I've been at work all day so I'm tired but some thoughts so far

GB stuff on ray is interesting the game I've played with him he approached ray the same way so the idea that rays post is mafia oriented could very well come from town gb so bit of a null just see him as trying to start convo.

I like oats though and yamato so far

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 03:22 GMT

#179

On August 18 2014 12:13 Tehpoofter wrote:

Show nested quote +

What do you like best about yamato? Why do you like him is probably a better question?

I've played twice with yamato once town and once as scum. While in the town game he actually posted and didn't lurk in his scum game he had maybe a page filter. So just based off my experience with him i like that he's posting....as long as he keeps posting and actually delivers on what he says obviously.

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 03:58 GMT

#197

On August 18 2014 12:38 Tehpoofter wrote:

Show nested quote +

He has declared people town not sure what he should be delivering on unless you just mean that in general.

I was mainly talking about in general not things up till this point.

@oats hard to quote more than one on my phone

generally yamato has been decent at readingi like him buti like him but i don't neccessarily have a toqn read atm on him i only have one towny read and a few nulls.

@GB atleast let me respond before throwing suspicion my way after you got called on something. shifting pressure is usually a scummy point me and intentions up to this point since I've been here. And right now

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 11:08 GMT

#246

Why would you give yamato a town read pass right now? You being silly now xat.

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 11:23 GMT

#250

On August 18 2014 20:13 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

Why dont you answer rayn's question before asking other people if they are being silly?

I saw this post and reread the thread again and Ray never asked me any questions he called me scum a few times, which I think is a shitty case at this point but I can see the merits a fluffy post that results in a null is probably the scummiest thing that has taken place in the thread at this point.

And also yea I can say or ask if someone is being silly if I want to you don't run me!

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 11:44 GMT

#253

I wasn't constantly pushing stuff in Neat & Tidy at first it wasn't till almost halfway through the day that I even got my first read out. I think you are pretty dumb for giving yamato a free pass at this early junction into day one he hasn't posted anything useful, I was hoping he would and I could town lean on him but he hasn't.

Xat feels like he is just trying to buddy people and go for a mislynch. If Yamato doesn't post more hes probably going to be mafia and I still really like oats

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 11:48 GMT

#254

On August 18 2014 20:40 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

Oh so this isnt a question?

Please.
##Vote Damdred

Your right I missed that no filters are killing me right now. Actually in the strictest sense of grammar it isn't a question XD. GB is posting a lot like he posted in the one game I played and approached ray the same way, it was interesting to me at the time not so much right now.

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 12:06 GMT

#257

On August 18 2014 20:57 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

So that post had nothing to do with rayn at all then.

What exactly was your read on rayn at that time, its confusing to me.

At the time I was pretty sure that Ray was town but wasn't the cop, and he didn't do anything the rest of his time alive to change my mind about being towny.

On August 18 2014 20:58 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

So why is us giving a free pass to yamato mean that you cant do shit about him? If you think he is scum, then do something about it instead of complaining

I'm not understanding what you are trying to push Oats, I have no way of knowing if hes mafia or not until he posts more or doesn't post more. I'm upset (more like think its dumb) that Xat gives up his scummy read on Yamato in the matter of a few minutes and says he will give him a free pass today for ray.

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 12:19 GMT

#259

On August 18 2014 21:15 Oatsmaster wrote:
Why do you care when you dont even have a scum read on him????

Is it dumb or scummy and why one rather than the other Damdred. You arent explain this very well.

I care because its dumb eliminating a person from your suspect pool an hour into day one, especially someone who has like 5 posts. At this point i'm paranoid of everyone.

Its more dumb than scummy at this point, and i'm probably not its early for me yet.

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 12:48 GMT

#266

I always have a hard time reading Xatalos if i'm to be honest I always find him scummy especially early game. But i'm going to have to say i'm leaning town on him by just a small percent I still think hes being dumb about Yamato but he trusts rays reads atm also just by reading the thread it looks like Xatalos would have the biggest filter day one so even if I did feel hes scummy I wouldn't push a lynch on him at this point its more town xat.

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 14:03 GMT

#274

On August 18 2014 22:46 Oatsmaster wrote:
Man I dont understand this part at all Damdred.

Show nested quote +

Why big filter = town and why wont you push him if you think he is scummy regardless of his filter?

buddy much?

Town Xatalos posts a lot and posts whatever hes thinking whenever in my experience with him. His filter size shows if hes being towny. And what i've noticed hes been pretty open about his reads and opinions isn't scared to be wrong and always tries to explain his thought process. And generally its always a bad idea to lynch into the people with the biggest filters day one normally they aren't mafia, if his play tapers off and he starts to lurk i'll rethink it but i don't think hes a good lynch for day one at all.

And Xat it did feel like you were just sheeping what Ray was saying at first but looking back over the thread I thought it was pretty consitant with what you been saying. So it was probably more of a reaction to being called mafia at this point, so yea i'm pretty town on you right now.

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 14:23 GMT

#284

Xatalos its really hard for me to say who I would be comfortable with lynching right now, most of the people haven't given content thats not fluff right now. A portion of that was them trying to dodge the witch so i'm going to wait a bit longer to decide. However GB throwing suspicion and then leaving the thread and not returning at this point has my interest at the moment.

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 18 2014 14:33 GMT

#285

On August 18 2014 23:19 Oatsmaster wrote:
Who do you know how to read Xata?
Meta totally overrated.

Damdred, please prove to me how Xata has been "open about his reads and thought processes".

While its true that meta is overrated Xata just looks and feels like he did his previous town games I played with him. I can't ignore that and still think its a bad lynch if we were to look at him.

Really hard for me to quote a lot of stuff right now, but Xata filter page 2-4 is pretty open and clear in his thoughts. Beside him getting yamato a pass for ray....Oats do you think that he hasn't been?