|
On June 04 2010 05:20 ices wrote: this turned into a stupid thread berating the author's credibility. why aren't we discussing the reaper rush? what the fuck are diablo 2 runewords? grief sounds stupid.
the point is, stop attacking the author and start discussing the content. this strat doesn't seem viable at high level play. i'm 2100+ before and 660+ right now in diamond. these kinds of all-ins work when your opponent doesn't really know what he's doing, but agaisnt any competent high level player this rush isn't going to last. it's just like protoss proxy gates. they were dominating early but now it's basically a free win. reapers just needed to be adjusted to and this strategy isn't competitive past past gold.
If the author didn't blatantly bullshit about how good he was and how effective the build was no one would be taking shots at him.
Also the build is old and counter-able, so theres not much to discuss
|
okay i re read the beginning and this author is almost certainly a douche.
yeah 6 barracks reaper is pretty bad, don't do it
|
The thing about that is, it only fails if the protoss specifically goes for a fast stalker. If anything about his build order would make him not get a fast stalker, he is basically going to lose no matter what. It ropes protoss into doing a single strategy vs terran. If you went 2x gate at first, or you proxied, or you tried to cannon, or proxy cannon, or lategate, or fast expo, or whatever- you've lost.
Terran can do just about any opening it wants against protoss, but if protoss does any opening other than gate->cy->gas, he's going to be at risk of "instant lose to reapers". Because the fact of the matter is, the reapers come so fast that nothing but the earliest stalker will be there before your base is dead, and no amount of zealots and probes can do a thing against reapers
-And because this build can set up the win before the protoss really even gets a chance to scout, you cant "react" to it, either. Its very much dependent on what build you decided to go before the game even began. If you make a gateway, then send that probe to scout- its already too late to change anything.
|
On June 04 2010 05:26 clan_iraq wrote: The thing about that is, it only fails if the protoss specifically goes for a fast stalker. If anything about his build order would make him not get a fast stalker, he is basically going to lose no matter what. It ropes protoss into doing a single strategy vs terran. If you went 2x gate at first, or you proxied, or you tried to cannon, or proxy cannon, or lategate, or fast expo, or whatever- you've lost.
Terran can do just about any opening it wants against protoss, but if protoss does any opening other than gate->cy->gas, he's going to be at risk of "instant lose to reapers". Because the fact of the matter is, the reapers come so fast that nothing but the earliest stalker will be there before your base is dead, and no amount of zealots and probes can do a thing against reapers
-And because this build can set up the win before the protoss really even gets a chance to scout, you cant "react" to it, either. Its very much dependent on what build you decided to go before the game even began. If you make a gateway, then send that probe to scout- its already too late to change anything.
Zealots and probes can do fine against a reaper to stall for a stalker to get out. Its not like you have unlimited time, maybe 30 seconds to get as many probe kills as possible before his stalkers out. You have like 4 SCV's mining, you have to do SO much damage for this to work, even a late stalker he can sacrifice some probes and get back in the game very very fast.
|
i can see how this strategy would beat certain protoss builds, but what does it have to do with actually playing the game? there's almost nothing about strategy involved, all you do is rush for the fastest possible reaper harass. if you win with it, nice, you won. if it fails, nice, you lost. it's such an all-in strategy that to be honest, wouldn't contribute to any personal growth as a player.
even if you said you were 90% diamond with this strategy, you'd still be about last place bronze in my book if you could only beat protoss doing this. let's be honest here, are you trying to win for a cool looking record or because you enjoy playing the game? it's still beta man, why would you waste any of your time basically not playing the game and doing the same crap over and over?
it sounds like you get off by masturbating to the clock and not porn, basically.
|
It works pretty decently against terran too, actually. Terran has many more options to deal with it, however, whereas stalker is the only protoss answer.
(1 reaper can kill 2 marines in a row with 2 hp remaining, so it creams right through a single rax, but can be stopped by a defensive bunker, marauder, scv loading, liftoff, 2x rax, etc).
Zealots and probes can do fine against a reaper to stall for a stalker to get out. Its not like you have unlimited time, maybe 30 seconds to get as many probe kills as possible before his stalkers out. You have like 4 SCV's mining, you have to do SO much damage for this to work, even a late stalker he can sacrifice some probes and get back in the game very very fast.
Eh, you get 30 seconds on the fastest possible stalker build, is the point. If you had a different opening than gate->cyb->gas asap, then those reapers might have as much as 90 seconds, with 2 reapers and a marauder. And thats the case where zealots and probes won't be able to hold it off until you can switch to a stalker.
The problem is, unless you really fend it off hard, the terran can get out 1-2 marauders with the upgrade while you're getting out a stalker- even with the fastest build the terran can have 1 reaper 1 marauder before your stalker- any slower build might mean 1 reaper 2 marauders if the bunker is pushed back (it frees up the 1 supply with that scv).
|
I practiced against this build a lot on incineration zone.
Using a typical 12 gate opening with a cyber core built immediately after, your scouting probe (after gateway) will see the suspicious lack of buildings in time for you to respond by building a zealot. The zealot plus 3-4 probes, plus ~2 more probes to kill the SCV building the bunker, buy you time (30 seconds) until your chronoboosted stalker comes out. Even using all these probes, you're still mining more than the Terran.
The upgraded marauder followup is difficult to deal with as well, but as long as you make enough units by chronoing your gateway (usually adding on a 2nd gate), and use probes judiciously, P wins.
Getting a fast stalker is "the only counter" but in fact is pretty standard play anyway.
|
On June 03 2010 15:33 deL wrote: If your army consists of like 20+ arhcons they won't walk their army into the vortex because 1) the strat is obvious and 2) they can beat your army straight up even with a portion of their force missing cos archons are rubbish.
Though to get a mothership you're probably pretty far ahead anyway. what you do is heavy heavy templar and storm to force them near the vortex then vortex and combine your archons and run them in the 8ish second window you have.
|
Aye, but how much of that "standard play" in TvP is due to this threat? It reduces the possibility of any other opening, in turn devolving the gameplay. Its a matchup warping problem really.
Because the thing is, thats 30 seconds with a 12 gate opening with a cyber core immediately after. What happens if you had done any other build in the world? Start with 2 gates and take a late cyber, or a late gate, or double gas.
But I should note with your thing there- you'd be better off sending 4-5 probes at the reaper, and send the zealot and some probes at the bunker. Depending on placement, probes will have a very very difficult time killing the scv, whereas if its mostly a zealot chasing the reaper, he can ignore it, kite around it and shoot the 2 probes attacking his bunker- never having to attack the zealot at all. And once a bunker goes up near your base, well thats that.
I've played enough good players to see some prolifically skilled responses to this. In one game, my bunker went up because he tried exactly what you described and failed to kill the scv in time due to placement, and the protoss used the really neat idea of forming a horizontal wall with his probes, cutting off my marauder so it could never reach the bunker around the stalker while taking potshots- and a bunker without a marauder in it will actually lose to the stalker due to longer range (6 vs 5.5 I believe). Now thats one neat way to deal with it.
But the point is, theres only one possible way for a protoss to beat this- get out a stalker before all his probes are dead- and that eliminates a huge pool of possible openings, while a terran could build a fast expo planetary fortress for all I care in TvP. So even if there is a way for protoss to respond to it, it warps the matchup.
|
What build is there vs terran other than "fast" stalker? Zealots are pretty meh vs all terran units without charge so there isn't a reason to build anything else.
|
what you do is heavy heavy templar and storm to force them near the vortex then vortex and combine your archons and run them in the 8ish second window you have.
tbh since most people will run their army into a vortex if you land it on them, you can just keep your archons off screen or cloaked and do it head on. Heck, if they don't run the other half of their army into a vortex, you should be able to beat them by dividing them anyway. The real problem is that when people know its coming, they can simply avoid the mothership. I think its something that you should really only be using as a tactic in FFA games or drawn out 1v1's come extreme lategame. For example, if your opponent has 50 3/3/3 void rays in PvP, you could kill them all in a single blast.
|
Fast stalker is standard play because terrans wall-in and all their units kite early zealots with ease. Same as it was in bw.
Also, regarding 6rax reapers, anyone who scouts on 9 (and on 1v1 maps, I think that is pretty common considering the prevalence of cheese) will have plenty of time to prepare for it. But that's the thing, protoss aren't even required to be "prepared" for this. They just need to deal with it given what they would have anyway.
|
On June 04 2010 06:09 MadduX wrote: Fast stalker is standard play because terrans wall-in and all their units kite early zealots with ease. Same as it was in bw.
Also, regarding 6rax reapers, anyone who scouts on 9 (and on 1v1 maps, I think that is pretty common considering the prevalence of cheese) will have plenty of time to prepare for it. But that's the thing, protoss aren't even required to be "prepared" for this. They just need to deal with it given what they would have anyway.
Yeah, I didn't think there was any other kind of opening. Do you really want to take the risk of getting Zealots or Sentries first, only to get owned by Reapers? Even an early marine+bunker rush gets toasted by an early Stalker.
Question is, are you going 10gate-14core, or 13gate-16/17core?
|
Theres that problem. The only deviation in protoss openings is "10 gate? 11 gate? 12 gate? 13 gate?" Thats pretty much it.
Whereas a terran could do any number of wacky things. He could go 1/1/1, or go 2 rax, or even 3 rax, or fast reapers, or proxy reaper bunker, or proxy marauder, or turtle tech, fast expo, heck even fast fortress choke sometimes (well maybe not that one), fortress rush, lift off to island, etc, etc, etc. Maybe they aren't all very good ideas, but they can work. But protoss is really jammed into a single build.
And thats the second part of the problem. Even though "fast stalker" is the only counter to "fast reaper", it doesn't by any means shut it down. Its clearly possible for a terran to win proxy reaper vs fastest stalker. You have to outmicro your opponent just to hang in there- controlling individual probes to deter his reaper and delay his bunker as you stall for the stalker. And since a good proxy reaper player sends two scvs, that bunker is a serious threat.
My point being- if this is the hard counter to the build, shouldn't it shut it down? As it stands, the protoss might be favored in that position, but not by much. I've beat myriads of protoss who tried to go fast stalker by outmicroing them. Now, that is what kills the parallels with other cheeses like 6 pool. If you know 6pool is coming, you can do a counter build to completely shut it down. A terran walls his base in, a protoss could 9forge or just chrono out early zealots, or hell any race can just pump nothing but workers and stop it pretty handily. But with proxy reapers, I can do it against protoss knowing that even if they do the counter build, it will come down to who micros better- and if they don't, its a free win for me.
|
On June 04 2010 06:58 clan_iraq wrote: Theres that problem. The only deviation in protoss openings is "10 gate? 11 gate? 12 gate? 13 gate?" Thats pretty much it.
Whereas a terran could do any number of wacky things. He could go 1/1/1, or go 2 rax, or even 3 rax, or fast reapers, or proxy reaper bunker, or proxy marauder, or turtle tech, fast expo, heck even fast fortress choke sometimes (well maybe not that one), fortress rush, lift off to island, etc, etc, etc. Maybe they aren't all very good ideas, but they can work. But protoss is really jammed into a single build.
And thats the second part of the problem. Even though "fast stalker" is the only counter to "fast reaper", it doesn't by any means shut it down. Its clearly possible for a terran to win proxy reaper vs fastest stalker. You have to outmicro your opponent just to hang in there- controlling individual probes to deter his reaper and delay his bunker as you stall for the stalker. And since a good proxy reaper player sends two scvs, that bunker is a serious threat.
My point being- if this is the hard counter to the build, shouldn't it shut it down? As it stands, the protoss might be favored in that position, but not by much. I've beat myriads of protoss who tried to go fast stalker by outmicroing them. Now, that is what kills the parallels with other cheeses like 6 pool. If you know 6pool is coming, you can do a counter build to completely shut it down. A terran walls his base in, a protoss could 9forge or just chrono out early zealots, or hell any race can just pump nothing but workers and stop it pretty handily. But with proxy reapers, I can do it against protoss knowing that even if they do the counter build, it will come down to who micros better- and if they don't, its a free win for me.
Okay this post is full of fail. Protoss openings are 10gate / 11gate / 12gate / 13gate. But then you go and proceed to compare that to terran builds not terran openings.
Protoss can go 1 gate, 2 gate, 3 gate, 4 gate, 1 gate 1 stargate, 2 gate 1 stargate, 2 gate 1 robo, 1 gate 1 stargate 1 robo, 1 gate expand, easily as much variety. Sure they have to build a gateway first, but terran has to build a barracks first also? So that point pretty much made no sense.
The reason fast stalker counters reaper proxy, is because if you do win the little micro fight, you win the game easy. Also, protoss definitely has the advantage in the micro fight. And im sure you've beaten countless low rank diamond and bnet forum noobs, but any skilled player can micro some probes and zealots against reapers/scv's for a little until the stalker is out.
So sure, the only counter you can't just hang out, you actually have to micro, but the micro isn't incredibly hard, and more importantly if you hold of the reaper then you will win, theres really no way you can't.
|
LOL im trying not to laugh, since im in class, at this blind ignorant conceited egocentric dipshit. hahahah
|
How do you compare the difference between 10/11/12/13 gate vs something like lifting off your command center and building a planetary fortress? We're talking bout what, a "9 refinery 11 engy" build?
With the protoss build orders listed, it is always Gateway -> Cyber Core -> Refinery (-> Stalker) (ok pylons can vary sometimes) With the terran build orders listed, it varies wildly.
9 refinery -> 11 engy -> I have no idea on the fortress 6 barracks -> 7 reaper -> 7 bunker ? 9 supply -> 11 rax? 9 rax -> 11 orbital command? 9 supply -> 11 rax -> 2nd rax -> 3rd rax
There are so many crazy options you have I can't list most of them because I have no idea on what your supply would be as you get them. It could be 1 rax, 2 rax, 3 rax. It could be an engy bay, hell it could be an ultra fast expo and planetary fortress, as I was saying. These build orders don't use the same buildings at all.
For protoss, you're always getting the same buildings, in the same order, the only difference being at what times.
|
On June 04 2010 07:24 dangots0ul wrote: LOL im trying not to laugh, since im in class, at this blind ignorant conceited egocentric dipshit. hahahah
Shouldn't you be jerking off to anime? Amazing what checking someone's post history can do edit: actually, as this is the internet, thats probably exactly what hes doing right now
|
On June 04 2010 07:30 clan_iraq wrote:Show nested quote +On June 04 2010 07:24 dangots0ul wrote: LOL im trying not to laugh, since im in class, at this blind ignorant conceited egocentric dipshit. hahahah Shouldn't you be jerking off to anime? Amazing what checking someone's post history can do edit: actually, as this is the internet, thats probably exactly what hes doing right now
So considering you decided not to respond I guess you understand the build is nothing great?
|
On June 04 2010 07:32 _Air_ wrote:Show nested quote +On June 04 2010 07:30 clan_iraq wrote:On June 04 2010 07:24 dangots0ul wrote: LOL im trying not to laugh, since im in class, at this blind ignorant conceited egocentric dipshit. hahahah Shouldn't you be jerking off to anime? Amazing what checking someone's post history can do edit: actually, as this is the internet, thats probably exactly what hes doing right now So considering you decided not to respond I guess you understand the build is nothing great?
Take a look a little higher
|
|
|
|
|
|