|
United States2822 Posts
Why can't people respect these two people for who they are - among the best of the best at their respective games? The lack of respect for these players or these games in this thread is astounding. I can understand you not liking Warcraft 3 as much as Starcraft as a competitive game, but to go as far as saying Warcraft 3 or its players suck and not having respect for it is absurd.
Speculating on which one is better is pointless now and will be pointless after this showmatch. There are so many factors to take into account that we can't fathom.
|
|
|
On July 18 2009 10:02 Sociopathic wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2009 09:59 Aegraen wrote:On July 18 2009 09:41 Sociopathic wrote:On July 18 2009 09:30 Aegraen wrote:On July 18 2009 09:27 Sociopathic wrote:On July 18 2009 09:14 Aegraen wrote:On July 18 2009 09:11 Sociopathic wrote:On July 18 2009 08:43 Tsagacity wrote:On July 18 2009 08:38 Sociopathic wrote:On July 18 2009 08:31 Comeh wrote: [quote] What is with this belief that progamers don't have any micro capabilities whatsoever? Has anyone seen Flash's marine control... Anyone? im not saying the starcraft pros have bad micro... that would be pretty stupid... but look at it like this: both starcraft and warcraft players are only human being they only have 24 hours a day to do things like sleeping eating training etc. assuming nada isnot a superhero who can do anything: warcraft players pretty much only train microing (cause macro is hilariously easy in wc3 ( and it will be so in sc2 to) starcraft players have to train a good chunk of macro too, cause it is just a part of sc. Warcraft players are just abit more trained in micro than starcraft players are (cause of the time), im not saying starcraft players are bad or anything. Isn't there a pretty big gap in the micro style though? Like microing a battle with 40hp units is a lot different from a battle with 300hp units. it of course is pretty different... it isnot exactly like wc3 neither its exactly like sc (cause abilities are becoming more important and easier to use (cause of intelligent spellcasting)) but my argument that wc3 players are more experienced with micro than sc players still stands. For the majority of SC lifetime micro was the dominant style. Macro has only recently (4 years or so) come of dominance. With that said, WC3 players are not experienced with the fast paced micro style that SC1/2 has. Simply put, one mistake and your army can disappear, this does not happen in WC3. It's going to be a rude awakening to WC3 players. The macro for SC2 also isn't as 'easy' as you claim it is. Even with MBS and auto-mine managing 4-5 bases is going to be on the order of 10^10 more demanding than WC3 macro. well ill probably put all of my unit producting buildings on one hotkeys ( lets imagine 8) and all my worker producing buildings on 9. Pressing 8 z( for example 6 zealots) and 9 p (for a probe in EVERY base(which i dont even have to micro cause automineing) every 20 seconds isnot even nearly as hard as sc micro... its a cakewalk Actually if you wanted 6 zealots you would press 8zzzzzz that is with Gateways, with Warp-gates you can't do that, you have to manually tell the warp-gate where you want to warp-in to. With Terran you have to deal with add-ons, and zerg has the Queen larvae mechanic that will take up a lot of macro. Of course macro will be 'easier' than SC, but it will also be as I said 10^10 of what WC3 requires. WC3 players will not do too well in SC2. Perhaps a few, but the majority are not. even if what u said is true (i still think that only larvae are using the 1 click per unit mechanic, but i could be mistaken) it would be a difference for wc3 AND sc players... the hardest part in sc micro was that you had to be physically in the production area while fighting (cause all of your hotkeys were used by units) this won`t be the case in sc2(u can rebuild units IN the fight without looking away, even in lategame) Let me reiterate. WC3 has nothing in common with SC. SC2 has 90% in common with SC. The gameplay is extremely similar pacewise and tech wise. The transition for SC players will be very easy and fluid. The transition for WC3 players is going to be very painful. To be quite honest, I don't see any WC3 pro even making top 15 in SC2 pro-gaming scene if most of the SC pros decide to come over. For example, I see these players doing better than Moon the defacto best WC3 player: Boxer Savior JD Bisu Flash Stork NaDa Leta JulyZerg Nal_Ra (If he decides to come back for SC2) Berserker/Iris Iloveoov (If he decides to come back for SC2) BaBy (This is probably controversial, I think he is going to do very well in SC2) EffOrt Kal In a Bo5 every single one of these players will wipe the floor with Moon/Grubby/Lyn in SC2. I will bookmark this thread and bring this back up once SC2 pro scene starts to form and take shape. I will also make a bold prediction: Boxer 1st SC2 Bonjwa! Heard it here first  dude u just dont seem to get it? the whole reason starcraft players are good at starcraft is the heavy impact of macro (of course there are a few exceptions but they are few and far between) in sc2 macro will be A FUCKING CAKEWALK. edit: moon isn`t the best wc3 players atm... he may be the one who won the most money, but he isn`t at his prime anymore I feel sorry for you. Poor guy, you didn't see StarCraft in it's most beautiful days - like 8-10 years ago But i DO believe that if you knew all about SC you would stop annoying people who know it more by such wrong statements.
Also SC2 macro won't be such a cakewalk, you will have to return to base to spawn mules/use photon charge/spawn more larvae/select place for new units to warp-in, manage even 3 expos.
On July 18 2009 12:59 scintilliaSD wrote: Why can't people respect these two people for who they are - among the best of the best at their respective games? The lack of respect for these players or these games in this thread is astounding. I can understand you not liking Warcraft 3 as much as Starcraft as a competitive game, but to go as far as saying Warcraft 3 or its players suck and not having respect for it is absurd.
Speculating on which one is better is pointless now and will be pointless after this showmatch. There are so many factors to take into account that we can't fathom. Problem is WC3 players always want to prove their wrong statements that 1 game supports 1 type of management - WC3 relying heavy on micro and SC relying heavy on macro, but in reality SC relies heavy on macro and heavy on micro and in many MU's on unit placement, getting good surrounds. 3-1 for SC, tnx.
|
On July 18 2009 19:24 Kaniol wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2009 10:02 Sociopathic wrote:On July 18 2009 09:59 Aegraen wrote:On July 18 2009 09:41 Sociopathic wrote:On July 18 2009 09:30 Aegraen wrote:On July 18 2009 09:27 Sociopathic wrote:On July 18 2009 09:14 Aegraen wrote:On July 18 2009 09:11 Sociopathic wrote:On July 18 2009 08:43 Tsagacity wrote:On July 18 2009 08:38 Sociopathic wrote: [quote]
im not saying the starcraft pros have bad micro... that would be pretty stupid... but look at it like this:
both starcraft and warcraft players are only human being they only have 24 hours a day to do things like sleeping eating training etc. assuming nada isnot a superhero who can do anything:
warcraft players pretty much only train microing (cause macro is hilariously easy in wc3 ( and it will be so in sc2 to) starcraft players have to train a good chunk of macro too, cause it is just a part of sc.
Warcraft players are just abit more trained in micro than starcraft players are (cause of the time), im not saying starcraft players are bad or anything. Isn't there a pretty big gap in the micro style though? Like microing a battle with 40hp units is a lot different from a battle with 300hp units. it of course is pretty different... it isnot exactly like wc3 neither its exactly like sc (cause abilities are becoming more important and easier to use (cause of intelligent spellcasting)) but my argument that wc3 players are more experienced with micro than sc players still stands. For the majority of SC lifetime micro was the dominant style. Macro has only recently (4 years or so) come of dominance. With that said, WC3 players are not experienced with the fast paced micro style that SC1/2 has. Simply put, one mistake and your army can disappear, this does not happen in WC3. It's going to be a rude awakening to WC3 players. The macro for SC2 also isn't as 'easy' as you claim it is. Even with MBS and auto-mine managing 4-5 bases is going to be on the order of 10^10 more demanding than WC3 macro. well ill probably put all of my unit producting buildings on one hotkeys ( lets imagine 8) and all my worker producing buildings on 9. Pressing 8 z( for example 6 zealots) and 9 p (for a probe in EVERY base(which i dont even have to micro cause automineing) every 20 seconds isnot even nearly as hard as sc micro... its a cakewalk Actually if you wanted 6 zealots you would press 8zzzzzz that is with Gateways, with Warp-gates you can't do that, you have to manually tell the warp-gate where you want to warp-in to. With Terran you have to deal with add-ons, and zerg has the Queen larvae mechanic that will take up a lot of macro. Of course macro will be 'easier' than SC, but it will also be as I said 10^10 of what WC3 requires. WC3 players will not do too well in SC2. Perhaps a few, but the majority are not. even if what u said is true (i still think that only larvae are using the 1 click per unit mechanic, but i could be mistaken) it would be a difference for wc3 AND sc players... the hardest part in sc micro was that you had to be physically in the production area while fighting (cause all of your hotkeys were used by units) this won`t be the case in sc2(u can rebuild units IN the fight without looking away, even in lategame) Let me reiterate. WC3 has nothing in common with SC. SC2 has 90% in common with SC. The gameplay is extremely similar pacewise and tech wise. The transition for SC players will be very easy and fluid. The transition for WC3 players is going to be very painful. To be quite honest, I don't see any WC3 pro even making top 15 in SC2 pro-gaming scene if most of the SC pros decide to come over. For example, I see these players doing better than Moon the defacto best WC3 player: Boxer Savior JD Bisu Flash Stork NaDa Leta JulyZerg Nal_Ra (If he decides to come back for SC2) Berserker/Iris Iloveoov (If he decides to come back for SC2) BaBy (This is probably controversial, I think he is going to do very well in SC2) EffOrt Kal In a Bo5 every single one of these players will wipe the floor with Moon/Grubby/Lyn in SC2. I will bookmark this thread and bring this back up once SC2 pro scene starts to form and take shape. I will also make a bold prediction: Boxer 1st SC2 Bonjwa! Heard it here first  dude u just dont seem to get it? the whole reason starcraft players are good at starcraft is the heavy impact of macro (of course there are a few exceptions but they are few and far between) in sc2 macro will be A FUCKING CAKEWALK. edit: moon isn`t the best wc3 players atm... he may be the one who won the most money, but he isn`t at his prime anymore I feel sorry for you. Poor guy, you didn't see StarCraft in it's most beautiful days - like 8-10 years ago  But i DO believe that if you knew all about SC you would stop annoying people who know it more by such wrong statements. Also SC2 macro won't be such a cakewalk, you will have to return to base to spawn mules/use photon charge/spawn more larvae/select place for new units to warp-in, manage even 3 expos. Show nested quote +On July 18 2009 12:59 scintilliaSD wrote: Why can't people respect these two people for who they are - among the best of the best at their respective games? The lack of respect for these players or these games in this thread is astounding. I can understand you not liking Warcraft 3 as much as Starcraft as a competitive game, but to go as far as saying Warcraft 3 or its players suck and not having respect for it is absurd.
Speculating on which one is better is pointless now and will be pointless after this showmatch. There are so many factors to take into account that we can't fathom. Problem is WC3 players always want to prove their wrong statements that 1 game supports 1 type of management - WC3 relying heavy on micro and SC relying heavy on macro, but in reality SC relies heavy on macro and heavy on micro and in many MU's on unit placement, getting good surrounds. 3-1 for SC, tnx.
I feel sorry for you. Poor guy, you didn't see Warcraft in it's most beautiful days - like today But i DO believe that if you knew all about Wc3 you would stop annoying people who know it more by such wrong statements.
|
|
|
The truth is, I think, that keeping units produced consistently isn't what decides pro level macro. Rather, it's knowing exactly how to maximize your economy for a selected strategy, down to the last resource collector.
Personally, I can keep units producing the entire game without much of a problem, but I'm still D rank on ICCup (on my way to D+, I think). The advantage of pro macro has to do with skillfully managing every aspect of one's economy - not just spending. In that, I think it's safe to say that macro in SC2 still won't be easy, though producing units will.
|
Problem is WC3 players always want to prove their wrong statements that 1 game supports 1 type of management - WC3 relying heavy on micro and SC relying heavy on macro, but in reality SC relies heavy on macro and heavy on micro and in many MU's on unit placement, getting good surrounds. 3-1 for SC, tnx.
so true
warcraft in it's most beautiful days- like today rofl your 17 years old talking about most beautiful wc3 days, go back like 4-5 years
|
i like both gamers but i do think that NaDa will roflstomp Moon ... i mean i think so atleast :O
|
|
|
On July 19 2009 00:42 wiesel wrote:Show nested quote +Problem is WC3 players always want to prove their wrong statements that 1 game supports 1 type of management - WC3 relying heavy on micro and SC relying heavy on macro, but in reality SC relies heavy on macro and heavy on micro and in many MU's on unit placement, getting good surrounds. 3-1 for SC, tnx.
so true rofl  your 17 years old talking about most beautiful wc3 days, go back like 4-5 years
watching games which would by today`s standards not even be remotely good is so beautiful... yeah
it may be less interessting in this time... but the skill evolves
edit: and im 16 thank you very much (and i got a betakey haha)
|
watching games which would by today`s standards not even be remotely good is so beautiful... yeah
it may be less interessting in this time... but the skill evolves
edit: and im 16 thank you very much (and i got a betakey haha)
Not even be remotely good? wtf...Competition was alot tougher back in those days.
|
the competition may have been a lot tougher, but by today`s standard the players 4 years prior were BAD
|
Sry but thats just bullshit. The tactics are mostly outdated ok, but microwise and skill level wise you will see some of the most beautiful actions ever.
|
On July 19 2009 01:02 Sociopathic wrote:Show nested quote +On July 19 2009 00:42 wiesel wrote:Problem is WC3 players always want to prove their wrong statements that 1 game supports 1 type of management - WC3 relying heavy on micro and SC relying heavy on macro, but in reality SC relies heavy on macro and heavy on micro and in many MU's on unit placement, getting good surrounds. 3-1 for SC, tnx.
so true warcraft in it's most beautiful days- like today rofl  your 17 years old talking about most beautiful wc3 days, go back like 4-5 years watching games which would by today`s standards not even be remotely good is so beautiful... yeah it may be less interessting in this time... but the skill evolves edit: and im 16 thank you very much (and i got a betakey haha)
This explains everything. I would recommend to you, to go back and watch every OSL and MSL from semi's to finals from 2000 to 2009.
SC pro's are on another plain over WC3. How many pro WC houses are there? How many WC3 drafts are there? How is SC2 anything similar to WC3? Simply put, the competition in the SC pro scene is much more immense than in the WC3 Pro-scene.
|
On July 19 2009 01:27 Aegraen wrote:Show nested quote +On July 19 2009 01:02 Sociopathic wrote:On July 19 2009 00:42 wiesel wrote:Problem is WC3 players always want to prove their wrong statements that 1 game supports 1 type of management - WC3 relying heavy on micro and SC relying heavy on macro, but in reality SC relies heavy on macro and heavy on micro and in many MU's on unit placement, getting good surrounds. 3-1 for SC, tnx.
so true warcraft in it's most beautiful days- like today rofl  your 17 years old talking about most beautiful wc3 days, go back like 4-5 years watching games which would by today`s standards not even be remotely good is so beautiful... yeah it may be less interessting in this time... but the skill evolves edit: and im 16 thank you very much (and i got a betakey haha) This explains everything. I would recommend to you, to go back and watch every OSL and MSL from semi's to finals from 2000 to 2009. SC pro's are on another plain over WC3. How many pro WC houses are there? How many WC3 drafts are there? How is SC2 anything similar to WC3? Simply put, the competition in the SC pro scene is much more immense than in the WC3 Pro-scene.
starcraft`lers are superhumans who can train 342253456344356345862347894634894523 times faster than other players i get it...
not
|
Starcraft players in korea have a huge training advantage over other gamers how can you even argue about this but yea i'll stop it now, its senseless ...
|
On July 19 2009 01:31 Sociopathic wrote:Show nested quote +On July 19 2009 01:27 Aegraen wrote:On July 19 2009 01:02 Sociopathic wrote:On July 19 2009 00:42 wiesel wrote:Problem is WC3 players always want to prove their wrong statements that 1 game supports 1 type of management - WC3 relying heavy on micro and SC relying heavy on macro, but in reality SC relies heavy on macro and heavy on micro and in many MU's on unit placement, getting good surrounds. 3-1 for SC, tnx.
so true warcraft in it's most beautiful days- like today rofl  your 17 years old talking about most beautiful wc3 days, go back like 4-5 years watching games which would by today`s standards not even be remotely good is so beautiful... yeah it may be less interessting in this time... but the skill evolves edit: and im 16 thank you very much (and i got a betakey haha) This explains everything. I would recommend to you, to go back and watch every OSL and MSL from semi's to finals from 2000 to 2009. SC pro's are on another plain over WC3. How many pro WC houses are there? How many WC3 drafts are there? How is SC2 anything similar to WC3? Simply put, the competition in the SC pro scene is much more immense than in the WC3 Pro-scene. starcraft`lers are superhumans who can train 342253456344356345862347894634894523 times faster than other players i get it... not what the fuck is with this guy? of course you wont get it.
|
i gonna laugh when your elitist world is shattered by wc3 players being as good in sc2 as sc gamers
|
On July 19 2009 01:31 Sociopathic wrote:Show nested quote +On July 19 2009 01:27 Aegraen wrote:On July 19 2009 01:02 Sociopathic wrote:On July 19 2009 00:42 wiesel wrote:Problem is WC3 players always want to prove their wrong statements that 1 game supports 1 type of management - WC3 relying heavy on micro and SC relying heavy on macro, but in reality SC relies heavy on macro and heavy on micro and in many MU's on unit placement, getting good surrounds. 3-1 for SC, tnx.
so true warcraft in it's most beautiful days- like today rofl  your 17 years old talking about most beautiful wc3 days, go back like 4-5 years watching games which would by today`s standards not even be remotely good is so beautiful... yeah it may be less interessting in this time... but the skill evolves edit: and im 16 thank you very much (and i got a betakey haha) This explains everything. I would recommend to you, to go back and watch every OSL and MSL from semi's to finals from 2000 to 2009. SC pro's are on another plain over WC3. How many pro WC houses are there? How many WC3 drafts are there? How is SC2 anything similar to WC3? Simply put, the competition in the SC pro scene is much more immense than in the WC3 Pro-scene. starcraft`lers are superhumans who can train 342253456344356345862347894634894523 times faster than other players i get it... not
i feel a troll... cause everything that he has written sounds like he doesn't know what the hell he's talking about, not only that he's 16...
|
On July 19 2009 02:00 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On July 19 2009 01:31 Sociopathic wrote:On July 19 2009 01:27 Aegraen wrote:On July 19 2009 01:02 Sociopathic wrote:On July 19 2009 00:42 wiesel wrote:Problem is WC3 players always want to prove their wrong statements that 1 game supports 1 type of management - WC3 relying heavy on micro and SC relying heavy on macro, but in reality SC relies heavy on macro and heavy on micro and in many MU's on unit placement, getting good surrounds. 3-1 for SC, tnx.
so true warcraft in it's most beautiful days- like today rofl  your 17 years old talking about most beautiful wc3 days, go back like 4-5 years watching games which would by today`s standards not even be remotely good is so beautiful... yeah it may be less interessting in this time... but the skill evolves edit: and im 16 thank you very much (and i got a betakey haha) This explains everything. I would recommend to you, to go back and watch every OSL and MSL from semi's to finals from 2000 to 2009. SC pro's are on another plain over WC3. How many pro WC houses are there? How many WC3 drafts are there? How is SC2 anything similar to WC3? Simply put, the competition in the SC pro scene is much more immense than in the WC3 Pro-scene. starcraft`lers are superhumans who can train 342253456344356345862347894634894523 times faster than other players i get it... not i feel a troll... cause everything that he has written sounds like he doesn't know what the hell he's talking about, not only that he's 16...
sorry to disappoint you no troll here
|
|
|
|
|
|