[W][M] Newbie Mafia XXI - Page 2

On June 05 2016 01:18 blkcoffee wrote:


So what exactly is your read. If he flipped what would he be in your opinion?

On June 05 2016 01:51 blkcoffee wrote:


Sorry I wasn't clear. Right now what is your read on qt? I'm not really too bothered on your read of him after he flips.

On June 05 2016 02:35 Tumblewood wrote:

that's not counterproductive to the town though
oh my... have you heard of the player "Palmar"? most people regard him as one of the best players on the site, and he almost never substantiates his reads or answers questions on D1. This is his filter from the last game he played.
One can be helpful to town without backing up what one says.

On June 05 2016 06:33 Fecalfeast wrote:
I'm tired of phone reading with my girlfriend here so I'll just post what i have so far

Super probably didn't roll scum for the 10th time.
Jealous is making posts i don't really want read but is being towny
Quicktwist is being trolly but having moments of clarity so i can't be too upset with him

I think skynx is scummy because he is hardly commenting on anything relevant when he posts while also not chatting it up or anything. Posting for the sake of posting

I'm only on page 27 so grains of salt all around

I'm going for slurpees anyone want anything?

On June 05 2016 22:31 Superbia wrote:
Skynx can you give me some updates regarding your thoughts atm?

On June 05 2016 22:57 QuickTwist wrote:


No response from them on this.

On June 04 2016 09:37 Skynx wrote:

Yeah i changed my mind now. QT and Superbia was just spamming and me tunnel visioning one of them didn't help. Newbie mistake.
They both sound scummy.

On June 06 2016 03:22 Tictock wrote:
Skynx was brought up and I had some misgivings regarding his opening (was going to include him in my post yesturday but ran out of time).



I'm really not a fan of this opening because he's useing a one line rule to throw out very unfounded reads. There is also no indication that he is actually trying to apply the rule he's using here. "Town likes clarity" into "sounds towny" or "keeps things clean".

I really have a hard time understanding why Super would have been the most scummy based on the criteria of contentless posts as well.

This also bugged me


Really odd dodgy answer after he very clearly gave QT a townread in his open (or at least a lean).

I also find it pretty interesting how he refines his read of QT but his read on Super remains static.


Since I'm finding QT fairly scummy myself I tend to agree with Skynx's little case on him, but I'm also aware that a fair few of his points were just parroting what had been mentioned already.

I might be pretty fine with lynching Skynx today.

---

Disclaimer: This post was written over a much longer period of time than it should have. There has been a random bit of roommate drama over that past hour so I've been a little distracted while trying to put my thoughts together.

I'm gunna take a bit to resolve things then I'll do my little skim-over/catch-up and see how things feel as we are getting into EoD here.

On June 05 2016 01:51 blkcoffee wrote:


Sorry I wasn't clear. Right now what is your read on qt? I'm not really too bothered on your read of him after he flips.

On June 06 2016 00:00 QuickTwist wrote:
OK I reread the thread, here are my reads:

Skynx and Ticktock are far and away my strongest scum reads and I really want one of them to get lynched today. I would be OK with a scott lynch.

The Town AF people are:

Emperorchampion
blkcoffee
beentheredonethat
Tumblewood

These are the people I will not be voting all game.

On June 06 2016 07:57 Tictock wrote:


Oh hello there.

On June 07 2016 14:22 Superbia wrote:


Guy said he was afk for strategic reasons and has been defensive