|
On December 20 2016 18:19 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 18:08 Rels wrote:On December 20 2016 18:05 Koshi wrote:I reread Exo and the first 10 pages of the game and nothing Exo did is showing any mafia mindset. I think the case on him boils down to "odd town play". The case Rels makes on Exo, I don't know if that makes him mafia, it is a very odd play for mafia to constantly push such a deep idea while defending. "If you think I am mafia you should also think disformation is mafia, but you don't think disformation is mafia so you are mafia". I am reading Exo more like odd town than cornered mafia. So currently I still don't like disinformation, sicklucker, Alakaslam & Rels. I might really not like Rels. Why ? If you are asking why I don't like you. I don't know yet. But my feels say you are potential mafia.
That is what I'm asking about and this doesn't statisfy me.
Why is SL anything other than null ?
|
On December 20 2016 18:24 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 18:22 Rels wrote:On December 20 2016 18:19 Koshi wrote:On December 20 2016 18:08 Rels wrote:On December 20 2016 18:05 Koshi wrote:I reread Exo and the first 10 pages of the game and nothing Exo did is showing any mafia mindset. I think the case on him boils down to "odd town play". The case Rels makes on Exo, I don't know if that makes him mafia, it is a very odd play for mafia to constantly push such a deep idea while defending. "If you think I am mafia you should also think disformation is mafia, but you don't think disformation is mafia so you are mafia". I am reading Exo more like odd town than cornered mafia. So currently I still don't like disinformation, sicklucker, Alakaslam & Rels. I might really not like Rels. Why ? If you are asking why I don't like you. I don't know yet. But my feels say you are potential mafia. That is what I'm asking about and this doesn't statisfy me. Why is SL anything other than null ? PoE makes his mafia chance higher.
Why are you voting him then ?
On December 20 2016 18:25 Koshi wrote:
Because I like you are here I shall read the latest pages as well. Maybe my feels are off. (wouldn't hope on it)
Because that literally never happened in the history of TL mafia.
... right ? p:
|
Kmatt might be townier that I thought. I didn't like his early posts but that's because I didn't understand the logic. The rest of his filter is pretty natural, especially on exo, and I don't remember Kmatt being a good scum in the last game he played. I will have to reread it at some point to verify that thought.
|
I don't know if I want to lynch disfo. There are things in his filter might indicate him as scum (not his hedging, he's known to do that as town): his first post, his "HF point on me is good" post, his very bad reasonning on SL on Slam. But there are things that are good like this post:
On December 20 2016 04:05 disformation wrote:*sigh* okay, appears I am playing shit tier level currently. have another shit tier post on exo then: Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 02:15 ExO_ wrote:On December 20 2016 02:11 Holyflare wrote:
Then why the fuck are you angry at mafia calling you mafia? What possible reason is there for you to be tilted that he's playing his alignment?
What I'm saying is and what you've now confirmed is you're getting tilted by someone doing a shit play when it's their literal job to do that. It doesn't make sense at all. What if they aren't mafia? I don't like being called mafia at all. Especially for bullshit reasons. Literally look at the end of the most recent game I played. If you think this is getting "tilted" then I get tilted easily I guess. I don't understand why I'm not allowed to be tilted, especially when I say one sentence and am immediately voted and teamed by 2 people. Either way it's far too early in the thread for me to lock into both of them being mafia. So I can't just brush them off entirely. THAT would be a scummy thing to do. basically I can see him reacting badly to a SR on him (as either alignment), because I am prone to doing that, too (as either alignment). So I am thinking NAI here. Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 01:57 ExO_ wrote:On December 20 2016 01:56 Koshi wrote:On December 20 2016 01:53 ExO_ wrote:On December 20 2016 01:47 Koshi wrote:On December 20 2016 01:39 ExO_ wrote:
I'm fairly certain in past games Koshi has said something roughly along the lines of wasting inactive players is a waste of time, and we should focus on finding scum instead. Why is he so ready to lynch inactives now? When there is content to discuss, sitting on your hands and lynching inactives is bad. Is that what I am doing Exo? What am I doing Exo? Can you tell me what I am doing? You and evidently kmatt think that the first post I make into the thread, because it's literally one of the first things I noticed when I realized the game started is making a huge case. I posted one sentence, and suddenly thats a case against kmatt? If you want to talk about overreaction, that's a huge overreaction. He immediately omgus me. I was literally still in bed and it tilted me a bit. And you hop on in support of him right away, and then suggestion we should vote off an inactive. You won't commit to voting me, but I don't see you discussing anything else right now I am fully committing voting you. Just cba to do it on phone. I can only do so much. You are top priority atm. Pls answer my questions truthfully. You are on thin ice. I couldn't care in the slightest about being on thin ice with you. You're a loose cannon. But how can I answer questions if you haven't even asked any? His "I dont give a fuck" attitude towards koshi is rather town than scum imo. The thing that confused me for that most part is that he suddenly brought me up. Yeah Im super biased, deal with it. Cause it does either make no sense or is a super bad deflection attempt. Maybe both? Problem is that town likes to do things that dont do much sense. Another thing that ULTRA confuses me is this (note these two posts are back to back): Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 02:09 ExO_ wrote:On December 20 2016 02:07 Holyflare wrote:
Like the kmart guy could be mafia and exo doesn't even factor that in. Just full on tilt mode for no reason. .....what. That's literally the first thing I implied, and have continued with. just wat Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 02:15 ExO_ wrote:On December 20 2016 02:11 Holyflare wrote:
Then why the fuck are you angry at mafia calling you mafia? What possible reason is there for you to be tilted that he's playing his alignment?
What I'm saying is and what you've now confirmed is you're getting tilted by someone doing a shit play when it's their literal job to do that. It doesn't make sense at all. What if they aren't mafia? I don't like being called mafia at all. Especially for bullshit reasons. Literally look at the end of the most recent game I played. If you think this is getting "tilted" then I get tilted easily I guess. I don't understand why I'm not allowed to be tilted, especially when I say one sentence and am immediately voted and teamed by 2 people. Either way it's far too early in the thread for me to lock into both of them being mafia. So I can't just brush them off entirely. THAT would be a scummy thing to do. Does he believe they are mafia or not? Which is why I asked him to explain his reads again. So his filter makes 0 sense to me, but not making sense is not necessarily scum indicative. So I would love for him to come back and post some actual reads. TBH I am in a super weird spot on ExO_. like he does not make much sense, but I am not finding him too scummy. yet, I dont really have legit scum reads, so he looks like the best bet.
I think this post is hard to do as scum, and even more in disfo's position, when he's been attacked for being on the side on not taking position.
|
On December 20 2016 19:03 Alakaslam wrote:
Rels is too unsure in the wrong places.
Just a vibe; vibes fail me a lot.
Just tossing it out there because fish, mc chicken, I'm voting the vibe. So this vote isn't technically a ninja vote.
(I did this at 2AM but whatever.)
What does that mean ? What am I unsure wrongly about ?
|
On December 20 2016 19:05 Koshi wrote:
I disagree. That post is extremely easy to make as scum. He made shitpost after shitpost, didn't do jack shit the entire time this was being discussed "live", and then at some later point in time he makes a recap post on Exo.
Really not impressed by that.
There are 2 things speaking in disformation his favor:
1) he was quite quickly poe'ed on the right people.
2) his tone is consistently terrible.
He made a recap post that resulted at NO conclusion, when he was under pressured for being waffled. This is NOT easy to make as scum, not the recap part, the not taking position part.
|
On December 20 2016 19:06 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 19:03 Alakaslam wrote:
Rels is too unsure in the wrong places.
Just a vibe; vibes fail me a lot.
Just tossing it out there because fish, mc chicken, I'm voting the vibe. So this vote isn't technically a ninja vote.
(I did this at 2AM but whatever.)
Ty slam. This is really good. Ty.
You're beginning to annoy me
|
On December 20 2016 19:13 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 19:11 Rels wrote:On December 20 2016 19:05 Koshi wrote:
I disagree. That post is extremely easy to make as scum. He made shitpost after shitpost, didn't do jack shit the entire time this was being discussed "live", and then at some later point in time he makes a recap post on Exo.
Really not impressed by that.
There are 2 things speaking in disformation his favor:
1) he was quite quickly poe'ed on the right people.
2) his tone is consistently terrible. He made a recap post that resulted at NO conclusion, when he was under pressured for being waffled. This is NOT easy to make as scum, not the recap part, the not taking position part. Is this opposite world?
Nope.
But if they're partners though everything I've just said doesn't hold weight actually.
|
On December 20 2016 19:15 Alakaslam wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 19:09 Rels wrote:On December 20 2016 19:03 Alakaslam wrote:
Rels is too unsure in the wrong places.
Just a vibe; vibes fail me a lot.
Just tossing it out there because fish, mc chicken, I'm voting the vibe. So this vote isn't technically a ninja vote.
(I did this at 2AM but whatever.)
What does that mean ? What am I unsure wrongly about ? some of your stances on disformation, some of your ideas regarding who would be scum why, that kind of thing. I find it odd though, what could I have meant? I find that I am really unclear, even in IRL with people. That probably explains lots of people's confusion with me on here. I am just a really bad communicator. Like I would assume people would get what I meant from what I said, that they'd see the subtleties I intended rather than others. So I wouldn't think the subtleties through like what could I even mean
wat
|
The thing is, he was pressured to take a stance and he made a big post with qutoes in it, to have no conclusion. It's so obviously scummy that I have doubts scum!disfo would post it without changing the conclusion to be "exo could be scum maybe" or whatever.
|
On December 20 2016 19:23 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 19:22 Rels wrote:
The thing is, he was pressured to take a stance and he made a big post with qutoes in it, to have no conclusion. It's so obviously scummy that I have doubts scum!disfo would post it without changing the conclusion to be "exo could be scum maybe" or whatever. THAT IS NOT HOW THIS GAME WORKS.
Yep it is, and you will STOP yelling at me
|
On December 20 2016 19:25 Koshi wrote:
And the conclusion is "exo could be scum maybe"
Like what the fuck are you even doing Rels?
fuck it IS true. He said he has no opinion but at the same time that exo is the best lynch
|
K I was wrong. Still I'm fucking annoyed at the fucking negativity I received.
On December 20 2016 07:59 disformation wrote:Alright fair enough. With majority lynch in mind, we probably have to consolidate on ExO_ regardless. Unless he comes back with some really good stuff. While we are at good stuff: @Rels: Hey, psst. Yeah, you. You look like the type. Got any of those: + Show Spoiler +
This is bad since he has no read on ExO but is OK to lynch him multiple posts
|
On December 20 2016 19:32 Holyflare wrote:
Also exo's appeal to emotion is not doing it for me. There should be a wall of text on disformation there instead. Disformation has done everything exo should be calling him mafia for, the confirmation bias should be extremely strong.
But appealing to emotion instead....
Yep it was only emotional stuff in it
|
On December 20 2016 19:15 Alakaslam wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 19:09 Rels wrote:On December 20 2016 19:03 Alakaslam wrote:
Rels is too unsure in the wrong places.
Just a vibe; vibes fail me a lot.
Just tossing it out there because fish, mc chicken, I'm voting the vibe. So this vote isn't technically a ninja vote.
(I did this at 2AM but whatever.)
What does that mean ? What am I unsure wrongly about ? some of your stances on disformation, some of your ideas regarding who would be scum why, that kind of thing. I find it odd though, what could I have meant? I find that I am really unclear, even in IRL with people. That probably explains lots of people's confusion with me on here. I am just a really bad communicator. Like I would assume people would get what I meant from what I said, that they'd see the subtleties I intended rather than others. So I wouldn't think the subtleties through like what could I even mean
Now that the thing on disfo is settled, please expand on the bolded.
|
On December 20 2016 19:38 disformation wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 19:33 Rels wrote:K I was wrong. Still I'm fucking annoyed at the fucking negativity I received. On December 20 2016 07:59 disformation wrote:Alright fair enough. With majority lynch in mind, we probably have to consolidate on ExO_ regardless. Unless he comes back with some really good stuff. While we are at good stuff: @Rels: Hey, psst. Yeah, you. You look like the type. Got any of those: + Show Spoiler + This is bad since he has no read on ExO but is OK to lynch him multiple posts If you paid attention ExO_ is in my poe...
I have a problem with that. Your whole "recap" post on him was looking like you were gonna say he's a null read or something like that. There is a disconnect with your reasonning and ExO being your main scumread.
|
On December 20 2016 19:40 disformation wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 19:40 Rels wrote:On December 20 2016 19:38 disformation wrote:On December 20 2016 19:33 Rels wrote:K I was wrong. Still I'm fucking annoyed at the fucking negativity I received. On December 20 2016 07:59 disformation wrote:Alright fair enough. With majority lynch in mind, we probably have to consolidate on ExO_ regardless. Unless he comes back with some really good stuff. While we are at good stuff: @Rels: Hey, psst. Yeah, you. You look like the type. Got any of those: + Show Spoiler + This is bad since he has no read on ExO but is OK to lynch him multiple posts If you paid attention ExO_ is in my poe... I have a problem with that. Your whole "recap" post on him was looking like you were gonna say he's a null read or something like that. There is a disconnect with your reasonning and ExO being your main scumread. Since when do I have scumreads this game?
You JUST JUSTIFIED YOURSELF saying he's in your POE
|
On December 20 2016 19:42 disformation wrote:
Like my "conclusion" on ExO_ was litterally: he is pretty nully cause I cant make sense of him, but at the same time he looks the worst of all players.
that is not really a scumread
Then replace "main scumread" by "main lynch candidate".
|
On December 20 2016 19:43 Alakaslam wrote:
^^ ok
See vote thread
Goodnight people
On December 20 2016 19:35 Rels wrote:Show nested quote +On December 20 2016 19:15 Alakaslam wrote:On December 20 2016 19:09 Rels wrote:On December 20 2016 19:03 Alakaslam wrote:
Rels is too unsure in the wrong places.
Just a vibe; vibes fail me a lot.
Just tossing it out there because fish, mc chicken, I'm voting the vibe. So this vote isn't technically a ninja vote.
(I did this at 2AM but whatever.)
What does that mean ? What am I unsure wrongly about ? some of your stances on disformation, some of your ideas regarding who would be scum why, that kind of thing. I find it odd though, what could I have meant? I find that I am really unclear, even in IRL with people. That probably explains lots of people's confusion with me on here. I am just a really bad communicator. Like I would assume people would get what I meant from what I said, that they'd see the subtleties I intended rather than others. So I wouldn't think the subtleties through like what could I even mean Now that the thing on disfo is settled, please expand on the bolded.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
![[image loading]](http://previews.123rf.com/images/johanspeed2/johanspeed21007/johanspeed2100700020/7332635-Isolated-Reeds-on-shore-in-swamp-wetland-Stock-Photo-reeds.jpg)
3876
1155
350
EPT
