in sc2 macro will be A FUCKING CAKEWALK.
It will surely be easier than in BW now but what makes you think it will be a fucking cakewalk? Macro will still be a very heavy factor in Sc2
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
wiesel
Germany727 Posts
in sc2 macro will be A FUCKING CAKEWALK. It will surely be easier than in BW now but what makes you think it will be a fucking cakewalk? Macro will still be a very heavy factor in Sc2 | ||
|
SoleSteeler
Canada5472 Posts
The thing about these top players from both games is they're smart, skilled, and motivated. Not that they have a particular affinity for one style of video game (like only SC or SC2; only War3). Yes, War3's micro is fundamentally different than SC's, and yes SC's is harder (if you really think otherwise you're kidding yourself). THAT DOESN'T MEAN SOMEONE WHO PLAYS WAR3 ISN'T ALSO CAPABLE OF PERFORMING SC-STYLE MICRO. How close to the top level, who knows — it depends on the player. Someone like Moon could potentially train himself to be as good micro-wise as a top SC progamer. Who's to say otherwise? Also, the transition for War3 players to SC2 will be absolutely painless. SC (and thus SC2) is so fundamentally easy to play, there's no reason to think that War3 players will start out and be like, "huh, where's my hero? My TP scroll. Wtf!" They'll learn immediately the basics of the game and adapt. If they don't already know already. (Seriously, who doesn't know at least something about SC now? Especially if you've played War3?) This is called basic human intelligence. To assume that because one person plays War3 and they won't be able to transition to SC2 is absolutely retarded. It's also retarded to predict someones potential. You can't compare the style of Moon to Bisu, for example. Yeah, I would guess Bisu is probably overall more skilled in most regards, but you CAN'T fucking know until you actually see what happens in SC2. To be quite honest, I don't see any WC3 pro even making top 15 in SC2 pro-gaming scene if most of the SC pros decide to come over. is just so incredibly ignorant. How could you possibly come to that conclusion?edit: moved stuff around, a little less aggressive. | ||
|
Skyze
Canada2324 Posts
Its a pointless argument, everyone who hasnt played war3 will just assume bw micro is harder, but they are wrong. BW used to be about micro, but in the past 3-4 years it has really shifted. Now the only time you see insane micro is by the absolute top players, like Bisu and JD. The old days of Boxer, Chojja, Kingdom, etc are pretty much dead, because as amazing as they are in the micro game, they havent evolved to the macro oriented style of play that BW has become. But without the 5-7 years of metagame development and "perfect build orders" figured out, the macro game wont be at the start of SC2, so that takes out all the replay-watching-stealing-builds crowd from the first few years at least, leaving the best players who can micro and adapt to any situation as the top players, such as Boxer and Moon. War3 players are more trained to be aware of their surroundings and strategy because they have to predict creep patterns AND constantly scouting their opponents, where in BW, sure you have to scout but generally you know how the game is gonna play out, all you have to watch for is drops and expos. Another reason War3 players will probably dominate the top of the SC2 ranks when it first comes out is because the absolute top-notch SC players right now, Flash/JD/Bisu/fantasy/etc, will still be playing SC for the next 2-3 years until the money is drained, so they wont make the move right away, while War3 is pretty much a dead game unfortunately in the money section, warranting more to move over to where the money is in SC2. | ||
|
Sociopathic
Germany24 Posts
On July 18 2009 10:25 SoleSteeler wrote: How the fuck can you guys make assumptions on how good War3 players will be in SC2? You think that the micro-heavy, small army mentality is so ingrained in their heads they won't be able to, you know, adjust to a new game? The thing about these top players from both games is they're smart, skilled, and motivated. Not that they have a particular affinity for one style of video game (like only SC or SC2; only War3). Yes, War3's micro is fundamentally different than SC's, and yes SC's is harder (if you really think otherwise you're kidding yourself). THAT DOESN'T MEAN SOMEONE WHO PLAYS WAR3 ISN'T ALSO CAPABLE OF PERFORMING SC-STYLE MICRO. How much the top level, who knows — it depends on the player. Someone like Moon could potentially train himself to be as good micro-wise as a top SC progamer. Who's to say otherwise? Also, the transition for War3 players to SC2 will be absolutely painless. SC (and thus SC2) is so fundamentally easy to play, there's no reason to think that War3 players will start out and be like, "huh, where's my hero? My TP scroll. Wtf!" They'll learn immediately the basics of the game and adapt. If they don't already know already. (Seriously, who doesn't know at least something about SC now? Especially if you've played War3?) This is called basic human intelligence. To assume that because one person plays War3 and they won't be able to transition to SC2 is absolutely retarded. It's also retarded to predict someones potential. You can't compare the style of Moon to Bisu, for example. Yeah, I would guess Bisu is overall more skilled in all regards, but you CAN'T fucking know until you actually see it in actuality. Show nested quote + To be quite honest, I don't see any WC3 pro even making top 15 in SC2 pro-gaming scene if most of the SC pros decide to come over. is one of the most ignorant statements I've heard on these SC2 forums. You have absolutely nothing to back up a statement like that. Nothing whatsoever. quoted for truthness | ||
|
wiesel
Germany727 Posts
not like it's a rocket-science | ||
|
Skyze
Canada2324 Posts
(i know war3 has iccup, but its not used commonly, and this was a joke -_-) | ||
|
wiesel
Germany727 Posts
| ||
|
strack
Germany14 Posts
After a while there will be young skilled players who start playing RTS srsly for the first time and the future belongs to them and not some 40 year old Starcraft player named boxer (no disrespect) and definitely not to WC3 players. Warcraft 3 players will fail hard. I have no respect for anyone who plays that *** It's bad. It's really really bad. | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
Anyway, I don't have the energy to deal with this thread at the moment but I think you are gonna be surprised - there are lots of talented players in the WC3 community, just as in the SC community. | ||
|
Aegraen
United States1225 Posts
On July 18 2009 10:53 FrozenArbiter wrote: Strack, please keep the hatred to a minimum. You don't like the game, fine. No respect? That's kind of.. weird I think. Anyway, I don't have the energy to deal with this thread at the moment but I think you are gonna be surprised - there are lots of talented players in the WC3 community, just as in the SC community. That may be, but in a completely different style RTS. It's like comparing CS1.6 players to Halo3 players. You think if CS2.6 (Not source as it is all noobified) came out that Halo3 players could make the transition and play on a field close to the current CS1.6 pros? Same thing here. No comparison. | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
2) MooN is not some random WC3 player, MooN is THE best WC3 player EVER. 3) While it is a similiar game, it is in the end a new game. General talent will win out early on. Many of the pros (in both games) are just products of mass practice, I don't think their advantage will be too big.. | ||
|
SoleSteeler
Canada5472 Posts
| ||
|
wiesel
Germany727 Posts
On July 18 2009 11:06 FrozenArbiter wrote: 2) MooN is not some random WC3 player, MooN is THE best WC3 player EVER. Run before the Grubby fanboys hit you :D | ||
|
Skyze
Canada2324 Posts
And to strack.. lol you are funny. I wont even reply to someone so uninformed. Keep in mind 90% of the top war3 players are very good at BW also, or was when they played. Very little have just picked up War3 first, most played years of BW too. What about some of the lesser known RTS gosus, like SK.Select (top DOW player I think?) and etc? He will be good at SC2 also. | ||
|
wiesel
Germany727 Posts
On July 18 2009 11:15 Skyze wrote: I think Grubby is more overall successful (not talking about money winnings, but leagues, etc.. his team almost always wins WC3L, due to his excellent play. Most consistant war3 player ever) but Moon is more talented/skilled. Well there's a huge MoonVsGrubby flamewar nearly everyday on german wc3 forums , let's not start it now hehe. Back to Moon vs Nada i just hope for some nice big battles not those rather low economy battle reports. And i root for Nada of course! But both will be offracing a few games i guess, after all its just for show. | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 18 2009 11:10 wiesel wrote: Show nested quote + On July 18 2009 11:06 FrozenArbiter wrote: 2) MooN is not some random WC3 player, MooN is THE best WC3 player EVER. Run before the Grubby fanboys hit you :D Meh Grubby lost 1-2 to Dreiven in SC2 ;P!!! ![]() | ||
|
CongoJack
Canada417 Posts
| ||
|
RyanS
United States620 Posts
On July 18 2009 11:06 FrozenArbiter wrote: 1) MooN is an excellent SC player - easily top foreigner level. 2) MooN is not some random WC3 player, MooN is THE best WC3 player EVER. 3) While it is a similiar game, it is in the end a new game. General talent will win out early on. Many of the pros (in both games) are just products of mass practice, I don't think their advantage will be too big.. *Moon ![]() But yea I think it will be a close match and it is hard to say who would win. I think it would depend on previous experience in the game and who gets in better practice before the match. If they are just thrown in the booths with no practice it will be up to pure talent and lucky guess work on units. | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
![]() And I agree, I hope they both got a chance to practice. If not, I think Moon's chances are excellent as he's played the game many times now. Don't think Nada has been at nearly as many of the events with SC2 as moon has? Neither result would surprise me tho, nor would them not playing at all but simply taking on other players (saving the Moon vs Nada encounter for closer to release). | ||
|
ggfobster
United States298 Posts
On July 18 2009 02:45 wiesel wrote: Moon is so bad nowadays only a former shadow of himself, voted for nada of course Ummm... NO. Have you watched anything recently? Moon has been dominating lately. He's STILL coming up with new strats and beating pros. Just last week I saw a new strat where he builds an expansion BEFORE his hero. He was expanding at like 1:00 minute into the game. Few players do this kind of stuff in the game except Moon (well I'm sure a lot try but no one usually wins except Moon). The only other player that does some incredibly risky and different strats is TH000, who I expect to be a badass at SC2 if he makes the transition (which he probably will because he's still young and upcoming). Can't wait to see Nada and Moon face off. ^^ | ||
| ||
SOOP
SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4
ByuN vs RogueLIVE!
IntoTheiNu
FanTaSy99
Maru
Rex37
ByuN (SOOP)
SHIN
soO31
Classic
herO (SOOP)
Rogue
[ Submit Event ] |
|
|
Replay Cast
Monday Night Weeklies
PiGosaur Cup
The PondCast
OSC
Replay Cast
GSL
Patches Events
OSC
Replay Cast
[ Show More ] KCM Race Survival
RSL Revival
BSL
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
BSL
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
WardiTV Weekly
|
|
|