EDIT 2: I am not specifically suggesting vortex use should be useless after patch. But there was a reason for the term Archon "Toilet", it is perfectly fine to use vortex for positioning your splash damage units near opponent's army or for closing the distance of your melee units.
Hello guys,
As you know patch 1.3.0 introduced this : Units leaving the Mothership's Vortex are now un-targetable and immune to damage for 1.5 seconds
I was watching CatZ's stream. I think he was practicing with KiWiKaKi and I couldn't manage to get screenshot but:
CatZ enganged KiWiKaKi it was kind of a 200 vs 200 battle. KiWiKaKi used vortex so CatZ jumped into vortex with all his units. (Which was ideal for the situtation at that time) When vortex effect was gone, it was a slaughter again like previous state of the game. CatZ's all units vanished.
It seems that 1.5 seconds is not enough to stop this. I couldn't find any topic about this yet regarding patch 1.3.0.
Has anyone experienced the same thing that CatZ experienced? What are your thoughts about it?
well you need more than 4 archons now to pretty much one kill all units? I mean with 200 army, you can't spread all that at once in 1.5 secs I think what blizzard is trying is limit the damage i guess? Even with the nerf, that doesn't mean you will put your army in the vortex
I actually just put up a video demonstrating the new vortex changes:
The tldr is: archon toilet against mutas is weaker but it still works unless the zerg INSTANTLY micros away when the vortex ends. Mutas unclump very slowly. Also, colossus toilet is still pretty dang strong.
Basically the toilet will no longer 1-shot entire armies but they still do tons of splash damage all at once, making them a real threat
just from my observation of GomJabbar's video (uber kudos for making that btw), vortex basically makes the units immune to the first volley from the archons but the second volley does full damage.
The tldr is: archon toilet against mutas is weaker but it still works unless the zerg INSTANTLY micros away when the vortex ends. Mutas unclump very slowly. Also, colossus toilet is still pretty dang strong.
Basically the toilet will no longer 1-shot entire armies but they still do tons of splash damage all at once, making them a real threat
Archon toilet will be strong against broods or slower units like i said earlier even with nerf you can't just put all your unit in the vortex since it will be harder to pull them out I think its good that blizzard didnt remove it completely and you need to micro out of vortex now
works as expected and is now still a very powerful lategame skill.
small changes to things dont always make them totally useless like very many here in the forums suggest on every patchnote. i dont know how many times i have read that stupid sentence that after 1.3 vortex will be totally useless.
The tldr is: archon toilet against mutas is weaker but it still works unless the zerg INSTANTLY micros away when the vortex ends. Mutas unclump very slowly. Also, colossus toilet is still pretty dang strong.
Basically the toilet will no longer 1-shot entire armies but they still do tons of splash damage all at once, making them a real threat
Awesome! You made a very clear and demonstrative video ^^
Last thing I'm curious is the baneling toilet and what happens...do they deal damage or do they just blow up and fail?
It seems to work better on air units because of how slow they unclump. If the archons can't fire instantly, they'll just fire later, when the mutas are about as clumped as half-stacked micro formation. It's still good, but not as insanely OP as it was.
From my testing, it seems like the archons do the damage you would expect them to do if they got into the middle of a zerg ball, so while you would never get them into such a good position without vortex, they aren't really splashing more units than you would normally expect. The archon toilet is pretty much dead as far as I can tell. Even 20 archons in a toilet didn't really do much.
On March 23 2011 16:53 ReketSomething wrote: Last thing I'm curious is the baneling toilet and what happens...do they deal damage or do they just blow up and fail?
They are untargettable, so I presume that It functions just as if the banelings don't "see" the units. After the 1.5 seconds, they will all explode, perfectly spread throughout the other army.
Edit:NVM actually if I move the non-vortexed colossus closer to the vortex they do much better, perhaps because it removes surface area for the emerging colossus...
What the video above shows isn't archons splashing a bunch of units on their way out of a vortex, its archons splashing a bunch of units. A bunch of archons standing under a bunch of mutalisks is a bloodbath to begin with. If you try using different units, you will see that the vortex is not indeed completely useless. (Just tested it with ultralisks, and they completely spread out before the archons even started attacking the first one.)
Obviously 20 archons was massive overkill pre-patch.
But one thing to note about vortexes...the units appear to pop-out in random places. That time all the archons appeared at the bottom (even though they came in from the top-left). Once I had the archons almost surround the army and it couldn't expand properly and it did way more damage. So theres a bit of luck involved.
The tldr is: archon toilet against mutas is weaker but it still works unless the zerg INSTANTLY micros away when the vortex ends. Mutas unclump very slowly. Also, colossus toilet is still pretty dang strong.
Basically the toilet will no longer 1-shot entire armies but they still do tons of splash damage all at once, making them a real threat
your voice totally sounded like idra there for a second :D
Obviously 20 archons was massive overkill pre-patch.
But one thing to note about vortexes...the units appear to pop-out in random places. That time all the archons appeared at the bottom (even though they came in from the top-left). Once I had the archons almost surround the army and it couldn't expand properly and it did way more damage. So theres a bit of luck involved.
yea I agree, seems like the overall effectiveness of the toilet vs ground units is a little random and obviously not as good as it was. I do feel that its effectiveness vs air units is still very strong. But I'll let the pros decide whether its a tactic worth its cost.