|
On January 21 2015 01:43 Holyflare wrote: I think all your points about other players today are based on "if a player flips x" vivax. It's kind of bad tbh
Then wait for what I will post if SL flips scum, cause mafia might as well concede afterwards.
|
On January 21 2015 01:47 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 01:41 Vivax wrote:On January 21 2015 00:56 Damdred wrote: lol you aren't accosting me
Marv is more than likely town, I spoke earlier that his tone is way different than when he is mafia it doesn't really sound dejected and he seems to be enjoying himself while hes playing. His push seems sincere and even his tiff with Vivax looks ok. I wouldn't lynch him today at all Will go back to this post if SL flips scum today. Cause it looks nothing except like a post to somehow make yourself look better with marv. What would you expect him to say about me?
I would expect him to focus on the SL issue cause my theory assuming SL scum flip invovles Damdred being scum and thus right now Damdred is just trying to improve his odds of survival by buddying you.
|
On January 21 2015 02:34 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 01:47 marvellosity wrote:On January 21 2015 01:41 Vivax wrote:On January 21 2015 00:56 Damdred wrote: lol you aren't accosting me
Marv is more than likely town, I spoke earlier that his tone is way different than when he is mafia it doesn't really sound dejected and he seems to be enjoying himself while hes playing. His push seems sincere and even his tiff with Vivax looks ok. I wouldn't lynch him today at all Will go back to this post if SL flips scum today. Cause it looks nothing except like a post to somehow make yourself look better with marv. What would you expect him to say about me? I would expect him to focus on the SL issue cause my theory assuming SL scum flip invovles Damdred being scum and thus right now Damdred is just trying to improve his odds of survival by buddying you.
Like, my theory is: Damdred knows SL will flip scum and thus focuses on posting townreads on the people who are pushing SL.
|
Time for a quick Kelsier filter dive cause he would be the third in my scum team with SL and I want to see if I can find clues that point towards that.
|
HF just give me a break. I'm scumhunting in a really unusual way right now. If SL is mafia you will call me a genius afterwards.
|
ALSO: I just checked the voting thread. Why isn't KSC voting SL?
He isn't commenting on any of the reasons marv and HF posted, instead
His latest posts:
On January 21 2015 01:14 KelsierSC wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 01:13 sicklucker wrote: You guys scum read me everygame tho especially you dandred. Dandred name one game where you didnt scum read me. You cant. that isn't a good argument
Kelsier disagrees with SL. Ignores marv and HF arguments for SL being scum.
On January 21 2015 01:11 KelsierSC wrote: so dam, your main reasons for scum reading SL would be the "anger at lian" thing?
Followup on this: 0. Does he try to push suspicion on Dam afterwards?No, he does this:
On January 21 2015 01:25 KelsierSC wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 01:24 Half the Sky wrote: Nope. I remembered the thing with Lian because Lian had been calling him out from the beginning. alright. you didn't mention him dodging the question about damd? that felt like a big sidestep
Instead of going further after Dam, he tries to sway discussion to HTS to protect both Dam and SL.
On January 21 2015 01:28 KelsierSC wrote:sorry dam can you answer this for me Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 01:11 KelsierSC wrote: so dam, your main reasons for scum reading SL would be the "anger at lian" thing?
This still hasn't been answered by Dam. Yet Kelsier feels it's more important to go after HTS at the moment.
Trust me guys. We lynch SL today, and all these interactions I just displayed will display that Dam and Kelsier are his scumbuddies. + The way Kelsier tried to buddy marv and push suspicion on me when we were fighting while both town.
If SL flips town then..I'll have to go back to my old theory.
|
On January 21 2015 02:48 batsnacks wrote: Marv vivax is still doing that thing you voted him for earlier. The only thing that's changed is you're not the target.
Wait? WHat are you alluding to?
THat I try to find all scum at once? If SL flips scum I'm nominating myself for best town 2015.
|
On January 21 2015 03:00 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 02:57 Vivax wrote:ALSO: I just checked the voting thread. Why isn't KSC voting SL? He isn't commenting on any of the reasons marv and HF posted, instead His latest posts: On January 21 2015 01:14 KelsierSC wrote:On January 21 2015 01:13 sicklucker wrote: You guys scum read me everygame tho especially you dandred. Dandred name one game where you didnt scum read me. You cant. that isn't a good argument Kelsier disagrees with SL. Ignores marv and HF arguments for SL being scum. On January 21 2015 01:11 KelsierSC wrote: so dam, your main reasons for scum reading SL would be the "anger at lian" thing?
Followup on this: 0. Does he try to push suspicion on Dam afterwards?No, he does this: On January 21 2015 01:25 KelsierSC wrote:On January 21 2015 01:24 Half the Sky wrote: Nope. I remembered the thing with Lian because Lian had been calling him out from the beginning. alright. you didn't mention him dodging the question about damd? that felt like a big sidestep Instead of going further after Dam, he tries to sway discussion to HTS to protect both Dam and SL. On January 21 2015 01:28 KelsierSC wrote:sorry dam can you answer this for me On January 21 2015 01:11 KelsierSC wrote: so dam, your main reasons for scum reading SL would be the "anger at lian" thing?
This still hasn't been answered by Dam. Yet Kelsier feels it's more important to go after HTS at the moment. Trust me guys. We lynch SL today, and all these interactions I just displayed will display that Dam and Kelsier are his scumbuddies. + The way Kelsier tried to buddy marv and push suspicion on me when we were fighting while both town. If SL flips town then..I'll have to go back to my old theory. You really aren't reading the thread are you vivax? I have answered that question?
Sorry could you repeat your reasons for scumreading SL cause I didn't find the answer in your filter while I had Kelsier, Damdred and SL open at the same time.
|
On January 21 2015 03:01 Holyflare wrote: I think vivax has actually gone insane.
I'm still ill and under pharmacological influence, yesterday I had 39 ° fever and was stumbling around and blabbering nonsense.
But right now I feel like what I say makes sense.
|
And if anyone wants to suggest I'm scum come out right now (It'd probably be Kelsier cause he's mafia and needs to save SL in some way).
But with all the work I'm doing, all the theories I'm suggesting, all filters I'm diving, I can't be mafia cause then I'd just be looking for some easy mislynch and lurk.
|
On January 21 2015 03:06 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 02:52 Damdred wrote:On January 21 2015 01:28 KelsierSC wrote:sorry dam can you answer this for me On January 21 2015 01:11 KelsierSC wrote: so dam, your main reasons for scum reading SL would be the "anger at lian" thing?
Weird anger, the pressure vote falling off so fast when SL doesn't have a ton of experience with Marv. Not really scum hunting until forced to.
Did Kelsier reply to this reply and give a conclusion on what your reply means for your alignment or is he still trying to paint HTS scum?
|
On January 21 2015 03:08 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 03:00 Vivax wrote:On January 21 2015 02:48 batsnacks wrote: Marv vivax is still doing that thing you voted him for earlier. The only thing that's ch anged is you're not the target. Wait? WHat are you alluding to? THat I try to find all scum at once? If SL flips scum I'm nominating myself for best town 2015. For sheeping? OKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK. Like are interactions were so weird. You and marv were having a retarded fight and showing you were both obvious town. I come and interject saying your both towns and to look elsewhere . Your town reading me for this and then marv goes "SL IS MAFIA" then you go "OK SURE" So like screw self meta. Look at mspaint where im scum. Ve/hf/hopeless were all fighting and calling each other mafia. What do I do? I sit back and dont post at all day 1 or even day 2. I dont freakin come out and tell everyone their obvious towns as mafia thats pretty dumb.
Defending towns fighting each other pushes your scum agenda, which is survival. So in this case your motive was to buddy up both of us.
Now I actually believe marv is town, HF's arguments are good, Damdred makes up some own reasons for scumreading you, and Kelsier doesn't go after you but questions you half-assedly and tries to direct attention to HTS.
|
On January 21 2015 03:10 batsnacks wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 03:00 Vivax wrote:On January 21 2015 02:48 batsnacks wrote: Marv vivax is still doing that thing you voted him for earlier. The only thing that's changed is you're not the target. Wait? WHat are you alluding to? THat I try to find all scum at once? If SL flips scum I'm nominating myself for best town 2015. marv voted you for making associative reads So you made more associative reads Then he unvoted you for "reasons I wouldn't like" And you keep making associative reads Its just not a logical progression from marv (or from you but that's not the point in trying to make). It seems like marv only thinks your associative reads are scummy when he is a part of them.
He unvoted me cause I said "When I'm town and he's scum and I call him scum he calls me a nutjob" Cause when he's town and I'm town and I call him scum, he just fullout OMGUSES me and tries to lynch me, happened recently in a game where he lynched me D1 and we were both town. When I'm mafia and he's town I don't even dare going after him cause he catches me so easily.
I'm pretty confident marv is town. Sheep him and if SL isn't scum we will have to reroll up my theory of HF + Marv + Damdred or Kelsier
|
MY THEORY FITS PERFECTLY. DAMDRED JUST MENTIONED OWN REASONS FOR SL BEING SCUM AND ISNT EVEN VOTING HIM IN THE THREAD
|
So basically we wait to see if SL flips scum, if he does we already won cause I already uncovered all their interactions and theywill concede.
Damdred is reluctant to vote SL or we'd see his vote in the voting thread.
Kelsier is pushing suspicion onto me and mostly HTS.
|
I want to bring this up again:
The spacial anomaly pulls people into them. So I'm currently assuming it is a role with an alignment conversion mechanic.
I'm assuming now, that scum used this anomaly to convert batsnacks since they need help right nw.
On January 18 2015 04:01 Artanis[Xp] wrote: Setup: It's a semi-open setup. 10 Town players, 3 Mafia players. 1 factional KP. Up to two blue roles, up to one special red role. There may be a miller in the game. The potential blue roles are not revealed but count on ordinary roles.
Example Town role: Lost Spirit The void's grasp is becoming stronger. You have to break free before the void consumes you. You have no special powers but your vote. Make it count.
Example Blue role: Satellite You're a satellite who detected several anomalies around the Void. Each night you may check one player and find out if they're a Lost Spirit or a Spacial Anomaly.
Example Red role: Spacial Anomaly You're a spacial anomaly. Your gravometric pull is drawing nearby spirits into the Void. You can find your QT here: <link>
Now to the stuff that fits this theory:
On January 21 2015 03:23 batsnacks wrote: Vivax isn't it weird that marv is okay with you using "bad" associative reads to justify your vote on SL?
Marv said your associative reads were scummy, shouldn't marv be concerned that you are using scummy tactics to push his lynch target?
Batsnacks earlier said that when I was pushing the marv + Hf + Kelsier/damdred theory. He said he was agreeing with me.
Then he said it was just an advocatus diaboly strategy. Which means he didn't agree with me (and hence townread marv) but openly claimed to do so. Speculative purpose: See if other scum would jump on my theory and support it.
BUT NOW Now batsnacks has been converted, we're dealing with 4 scum. Now batsnacks completely threw his disagreement with my marv etc. scum theory into the trash, and instead tries to push my suspicion back to marv.
While at the same time implying that me and marv could be scum together cause of this line:
Vivax isn't it weird that marv is okay with you using "bad" associative reads to justify your vote on SL?
|
On January 21 2015 03:41 sicklucker wrote: Why would scum convert batsnacks? Your terrible. You know hf is in this game right?
Cause if you're scum converting batsnacks would put him in a terrible spot after pushing you.
|
On January 21 2015 03:43 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On January 21 2015 03:41 sicklucker wrote: Why would scum convert batsnacks? Your terrible. You know hf is in this game right? Cause if you're scum converting batsnacks would put him in a terrible spot after pushing you.
EBWOP: converting HF
|
On January 21 2015 03:44 marvellosity wrote: Killing Vivax might actually significantly improve town's chances of winning even if he flips town.
I've never been this tempted by a policy lynch before (except that BH occasion)
You'd favour a policy lynch that gives you zero information over your own scumread? We should just kill SL and then I'll solve this game during the night phase.
|
WHAT IS THIS SHIT MARV IS PULLING OFF?????????????
HE HAS A SCUMREAD, I AGREE WITH HIM, HE TOWNREADS ME, AND THEN HE WANTS TO POLICY ME GIVING US ZERO INFORMATION.
|
|
|
|