Bavarian Nightkills - Page 15

On July 06 2016 03:47 prplhz wrote:

What Palmar games you checking up on and what are your findings?

On July 06 2016 03:59 Palmar wrote:

Oh I'll compare a nice best of series for y'all to read when I'm home

On July 06 2016 04:02 prplhz wrote:

i didn't ask for this

On July 06 2016 03:54 Shapelog wrote:

I don't mean now, I just mean in general. Meta only gets you so far, and can fuck you in the late game/lylo (sorry kush)

What am I over analyzing? If you have read X Reason to Town read Palmar based off of what you read, you shouldn't be psyched out by a win rate. Especially for your next point, where you said that we have played with each other before. We could tell you if your point stands or not with our knowledge.

You also do realize that Palmar has voted 2 people, 1 based off of fake tone, and the other cuz he is damdred right?

And yes, it can be obv is someone is playing different (aka scum) but even if you read their games, it will be harder if you haven't played. Not impossible, but still harder. IF you really want to, sure. As you said, the game is kinda slow. But if you have a reasoning like with Palmar, say it. Maybe add at the bottom "I've noticed that Palmar wins a lot. So it has me worried." to express it.

On July 06 2016 01:27 Damdred wrote:
Zzz koshi almost confirms himself

On July 06 2016 04:04 Damdred wrote:
Koshi can go into town pile anyway just because hes reading and seems relaxed in his talking.

Damdred
Koshi
Ve
Palmar
Kush

@shape idk I didn't really pay attention to noir I don't think I played in it. But my experience with Kush is the opposite. I will reevaluate as I go obviously.

On July 06 2016 04:11 Vivax wrote:
Damdred I still don't understand how you formed your kush TR, but my guess is that it's not the same reason VE would mention.

Shape too pointed out how kush played in noir and I'm not going to settle down for you townreading him cause his thought process was good cause?

I think your reasoning there was very lazy. If I can think of a reason to TR kush it's not that his thought process was good.

On July 06 2016 01:56 sicklucker wrote:


well being mafia it was literally my job =]

On July 06 2016 01:28 VayneAuthority wrote:
because thats rule #394 of the internet, if you use mean/bad words then you are angry irl and you are a meanie

if you insult people in a passive aggressive way you are witty and probably a wealthy businessman or doctor

On July 06 2016 04:15 prplhz wrote:




Koshi from "almost confirmed" to "town pile anyway" in 2 hours?

This is just a list of people you've played the most with before. It's pretty underwhelming.

On July 06 2016 04:15 prplhz wrote:




Koshi from "almost confirmed" to "town pile anyway" in 2 hours?

This is just a list of people you've played the most with before. It's pretty underwhelming.

On July 06 2016 02:48 Damdred wrote:


Kush basically is a barely existing scum player IMO, he has a couple games probably that are ok. But generally super lucky doesn't push anything and has a hard time faking tone/content.

While I think it's early he at least had some thought process which I thought was good of him.

I'm not narcissistic though just honest teehee

On July 06 2016 04:17 Race Bannon wrote:


Meh


Okay, apart from flavor the amusement in forum mafia depends entirely on interaction and there are numerous obstacles to be overcome, some of them not initially apparent.

It requires long-term attention, effort and nonchalance, but good luck realizing you're failing or making others fail at the 3rd requirement before it's too late to let it slide; nevertheless swearing and busting balls can make up a considerable percentage of the fun which tightening regulations on freedom of expression would dampen.

So with all this investment that we know this game is good at luring there's a high risk of the rewards falling short, even if you're victorious.

Once upset there's nothing worse than having to tiptoe on the edges of the rules of conduct in order to circumvent getting penalized while still communicating what is on one's mind with high fidelity to emotions. Some might be more talented at this than others but is this the skillset people want to exhibit in a game of mafia?

Fuck no, I think finding scum and manipulating town into mislynching townies while having a jolly time is, but if someone gets between you and your rewarding experience chances are that holding back will only creep up on you later.

On July 06 2016 03:29 Vivax wrote:
Related is badly worded. To put it simple you chain a lot of different stuff together and I read it as lack of emphasis and interest. I tend to be very extensive about an argument if I believe it's the right one, while you seem to talk about (figuratively speaking) dozens of different things that don't have much to do with each other.

You reply to DCW, reply something to RB, talk about kushs alignment, talk about Palmar, talk to Jinx, if I break down your post into parts.

I guess it feels...confusing? to me. Like your purpose is not to pursue who you think is mafia but just to reply to as many things as possible. I would like to call it scummy but I'm still on the fence.

On July 06 2016 04:18 Damdred wrote:


I don't think this is true in any sense of the word. I have played a lot with Koshi and Palmar.

Kush is hit and miss, VE is a seldom played with. And that Damdred fellow i just can't escape him or his bad posts.

As for that I at least have reads that I have in thread that people can talk about instead. What are your reads exactly prp?

On July 06 2016 03:31 Shapelog wrote:
Anyways, going to the Palmar meta point I keep Referencing.
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/509751-names-are-hard-mini-mafia?user=Palmar

It is interesting to compare these two, cause while Palmar does do the same thing (Damdred is scum/vote in Name, Koshi is scum/vote here.) they way they went about it is different.

One thing in name though, that he did more there then here, was push the damdred lynch. He might of made a joke post, but he was back on it. Aka, he was more focused on the lynch then joking.

Here, it is IMO different, almost reversed. While he is pushing a Koshi push here and there, he has a bunch of other posts in-between. Most of which are jokey, and while he does go back to the Koshi vote, It seems honestly more to piss off Koshi then anything else.

The damdred off vote also is less bitey then the switch to me in name.

Thoughts?

On July 06 2016 04:29 Race Bannon wrote:

Okay shape is town too.