EPT[OSL] Bacchus 2008 Ro16 Day 3 - Page 26
| Forum Index > Brood War Tournaments |
|
kramus
United States1259 Posts
| ||
|
Catyoul
France2377 Posts
| ||
|
GeLaar
2421 Posts
On January 23 2008 20:57 Alethios wrote: Still a bit confused about what happened there.. They aren't playing again, next match up annouced. I would assume that July won... but i'm not entirely sure. Perhaps a decision is pending? July looked pretty mad. my korean isn't exactly great, but from what i understood from the announcement, it ended with "however, given that bisu had such and such, and july had his hydras, july gets the win." i'm fairly sure about the "july gets the win" part at the end. | ||
Nyovne
Netherlands19141 Posts
| ||
Aesop
Hungary11305 Posts
| ||
|
Alethios
New Zealand2765 Posts
On January 23 2008 20:57 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: oh overtime in all the sports i watch is like next point wins because its a tie i dont watch soccer though yeah haha In some sports (like Rugby), extra time is played simply to make up the time lost during the game due to interruptions and such. So officials ruled that July won? Would have liked to see Bisu concede graciously though. GG anyway | ||
|
kramus
United States1259 Posts
On January 23 2008 21:00 Nyovne wrote: Even with 1 DT out hed have lost, just split the 12 hydras + more on the way and rape everything silly. Nothing 1 DT can do about that hehe. Didn't july not have an overlord there? I know bisu killed one, not sure if there was another already there. | ||
|
GeLaar
2421 Posts
On January 23 2008 21:00 Hittegods wrote: You mean because it's his responsibility to make sure the computers work and are set up correctly? Removing your headphones and your computer crashing aren't really the same thing. yes, it's not the same thing. in savior's case, he did something wrong and they had a rule for it, and he got a penalty point. in bisu's case, he did nothing wrong and they had a rule that would have helped him, and it was not applied. | ||
|
Catyoul
France2377 Posts
| ||
|
OctoPuSs
Canada5279 Posts
| ||
Carnac
Germany / USA16648 Posts
On January 23 2008 21:03 Catyoul wrote: me neither, i voted julyI can't believe the liquibets : | ||
|
diehilde1
Germany522 Posts
On January 23 2008 20:57 Hot_Bid wrote: this is mostly because it's not a mainstream sport, if millions of dollars were on the line, your "honor" goes right out the window sure it's easy to concede when the culture and community is still small and close knit and your entire life isn't banking on one game osl finals, yellow's last chance at an OSL title, 5th game final set this happens, you think he'd not take the option at a regame? what if the prize money was a whole year's salary? but the prize money isnt a whole years salary. And in fact the fans worship the ones with really high sportsmanship, thus these guys make more money from commercials and stuff. If you come with a financial argument, you have to see that things like conceding the game out of manner when it was clearly over are the things that form ur image as an Idol for the fans. The more fans, the more money u can earn. | ||
|
TheTyranid
Russian Federation4333 Posts
Looks like someone is spiraling downwards.  In other news Lee Jae Dong is on an 11 game winning streak and is 16-1 in his last 17 games. With his recent win he also climed to 4'th in ELO peaks behind only Oov, Savior, and Nada and is now an undisputed ass-raping monster. | ||
|
RowdierBob
Australia13427 Posts
It would have be an absolute disgrace if Bisu got a regame there. Rules are there for a reason, but they have to be flexible. If there is any doubt there should be a regame, but this game was 100% July's. | ||
|
Piste
6183 Posts
edit: Why do I mix up yellow and kwanro? do they look like same at all? | ||
|
BlackSphinx
Canada317 Posts
| ||
Hot_Bid
Braavos36401 Posts
On January 23 2008 21:04 diehilde wrote: but the prize money isnt a whole years salary. And in fact the fans worship the ones with really high sportsmanship, thus these guys make more money from commercials and stuff. If you come with a financial argument, you have to see that things like conceding the game out of manner when it was clearly over are the things that form ur image as an Idol for the fans. The more fans, the more money u can earn. i don't think you understand what i'm saying, if progaming was for millions of dollars in salary, an OSL win matters much more than fan perception, as a team will pay for success imo and i talked to mani about this (and we disagree) the best solution is to replay the game from the moment of disconnect (where bisu would 99.99% lose). but since that's not available, they can't award the game to july because there was still a possibility, however small, of him building a gate somewhere in the corner of his base and killing the hydras and coming back. it's like 0.0001% but i think they have to do it. edit: look, i'm not saying the "right" or "fair" outcome didn't happen; july won that game. i'm just saying it's something OGN needs to think hard about. | ||
|
azndsh
United States4447 Posts
On January 23 2008 20:57 Hot_Bid wrote: this is mostly because it's not a mainstream sport, if millions of dollars were on the line, your "honor" goes right out the window sure it's easy to concede when the culture and community is still small and close knit and your entire life isn't banking on one game osl finals, yellow's last chance at an OSL title, 5th game final set this happens, you think he'd not take the option at a regame? what if the prize money was a whole year's salary? I can't say for sure given your extremely stretched and hypothetical situation, but I'd expect him to concede the match if he was seconds away from typing "gg". Progamers are regarded as pop idols and quite differently from athletes in other sports. You do not hear girly screams of delight erupt when someone makes a particularly beautiful jump shot. They act by and are held to a much higher standard of honor and sportsmanship, even if its just by their fans. | ||
|
Catyoul
France2377 Posts
Jeadong top right Backho bottom left P does pylon at his nat | ||
GTR
51638 Posts
| ||
| ||
