vs protoss. It is countered to easy if scouted, and they will scout you.
1763 Points Diamond Terran.
I love this one. It's like 'I can't kite roach with hellion/reaper forever ... IMBALANCE !' Thors are insanely good at killing roach ... wait, just like tanks ! Or even marauders ! This matchup is just more balance and u cant a+move anymore.
I think TvZ is now very well balanced.. Terran just needs to move on and forget about stupid early Reaper abuse, which wasnt that fun after all.. And I speak from Terran point of view.
On October 20 2010 02:24 Huragius wrote: Sure, whenever a Terran wins, it's because of the imbalance. When zerg wins it's due to his superior skills. I will tell you what zerg now does: 1) FE, with few roaches and spine crawler. ( Stops hellions harass) 2) 3-4 Queens win overseer (insane creeps spread, banshee harass proof, overseer scouting after defending.)
No rush helps against this. And after zerg gets eco running, he masses roaches and sends them a-move, and I'm serious. Mine APM was about 130 last few games against zerg and they were like 80-100 and it was insane hard to play. TvZ favours zerg as hell in my eyes now. And bio build against zerg is a fail like mech vs protoss. It is countered to easy if scouted, and they will scout you.
1763 Points Diamond Terran.
I love this one. It's like 'I can't kite roach with hellion/reaper forever ... IMBALANCE !' Thors are insanely good at killing roach ... wait, just like tanks ! Or even marauders ! This matchup is just more balance and u cant a+move anymore.
This is what I've been trying to say.
But of course; I'm nowhere near the skill level of the likes of KawaiiRice and others in this thread. All I'm trying to say is that it is easier to improve when you have an open mind. A mind focused on WHAT DOESN'T WORK will only find stuff that DOESN'T WORK....
I haven't made any suggestions to builds/openings/strats in this thread, because others are better at it. I haven't made claims that my skill is higher than others. I'm just trying to get people to think creative about what to do.
You should think of solutions with your mind set to believe that there exists such solutions. Only that way can you find them.
@OP: I'm a little confused. Is the point of your post that there's no Terran harass/aggression strategy that doesn't fail if the Zerg player is prepared for it? This has always been the case. The only difference now is that the number of different and disparate options available in the very early game has been constrained since 5rax reapers is no longer viable.
Yeah, banshees, hellions, and early bio or bio/mech pushes with fail if the Zerg player is prepared...but that's always been true. If it wasn't then that'd mean there's a TvZ uncounterable tactic and that would be fucking absurd.
There are a lot of posts, including some by progamers, that complain about certain builds not working if they get scouted. ... Perhaps the problem isn't with the matchup but with the tendency to rely on builds that hinge so singly on surprise. Consider this article.
There's a lot of apocalypse talk in this thread. Even among people who are pretty good, which is disconcerting.
Last week everyone was whining about ZvT being so hard. And now the opposite. Seriously, give me a fucking break. 1 roach range and the capability to 14 hatch did not turn zerg into this supposed powerhouse that just owns anything the terran makes. Terrans still have far more usable builds, and still have a crazy defensive advantage, and still can make a big ball of anything and own 90% of zerg armies unless the zerg completely outmicros you and uses like 5 different units flawlessly.
Very little has changed. If we look at the stats in 2 months and see 40% of players are zerg and 10% are terran (like the opposite is now), then we can fucking talk. But we all know that's not going to happen.
On October 20 2010 01:15 TSL-Lore wrote: 1800-diamond zerg chiming in here
I have definitely been enjoying the ZvT match up a lot more now. Been getting a lot more wins as a result I believe. Not having to worry about proxy rax AND reaper rush definitely simplifies the match for a Zerg. However, the patch didn't touch the core fighting units that Terran has (marines, marauders, tanks, thors, etc), all of which are forces to be reckoned with. In the end, i think the reaper changes were good (because that play style is totally retarded and not fun to watch anyway), but the supply->rax requirement was bad (proxy rax is just about the most ballsy and cool thing Terran can do).
Watching the games between IdrA and QXC got me thinking about the not-so-dreaded Hunter Seeker Missile. When QXC was researching it and IdrA was running around with his swarm-like mass of low HP units (muta/ling/bane) i was thinking, "AWESOME, we're going to see a revolution in TvZ where HSM becomes as important as Irradiate was in SC:BW." But then... QXC casted it and it landed on the ling swarm. The result? Totally anti-climactic. It only killed like 6 zerglings and damaged maybe 20. We've seen HSM do incredible damage when used on stacked Mutas during the Beta, but this is really only under perfect conditions.
I think HSM will definitely become more of an integral ability in the TvZ match up... but probably only after it gets patched. Whether the energy cost goes down, the research requirement goes away, or the damage gets buffed, any one of these changes would probably make it a lot more dangerous for the zerg, and a lot more entertaining for the fans. If HSM could potentially do really significant damage, watching one get released and hearing that high pitched droning would definitely get my blood pumping, whether i'm watching or playing.
I see HSM as an ability that either does catastophic damage (think mutas that stay clumped on an irradiate) or controls space (again, think mutas that are forced to retreat when an irradiate is cast). Just hearing the HSM should be enough for the Zerg to have to retreat, allowing the T to control that space for a moment, and allowing the T to kill the expansion/protect his own mineral line/control a watch tower/etc.
Aside from all this, i do believe that the majority of the ZvT match up right now is quite balanced. In the matches i play vs Terran, I find that I destroy the terrans who march blindly into my creep with their seemingly scary army. Its the terrans that have good positioning that can still get me. Terrans are complaining a lot right now because, I believe, most of them haven't learned how to get good positioning. You can't just present yourself like a flock of sheep in the middle of creep. Get a Raven, kill tumors, control choke points or position your army against a wall so it can't be surrounded so easily. There's still a lot left to be discovered, so go out there in discover it instead of sitting in this thread and complaining!
quick edit regarding KawaiiRice's question "how do you scout a spire? don't tell me scan." I think terrans aren't using flying buildings nearly often enough. A barracks has WAY more hit points than an overlord, flies about TWICE as fast, is pretty much cheaper (you don't lose supply when you lose it) and Zerg doesn't have nearly as much anti-air to stop it from seeing everything before spire.... so yea, i think that's how you scout spire tech without scanning.
On October 19 2010 23:26 MforWW wrote: Not to be a dick, but now Terrans are just going to have to learn how to micro their stuff better when they make a push if they want to win.
While zerg have to do absolutely no micro to win against 90% of armies in the late game. Blings, Slings, and Roaches A-Move, Infestors use growth, and mutas just magic box.
I'm not agreeing with the other guy, but this is totally false.
You have to time everything right. If you move in with blings too quickly, they will die to tank fire before the rest of your army engages. Same with infestors.
If you move in too quickly with mutas, they get shredded by stimmed marines extremely fast.
You have to stop your mutas at just the right time, or else they will bunch up and try to attack and die to thors.
On top of all of this you need to flank to reduce tank splash and to prevent marine/maruader from stimming and running back behind tanks.
None of these things are very difficult to do by itself, but doing all of it together is extremely difficult. Saying "zerg have to do absolutely no micro to win against 90% of armies in the late game" is total bullshit.
100% agree with this. Managing the Zerg army is definitely the most micro-intensive of all armies to manage. I've played plenty of Terran and Protoss and colo/stalker/any-unit-for-flare or MMM/tank is way easier to manage than sling/bling/muta/infestor. The only time Z can A-move and own is when the Z army is way way bigger.
On October 20 2010 03:15 ToxNub wrote: There's a lot of apocalypse talk in this thread. Even among people who are pretty good, which is disconcerting.
Last week everyone was whining about ZvT being so hard. And now the opposite. Seriously, give me a fucking break. 1 roach range and the capability to 14 hatch did not turn zerg into this supposed powerhouse that just owns anything the terran makes.
Yes, 1 roach range combined with building health, reaper nerf, and sd before rax requirement actually did turn Zerg into a powerhouse into ZvT. I hate how people don't understand that very small changes completely change game balance.
There's some bad Zerg players I used to absolutely destroy on ladder every single game and now I can't beat them at all. I even played a Terran player the other day who was playing as Zerg for fun, and I'd actually do better playing against his terran than his zerg. Rather it's balanced or not, there's no doubt that this change massively changed TvZ. I've felt the results myself.
This was not a subtle change at all. Several very good terran players have said essentially the same thing. Of course, because this is the TL strategy forums, 50% of the posts disagreeing are just trying to have whiny race wars or are talking about how they got owned in high plat by mass thors, so it's balanced.