the obvious conclusion to draw from this is about 55% chance grack is scum and 55% chance sharkie is scum. if vivax or silver is scum we've just gotta take the L on this one

either way I would not nominate either of them for a mission from now on, and I was already hoping we could stay clear of ec and sl, why makes the decision going forward pretty easy. and it's possible that in the future sharkie or grack is obv down but it's not quite there yet from both of them. indirectly rtani is cleared -- not 100% but like 85% -- I guess. if I had the fine fortune of nominating this team it would be pretty obvious me/rtani/vivax/silver for the first four and then a tough choice between grack/sharkie/super. if I had to guess on who I'm misreading it would be super because I am long overdue on a reevaluation
actually lemme adjust that: 65% grack 45% sharkie because I seriously doubt someone who has never played mafia before is thinking ahead and predicting that they're gonna get two sabotages out of passing up the first one. like town cred and how victory mechanics affect that is not something that is apparently obvious in the first game
still go with super though, there are easily three people more likely to be scum than super

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 08 2017 05:45 GMT

#1295

grack/sl/ec is the team that makes the most sense rn and I will approve any team that doesn't have one of them and doesn't have both both super AND sharkie

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 08 2017 15:21 GMT

#1329

looking back at the votes I'm not giving super and ec enough credit... I'd accept either (or both) of them faster than I'd accept sharkie
+ Show Spoiler +

me
silver
vivax
...
rtani
super
ec
...
sharkie
grack
sl

and of course one of grack and sharkie is town, probably, which is the trouble. so really there has to be one of my townleans/nulls that I'm wrong on. feels like a crapshoot whether we get this right. ugh I wanna go back to nominating 3 people

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 08 2017 23:19 GMT

#1411

hahaaaa I'm a fucking idiot. so this is just a four person mission. and one of them is sl. is this a filibuster nomination or did you really think this mission would fly
(I could read the thread for the answer... well, I should... I might, if I'm feeling generous)

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 08 2017 23:23 GMT

#1412

but as it stands sl and grack are dealbreakers on this mission

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 09 2017 15:53 GMT

#1506

On February 10 2017 00:47 emperorchampion wrote:

Show nested quote +

On February 10 2017 00:19 RtaniSoul wrote:

On February 09 2017 21:41 emperorchampion wrote:

On February 08 2017 22:14 Silverika wrote:
I think EC is a spy because he never takes a hard stand on anything. Most of his comments are very blendy and he doesn't stick out on anything.

Rtani Soul is very Town. Not only because of the amount of analysis in the game, but the tone of the posting, the level of frustration, and they make no sense as scum with anyone on the failed mission.

I thought Grack would never fail a mission with sharkie there to take the fall but I'm gonna stop using this kind of stuff to analyze and actually filter dive grack more. There are things from sharkie and Vivax that look pretty Town so I can't write either of them off as spies.

Also, I want to look at that old resistance game so many of you were in. Will do this in a little bit-filter dive grack and look at that game.

~SilverWolf77

Hmm your first two sentences are false. I stood up for my initial team, I stood up against 1 scum on the initial 3, I stood up for super as town, now I'm pretty sure that vivax is town. just nobody cared when the first mission passed, until the second one failed.

On February 08 2017 21:54 RtaniSoul wrote:
EC, who do you currently think is mafia?

ugh fuck, vivax looks like town to me, same with super still. You're maybe town, unfortunately. sharkie thinking vivax is mafia is logical to me, but I don't see vivax as scum here. silver still town. between sharkie and grack, grack probably town. I didn't really like his crazy theory of rtani and vivax. I can see the basis, but I think it's more likely grack mafia then rtani/vivax.

hmm sl I kinda liked his list. I think it's right to exclude grack/sharkie, but I don't trust sl himself. His game position is such that he can just sack himself on the next mission. I think I'm still rolling with sharkie/sl/ +1. +1 is probably tumble, with a pretty outside chance of rtani. sharkie is maaaybe grack, but I think the others are less likely imo.

It is very difficult for me not to call you mafia for believing we're "maybe town" when Vivax said we're an easy townread.
Vivax.
Vivax.

Great so that makes me scum because....

why would you ever listen to vivax

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 09 2017 15:55 GMT

#1510

I don't think vivax has ever maintained this level of activity this long as scum and I think we are safe to write him off

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 09 2017 15:59 GMT

#1512

On February 10 2017 00:54 RtaniSoul wrote:
You also missed the post right below it.

Show nested quote +

On February 10 2017 00:53 Tumblewood wrote:

On February 10 2017 00:47 emperorchampion wrote:

On February 10 2017 00:19 RtaniSoul wrote:

On February 09 2017 21:41 emperorchampion wrote:

On February 08 2017 21:54 RtaniSoul wrote:
EC, who do you currently think is mafia?

It is very difficult for me not to call you mafia for believing we're "maybe town" when Vivax said we're an easy townread.
Vivax.
Vivax.

Great so that makes me scum because....

why would you ever listen to vivax

Welcome back Tumble, I look forward to your many nuggets of wisdom.

pro tip
if you split enough bread tabs in half you can fill up a plastic baggie with half-bread-tabs

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 09 2017 17:26 GMT

#1519

sl has 0 analysis on players beyond x is bad, dumb, emotional, etc idk how anything about his tone + Show Spoiler +

which is basically the same no matter what

makes him townie with that

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 09 2017 17:29 GMT

#1520

lookin at this there are only 5 players in this game trying to convince anyone of anything. ec particularly pisses me off though for how much analysis he has despite that

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 09 2017 18:41 GMT

#1527

silver, because you think grack is confscum does that make sharkie conftown for you?

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 10 2017 22:20 GMT

#1585

unless you think vivax is scum this team is always a reject. and I do not

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 11 2017 18:49 GMT

#1630

this isn't right
objectively grack should be scum or something but there's just no way he's scum. like maybe he's delivering an oscar-winning performance but I just don't see it, the missions say scum but everything else just screams town about him. it's gotta be sharkie or vivax

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 11 2017 18:58 GMT

#1631

gracj do you believe in your team

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

February 17 2017 19:22 GMT

#2286

wow are those replacements a new record? I really feel shitty about missing my vote twice, because it was so stupid and unnecessary. apologies to ec and sharkie, and of course the hosts, for that.
I thought the game was going pretty well for scum till I replaced out, can't say I followed what happened after. seemed like on the third mission scum was creating plenty of chaos and no one's reads lined up. dunno what went wrong but gj to town for whatever it was.
sharkie played a very good first scum game. really impressive except for that first day. silverika did a great job of confirming themselves town, and grack fought the good fight when town turned on him.
overall I think this format takes a little too long for the forum. every player slot had to go through over ten cycles which is a little much for any game
well hosted though. thanks to rels and whoever the cohosts were for running this game