|
On October 21 2015 05:22 sicklucker wrote:
to the newbs claiming a dead role (at first as a joke) and then as a why the hell not ill draw the nk.
Theres no way I do this as mafia theres no strategic advantage to draw out the veg cc. If i claimed cop sure but the veg is a dead role.
RELS HOW DO YOU THINK IM MAFIA HERE. i told you not to make an even better claim last game because it put you and moosy in a deadlock where one of you is always scum. I would never do this as scum and you know it your blowing my mind right now please dont leave im going to convince your moron ass
That's the thing, SL
It will automatically put you in a deadlock. In this case, you are going to die because you did what you did.
It's what I said, really. You could really be town role swapping, or you could be mafia trying to look you're town role swapping.
Which makes your claim a shit argument to decide if I should vote you or not.
|
On October 21 2015 05:28 boxerfred wrote:
thing is, why would scum fakeclaim a vig if the vig already shot? it just doesn't make sense to me. you'd exchange a scum member vs. a named town. not sure if I'm willing to jump on sicklucker here especially since others (namely shining and fecalfeast) managed to stay under everyone's radar.
Exactly. That's why I'm telling everyone to not consider SL's claim when analysing if he is scun or not. He could've done it regardless of alignment
|
On October 21 2015 05:28 sicklucker wrote:
which i instantly rescinded *
It doesn't matter, you could've done it as any alignment.
I'm voting you because of your lackluster push on lone meow and because drunk bear said so. He can't be wrong.
|
On October 21 2015 05:33 boxerfred wrote:
how about we drop the rels/sl stuff because I start thinking both are town and either follow the first scumreads (mainly eversince) or look into people that dropped kinda under the radar (ff/shining/vonthin)? Or, we set up some tinfoil theory about farah? though I still think we can do an associative read between farah/eversince since she made that D1 case on him which was strong.
SL is still a scum read of mine. So no 
|
On October 21 2015 05:33 boxerfred wrote:
how about we drop the rels/sl stuff because I start thinking both are town and either follow the first scumreads (mainly eversince) or look into people that dropped kinda under the radar (ff/shining/vonthin)? Or, we set up some tinfoil theory about farah? though I still think we can do an associative read between farah/eversince since she made that D1 case on him which was strong.
What?????
|
On October 21 2015 05:41 boxerfred wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2015 05:40 GlowingBear wrote:On October 21 2015 05:33 boxerfred wrote:
how about we drop the rels/sl stuff because I start thinking both are town and either follow the first scumreads (mainly eversince) or look into people that dropped kinda under the radar (ff/shining/vonthin)? Or, we set up some tinfoil theory about farah? though I still think we can do an associative read between farah/eversince since she made that D1 case on him which was strong. What????? read the following sentence. Eversince flip as scum will confirm farah as town. Everything else can be tinfoilhatted into oblivion.
But why do you suggest we tinfoil things???? I mean, it doesn't make sense
|
The fact that you're only commenting about this now makes me think you're mafia
|
On October 19 2015 20:32 KelsierSC wrote:
well there wasn't that much to catch up on really so I'm going to post where i'm at.
starting with the most important part, scum reads
Moosy - His spammy opening was no good and the feeling I got from the entire opening exchange was that mafia was in there. I'm not going to repeat the whole line of questioning about vonthing but it showed he was just spamming and asking questions for the sake of it with no real care for the answer, he hasn't returned to do anything since that point. I'm still waiting on a few things but he is scum right now
scott31337 This is two fold really, I think Rels caught him out first with how he interacted with moosy , how he pretended he knew it was a joke. The second part is on his return he didn't actually clarify that point and talked about something else and then disappeared, once again i'm waiting on his return but it looks like lack of interest/reading.
eversince I mean...perhaps I am biased in this case. His "catch up" entrance to the thread was with a point about shinings opening post. Then he got into ff about not explaining reads. After that he moves onto me, calls me the lync says i'm mucking up the thread and then after deciding i'm scum he then produces the case on me, I think I provided a decent refutation to that case and after that he just disappeared.
To me it seemed his entrance was picking on some random people and then jumping on the leading lynch target but it showed he hadn't really read the thread properly. Furthermore his case felt like he called me scum then read my filter and had to find things to call me scummy.
I'd lynch either of these 3 right now.
In the next tier of players who I don't like/scum lean
vonthin - started off as a townlean for me but he has really fallen off, hasn't posted anything since his list pos It seems to be based mostly on the start of the game and who shit posted the most , with things moving on he really needs to do something.
lonemeow - I agree with what boxerfred said really and his play has just been nothing so far
I have some people who I think are town but not too many, you guys are sort of lazy
Rels I like the points on scott, I think he's been active and sensible so far. In general I like the way Rels posts but yeh i'm calling him town
farah newbie willing to engage and give thoughts. probably town
SL calling him town and moving on
then a few people who are like town leaning but it's not really based on too much
GB - like I got mad at him but I seem to do that all the time and it's best to step back a bit. Lot of people think he's sort of town and he was trying to be relatively serious. I'm waiting to see what he does as we near deadline.
FF - I liked his attitude coming in but he hasn't posted that much
BF - liked some of his posts, probably should post more
Shining - Can't really see any malicious agenda behind his questioning.
That's what i'm thinking, if I missed you off then you are probably scum.
Kelsier last list post. Reminding that he brought strong suspicions on Eversince.
Farah can you explain to me what on Eversince made you think he is town?
|
FF, I didn't have a scumread on you. I thought you could be scum. It could mean you were trying to hammer scott. So I voted Eversince.
It would also make more clear for further VCA when the wagons got the same numbers of voters. If Eversince is scum then mafia surely needed to hammer scott.
And to be fair the fact that you took the effort probably means you're town.
|
On October 21 2015 18:51 Rels wrote:Show nested quote +On October 21 2015 18:38 GlowingBear wrote:
And to be fair the fact that you took the effort probably means you're town. How sure are you of that fact ? I checked FF's meta, and 3 mafia games out of 4 he had a gigantic filter with a lot of trash in it. So it's pretty different from this game obviously.
I've played games with him before and for what I remember he is pretty effortless, especially if he isn't on the chopping block.
The fact that he built a case on me when nothing was happening makes him very townie to my eyes.
I must say I'm having a fairly bad time at reading the newbies.
I won't change my vote today, my best bet on scum is on SL considering his gameplay only. Also the fact that one confirmed town (two, because I'm confirmed town to me) and no other people jumped on his wagon makes it really suspicious. I'd expect mafia to push his wagon.
|
On October 21 2015 13:09 FarahBlackwing wrote:
So von and sicklucker are super dumb telling I think is the phase.
Which is sorta good because I want to eliminate von from the pool now.
Sorry, is this your first mafia game?
|
On October 22 2015 00:16 FarahBlackwing wrote:
Already have given my reasoning on town reading shining.
And yes this is my first mafia game.
When did you get to learn this term "dumb tell"?
|
On October 22 2015 00:24 FarahBlackwing wrote:
After my initial question(about busses) I looked up terms/items to have a better understanding of some things so I didn't clutter the thread and asked questions. That's where I got the terms dumb tells/omgus and a few others.
Can you link me to the place you found it?
|
Farah can you link me the place where you got the information?
|
On October 22 2015 00:57 FarahBlackwing wrote:
I already did GlowingBear
Fair enough
|
On October 22 2015 01:34 Rels wrote:RIGHT ?
LOLOLOLOLOL
|
I want every people who isn't reading sicklucker as scum to tell me what makes him town EXCEPT the claim.
|
On October 22 2015 01:49 MoosyDoosy wrote:Show nested quote +On October 22 2015 01:28 FarahBlackwing wrote:
Moos why were you so against lynching ever yesterday to the point of misrepresenting me. And today you are super onboard when nothing changed from yesterday I care about ~30% for this game up from the small 8% or so that I had. I also had just ignored Ever's big posts until I gave a go through her filter.
Let me help you then
##Unvote
##Vote: moosydoosy
|
On October 22 2015 03:49 Eversince wrote:
Glowing when I couldn't wrap my head around the Sick claim yesterday I was giving mafia vibes to you.
Rels reiterates basically what I was pondering to the note why not pick at him?
It's not about WHAT you said, it is about the initial disinterest you had on the claim.
I mean, there was a claim AND a counter claim but instead of dropping any discussion you were having to give thoughts about it, you kept pushing Boxerfred. I would expect a townie to immediately react to the claims. Unless you know both their alignmebts, so it is disinteresting
|
On October 22 2015 03:58 MoosyDoosy wrote:
I think it's cute how boxerfred thinks that I care if I'm lynched or that his vote is supposed to pressure. lol.
No it's cute that you keep scumreading him even after you voted WITH him last day
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
